5 ms·
I recall debating this with a dude who was into makeup and masks; he pointed out the blooms moved like rubber as the character runs; seemed pretty conclusive.
by h2odragon 5y ago
I recall debating this with a dude who was into makeup and masks; he pointed out the blooms moved like rubber as the character runs; seemed pretty conclusive.
I love how prosaic and simple some of their practical effects are; but the real accomplishment to me is how hard it is to pay attention to those details, to notice them; when everything flows so smoothly into captivating scenes.
- agumonkey 5y agoI remember rewatching T2 on computer after seeing stan winston studio showing props. The movie shows a lot of these physical props for very small frame numbers. Very hard to notice if you slow things down but at normal speed it just flows through the context of the scene. It's a minimal amount of detail that your brain needs to have to accept continuation. Probably a byproduct of the time.. can't CGI all the things so you have to optimize and find the best bang for your bucks in every dimension.
- jonathanlydall 5y agoReminds me of one New Years Eve party where Aliens was playing on the TV and a friend walks past and says "Watch Bishop's severed body now as he grabs Newt to stop her getting sucked out the air lock...", and clear as day you can see the lower part of the actors body come out a hole in the ground when he grabs Newt. I had probably seen the movie a dozen times before but never noticed it. In a similar vein, just after having watched X-Men 2 in a cinema a (different) friend who did CGI animation for a living pointed out that during the scene where Magneto moved the bridge, you can see that the shadows on the water don't move with the bridge. His theory was that the special effects team were likely completely aware, but looked at the amount of effort required and hoped no one would notice. I never noticed the problem myself until it was pointed out. I guess back then when special effects were monumentally difficult and computers weren't as capable as they are now, directors often relied on the audience's attention being elsewhere at that moment and thus being less likely to notice.
- noja 5y ago> and clear as day you can see the lower part of the actors body come out a hole in the ground Screencap: https://avp.fandom.com/wiki/Aliens_goofs?file=A2blactorholep1.jpg https://avp.fandom.com/wiki/Aliens_goofs?file=A2blactorholep... (fixed in the bluray) from https://avp.fandom.com/wiki/Aliens_goofs https://avp.fandom.com/wiki/Aliens_goofs
- RubberbandSoul 5y agoThere's a couple of those. The "caseless" ammo assult rifle is obviously ejecting spent casing in some scenes. The rotating light on top of the mecha suit loader is smashed when the queen drags it down into the airlock but is whole again once down in the pit.
- Crontab 5y ago> directors often relied on the audience's attention being elsewhere at that moment Your comment reminds me of this Raiders Of The Lost Ark scene: https://www.reddit.com/r/MovieDetails/comments/8u3aey/in_the_last_scene_of_the_chase_sequence_in/ https://www.reddit.com/r/MovieDetails/comments/8u3aey/in_the... I have to admit not noticing this for decades.
- beebeepka 5y agoHey. It's only hard because most movies are still a blurry 24 FPS mess. Look what happened to the Hobbit movies. I had a friend complaining more FPS suck because he was able to see makeup and everything else wrong with the movie. That's why certain directors don't want any advancements in this area. It will make their job a lot harder than it is now
- kadoban 5y agoIt's _mostly_ due to how human vision works really. Our visual system is good at focusing on certain parts, and the rest just gets elided unless you specifically focus on it. VFX are magic tricks put to film.
- wly_cdgr 5y agoThey are not a blurry 24 FPS mess. They are an efficient 24 FPS sweet spot
- kuschku 5y agoIn many movies, I just can’t see motion and the blurry mess becomes entirely impossible to see. Which is why I end up reading plot summaries on wikipedia instead. 24fps is far too low.
- mattowen_uk 5y agoThe blurry mess of fast CGI is NOT down to the 24fps problem. As the action is so fast, it's faster to render complex scenes in lower detail CGI as the eye (mostly) can't see it. However if you pause the action, you can clearly see where the rendering shortcuts have been made (The Transformers movies are a good example of this).
- kuschku 5y agoI'm not just talking about CGI, even e.g. taking my own a6300 and recording a moving scene has this effect (even with the 180° shutter rule). It's just as choppy as 24Hz at 1/1600 shutter, but in traditional film, it's choppy and blurry due to the slow shutter, so I can barely see anything. For quite se time I'd run upscalers to pre process all movies I was watching to 60Hz or 75Hz just because it was noticeably easier to watch.
- Someone 5y ago> he pointed out the blooms moved like rubber as the character runs; seemed pretty conclusive. Is it? If we could build such robots, they would be plastic. Any holes shot into them wouldn’t be rigid, and would deform when they moved. Or are you saying “moved like rubber” obviously looks different from whatever way the stuff this robot is supposed to be made of would move?
- h2odragon 5y ago"Moved unlike CGI" is what i meant.