2 ms·
> I don't understand why America, long a champion of immigration, doesn't open the floodgates back up. The US is not, and has never been, a champion of immigra
by kelnos 5y ago
> I don't understand why America, long a champion of immigration, doesn't open the floodgates back up.
The US is not, and has never been, a champion of immigration. Immigration has been seen as "people taking our jobs" pretty much since the founding of the country. Immigration has always been tolerated as a "necessary evil" by policymakers.
> We could onshore factories and staff them from all over the world. Pay workers wages comparable to what they would get from working in factories at home (ie. not "US wages" since we can't compete on cost with China, Vietnam, etc.), but give them decent hours, a housing stipend, education for their kids, and a promise of US citizenship. Also offer them courses on American culture, English, etc. "Melting pot" rather than unsupported labor. We could make it really comfortable and attractive.
Where does all the money for that come from, though? Existing citizens will not tolerate the tax hikes. And if the companies are paying "home country" wages, the people who come here won't have any purchasing power. You're basically importing poverty if you do that, and are creating a weird hybrid of a "company town" system, which we know leads to abuse and exploitation.
> To keep natural born citizens from getting angry, we can offer tax incentives for people having children. We can pay kids $20/week to study and get good grades (not a bad idea - it especially incentivizes poorer kids!).
I don't think these suggestions are politically feasible. Many of the people who hate immigration would also see a bunch of that stuff as "welfare" and "handouts" and wouldn't want it.
- seanmcdirmid 5y ago> The US is not, and has never been, a champion of immigration. Immigration has been seen as "people taking our jobs" pretty much since the founding of the country. Immigration has always been tolerated as a "necessary evil" by policymakers. That isn’t true at all, if only because the US isn’t some homogenous being with one opinion. Immigration as a “necessary evil” is still pro immigration, vs a place like China where getting even a green card if you aren’t Han requires an act of god.