35 ms·
Dont get excited. Article starts with a lie right off the bat: >Customers join more than 5,000 Apple Authorized Service Providers (AASPs) and 2,800 Independent
by rasz 5y ago
Dont get excited. Article starts with a lie right off the bat:
>Customers join more than 5,000 Apple Authorized Service Providers (AASPs) and 2,800 Independent Repair Providers who have access to these parts, tools, and manuals.
AASPs and IRPs do NOT get access to 'tools, manuals and parts'. They get access to batteries and screens at significant markup and repair manuals that say "mail device to Apple" in case of other defects. Yes, AASPs are Prohibited from component level repair. AASP/IRP can not replace a charging port, its that bad.
But I get to buy original display from Apple so its still good? Well, Apple will sell you display assembly at the cost of Fully working second hand device.
>By designing products for durability, longevity, and increased repairability
They had to set Sarcasm Generator all the way to 11 to write this.
What this is is Apple getting scared. They can smell losing their long battle against Right to Repair and are trying to make smallest steps possible giving appearance of caving in.
- reaperducer 5y agoscreens at significant markup If an original Apple screen cannot be purchased on the open market, how do you know it's marked up?
- HelixEndeavor 5y agoBecause if the cost Apple is selling the screen at reached a certain percentage of the cost of a new device, it becomes clear that they did not pay that much for the screen, otherwise they wouldn't be making a profit on their phones.
- atmosx 5y ago> What this is is Apple getting scared. They can smell losing their long battle against Right to Repair and are trying to make smallest steps possible giving appearance of caving in. This was my take as well. They might now something about an upcoming bill that everyone else will learn in 6-8 months :-)
- tailspin2019 5y ago> AASPs and IRPs do NOT get access to 'tools, manuals and parts'. They get access to batteries and screens at significant markup and repair manuals that say "mail device to Apple" in case of other defects. Yes, AASPs are Prohibited from component level repair. It may depend on the territory and the specific AASP but this isn’t universally true. This is understating what AASPs have access to and the types of repairs they can carry out. Not to unduly support Apple though - they are admittedly very restrictive on all this.
- mihaaly 5y agoSo it's basically deception tactics in a legal battle? "Nice!" : )
- Nextgrid 5y agoI agree that it's not great, but IMO a big problem with the IRP program for repair shops is that you had to submit your customer's data and wait for the part to be shipped (you couldn't order parts to stock them in advance). These aren't dealbreakers for the end-user though, and in a lot of cases the problem with authorized repair isn't the cost but availability or having to ship your device off. Being able to do the repair yourself (even if still paying a markup on the part) is still a welcome improvement. "Tools and manuals" would most likely include tools or solutions to legitimately override any linking of parts to its original phone, so you can finally replace screens or Touch ID/Face ID sensors.
- IanSanders 5y agoThe only reason for the markup, is because they can, which they ensured in advance
- viro 5y agoApple themselves don't do component level repair. Why do you think those "tools, manuals" even exist.
- guywhocodes 5y agoWow nice clown move, someone does, someone uses those manuals.
- rasz 5y agoSame way you can argue Apple dont even manufacture anything themselves, its contractors all the way down. The fact is they separate real repair from their Users, funneling it thru sale channels in order to upsell at every step. "Oh it doesnt charge? Replacement logic board will cost $700-$1100, or you can "upgrade" to M1 air for only 1295.99!!1"
- viro 5y agono its the fact that component level repair isn't really provided by most OEMs. It was never offered on any of my past laptops
- HelixEndeavor 5y agoRight, but all you need to do component level repair is access to schematics and the ability to buy the chips. The schematics definitely exist - they have to, in order for the motherboard to exist. And the chips on the motherboard probably exist too. But Apple would clearly rather you didn't know that, since they contract their chip manufacturers to not sell the chips to anyone else for any purpose.
- Danieru 5y agoJust how Apple does not calculate profit on their AppStore eh. What a wonderfully self serving coincidence. Apple does not do component level repair because they want to push new devices and at reluctantly sell parts at obscene profit margins. That does not imply component level repair is not economically viable. It only implies that Apple is that sort of dinasour which Silicon Valley is supposed to disrupt.
- IanSanders 5y agoI'm all for forgiveness, however in this case even if they executed it perfectly, I'm not sure supporting them would be the right thing to do, especially now that Framework laptop is a thing, hopefully to be followed by a larger model and a Framework phone.
- cr3ative 5y agoWhich part is a lie? Parts are available - yes. Screens, modules, etc. Tools are available - sure. Pentalobe screwdrivers, etc. Manuals are available - yes they are. You call their quality sub-par, but none of that is a lie. Component-level repair is probably prohibited by AASPs because it'd have very variable quality outcomes compared to module swaps, and they're putting their name to the quality of the repair.
- jasonjayr 5y agoBut that's the thing. If it's self-service repair; then Apple's name is not on the quality of the repair, that's 100% clear. Apple's name is, however, on the quality and availability of the parts, instructions, and repairability.
- cr3ative 5y agoI agree with you there, the parent was decrying the nature of AASP repairs.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoI've argued this in another post recently, but I almost feel that we need a new word that means "so gross a misrepresentation that your average person would have a completely different view of the reality of the situation." I feel like (especially on the Internet) it's pretty easy to deliberately mislead, and then when people call out a statement as BS, it turns into this game of "But see, screens are parts, a screwdriver is a tool!" Yes, I understand Apple is not technically lying here, but they are deliberately misrepresenting the repairability of their products. It's almost like that game kids play of "I'm not touching you, I'm not touching you" when they sit half an inch from their siblings to annoy them.
- varjag 5y agoPeople who are able to reflow BGA chips are not the market of this. There isn't a magic, hidden tool to get your way around fairly advanced skills.
- 5y ago
- namdnay 5y agoDo Apple actually do component-level repair? Or do they just bin it and send a new one?
- aequitas 5y agoMy guess is they aggregate defect units in specialised locations that can do bulk repair and make them available for refurbished (or even new) units depending on the demand or tossed/recycled for EOL products/parts.
- grishka 5y agoI don't think they ever do. Even "officially" replacing the battery on those MacBooks where it's glued in meant replacing the entire top case along with it. I'm 99.999% sure they would also replace the entire motherboard rather than the actual $0.05 component on it that failed.
- IanSanders 5y agoTheir smaller / cheaper iphone line (SE?) is made mostly from recycled components I heard
- grishka 5y agoProbably their usual greenwashing stuff like "100% recycled aluminum"
- IanSanders 5y agoI meant from previous generation iPhones of the same form factor - it used exactly the same screen and camera
- namdnay 5y agoI suspect they mean "recycled" as in "we reuse existing assembly lines / stocks of parts" and not "we take apart old iphone 8s to make SEs". That doesnt seem feasible from a quality assurance POV
- specialist 5y agoOEMs must be required to provide all parts at cost plus s/h. And misc docs for free. I totally get that Apple is constantly under seige from scammers, knockoffs, etc. Not my problem. Further, setting up official spares channel would likely resolve 90% of fraud by fullfilling a definite need. No diff than acceptible streaming moots most demand for pirating. Lastly, I'm fine with self repair requiring an official factory reset, or whatever, for stuff dependent on the secure enclave. Like rebinding FaceID to a new camera/display assembly. A fair tradeoff between security and convenience. So I can repair my phone now, suffer with entering PIN, and then make a quick stop at a Genius Bar later, at my leisure, to reenable FaceID. With so many third parties trying to pwn Apple gear, I totally grok this precaution.
- tibbetts 5y agoMaintaining inventory makes “cost” a weird concept. And I can’t think of any regulation requiring anyone to provide something at “cost” that works well.
- HelixEndeavor 5y agoIf they're able to maintain inventory on all of their current products I think they can probably maintain inventory on parts for them.
- katbyte 5y agoA lot of their “inventory” is “ship it right after manufacture directly to the customer”.
- kube-system 5y agoOf course they can, the person above was alluding to the fact that keeping an inventory of parts often costs more than the parts themselves.
- throaway46546 5y agoIf you could get all parts at cost couldn't you build your own iPhone for less than the price of an iPhone?
- BoorishBears 5y ago> They had to set Sarcasm Generator all the way to 11 to write this. Except the M1 Air did improve battery repairs, and the M1X Pro. Apple Watch Series 6 has fewer finicky seals. The only move in the wrong direction has been locking parts, and it looks like this is the fix right here? It's sure weird the quality of the of comment you can get away with if you're bashing something unpopular around here...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- audunw 5y agoI'm all for pushing for more right-to-repair, but I'm not sure pushing for facilitating component level repair that require soldering is the right way to go. Those kinds of repairs are incredibly difficult (I've done some myself). There are very few people I would trust to do it right, and it's hard to know which repair shop to trust. If Apple put out manuals and components for those kinds of repairs, I can imagine the number of botched repairs skyrocketing, and the resale value of the phones diminishing significantly. I think there's a balance to strike: you want easy repairs to keep phones going for a long time, but you also want people buying used phones to not worry about getting a frankensteined phone that will last 2 weeks before dying. Only by having high trust in the second hand market do you actually get phones that get used for years and years rather than staying in a drawer or getting trashed when people buy new ones. I would even support having ID-tags on all components and having them bound to the phone, as long as anyone can buy original replaceable components from Apple at a fair price, and that anyone can do the binding procedure themselves.. including moving components from one phone to another. You should be able to see the history of all the components in the phone, so you have some idea if a third party repair shop just moved an ID chip from an old original battery to a new unoriginal one, or used a really old original battery. I've experienced several times that screens and batteries you get at third party repair shops die/break much faster than the ones that come with the phone. Why is that? Is it really better to use brand new electronics that will be trash in a few months, just to extend the life a bit? If you're going to replace the battery and screen, you better be damn sure that the phones lasts 2-3 years or more, because you're buying brand new parts, constituting a large fraction of the rare and expensive materials used by the phone.. so it's not that much better than just buying an entirely new phone where all components could easily last 5 years if you treat them well.
- bluSCALE4 5y agoYou do realize you're holding the repair industry against your ability, right? You've probably attempted a few handful of repairs that required solder. You do realize people do this for a living? Sure, I'd probably say that 1/2 the people out there claiming to be repair people are just hacks with no skill but I've come to realize that that's the truth in ANY industry. You wouldn't want a new engine for a timing belt change, or a master cylinder repair. Would you take it to Jiffy Lube for this stuff? Absolutely not, but there are qualified people out there to do the work just as there are people that can rip out a pinless chip and replace it in their sleep.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kosh2 5y agoAgreed. This looks much more like a tactic against true repairability than a real commitment to it: It will be used as an argument why laws with teeth to guarantee real repairability are not needed. "Look here, we do repairs and such! No laws needed! We regulate ourself just fine!"
- kokey 5y ago>By designing products for durability, longevity, and increased repairability They had to set Sarcasm Generator all the way to 11 to write this. I have found iPhones to be the most repairable compared to the other smartphone brands I've repaired. Macbooks are a different story, but I see Macs and Macbooks as a different type of product compared to a PC which is modular by nature since the first IBM PC clone. Some non-Apple parts for iPhones are terrible, so it's nice to have the option of genuine parts though it's not going to be useful if it's very expensive.
- ChrisRR 5y agoThis feels like when Apple lost the Samsung curved corners case and basically posted "We're sorry that Apple phones are so cool and Samsung's aren't" on their front page They're knuckling under in the most Apple way they can
- saagarjha 5y agoWhen has Apple ever done this?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]