6 ms·
> under five minutes – about the same amount of time it takes to fill up a gas tank 'about' is doing some serious work there. Maybe it's on par with the entir
by Dylan16807 5y ago
> under five minutes – about the same amount of time it takes to fill up a gas tank
'about' is doing some serious work there. Maybe it's on par with the entire time spent at the gas station, but I'd say "under two minutes" is a better estimate of the actual transfer.
- unpolloloco 5y agoTwo minutes is shorter than most pumps I've been to recently (and seems to be the theoretical max fill rate). Seems stations are using one actual pump for multiple dispensers. Meaning that it takes more like 5 minutes to actually fill my car from empty. Also, there's the "good enough" argument - 5 minutes gets you to the point where there's no perceivable difference. 5 minute charging would be a game changer. That means urban dwellers could use EVs the same as gas engine cars and that road trips look exactly the same as they do now (presumably gas stations would add EV stations with enough market penetration). This cable isn't the big issue in making that happen, but it's needed. Battery chemistry and power distribution become factors at that point, but we're on the way to solving those issues too
- 0des 5y agoAre you perhaps from Europe where vehicles are smaller? Near me, larger trucks are most common, often with two fuel tanks.
- Dylan16807 5y agoNo, US. About a dozen gallons into the tank. But I bet the equivalent of a big two-tank truck will need significantly more than 5 minutes.
- maxerickson 5y agoAre those the folks waiting for electric stops to drop down under 10 minutes?
- jjcon 5y agoThe most popular truck in the US is the ford f150 which has a 26 gallon tank. The fill rate of gas stations is 10 gallons a minute in the USA (by law - they are capable of much faster fill rates). Even when only looking at trucks we are talking less than a 3 minute fill time for the vast majority of trucks. https://www.edmunds.com/ford/f-150/2021/features-specs/ https://www.edmunds.com/ford/f-150/2021/features-specs/ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gasoline_pump https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gasoline_pump
- masklinn 5y ago> The fill rate of gas stations is 10 gallons a minute in the USA (by law - they are capable of much faster fill rates). Surely there are “trucker pumps” in the US as well and 18-wheelers don’t have to fill at 10 gal? IIRC in Europe standard flow is 40L/mn (about the same as the US’ 10 gal) but high-flow pumps can to up to 200 or so (50 gal / mn).
- jjcon 5y agoYes there are trucker pumps in the USA and those have different fill rates - 10 gallons is just the consumer pump rate
- vel0city 5y agoThe fill rate of regular gas stations in the US is up to 10 gallons a minute. They're not going around and slapping fines if your pump is only pumping at 9 gallons per minute. I'm pretty certain most pumps around me aren't going exactly 10 gallons per minute, I'm often waiting 2+ minutes for 16 gallons of gas, but not every time.
- 0des 5y agoAn F150 is not what was being discussed, nor was 'the average american truck'. Generally in areas like this where the size is for the sake of utility and workload capacity, Super Duty (F250 and above) is the standard. You are not towing livestock or machinery with an F150 typically, or with any practicality. Just in the vicinity where I live, looking out my door, F350 is a common choice, with King Ranch being the preferred trim line due to its towing capacity.
- nharada 5y agoI don't know this feels functionally about right. Is there much of a difference between 2 minutes to fill up vs 5 minutes?
- JohnWhigham 5y agoYou're on HN; there's always going to be needless nitpicking and bikeshedding
- coolsunglasses 5y agoIf you're trying to get moving before your kids wake up, yes. A lot of children will sleep while the car is in motion but wake when it's stopped. This might sound trivial but when you've spent 50 hours over the course of two weeks in the car with kids I assure you it is not.
- Dylan16807 5y agoIt's not that much of a difference, but neither is 10 minutes. Yet the difference in technology to do 10 vs. 5 vs. 2 is pretty big.
- Mountain_Skies 5y agoThe electric charge up would take about twice as long as filling up with gasoline but in some cases that would be a good thing since you can leave an electric charging vehicle unattended while you go into the store or use the restroom. With gasoline you have to attend to the pumping operation the whole time. Neither is a huge use of one's time but being able to perform other tasks while refueling is a nice side benefit.
- gnicholas 5y agoDo most people go buy things or use the bathroom when filling up? If I am in my local area (where 95% of my fill-ups happen), I never do either. If I am on a road trip, there is a small chance (10%?) that I do one or the other. My main goal is to fill up and get going, but perhaps other people are different.
- Balero 5y agoOn road trips (driving for more than 2 hours), I almost always do. It's a good chance to have a break and stretch my legs. When I fill up in my local area I do it at the supermarket (which all have a petrol station attached where I am), so it's more that the shopping has a petrol re-fuel attached. Another time (pre-covid) I would fill up is on the commute. But the office had some charging points there.
- ars 5y ago> With gasoline you have to attend to the pumping operation the whole time. No you don't. ??? Why do you have to attend to it? Just use the trigger latch and let it fill. I mean you can't really just walk away anyway, because there's usually other people who want to fill up, but that would apply equally to electric.
- m-p-3 5y agoMost gas stations I've been at in Canada don't have latches.
- bryanlarsen 5y ago
- askvictor 5y ago'about' is fine here - it's in the same order of magnitude.
- jtbayly 5y agoEvery once in a while I do run into a pump that slow. In fact, it happened to me this morning. It was irritating, but tolerable.