4 ms·
What is "indeterminate form"? What does it mean for expression to "have a specific solution"? You see, 0^0 = 1, and it's obvious to a mathematician. The only p
by xyzzyz 15y ago
What is "indeterminate form"? What does it mean for expression to "have a specific solution"?
You see, 0^0 = 1, and it's obvious to a mathematician. The only problem is that the function f: [0, \infty) x R -> R, f(x, y) = x^y is discontinuous in (0, 0) and that's what causes problems -- for instance, this is the source of the whole "indeterminate form" notion. If a function f is continuous in (a, b), then for every two sequences a_n, b_n, such that lim a_n = a, lim b_n = b, we have lim f(a_n, b_n) = f(a, b). That's why lim (a_n)^(b_n) = a^b if (a, b) != (0, 0), and this is "determinate form". But if (a, b) = (0, 0), then no matter how we define 0^0, it does not follow that lim (a^n)^(b^n) = a^b = 0^0, because in this case, lim (a_n)^(b_n) can be every positive value, and so mathematicians used to call it "indeterminate form" (it's not common today, though). So, since this problem is unsolvable in a consistent (continuous) way, we define 0^0 = 1, to be consistent with exponentiation rules, at least.
I've never seen a need for an "intuitive" explanation of exponentiation -- the usual definition is as intuitive as one can get. The thing is, most people do not know, _why_ expressions like pi^e are supposed to make sense -- they just take exponentiation as given. Only then they need to make up some explanation why "exponentiation rules" are like this, and what exponentiation is about. Hell, people don't even know what real numbers are! How are they supposed to make sense of exponentiation with exponent other than natural number?
- Dove 15y agoWhat is "indeterminate form"? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indeterminate_form http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indeterminate_form You see, 0^0 = 1, and it's obvious to a mathematician . . . we define 0^0 = 1, to be consistent with exponentiation rules Well, you're going to be inconsistent with them no matter how you define it, since, as you point out, x^y should be zero if you approach (0,0) along the x=0 axis, and it should be one if you approach along the y=0 axis. 0^0 is simply an expression that doesn't make sense. There isn't an answer, and there certainly isn't something we could agree to define it as. It is gibberish, nothing more, nothing less. One cannot assume just because there are mathematical symbols on paper that they make sense.
- xyzzyz 15y agoBy "exponentiation rules" I mean algebraic equalities, like a^x * a^y = a^(x+y). Most of them work no matter if you define 0^0 = 1 or 0, but some of them are cleaner with 0^0 = 1. It's also consistent with cardinal and ordinal exponentiation (look it up). "Approaching along x axis" is not algebraic notion, it's analytic one. 0^0 makes no less sense than, say, -e^(i pi). They're both 1 because we define them like this. If you think that -e^(i pi) makes more sense than 0^0, please, explain me why. Also, mathematicians agree in this, seriously. Go and ask one.
- lotharbot 15y agoI haven't seen any reason why -e^(i pi)=1 could be considered incorrect. It's consistent with the Taylor Series expansion of e^x. It's consistent with the view of complex exponentiation as rotation. I don't know of any particular problems that arise from taking -e^(i pi)=1. This is not the case with 0^0=1, which is inconsistent with many limits. That's why 0^0=1 is an agreed-upon convention sometimes. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exponentiation#Zero_to_the_zero_power http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exponentiation#Zero_to_the_zero... has a fairly nice summary of the issues involved in defining it.
- xyzzyz 15y agoThis is not the case with 0^0=1, which is inconsistent with many limits. So what? It's only a problem if you want the exponentation function to be continuous, so you escape the problem by leaving it undefined. You could place similar unbased requirements on complex exponentiation to make it seem incorrect. For instance, real exponentiation always gives a positive value for positive base, while complex does not, so e^(i pi) = -1 is wrong. I agree that this is ridiculous requirement, but leaving 0^0 undefined because the math is not as we want it to be (e.g. exponentation is not continuous) looks just as ridiculous and silly to me. On the other hand, putting 0^0 = 1 makes it consistent many combinatoric formulas, and is also consistent with cardinal exponentation, where nobody objects to 0^0 = 1, when you look at 0 as the cardinal number.
- 15y ago
- joe_the_user 15y agoMathematicians don't argue about what an expression "really is" (or at least, real mathematics doesn't involve this). They define functions and use axioms to prove theories about them. "No really". Mathematics just isn't concerned with this stuff. Sometimes infinity it defined as single point making the real number compact, sometimes a "positive infinity" and a "negative infinity" are defined. Sometimes you add points to a given function to make it more tractable and sometimes you don't. But none of this "means" anything. The real number line can be embedded in a number of topological spaces. At least two division rings and various things (the complex numbers are most common). The way you extend a given function (say e^x) is going to vary depending on what space you're looking at as well as what topic you're interested in. Math works with definition systems and get theorems out of them. If you want to know what something "really is", consult philosophy or something.
- xyzzyz 15y agoAre you sure you're replying to right post? I ask, because nothing I see in yours can be seen as reply to mine -- it actually repeats my point.
- MetaMan 15y agojoe's reply clarified things somewhat - at least for me. Are replies always supposed to be rebuttals?
- xyzzyz 15y agoAre replies always supposed to be rebuttals? It turns out to be so. If a reply is not a rebuttal, it is usually preceded with something like "To clarify, ..." or "I wanted to add, that ...". I just got confused without it.
- joe_the_user 15y agoI felt the need to state what I thought was the case. Maybe originally it was a rebuttal but you don't disagree, feel free to take it as a clarification.
- DanielRibeiro 15y agoYes. Tying to define f(0) as 0 or 1 won't make it continuous, as approaching from the lines x = 0 and y = 0 will make the limits differ (the definition of lack of a limit).