9 ms·
> including an option that’s “at least as easy” as the one to subscribe Weirdly enough this sounds like a loophole. I can already see some companies trying to
by xg15 5y ago
> including an option that’s “at least as easy” as the one to subscribe
Weirdly enough this sounds like a loophole.
I can already see some companies trying to bullshit their way through an investigation: "Oh sure, we don't provide online cancellation, because our way to cancel is even easier than online:" *presents a way to cancel that is in practice more difficult than online*.
I think either mandating that cancelling must be possible using the same workflow as subscription or more clearly defining what "easy" means would be important.
- rolandog 5y agoIt should have been stipulated that unsubscribing should be offered immediately after the option to subscribe.
- logfromblammo 5y agoI think "unsubscribe" should only be offered after a customer has been charged. Before that, it should be "cancel" or "annul". For instance, if there is a "free trial" period, wait until after that expires, and the customer has been charged, before offering an "unsubscribe". But aside from the hair-splitting, yes, you are absolutely correct. If I have instant buyer's remorse, I should be able to click it away just as instantly.
- cgriswald 5y agoI don't agree. "Canceling" a free trial means the trial ends immediately. "Unsubscribing" during a free trial means the trial continues, but you are no longer subscribed so when the free part of your subscription runs out it won't automatically renew.
- SkittyDog 5y agoNone of that language is has a standard legal or regulatory definition, across the US. They are not precise terms, at least not yet. They are frequently used colloquially in ways that contradict your suggestion. I'm not saying your definitions are bad, or wrong... Quite the contrary, I think your ideas are great! But the specific terms & definitions aren't what really matter, are they? We just need standard language, with specified legal meaning, that consumers can invoke to make service providers jump to task.
- onionisafruit 5y ago“What’s easier than making a quick phone call? It’s certainly easier than getting internet access, typing a url into a browser address bar, validating a ssl certificate, establishing an http session, authenticating with your credentials then finding and clicking the cancel button.”
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- koheripbal 5y agoSome might try that but one call with the FTC legal team will make any company stop that shit immediately. You don't piss off gov't regulators
- user3939382 5y ago> You don't piss off gov't regulators Yep. If you deal with them you learn quickly that all that “splitting hairs” stuff you see in Hollywood dramas buys you nothing. For a lot of administrative compliance, with the state or Feds, they are judge jury and executioner and the rules are what they say they are. Unless you have a lot of money and influence don’t play games with them.
- mindslight 5y agoYou're certainly right for personal advice, but does the New York Times not have a lot of money? They've certainly got the influence bit covered. Once you can buy enough of your own bureaucrats to tie up their bureaucrats, regulators' power isn't so clear.
- BizarroLand 5y agoMore powerful than that though is that you don't want the regulators to have to do any work. Once they have work to do they are insanely efficient, at least when it involves punishing the person who made them do work.
- hwers 5y ago> mandating that cancelling must be possible using the same workflow as subscription I'd rather not put into the law that strict a requirement on our UI design.
- lrem 5y agoIn the meantime I'm sitting here and reading how the way out of one service includes registered mail. Probably multiple, couldn't figure that out. Fun, eh?
- xg15 5y agoWhy not? This is exactly the kind of UI that a company would want to sabotage with dark patterns - so I think if any UI had reasons to have strict legal requirements, it would be this one.
- GrinningFool 5y ago> I'd rather not put into the law that strict a requirement on our UI design. But you all had it your way and it is a net negative for the actual humans who have to deal with not having that UI element available. If it wasn't common practice to skip that UI 'option' in the first place, the regulation wouldn't be needed now.
- eropple 5y agoOther countries do, and it works fine. Why not?
- HelixEndeavor 5y agoI would like to see 1 reason you would find that this UI restriction would be a bad thing.
- jjk166 5y agoLet's say you subscribe to something as part of a 3rd party bundle, like say you sign up for newsletter A and there's a whole bunch of other options and you leave newsletter B selected to also subscribe to that. Then the workflow for unsubscribing from B would be going through the subscription workflow for A. This would be bad for all parties: it may be difficult or even impossible for the B group to change A's subscription workflow, group A likely suffers increased churn as pissed off consumers have its subscription manager open anyways, but most importantly it's incredibly unintuitive for the consumer to go through A to change B, especially if they are only loosely related. While maybe rare for spam email, it's a pretty common scenario for downloaded software. But more generally, there are lots of workflows that are substantially easier in one direction than the reverse. You'd either need to ban all such UIs that are directional, or you open up a huge loophole for bad actors.
- IanSanders 5y agoThere's also a "genuinely super easy way to unsubscribe, except it unfortunately is experiencing technical problems"
- Humdeee 5y agoI'm sorry sir, but the Cancel button is only available on the Advanced plans. Please upgrade to cancel (and allow 30 days for changes to occur).
- selcuka 5y agoThat's what happens with many of the Unsubscribe (from mailing lists, that is) buttons unless they are provided by a reputable third party such as Mailchimp etc.
- chadash 5y agoThat's just what's in the summary. The actual policy [1] spells this out in more detail with examples: > ROSCA requires negative option sellers to provide a simple, reasonable means for consumers to cancel their contracts. To meet this standard, negative option sellers should provide cancellation mechanisms that are at least as easy to use as the method the consumer used to initiate the negative option feature. For example, to ensure compliance with this simple cancellation mechanism requirement, negative option sellers should not subject consumers to new offers or similar attempts to save the negative option arrangement that impose unreasonable delays on consumers’ cancellation efforts. In addition, negative option sellers should provide their cancellation mechanisms at least through the same medium (such as website or mobile application) the consumer used to consent to the negative option feature. The negative option seller should provide, at a minimum, the simple mechanism over the same website or web-based application the consumer used to purchase the negative option feature. If the seller also provides for telephone cancellation, it should provide, at a minimum, a telephone number, and answer all calls to this number during normal business hours, within a short time frame, and ensure the calls are not lengthier or otherwise more burdensome than the telephone call the consumer used to consent to the negative option feature. [1] https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/documents/public_statements/1598063/negative_option_policy_statement-10-22-2021-tobureau.pdf https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/documents/public_statements...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- suifbwish 5y agoWhat about GYMS that make you show up in person to cancel your subscription but make it so you have to talk with someone who doesn’t work very often.
- suifbwish 5y agoThe bottom line is if I call up on the phone and tell a company to stop billing me or send them an email from the registered email on file THEY SHOULD BE LEGALLY LIABLE for every time they debit an account after that time. The fact this is not the case completely dumbfounds me.