12 ms·
tl;dr: Vaccination status correlates with a 13x reduction of infection risk and a 20x reduction of death risk. Now, to be clear that's a confounded number. Th
by ajross 5y ago
tl;dr: Vaccination status correlates with a 13x reduction of infection risk and a 20x reduction of death risk.
Now, to be clear that's a confounded number. The vaccinated are also likely to be taking other mitigation strategies seriously. So the vaccine itself will be somewhat less effective than this.
Nonetheless, this is pretty damning for the horse paste set. In decades to come we'll wonder and think and study how this all went so horrifically wrong.
- dehrmann 5y ago> Now, to be clear that's a confounded number. It's also confounded by urban vs rural. All else being equal, I'd expect rural people are less likely to get it because they interact with fewer people. So...confounded, very. Which direction? No clue.
- el_benhameen 5y agoFair to assume those confounding factors. I’m trying to think of things that might confound in the opposite direction. I believe vaccinated people skew older and therefore higher risk of reduce vaccine efficacy, infection, and severe illness. Anything else?
- nradov 5y agoThis data wasn't a random sample so we can't use it to quantify the difference in risk of infection.
- FabHK 5y agoWe can't assume that there are no biases, but we can certainly use it to quantify the difference. ETA: And, if someone now wants to argue that the vaccine does not work, they will have to come up with a plausible 20x confounder. Which in itself would be quite an achievement.
- gurleen_s 5y ago> The vaccinated are also likely to be taking other mitigation strategies seriously. It may not be the case in Texas, but I’d imagine the vaccinated are at equal or even greater risk than the unvaccinated because they are able to do more (attending events, school, etc).
- walterbell 5y ago> In decades to come we'll wonder and think and study how this all went so horrifically wrong. Hopefully we will investigate why almost all (rare) deaths after vaccination can be attributed to only 5% of lot numbers, a statistical anomaly with no easy explanation since this power-law curve appears in the data for both mRNA (Pfizer, Moderna) and non-mRNA (J&J) shots. Could the reason be variance in manufacturing or distribution?
- ohazi 5y agoSource?
- walterbell 5y agoOfficial VAERS data. Anyone can download the data and perform the analysis after importing into a SQL database. Since someone is inevitably going to criticize VAERS as a data source: it would be trivial for CDC to release a comparable non-VAERS analysis from Vaccine Safety Datalink, their non-public surveillance dataset. While VAERS is flawed due to self-reporting, there are legal penalties for submitting false information, no legal penalties for failing to submit an adverse event report, and bureaucratic and time overhead for each submitted case. So there are also arguments that VAERS is missing data.
- belltaco 5y ago>there are legal penalties for submitting false information It's never enforced.
- ajross 5y agoVAERS data is raw, is not a controlled study (it's literally just a collection of voluntary reports), has minimal data quality control, and includes all cause deaths. It's what you use to find crumbs worth study, not what you use to drive conspiracy theories on the internet. Basically, if you aren't an epidemiologist don't touch that stuff, it isn't for you. That's the equivalent of announcing you can land a plane because you played MSFS in the 90's.
- jraby3 5y agoIncredible how effective it is for people in their 40s. 55x is astounding.
- postingawayonhn 5y ago> The vaccinated are also likely to be taking other mitigation strategies seriously. It could also be true that vaccinated people are willing to take greater risks now that they knowingly have a level of protection.
- nielsbot 5y agoAnecdote: I personally feel more comfortable eating at restaurants after being vaccinated. A little, but more.
- votepaunchy 5y agoSomeone who is unvaccinated most likely never felt uncomfortable eating at a restaurant.
- pas 5y agoThere's a big crowd that just fears "big pharma" but also the virus too.
- majou 5y agoThis doesn't give enough credit to a lot of people who are simply wary about what goes into their body. The vaccines aren't risk-free; the damage of covid looks plainly to be orders of magnitude worse, but papering over any potential risk of vaccines is doing everything a disservice. Getting people inoculated is important, but the chilling effects of this kind of short-circuiting is worrisome. Lots of people are pro-mask, pro-mask-mandate, and still wary about the vaccine.
- ajross 5y agoThat's mixing up data sets. The "unvaccinated" of today (dominated by those who have refused the vaccine) aren't the same population of last April (people without access to a vaccine they want), to which you belonged. The latter were wearing their masks and being cautious. The former clearly aren't. While they're both "unvaccinated" they don't have the same behavior here.
- sennight 5y ago> In decades to come we'll wonder and think and study how this all went so horrifically wrong. lol, it might take decades to massage public consciousness for a desired outcome in the state's interest, but it certainly doesn't take that long to get a handle on the actual issues: institutions used up all their credibility on transparently obvious misinformation. It started with the WHO, an organization already hurting in that regard (Mugabe the goodwill ambassador... hard to top that kind of contempt), misrepresenting their Wuhan fact finding efforts. Then you had US politicians calling early efforts xenophobic and encouraging people to gather in chinatown to stick it to the racists, followed by the CDC saying masks weren't effective, before they were, and then weren't - and then double-masking. All while the stats were clearly going screwy, people suddenly stopped dying of anything but covid - the long running influenza tracking efforts were halted (or announced, but then reversed?)... oh, and obviously George Floyd tested positive. Mentions of "herd immunity" were scrubbed from the CDC's site, and the word "vaccine" redefined. So that is what went wrong: you can't expect appeals to authority to work when the authorities have seemingly gone out of their way to present themselves as liars who are trying to manipulate you by any means available to them.
- ajmurmann 5y agoYou call out a lot of unfortunate communication missteps. What are you referring to though with redefining the word vaccine?
- angelzen 5y agoBoth: "Immunity: Protection from an infectious disease. If you are immune to a disease, you can be exposed to it without becoming infected." Before: "Vaccine: A product that stimulates a person’s immune system to produce immunity to a specific disease, protecting the person from that disease. Vaccines are usually administered through needle injections, but can also be administered by mouth or sprayed into the nose." After: "Vaccine: A preparation that is used to stimulate the body’s immune response against diseases. Vaccines are usually administered through needle injections, but some can be administered by mouth or sprayed into the nose." http://web.archive.org/web/20210826113846/https://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/vac-gen/imz-basics.htm http://web.archive.org/web/20210826113846/https://www.cdc.go... https://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/vac-gen/imz-basics.htm https://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/vac-gen/imz-basics.htm
- throwawaysea 5y ago> Nonetheless, this is pretty damning for the horse paste set. Look I agree that vaccines confer a reduction in risk, but you really shouldn't be referring to ivermectin as “horse paste”. That is clearly pejorative misinformation, and is equivalent to calling all antibiotics “cow pills” just because there happen to be antibiotics administered to livestock.
- ajross 5y agoNo, sorry. People were literally taking horse paste formulations of a drug that did not work. That's not perjorative, it's descriptive. It sounds perjorative simply because it's outrageously stupid. But it's correct. Being embarrassed when someone calls you an idiot isn't being persecuted if you're actually being an idiot. If you don't want me to laugh at you for taking horse paste then don't take it.
- throwawaysea 5y agoA couple comments: first, you know full well that your comment is aimed at everyone who considered use of ivermectin, not just “horse paste formulations” - rebranding ivermectin that way was part of the misinformation pushed by CNN and a significant portion of the political left as the COVID culture wars heated up, and it remains wrong still. Ivermectin is correctly described as a Nobel prize winning drug, not “horse paste”. Second, a big reason some people resorted to those particular formulations is because politically biased pharmacy workers were refusing to fill prescriptions people legitimately got from their doctor, which again was a result of the COVID culture war pushed by people calling ivermectin “horse paste”. Third, tone down your aggression. Not only is it inappropriate for this place, but it just weakens your argument further.
- 8note 5y agoIt's properly described as a Nobel winning treatment for parasites like worms. Saying drug is a bit vague, and you lose the same plot as calling it horse paste. It's not some cure all, appointed by the nobels as good for all your ailments
- throwaway829 5y agoCNN/MSNBC have misinformed you about Ivermectin. Do you think the inventors would get a Nobel Prize if it was just for horses? Advil is also used for horses but we don't misinform people and call it pain killer for horses. The new Pfizer drug, with 89% efficacy, is a protease inhibitor targeting 3CLPro. Ivermectin seems to also work as a protease inhibitor targeting 3CLPro. Repurposing a drug that we know is safe means it came be deployed very rapidly. New and unknown drugs can take years before all side effects are known. If anyone is interested in hearing an informed opinion on Ivermectin check out Dr. John Campbell: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ufy2AweXRkc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ufy2AweXRkc
- dboreham 5y agoUnfortunately John Campbell has gone to the dark side a few months ago and no longer presents unbiased science.
- josephcsible 5y agoIt sounds a lot like you're saying "this scientist used to say things I agree with, but now he says things I disagree with, so you should ignore him now."
- joeman1000 5y agoSo many people make appeals to ‘science’ as if it’s some big monolith hanging in the sky. This is the first article I’ve come across that isn’t just a qualitative piece of propaganda designed to scare me. I appreciate actual statistics and ‘science’ that I can investigate. I’m a trained scientist and I’m struggling to find proper analyses that I can read with regards to this vaccine. Every time I hear a politician tell me “you have to be vaccinated because you have to be vaccinated” it just pisses me off so much. I try to be rational, and I can’t make a decision just because I’m scared. Give me the science and statistics please leaders!
- ajross 5y ago> CNN/MSNBC have misinformed you about Ivermectin. Are you saying people were not taking veterinary formulations of this drug (for which there is zero evidence of efficacy) without a prescription or any kind of supervision beyond what they read on Facebook? Because that's the takeaway I got. Again, at some point we're all going to have a big reckoning as to why this kind of discourse you're engaging in became so prevalent. It's not like we don't have an idea how to manage or understand infectious diseases. The linked article is about an extraordinarily effective control mechanism. Yet... horse paste. (And people on HN trying to defend horse paste as anything other than sheer idiocy by citing research they don't understand and that isn't even correct.)
- dang 5y agoYou set off a hellish flamewar with that swipe, and then you perpetuated it worse (by far) than any other commenter in this thread). That's egregiously against the site guidelines. You unfortunately have a long history of doing this and we've had to ask you multiple times, going back years, to stop. Seriously not cool. We ban accounts that do this. If you don't want to be banned, please don't do anything like this again—not just your root comment here, but your many other aggressive comments in this thread. In fact it seems like every single one of the 10 comments you posted to this thread has badly broken the site guidelines. That sort of spree is beyond bannable offense. I don't want to ban you, so please restrain yourself from doing this in the future. No matter how right you are or feel you are, no matter how wrong other people are or you feel they are, it is not ok to destroy the ecosystem like this. I'm sure you wouldn't set fires in a dry forest or in a public building, so please don't set them here. And please don't pour fuel or throw additional flammables in there either. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html p.s. Lest anyone misunderstand this as somehow cryptically taking the other side of the argument—I'm not. I'm simply concerned with preventing users from burning this place down. It doesn't matter what color the flames are.
- ajross 5y agoYou've editted that comment a number of times trying to explain why you flagged my top comment. Maybe... the initial comment wasn't actually all that bad? "Horse paste" really isn't a "swipe". It is a term used in exasperation for sure, but it is indeed a correct term for the drug preparation and how it was used by the community eating it. I'll take the hit on the responses, though. It's very hard to leave things like that alone, but I'll try.
- dang 5y agoThe initial comment was definitely that bad. Horse paste was obviously a swipe (what the HN guidelines refer to as calling names), and an inflammatory provocation. This has been a classic flamewar topic for some time now. The flamewar was entirely predictable. I compulsively edit everything I write - sorry if that was confusing. And thanks for the kind reply—I appreciate it, and believe me I know how hard it is.