3 ms·
>People are being pushed to do things that evolution really hasn't equipped them to do - sustained periods of low physical activity, high mental activity guided
by pydry 5y ago
>People are being pushed to do things that evolution really hasn't equipped them to do - sustained periods of low physical activity, high mental activity guided by willpower rather than instinct. That is pretty tiring.
I don't think it's a mental vs. physical thing at all.
I've had jobs where I had certainty about what I was doing every day, I witnessed the fruits of my labor and I had certainty about where I stood in the organization. I never suffered burnout from them.
I've also had jobs where I was always uncertain about what I ought to be doing, where the fruits of my labor often didn't seem to amount to much (e.g. perpetual project cancellations/always changing requirements/sudden architectural direction changes) and I was really uncertain about where I stood the whole time.
I tried dealing with it with sustained periods of heavy physical activity (e.g. jogging between tasks), meditation, etc. It only helped a little.
This perpetual miasma of uncertainty and consequent stress built up over time and when it became too much - that's when I burned out.
I don't doubt that working on a farm doing heavy physical labor under similar conditions would burn me out too. My parents used to sometimes give me vague gardening tasks when I was a teenager and I absolutely hated that.
- Apocryphon 5y agoMarx’s observation of the alienation of labor holds true. Have to wonder too if there’s such a thing as the ambiguity of labor. Not knowing where one stands in an organization is a continuous passive stress, a background drone of worries. It’s an emotional labor that even comes with jobs that aren’t primarily social.
- pydry 5y agoPerhaps. I never really "got" alienation. I had imagined it was something Tony at "Tony's artisanal, signature burgers" wouldn't feel but Tommy the McDonalds fry chef would. I think I've always found there to be some individuality and creativity in software work, so in this respect even when I'm burning out I feel more like Tony than Tommy.
- Apocryphon 5y agoThe description of where "the fruits of my labor often didn't seem to amount to much" seems to be summarize labor alienation.
- pydry 5y agoMaybe. I think it's just wasted labor, though.
- pastacacioepepe 5y agoThat's not what alienation means, if you go by Marx. The actual definition, from Wikipedia: >The theoretical basis of alienation within the capitalist mode of production is that the worker invariably loses the ability to determine life and destiny when deprived of the right to think (conceive) of themselves as the director of their own actions; to determine the character of said actions; to define relationships with other people; and to own those items of value from goods and services, produced by their own labour. Although the worker is an autonomous, self-realized human being, as an economic entity this worker is directed to goals and diverted to activities that are dictated by the bourgeoisie—who own the means of production—in order to extract from the worker the maximum amount of surplus value in the course of business competition among industrialists. It makes a lot more sense for it to apply to software developers too with this definition.
- pydry 5y agoLOL. This actual definition was what I double checked the example against. My uncertainty was because I always found this concept a little vague around the edges. What the fuck even is a self realized human being, for instance? Would Tony be one and Tommy not? Or neither? Or would the example need to be fleshed out before you could say?
- pietrovismara 5y agoThe worker is always an an autonomous, self-realized human being. It's working as a cog in the machine that alienates him. To stay with the kitchen examples, cooks would not be alienated if they could: - afford to eat where they work - have creative agency over the recipes - have the chance to meet with the customers of the restaurant who eat their dishes
- jseban 5y agoI think this is a really good point, and I think those physical jobs would have given the same burnout if they were equally meaningless/disorganised. Imagine being assigned physical tasks that change in the middle of execution, or are constantly being reverted etc, would probably drive people crazy just as much. But in physical work people just don't get jerked around as much, because anyone can see the dysfunction and poor organisation, while with knowledge work it's hidden.
- jimbokun 5y ago> I think this is a really good point, and I think those physical jobs would have given the same burnout if they were equally meaningless/disorganised. Dramatization of this in action: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0uuberh8Xks https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0uuberh8Xks