8 ms·
Congo badly needs money, so they have a huge incentive to sell their valuable (and renewable with right handling) wood form rain forests. The rest of the world
by nine_k 5y ago
Congo badly needs money, so they have a huge incentive to sell their valuable (and renewable with right handling) wood form rain forests.
The rest of the world badly needs the rain forests to remain, for climate and oxygen production reasons. It would be reasonable if they rest of the world bought the desired outcome from Congo, by paying for not cutting the trees. They (we) would have to pay to Congolese people a competitive price for each tree saved from cutting.
If we wanted to know what an environment policy might cost, that would be a good example.
- pvaldes 5y agoWe all know how this ended in Brazil. Buying land and managing it as private reserves, Wildlife Trust style, would produce much better results.
- stefantalpalaru 5y ago> The rest of the world badly needs the rain forests to remain, for climate and oxygen production reasons. Oxygen produced in that forest ecosystem is all used locally, so it's oxygen-neutral, like all ecosystems. It's the same with carbon fixation. https://www.nationalgeographic.com/environment/article/why-amazon-doesnt-produce-20-percent-worlds-oxygen https://www.nationalgeographic.com/environment/article/why-a... : «Trees don’t just exhale oxygen—they also consume it in a process known as cellular respiration, where they convert the sugars they amass during the day into energy, using oxygen to power the process. So during the night when there’s no sun around for photosynthesis, they’re net absorbers of oxygen. Malhi’s research team reckons that trees inhale a little over half the oxygen they produce this way. The rest is probably used up by the countless microbes that live in the Amazon, which inhale oxygen to break down dead organic matter of the forest. “The net [oxygen] effect of the Amazon, or really any other biome, is around zero,” he explains. Because of this balance between oxygen production and consumption, modern ecosystems barely budge oxygen levels in the atmosphere. Instead, the oxygen we breathe is the legacy of phytoplankton in the ocean that have over billions of years steadily accumulated oxygen that made the atmosphere breathable, explains Scott Denning, at atmospheric scientist at Colorado State University.»
- nverno 5y agoIf this could work, there would no doubt be plenty of money happily poured into it. There must be countless charities/non-profits, already raising heaps of money and manpower, attempting to do exactly this. There needs to be either strong local government (eg. National Parks in US) or strong incentives for locals to protect these habitats (eg. ecotourism in Costa Rica). Otherwise, international demand for valuable rainforest wood is just too great an incentive. I worked for a non-profit [1] in Borneo some years ago, where the incentive was free healthcare to communities that stopped illegal logging in their regions. However, it was barely successful at that specific endeavour- for example, large ironwoods, a highly valuable tree, are almost entirely gone- even if locals stop logging, loggers from elsewhere will just fill the void (govt there is a joke). 1. https://healthinharmony.org https://healthinharmony.org
- MomoXenosaga 5y agoCongo is a corrupt and lawless state. The official Congolese government can't even project power- the country is invaded by Rwanda backed militias.
- LatteLazy 5y agoThe World Land Trust do this on a private charitable basis and they get local people on board to make sure it's properly managed and doesn't collapse as soon as the westerns leave. They're very efficient and accountable. I highly recommend donating: https://www.worldlandtrust.org/donate/ https://www.worldlandtrust.org/donate/
- gnramires 5y agoA well regulated wood extraction business would probably be a good thing -- a small rate of wood extraction is sustainable, even a carbon sink (because wood goes into non-perishable products, trapping carbon in goods and structures), also provide an economy for the locals, even funds to better protect the forest. Of course, regulation needs to be very good not to clash with forest wildlife and keep sustainability...
- belorn 5y agoThere are no competitive price for each tree when dealing with this kind of situation, and if you simply paid one person to not cut down a tree, the next person behind them will also need to be paid. The only effective way is to make cutting down the trees worthless. We can look at how the world combated illegal hunting for inspiration. We made ivory trade illegal. We remove the tusk early from elephants, and promote tourism that want to see healthy alive elephants. People who are desperate don't gain as much from hunting elephants anymore, and so the elephants are slowly gaining in populations. Similar tactics are used to save Rhinoceros from illegal hunters. Make it illegal to trade wood harvested in the rain forest, and create major fines for any company that is found to have profited from it. Make similar law against any food grown on land with previous rain forests, and give people legal alternatives that make more economical sense.
- user3939382 5y agoI’m probably one of the few here who actually spent a lot of time in Congo: They could build a hydroelectric dam on the Congo River and produce enough electricity to power for themselves and a lot left over by estimates I’ve read. They’re rich in all kinds of other natural resources- diamonds, cobalt, etc. The problem is the corruption not the money.
- batushka3 5y agoSo to bribe again, basically. Africa is sinkhole of aid, maybe time to stop? People in lush tropical forest rely on fallen worms from a tree as a source of protein and a frog is a special treat. (this is a another solid point for low protein high carb diet you should eat) How can people not able to farm (raise a chicken at least) understand about such high dimension problem like rainforest preservation?
- hannob 5y agoThis was pretty much the idea of back then Ecuador's president Rafael Correa with the Yasuni project. Most of the rest of the world said "we won't pay".
- rsj_hn 5y ago> Congo badly needs money No, money is a veil. When people say "X needs more money", what they usually mean is "X needs more productive resources". But giving someone foreign currency doesn't result in increasing their productive resources. And the greatest productive resource that is lacking in Congo is state and private capacity to develop productive ecosystems. As long as productive resources are viewed as prizes that people fight over controlling with the gun being the ultimate determinant of who gets to own the prize, then Congo will remain a poor nation unable to produce much on its own. Remember that money is paper, and Congo can print its own. The only reason to give Congo American paper is to let them import more foreign consumption, which may be nice, but isn't going to help Congo develop what it really needs, which is skilled workers, respect for rule of law, property rights, an impartial judiciary and integrity on the part of local officials. In fact, flooding Congo with foreign money undermines all of the above, because it merely increases the pool of prizes that people with guns can fight over.
- Bobylonian 5y agoCongo is one of the countries, that is already receiving foreign aid, so claiming, that it is not receiving any is simply a lie. >>> They (we) would have to pay to Congolese people a competitive price for each tree saved from cutting. The biggest issue of all of the foreign aid is corruption. The output of aid in most cases makes few mega rich billionaires from Africa and total poverty for rest. There is hypocricity in the whole "save the forests" idea, because the only way to save forests is by dramatically reducing population - I don't see reappearance of forests(where squirrel can run wild and free without the need to touch the soil) in United Kingdom, where money should not be the issue. DRC has population >100 million - that fact alone is making unsustainable maintenance of forests, for a population, that has basic needs, that include roof above their home, clothing and food.
- jetsetgo 5y agoForeign aid is the lie that white people tell themselves and screech about all the time. Most of foreign aid is siphoned back via corporations, rest is scrapped by corrupt dictators and politicians. People get nothing.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- atlasunshrugged 5y agoDon't forget the "well meaning" NGOs that are on the ground and jack up the prices of apartments and local goods and sit in their gated compounds on western salaries until they get rotated to some other country.
- goohle 5y agoLOL, foreign aid is for country, not for people. Country has lot of expenses, which are paid from taxes, so aid helps to reduce taxes, thus everyone, who works and pays taxes, pays less. Your claim is like "if foreign worker helped to fix a bus, then it must pay all passengers also".
- whateveriguess 5y ago
- Bobylonian 5y agoHere is another problem to think about how humans are changing environment - forests and nature(with animals) are a source of diseases. If it is acceptable to massacre out of existence whole species of snails, that are part of malaria cycle, then destruction of forests in this is least concern.
- pvaldes 5y agoSnails aren't related with malaria, they are in the cycle of other diseases. In fact some snails could end helping us to treat malaria. If is acceptable to eliminate snails that cause diseases when they are alien species. South American snails shouldn't live in Egypt, for example.
- Bobylonian 5y agoSnails are part of lifecycle of parasite that is spreading malaria.
- pvaldes 5y ago> Snails are part of lifecycle of parasite that is spreading malaria. Hum... That claim sounds really strange to me. Plasmodium falciparum cycle has been thoroughly studied and it never mentions a snail. I think that you are confusing it with other organisms like Schistosoma (not even in the same Kingdom), but maybe is a recent discovery and I could be wrong. Can you share a link?
- Bobylonian 5y agoSadly, no. The one that I got information about those snails was YT video about eradicating some specific snails, to disrupt lifecycle of mosquitoes, as their larvae was living in these snails. I kinda feel regret(on other hand my regret is memory of having this extra information) that I have not saved link, because it was very long and very informative video and showed all the different issues, to do that task. I would highly recommend it to watch it, but you have to find it by yourself - may the RNG of YT is on your side in this task.
- atlasunshrugged 5y agoYeah, I think the problem is that we could pay for them to not cut trees but given the governance capacity, there is 0 question in my mind that logging would still happen, just totally illegally. I'm not 100% sold that governance = everything, but I think it does count for a lot. Plus, if not done well it'll just end up enriching the local elites like most aid does anyways (if you want a perfect example, look at Equatorial Guinea which lambasted wealthy countries at COP26 but whose former minister of forestry, and who I believe is related to the President, has a literal fleet of personal luxury cars... wonder how he got those?).