11 ms·
Features that more cameras should have
- mrandish 5y agoOne feature that wasn't mentioned is the option to capture and save as embedded metadata the camera's motion sensor info used for video stabilization. Some Sony cameras currently do this and the data can be used to increase stabilization quality by doing post processing in Sony's desktop app.
- dboreham 5y agoAgree on: the trend to get GPS data from a smartphone is particularly irritating (either drains power on the phone, or you forget to enable it). I miss the 6D/6Dii built-in GPS. I hadn't thought of sensor shift star tracking. That'd be useful, assuming it would work with, say, the R6.
- spaetzleesser 5y agoI wonder how much space a GPS needs. It can’t be much considering that I have a 50g watch with GPS that can run the GPS for 30 hours.
- mark-r 5y agoThat's the thing that's most baffling to me. It seems like GPS as a feature would cost nearly nothing in money or space inside the camera, but it's still extremely rare. Pentax had it in the K-3 II but dropped it for the K-3 III.
- nayuki 5y agoHaving owned several cameras, each has pros and cons in its GPS approach. Canon EOS 6D: Standalone GPS receiver on the body. Takes a long time to get first fix. Weak signal on airplanes. Heavy battery drain. Does not work underground or in big buildings. Canon EOS M6: Post-shooting tagging with GPS when camera connects to smartphone, using timestamps for correlation. Smartphones are extremely fast (e.g. A-GPS) and accurate (e.g. GPS+GLONASS), can use Wi-Fi for indoor geolocation, and can tag basically 100% of photos without missing any. The cons are the need for accurate timestamps, the need to keep the phone on and logging (potential high battery drain), and the need to manually invoke the sync action after shooting. Canon EOS RP: Bluetooth connection to phone. The phone's geolocation is fast and accurate. But the Bluetooth connection is terrible; takes 5~10 seconds to establish; cannot geotag missed photos after the fact (unlike the M6); the phone has a tendency to evict the Canon Camera Connect app which means no Bluetooth connection to the camera.
- jl6 5y agoWhatever happened to love for Live Photos? I think they’re great - absolutely perfect for situations with young kids who are constantly moving, or just to capture little vignettes of movement that bring a photo to life for a moment. But support for them is virtually non-existent outside the iOS Photos app. You can extract them as a pair of HEIC and MOV files, but I know of no Free photo management software that is capable of associating them and displaying them together (and yes, there are internal IDs in both files that make it possible to link them, so they aren’t quite as fragile as most sidecar files, although they are still fragile because Apple for some insane reason decided not to make use of the HEIF container format’s native ability to store both in the same file). I’m unsure if Android has an equivalent feature or how it’s implemented, but I’m pretty sure no DSLRs have anything like it.
- gengkev 5y agoPixel phones can take "Motion Photos" — it seems like this is basically just an mp4 file stuffed into a jpg somehow (but without sound). The Google Photos app lets you export it as an mp4 or gif file, or pick a specific timestamp to export a still image. It looks like the Samsung Camera has something similar, but I'm not sure if it's compatible...
- formerly_proven 5y ago> I’m pretty sure no DSLRs have anything like it. I'm not sure what you mean - pretty much all of these can capture 4K video where each frame is about as good as a still from a phone camera.
- jl6 5y agoThe equivalent would be a DSLR that can take 24MP stills and 4K (8MP) video simultaneously.
- formerly_proven 5y agoSome do.
- spekcular 5y agoA lot of these features are nice to have but definitely not essential, especially for general amateur photography. But here's one important feature the list misses: the ability to shoot uncompressed, or losslessly compressed, RAW images. The last time I checked, the introductory Sony cameras (the A6500 and its cousins) do not permit this. The customer can only access lossy compressed data. The same is true for lower-end Nikon DSLRs. Most of the time, this is not a problem – though in some situations with heavy postprocessing or harsh lighting, you will certainly see compression artifacts. I just find it amazing that they're asking customers to pay almost a thousand dollars for a camera+lens kit that doesn't support lossless compression, or let me access the true "raw" data. It's 2021! This is well-known technical knowledge taught in undergraduate CS classes.
- ryanianian 5y ago> The customer can only access lossy compressed data Honest question - is this a tech or a biz decision? I.e., is it more expensive to include output to raw? More i/o requirements or totally different chipsets or the like? Or is "raw" just deemed a "pro" feature that they feel they can upcharge for? (e.g. paying to flip a bit to unlock more battery life in an EV)
- spekcular 5y agoI think compression is done by default because it speeds up picture taking immensely. My understanding is that there's a buffer that holds recently shot pics while they're being written to the SD card. Clearly, if you use compression, you can fit more pics in the buffer, allowing more consecutive snaps before the camera locks up for a bit. Why it's lossy instead of lossless, I do not know. My guess is that lossy compression allows them to get more compression, and hence improve their effective buffer size for advertising purposes. I think 90% of the time this is a good trade-off. You can view some example artifacts here: https://stephenbayphotography.com/blog/sony-raw-compression-artifacts-real-examples/ https://stephenbayphotography.com/blog/sony-raw-compression-.... [Note that the author mentions being able to access uncompressed raw on his Sony after 2015, but it's a pro-level model. For the amateur models I believe there's no such option.] Obviously, if you're trying to make them happen, you can do it, but for pics of your kids/pets/plants/etc. in normal daylight situations it shouldn't be a problem. Still, as a technically minded person, it's infuriating to me that I can't access the original data.
- notJim 5y agoI agree with a lot of this stuff. I would really love to be able to do more processing in-camera. For example, if I'm doing focus or exposure bracketing, I am going to composite that in lightroom 100% of the time. Why can't the camera do this for me? I would at least love if I could tag those photos as being a pair, so that Lightroom could automatically detect this. I'm kind of surprised by how conservative camera manufacturers have been with adding new features. Some cameras don't even have intervalometers built in!
- LorenPechtel 5y agoI don't think the camera has the horsepower to do the processing, but I would like to see them tagged.
- rodgerd 5y agoAn Olympus EM-1 II has a pair of quad core ARM processors. The biggest challenge is that the hobbyist photography community is relentlessly, angrily furiously hostile to improving cameras in ways that move beyond pretending we're still using darkrooms, but with pixels. The hostility to anything that is more like the "fauxtographers" who take excellent photographs with phones is one rich source of that, but there are many more.
- argomo 5y agoIt boggles me how the big camera makers seem content to cede marketshare to smartphones. Obviously, they can't compete on pocketablity or ubiquity, but computational photography is their home turf. I shouldn't have to reach for my phone to take panoramas, photo spheres, and "live photos", and I'm not interested in spending hours compositing stuff later on the PC. The big camera makers do throw in a bunch of "modes" on their prosumer lines (which they toss out the window on their professional models) to pander to the consumer. Lame stuff, mostly. Give me some real stuff like auto-masking foreground subjects or out-of-camera photogrammetrly created 3D models. I get that prosumers are a dwindling niche and pros are where the money come from, but you need a source for more pros in the future, right? How does the camera compete if--as an artifact--it's inspirational value is outclassed by the mundane cellphone?
- FpUser 5y ago>"... Bulb Mode Preview Vibration Detection Shutter Firing Native Image Averaging " Pretty much vote for those. Not that the other are unimportant. "Native Image Averaging" - with the live preview please and the ability to zoom into that preview.
- DeathArrow 5y agoWhat I would like cameras to have is apps. Sony started some time ago to allow apps on their cameras under the name PlayMemories but for some reasons, they back off.
- notJim 5y agoI completely agree. Can you imagine have smartphone-level ability to add new functionality to high-end cameras? The things you could do would be amazing. Although I suspect and IO and processing power may be limiting factors, given that even a full-on PC can take a while to perform many operations.
- elischleifer 5y agoI disagree. Apps necessitate an app store, maintenance, updates, reasonable SDKs. For something like a camera apps as an expansion joint is a bridge-too-far. That's not to say that these cameras shouldn't provide an SDK for access to core functionality. I mostly would like Sony and others to open source there camera software so bugs/features can be addressed by the community.
- formerly_proven 5y agoFully disagree.
- novok 5y agoI want cameras that have apple airdrop, messaging apps, popular social media apps and file sync apps along with a full cellphone , wifi , bt, gps chip using android. It would be a dream to have my camera actually start syncing my photo shoot automatically when I plug it in the charger at home and have it not be a shit experience. OR wifi sync and phone sharing that doesn't suck. But no camera manufacturer has shown the ability to do that, so an android app mode is the next best thing so they can offload the software writing to much bigger tech companies instead. Top 1 annoyance with non smartphone cameras is sharing the photos I just took with other people at the event. I'm not fucking around with the frankly awful wifi experience on most cameras and I'm not going to bring a cable or sd card dongle to do so either. # 2 is the lack of built in GPS. It's 2021, adding GPS is extremely cheap, especially if you've already done wifi anyway. #3 is qi charging. After a shoot put the camera on the wireless dock and everything is syncing well with the local desktop computer.
- sp332 5y agoWhat is a flash commander?
- gridspy 5y agoIsn't that the gizmo that triggers external (studio / photo-shoot) lights to flash? It sends a radio or IR signal on shutter press rather than flashing on the camera. An alternative are studio lights which are set up to trigger when the camera flash itself goes off.
- jeffbee 5y agoCommander mode uses the flash to send the commands. It’s actually bananas what the protocol can do. A Nikon commander can signal three different groups of speed lights to test-fire, figure out the power the photo requires from each group, signal them all to dial in the exposure, then signal them all to fire. It does this all with 1960s technology.
- dmead 5y agoahh wouldn't the star tracker require pretty specialized or higher powered hardware? seems a bit much to cram into a camera no? unless you want the cost to increase by the cost of 1 cell phone?
- KMnO4 5y agoThe hardware is already there. You don’t need to move much to counteract the movement of the stars. Many cameras have in body stabilization, which can move the sensor around. Pentax had had this for a while (as early as 2011). https://www.ricoh-imaging.co.jp/english/explore/astro/ https://www.ricoh-imaging.co.jp/english/explore/astro/
- user_7832 5y agoI doubt you need that much hardware/costs, given that even an Arduino can do it [1]. From an outsider's perspective though, camera companies are probably hesitant to shake up what's already there which is probably they don't add such features. 1. https://blog.arduino.cc/2020/02/26/openastrotracker-is-a-tracking-and-goto-mount-for-dslr-astrophotography/ https://blog.arduino.cc/2020/02/26/openastrotracker-is-a-tra...
- gridspy 5y agoSounds like it's a pretty simple loop of 1. Find bright spots in last second of exposure (which is then added to a sum for the final picture) 2. Compare their locations to bright spots in the previous second 3. Move the sensor slightly so the bright spots remain "in the same place" on the sensor. Note that cameras with integral anti-vibration do that by moving the sensor, so they already have the hardware for (3). For star tracking there would be a max speed of stars based on Earth's rotation multiplied by focal length you could use to set a reasonable cap on movement. You could also expect similar movement for each second to the seconds before. The camera could have a data structure per star being tracked, capping the number used to say 32 or 64 "stars" for accuracy. Each "Star" would "vote" how much movement has occurred. You'd gain faith in various stars as analysis frames go by if they keep giving valid results, a black-list of "not stars" would also be useful. Some would be stationary, like lights on the ground. Some would be bogus, such as navigation lights on aircraft. Actual stars should expect similar movement and "agree" though if the zoom was low it might change across the image.
- sh-run 5y agoI have an Oly EM1.3. Pro-capture on a rental EM1.2 is what originally sold me the camera, but Live ND (image averaging) is probably my most used feature outside of standard aperture priority shooting. It's pretty fun what you can do with it. Here's an example from a backpacking trip last year: without Live ND: https://i.imgur.com/kJjEDmt.jpg https://i.imgur.com/kJjEDmt.jpg with Live ND: https://i.imgur.com/IhHzo4T.jpg https://i.imgur.com/IhHzo4T.jpg Both taken (handheld at 100mm) on my Panasonic 100-300/F4.0-5.6. I tend to carry it and my Oly 12-40mm f2.8 when backpacking.
- spaetzleesser 5y agoA built in ND should be standard.
- formerly_proven 5y ago> 2. Sensor Dust Protector Curtain > Currently Found On: Sony A9 II and A1; Nikon Z9; Canon full-frame mirrorless cameras other than the EOS RP That's not really accurate - the Sony and Canon are just using one of the shutter curtains for this, while the Z9 doesn't have a shutter so gets a dedicated mechanism not nearly as fragile as a shutter. > 6. Bulb Mode Preview Not sure how this is supposed to work without having a non-destructive readout sensor, unless it's just an approximation based on a quicker exposure before starting the bulb exposure. > 8. Native Image Averaging idk all of those guys are shooting raw anyway, so just stack them which you were probably going to anyway? > 14. Raw Histograms Yeah. > 15. 16-Bit Raw Probably in the next generation of landscape cameras like the Z7III > 18. Base ISO Below 100 Mostly a fight with physics.
- mark-r 5y agoRaw histograms are a no brainer, I don't understand why this isn't already commonplace. 16 bit raw is another matter. If you're not getting 16 bits of dynamic range from the pixels, all you'd be doing is getting a more accurate reading of the noise. That just adds a lot of expense for no perceivable gain.
- ben7799 5y agoSome of these seem like they are workarounds that aren't going to be required in future camera designs. Others fall well into the amateur photography traps of "I must have this techno gadget in the camera to get better", whereas Pros have been getting that shot for decades without said gadget. I have a pretty fancy system (but have been gradually losing interest the last 5 years or so) but I feel like it's all becoming irrelevant over time and the camera companies are going to be left with a very small pro market (that's much more pragmatic about upgrades) and the hard core amateur market that just buys everything to show off. The biggest things that would keep camera systems relevant would be much better connectivity options to your phone or other device. Make it really easy and seamless, and wireless. Or put LTE right in the camera.
- mark-r 5y agoI already pay a monthly fee for LTE to my phone. No way I'd want to double it so my camera could have a connection.
- mfranc42 5y agoIt's all fancy shit. But guess what. My 35mm camera from eighties has command back with intervalometer. I can say stuff like in 10 minutes do an hour long exposure directly on the camera. The fact that I cannot do it on modern camera without cables or mobile phones is a travesty.
- onion2k 5y agoMy Panasonic Lumix FZ82 has a built-in intervalometer, and stop motion, slow mo video, WiFi and Bluetooth remote control, and a lot more. Plus a 60* optical zoom. All for about $350 these days. Its a great daily-driver camera.
- mfranc42 5y agoI have Lumix S1. It has gazillion of features, but, for example, the exposure duration is limited to 1 minute. :-(
- spaetzleesser 5y agoThese limitations are just stupid. Thank God Fuji jumped from 30s to 15min a while ago.
- onion2k 5y agoThey aren't stupid. Sensors get hot while they're taking an image, and if you can't dissipate the heat quickly enough you have to limit the exposure time. It's likely that new Fuji sensors just run cooler, so they can increase the time they're active.
- spaetzleesser 5y agoI don’t think that explains it. They allow you to use Bulb mode and go for as long as you want without restrictions.
- mfranc42 5y ago
- matonias 5y agoTapping into this conversation... which brand has good software to play around with? Canon has https://magiclantern.fm/ https://magiclantern.fm/
- LorenPechtel 5y agoOne more feature I would like to see, I've never heard of a camera supporting it but there has been aftermarket support on some Canons: Automatic shooting of HDR exposures. Stacking them requires some human intervention and shouldn't be done on the camera, I'm simply thinking of the shooting. You put your camera on a tripod, select HDR and push the button. It shoots a frame and checks the histogram--are pixels falling off either end? If so, adjust only the shutter speed and shoot again. Keep doing so until the slowest shot has nothing falling off the dark end and the fastest shot has nothing falling off the bright end.
- namibj 5y agoMy Canon IXUS 100 IS did that with CHDK firmware loaded on. I guess that may be the aftermarket support you're referring to?
- rodgerd 5y agoThis is built-in to Olympus cameras and has been for years.
- mgdlbp 5y agoI've seen several Fujifilm bridge cameras with in-camera stacking; not sure about the rest of their line.
- sainotbot 5y agoPretty sure you can choose DR100, DR200 or DR400 since the X-T1. My X-T4 definitely has it.
- spaetzleesser 5y agoThat’s not really HDR though.
- IshKebab 5y agoWhy does stacking them require human intervention? For a completely static scene I would have thought the algorithm is fairly simple and unambiguous.
- shrx 5y agoAs a Canon camera owner it's sad to see it missing from the supported cameras lists under nearly all of the features mentioned. Mine does have a GPS unit, though.
- threeseed 5y agoI want to see smaller form factors e.g. Sony RX1, Sigma fp. The whole point of mirrorless was to move away from DSLR sized kits and yet years later we are back there again. Also would be nice to see more options for manual focusing. Pixii is interesting being a digital rangefinder but there isn't much innovation here.
- The_Colonel 5y ago> The whole point of mirrorless was to move away from DSLR sized kits That's a wrong assumption, it was certainly never "the whole point", just one of the factors.
- nomel 5y agoBesides mirror slap/vibrations, what's the other benefit? Size, and therefore cost, of glass is why all of my professional friends moved over. You can get better lenses for cheaper. And, the cameras themselves are much simpler, so can be cheaper/higher quality. Many of the "live viewfinder" benefits already existing in DSLRs that had live viewfinder modes, with the rest being excluded for cost or differentiation (focus pixels, live histograms, etc). I saw it as an more of an eventuality of the live viewfinder being made more featureful than the lens view, so removing the mirror just made sense. The only people I know that are still using DSLR are those that "need" the classic viewfinder, but there's no reason the features of a mirrorless camera couldn't be put behind a sometimes-flopping mirror. The only problem with that would be vibration and the increase in size of the camera and lens.
- namibj 5y agoThe lower back focal distance from not needing a mirror and optical viewfinder allows significantly better optics.
- nomel 5y ago> allows significantly better optics Yes, that's the primary driver for the size/cost of an equivalent lens. Smaller lens also means less distortion/non idealities, for the same cost.
- barbegal 5y agoI've wondered about a lot of these features and how they would be ubiquitous if only every brand of camera has a standard way of loading applications and interfacing with the sensor and lens. Sadly such an interface doesn't even exist on Android.
- terramex 5y agoI'll add one idea to the list: tracking moving objects using IBIS. Like when you shoot moving car or flying bird - use existing autofocus to detect the object and then track it over exposure time to keep it free from motion blur but get nice, blurred background. Pentax have simple version of that for tracking stars mentioned in the article but I hope some company figures out how to do it for arbitrary, fast moving objects in real-time. Sony a9 series already got rid of blackout during shooting so it is technically possible to get image data in realtime, have continuous autofocus and save full size RAW files at the same time: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_ZXFI-eIXk8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_ZXFI-eIXk8
- formerly_proven 5y agoI don't think IBIS systems have enough travel to do something like that, especially for the longer focal lengths where this would be useful. In the meantime optical stabilizers and IBIS systems already smooth your pans on the micro-level pretty well.
- sudosysgen 5y agoThey'd only have to track for 1/400th of a second, it's definitely possible.
- spaetzleesser 5y agoI don’t think they can move the sensor fast enough. It would also only work for objects whose parts don’t move. Airplanes may work but with birds the wings move in different directions. But I think with much faster sensor readouts you will be able to compute sharp images sometime in the future.
- brokenmachine 5y agoBack-in-time buffer is amazing, I have it on a Casio camera of mine. You hold the shutter halfway and it takes photos at whatever speed you choose (I usually have it at about 10fps), then when you press fully, it stores up to 40 shots from before you fully pressed the shutter (you choose beforehand how many shots to store from before the full shutter press). I would love to have a full-frame mirrorless with that feature, but alas. I've got a lot of nice photos of birds taking off, fish jumping out of the water, street photography to capture people in an exact position of my choosing, the exact moment a bat hits a ball, and many other things that would have been almost impossible to capture otherwise. It amazes me how stuck in the past camera companies must be, there's so little innovation. Even something as basic as wifi/phone support is almost always half-baked and barely functional. There's so many opportunities to improve with good phone integration too. You buy a $2k SLR, yet it's still difficult and time consuming to simply snap a picture and send it using your phone. It shouldn't be this complicated.
- twoWhlsGud 5y agoIndeed. I've used it on my Olympus gear (Fuji X sytem also has it, btw) and it's very helpful when, e.g. you know that bird is going to take off at some point but not exactly when. Given how simple it is (a ring buffer for images captured using an electronic shutter mode basically) it's surprising that every camera with a decent e-shutter implementation doesn't have this.
- _ph_ 5y agoA good list with a lot of very useful features. One thing I found interesting there was, that Olympus was the brand which implemented a lot of those features. Micro Four Thirds is often ignored for its "small sensor". But in practise, a lot of features often count more than the sensor size (which of course has a lot of advantages for optics design, as size and portability). All photographers should pay more attention to Olympus, or rather OMDS, as the new company is called. They are making really good and versatile cameras.
- tuatoru 5y agoOlympus also has some excellent lenses quite reasonably priced. The brand is seriously underrated. (Ssh, don't tell anyone.)
- _ph_ 5y agoIndeed, it is. The lenses just are great. I have a large Olympus setup. Could I have gotten any full frame camera? Yes, but for most tasks I consider the Olympus the better choice in the combination of features, great optics and a small kit which can be carried even with a bad back. For me, the only real competitor is the Leica M system :)
- tuatoru 5y agoI agree, and I would love to try a Leica, but I don't have that kind of money for one among several hobbies. :-) I also don't get this term "full frame". When I started photography, "full frame" was 120 format. 35mm was "compact camera". And I think you need to go to 120 (at least) to do noticeably better than Olympus micro four-thirds.
- _ph_ 5y agoIt is just a term which got established. Most of the times, I just talk about the 35mm format. The best explanation is, that Canon and Nikon used to sell digital versions of their 35mm camera with smaller sensors. And when they started to make 35mm digital sensors, these cameras were "full frame", as the digital camera had the same sensor size as the film cameras of the same system had. I don't care to much about those terms, I am happy with Olympus. With respect to the Leica: if you can trust your self control, by all means try out a Leica, it is an experience one should have. But yes, deposit your credit card at a safe place, they are lovely. For me the downfall was that I bought a M-mount Voigtländer 40/1.4 as a short tele lens for mFT, back then when there where not many prime lenses to choose from. It works lovely on a digital M :)
- computerfriend 5y agoThe only feature I really feel is missing is photo encryption. It's something journalists have been asking for ever since DSLRs existed, and doesn't seem technically infeasible.
- ZDurmPhoto 5y agoI've been a working pro for nearly 35 years. One feature I would love is a shortened shutter response mode. Something akin to 6ms response from shutter trigger (this has nothing to with shutter speed). Canon actually built a camera like this in the film days - The Canon EOS RT and EOS 1N RS. It used a pellicle prism so no mirror had to be lifted out of the way to make an exposure. Why would anyone want this? Let me show you how I photograph wild bats in flight at night. I have many other use cases. For now I have to mount a shutter on the front of my lens to gain back the shutter response that i use to utilize from these film cameras of old.
- twic 5y agoI wonder if the Olympus "pro capture" mode mentioned in the article would do the job. That effectively gives you the ability to choose the shutter response time after you have taken the photo, including the option of negative values.
- troutmskreplica 5y agoTo be very contrarian and sound like a bit of a neo-Luddite, I have been a photographer for more than 30 years and have never taken photographs as good as the ones I take with my Leicas, which are the most feature-poor expensive cameras you’re likely to find. No auto-focus, no video, limited feature light metering, etc. I drooled over getting a Leica M for 15 years and finally took the plunge about five years ago. Best choice I have made gear-wise in all this time. After getting the first, I went ahead and got the Monochrom as well (yes, B&W-only sensor).
- Valgrim 5y agoOne feature I've been unable to find anywhere is the ability to sync the sensor clock very precisely, either manually as a menu option or using radio signals (Bluetooth, Wifi, GPS or tv broadcast, I'm not sure which would be better). The idea would be to sync perfectly multiple cameras to capture an event in time exactly at the same moment, but from different angles. I know professionnal cameras can do this using a Genlock, but with the amount of sensors and radios on modern cameras, I'm pretty sure this could be made available to the masses.