58 ms·
> Now if I put a million dollars in the bank, I lose wealth due to inflation, so I'm incentivized to put it in a fund or something now, which is a lot riskier t
by whimsicalism 5y ago
> Now if I put a million dollars in the bank, I lose wealth due to inflation, so I'm incentivized to put it in a fund or something now, which is a lot riskier than bank interest.
Yes, people investing in productive enterprise is actually better for real output, prices, and generally overall welfare.
- cies 5y agoConsumers buying is what drives production. Not investment. > better [...] prices, and generally overall welfare. How does investment do that? Plenty examples of the opposite can be found. I find those claims baseless.
- whimsicalism 5y agoInvestment and low rates drives wages which drives consumption. Investment also shifts aggregate supply to the right, which causes more output.
- RussianCow 5y ago> Investment and low rates drives wages which drives consumption. I know this is Economics 101, but is there any evidence that this actually happens in practice?
- Clubber 5y agoIt's certainly good for the shareholders to have more money in the market, I'm not sure about the others. I know I'd much rather have a solid 6-7% interest return than a flaky market return.
- whimsicalism 5y ago> I know I'd much rather have a solid 6-7% interest return than a flaky market return. And college debt holders, mortgage holders, generally impoverished people would rather have lower rates on the debt that they have. They'd also rather have jobs, which again comes with more investment. They'd also like to have a higher quality of life, again which comes with more investment in capital/production/real output.
- Clubber 5y ago>generally impoverished people would rather have lower rates on the debt that they have. Generally impoverished people aren't granted lower rates because of the credit system. They typically pay usury rates. Only people with existing assets / collateral get low rates. >They'd also rather have jobs, which again comes with more investment. Generally impoverished people have shit jobs, that's why they are generally impoverished. Also, investment leads to automation and offshoring which actually lowers jobs. >They'd also like to have a higher quality of life, again which comes with more investment in capital/production/real output. If investment in capital/production/real output helps impoverished people, it's very little. It generally helps already wealthy people. You're looking at stuff from a textbook macroeconomic position. In the realistic / microeconomic world, things aren't as you are portraying them.
- whimsicalism 5y ago1. If you get higher interest rate returns, how do you think that is being paid for if poor people aren't getting higher rates? 2. Unexpectedly lower interest rates increase employer competition in the labor market, raising wages. This is well studied. 3. The quality of life of a poor person in the US is unimaginably better than that of someone ranked relatively the same 100 years ago. That is due to investment. Denying those massive quality life improvements is absurd, although increasingly popular in our out-of-touch political climate.
- Clubber 5y ago>1. If you get higher interest rate returns, how do you think that is being paid for if poor people aren't getting higher rates? Loans to business, home loans, etc. Education loans really weren't a big thing because education used to be subsidized. Also, poor people aren't the only source of ROI on loans. They're quite lucrative though because they seldom are able to pay the principal and are an endless source of interest payments. 2. Unexpectedly lower interest rates increase employer competition in the labor market, raising wages. This is well studied. Yet wages have been largely stagnant for 40 years, how do you account for that? Got links? https://www.epi.org/publication/charting-wage-stagnation/ https://www.epi.org/publication/charting-wage-stagnation/ 3. The quality of life of a poor person in the US is unimaginably better than that of someone ranked relatively the same 100 years ago. I'm interested in how you are measuring this. Got any links? How about the quality of life from someone 40 years ago before neoliberalism? >Denying those massive quality life improvements is absurd Which quality of life improvements are you referring to? Are you being intentionally vague? I mean we can buy cheap plastic crap from China, but that's at the expense of US manufacturing jobs, isn't it? Food certainly isn't cheaper. Healthcare and housing isn't either. So yes, if you believe buying cheap disposable stuff from overseas is a massive quality of life improvement, then ok. Take a stroll down middle America and tell me how good they have it. I know lots of towns with boarded up main streets because all the manufacturing went overseas. That's where the investment went. Again, you're quoting macroeconomic theory when microeconomic conditions on the ground subvert any gains in macroeconomic theory. How does investment drive up wages when labor investment is say 90% overseas or automation?
- Burnafter186 5y agoWhat do you think banks do with your money, exactly?
- whimsicalism 5y agoLoan it out? What is your real question? I would rather not play Plato to your Socrates in a comment thread.
- PeterisP 5y agoThe point is that your money gets invested in productive enterprise in any case, no matter if it's done through equity financing or credit financing; so if you take out money from your savings account and buy shares then that does not really change the total amount of investment in the economy.
- whimsicalism 5y agoYes, both of those are increased with lower rates. My point remains exactly the same.
- MisterMower 5y agoSavings does exactly that. You’re money doesn’t just sit in the bank, the bank loans it out to people engaging in economic activity, businesses that want to expand, buy inventory, etc.
- imtringued 5y agoIn our fractional reserve system your saved money literally sits in the bank. The debtor gets fresh money and when he repays the loan the money disappears into thin air. It's important that people delay consumption so that there is enough room for investments but european countries are running well below capacity. Savings mostly affects inflation rather than the nominal amount of money that can be lent out.
- spiralx 5y agoNo, banks create money when they make a loan, they don't lend out deposits. Loans are constrained by risk and by reserve requirements set by central banks. https://www.bankofengland.co.uk/-/media/boe/files/quarterly-bulletin/2014/money-creation-in-the-modern-economy.pdf https://www.bankofengland.co.uk/-/media/boe/files/quarterly-...