5 ms·
Computer science is an extremely young field. The parts of the field that number theorists could dabble in quickly got fleshed out and got hard as they could ap
by Jensson 5y ago
Computer science is an extremely young field. The parts of the field that number theorists could dabble in quickly got fleshed out and got hard as they could apply the millennia of accumulated number theorist knowledge, the parts more related to how to work with computers (such as algorithms or program structure) is still young today.
Edit: Note that the frontier of the field will always be extremely hard no matter what time you live in. The reason is that things will be poorly understood and written, there will be no good textbooks or explanations, you have to trudge through all that often without anyone to help you understand things or correct you. It took centuries for calculus to become as easy as it is today.
- nemo44x 5y agoRight - novel thought is always difficult. It’s looks easy and obvious looking back but that’s because, as you’ve pointed out, effective teaching exists for it that draws obvious connections.
- Frost1x 5y agoIt's interesting how in education and academics this is well known and understood, however the second you transition out of education/academia to the real world in industry, it's as if all this is lost/unknown or the burden is simply ignored to create a pressure on everyone doing the work. Businesses and business leaders often think novel work should be simple because that's what you trained for. You studied computer science, maybe even have your Ph.D. and therefor should be able to anything and everything possible using computers quickly and efficiently. There's a large trench between what people expect and what reality is here.
- amusedcyclist 5y agoThe author is actually talking about the opposite situation, where CS theory departments now have a lot more number theorists (and other mathematicians) dabbling in CS theory, which has lead to use of far more complex tools than before. (Fourier analysis of Boolean functions is one example I'm familiar with)
- Jensson 5y agoIt might use more connections to number theory today, but the connection was always there and to understand it you had to understand number theory to a deep level from the start. The other parts of computer science had to slowly build depth as it was new ground.
- eru 5y agoThe frontier isn't always hard. When someone discovers a new powerful technique, there's often a wave of people just applying it to everything, and seeing what sticks. See https://slatestarcodex.com/2016/11/17/the-alzheimer-photo/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2016/11/17/the-alzheimer-photo/
- wittycardio 5y agoThe frontier was breached when someone found that powerful technique. Then it was no longer the frontier
- dekhn 5y agono, in science, technique isn't frontier, discovery is. technique is just what you build to expand the frontier.
- wittycardio 5y agoNot in cs theory or math, it is almost entirely a study of technique. If you look at papers quite often the abstract will emphasize the novelty of their technique rather than just the result
- dekhn 5y agoneither cs theory nor math is science. CS theory is a form of applied math, and math is not science, it's a distinct process (that is used by science, as a technique). My comment doesn't apply there.
- wittycardio 5y agoThis is an article about CS theory...
- dekhn 5y agothis subthread is about science, I'm responding to https://slatestarcodex.com/2016/11/17/the-alzheimer-photo/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2016/11/17/the-alzheimer-photo/
- bsedlm 5y ago> It took centuries for calculus to become as easy as it is today. it's easy to use, but it's (IMO) even harder to understand correctly than before. I'm referring to a mathematical-level understanding; i.e. you could re-invent it because of how well you undesrtand all of it.
- P_I_Staker 5y agoHow so?
- danuker 5y agoI would guess the sheer size of it. For instance, I can't take a derivative without the rules in front of me, though the concept of derivatives is simple.
- sudosysgen 5y agoI mean, you probably forgot how to, but taking a derivative without using any derivation rules has always been an exam question for me whenever I take a calculus class.
- 1980phipsi 5y agoDerivatives are usually quite a bit easier than integrals.
- bsedlm 5y agoAs far as I've understood so far, back when calculus was invented people would think about it using infinitesimals. But nowadays it is taught without mentioning them; in short, caluclus is now taught emphasizing the ability to use the techniques and that's it. I think that during the 19th century when it (along with logic) was being formalized they decided to throw away the old original ways to think about it. This ends up making it really hard to understand in exchange for making it "formally sound" and "user friendly".
- gmadsen 5y ago
- sircastor 5y agoOnce, during one of my classes I was reading an assigned paper and realized “hey, I know this guy…” it was an exciting little moment. I shared it with a friend who noted that unlike most fields, CS is young enough that many of the pioneers in it are still around.
- ddlutz 5y agoThis has happened a few times, I've ended up reading research papers of people I work(ed) with professionally.