10 ms·
Campagnolo's revolutionary new gearing system from 1946
- trhway 5y ago>The very founder of the Tour de France bicycle event himself, Henri Desgrange, deplored such technology. “I still feel that variable gears are only for people over forty-five,” he said. “Isn’t it better to triumph by the strength of your muscles than by the artifice of a derailleur? We are getting soft. Come on, fellows.” In my teen-age years in 198x USSR i, like pretty much everybody there back then, had a fixie because "sport" bicycle with gears cost double (64 vs. 130 rubles with engineer salary being 200), and i envied the lucky few "sport" owners especially when i had to cycle my fixie uphill :). Now living in US I was really surprised how fixies became the trend as supposedly being superior to the gears.
- spamizbad 5y agoThe irony is that a version of this exists today: Lance Armstrong teased Chris Froome's larger rear cassette (Froome used lower ratios on climbs to maintain a higher pedaling cadence)
- angled 5y agoAt the mere cost of destroying your knees…
- Lio 5y agoNot necessarily "better", just different. There is no one bike that will excel in all conditions. If you live somewhere relatively flat then trading off the flexibility for the reliability, low cost and light weight of a dérailleur free gearing system might be worth it. Same goes for hub gears. You trade heavier weight and efficiency for not having the gear box exposed. Personally I like the rang of a compact crank and a double up front when on tarmac or gravel and a 1x when on single track but that's just me.
- jacquesm 5y agoIt's a fashion statement, nothing more than that. Like a towel, when a man has a fixed gear bicycle others will immediately assume the presence of expendable income, a recent model iPhone, a loft apartment and a high bandwidth connection.
- TremendousJudge 5y agoI'm told fixed gear bicycles are very fun to ride as well
- rhinoceraptor 5y agoIt's like the difference between driving a manual transmission versus driving an automatic. You're way more connected to the machine, especially when you're out in the country where it's quiet, because fixed gears are a lot quieter than normal bikes. There are a lot of cliches people use to describe it, but you just kind of have to experience it to get it.
- jacquesm 5y agoIt's the difference between driving a regular car and one without a gearbox, brakes and clutch, in other words, not something suitable for use in traffic.
- rhinoceraptor 5y agoWhat makes you think riding a fixed gear bike is unsuitable for traffic?
- jacquesm 5y agoBikes without brakes are illegal in traffic where I live, and rightly so, I'm a long time bike enthusiast and these fashion statements are downright dangerous, both to the rider as well as to other users of the roads. That it even needs to be pointed out that operating any vehicle without brakes is unsuitable for traffic is a bit strange to me, but there you go.
- suprfnk 5y ago> Furthermore, from our calculations, this is the most advanced a racing bicycle will ever be or can ever be. The very nature of the 1/8″ wide sprockets means four is the maximum one freehub can carry. Ah, the "640k ought to be enough for anybody" of the bicycling world. These days you can get 13 speed on the back derailleur alone -- not even taking into account the front derailleur.
- xchaotic 5y agoyup - even Campagnolo's own EKAR is 1x13
- devb 5y agoThat was written to be tongue in cheek. This is not actually copy written in the 1940s. > this is to be enjoyed and imagined, not taken for fact. Read with a speedy wartime radio advert voice.
- stefs 5y agoone of the more recent developments is combining a rear derailleur with a internal gear hub (both electronically and wirelessly shifted) and a single front chainring. some upsides, some downsides, but definitely something to watch.
- mcntsh 5y agoActually, internal gear hubs predate the derailer system, but in the past 20 years IGHs have gotten much better and are making a come back.
- stefs 5y agoyes, i meant combining an IGH with a rear derailer (instead of a front derailer). afaik there's only one supplier of those currently (and the system is a bit half-baked, i.e. no DI2 compatibility for reusing the existing shifters).
- hocuspocus 5y agoThe biggest issue is the complexity, weight and poor efficiency compared to a derailleur. And also fewer and unevenly graded gears, though that's probably less true with Pinion hubs. It's not that hard to avoid shifting under heavy load (higher-end IGHs shift fine under some load). And on a commuter bike, being able to shift gears at a standstill is great. Edit: you completely changed the content of your message and my reply doesn't make a lot of sense now.
- Lio 5y agoGino Bartali, mentioned in the article, has the most amazing back story. He used his bike training to smuggle secret documents for the Italian Resistance and was awarded Righteous Among the Nations for helping Jews escape the Nazis. Like many he stayed quite about his wartime exploits and was only recognised for them after his death. A quite remarkable man.
- gpderetta 5y agoThanks for the pointer, I did not know about that. From his wiki page: "The good is done, but it is not said. And certain medals hang on the soul, not on the jacket".
- ubermonkey 5y agoMy two favorite largely unknown cycling stories from history are (1) this one and (b) the story of Major Taylor.
- 1-more 5y agoI'm in the middle of The Fastest Man in the World about Taylor right now. It's a gripping read, and it does a lot to tie in the politics of the era, what the bicycle boom meant for New York before the advent of the personal car, and the wider ripple effects of the bicycle boom such as on the Free State of the Congo. My fun fact about Taylor is this: In November 1898 he set a world record 1/4 mile time at 22.2s averaging 40.5 mph. The earliest land speed record by a car that I could find (on wikipedia so I'm not that thorough) was set by an electric car(!) on Dec 18 1898 at 39.245 mph. So he threw down a gauntlet and a month later cars failed to pick it up. A hero in the war on cars.
- usrusr 5y ago> and was only recognised for them after his death. Yeah, that was a painful day when you considered yourself a Coppist ;) "damn, turns out the other guy was even more awesome!"
- Lio 5y ago
- freediver 5y agoAlso back in the day, bicycles didn't have the freehub on the read wheel, so going downhill meant you always had to turn pedals to match wheel speed, no exception, you couldn't just stop and idle like today. Proud owner of a Campagnolo groupset on a custom made bicycle, wanted it for heritage reasons.
- Lio 5y agoThis is how track bikes work. It's quite a shock the first time you go to a velodrome if you've never ridden one before.
- xchaotic 5y agoalso proper fixie/messenger bikes. I used to use one when commuting in London, due to low price it was relatively unattractive to bike thieves and it was very simple to maintain - no brakes, no gears (you had to skid/backpedal to stop quickly)
- sleavey 5y agoDidn't they get banned or there was a campaign to ban them after someone was killed by someone riding a fixie, in London?
- andylynch 5y agoYou're probably thinking of Charle Alliston who killed someone on Old St and got 18 months for it - to be road legal, fixed-gear bikes must still have a front brake, and have at least since the fifties, A fixed gear counts as a back brake but you must have two for redundancy.
- xchaotic 5y agoThis. Most cyclist fatalities in London are caused by Heavy Good Vehicles illegally overtaking and then turning and therefore trapping the poor cyclist in the blind spot. Nothing to do with the wheel hub design or bicycle braking system.
- top_sigrid 5y agoWhile this is amazing, I keep wondering, why - even though in the 1940s - they didn't come up with the idea of a chain tensioner to compensate for different sprocket sizes. Instead they used this wheel suspension quick release mechanism which needed to be operated while driving, which just seems insane. Weren't chain propelled systems a thing in other machines back then and a chain tensioner a known solution? Or were they just not suitable for a bike back then for some reason? Does anybody know something about this?
- jzwinck 5y agoIt's because there was no freewheel. A chain tensioner only works well when there is driving force applied in one direction, not the other. Put any force backward into the pedals (e.g. to slow down) and the tensioner will be forced to its most slack position (or broken off).
- top_sigrid 5y agoOk, this makes perfectly sense and is actually quite easy to understand. Thanks from a mechanical noob.
- mauvehaus 5y agoThe article describes it as four sprockets on a freehub. One would hope that cyclingtips.com would get that fairly material detail correct. It also mentions the rider having to pedal backwards to shift the chain among the sprockets. That would not be possible on a fixed hub without slowing to a stop and reversing. One suspects that would rather negate any benefits of this system over a flip-flop wheel.
- jzwinck 5y agoThe freehub was not invented for another 30 years. But I see that the Cambio Corsa did have a freewheel (similar idea). I was wrong to think it used four fixed gears. So indeed it could have used a chain tensioner! Video showing it in action (skip to the middle): https://youtu.be/MQe0fLEQ2jY https://youtu.be/MQe0fLEQ2jY
- danw1979 5y ago> Early indications suggest the highly complex and somewhat controversial system consists of two levers mounted on the rear of the frame. The longer of these two levers operates the rear wheel quick-release retention mechanism. The shorter lever guides the bicycle chain across a revolutionary four sprocket cluster on the rear freehub. An interestingly early example of a dangerous “dark UI”.
- jjt-yn_t 5y agobicycle [expense] [luxury] phrase from the 1970s: "full campy"
- lonelyasacloud 5y agoGiven the UCI's normal pace of innovation it's somewhat surprising that pro cyclists aren't still stuck with this.
- jacquesm 5y agoTwo words: disc brakes.
- TremendousJudge 5y agoI'm pretty sure that they don't run disc brakes because they are too heavy
- kevin_thibedeau 5y agoThey do run disc brakes because it's been forced on everybody. The weight is irrelevant when you already have to find ways to make the bike heavy enough to meet the minimum limit.
- lonelyasacloud 5y ago"The weight is irrelevant when you already have to find ways to make the bike heavy enough to meet the minimum limit." Exactly, and the minimum weight limitation comes from :-)
- gerbilly 5y agoAlso disc brakes can give you brake fade. I have a hydraulic disc with a 203mm rotor, and even that huge disk sometimes fades on long descents.
- walrus01 5y agoThe advantage of disc brakes on the medium to high end consumer road bike, however, is that you wear out the cheap and consumable pads and rotor, not the rims on what might be a $2000-by-itself 700c wheelset. the large bike manufacturer sponsors of the pro teams of course want their team to ride the equipment that they're selling to consumers as the current and next model year. or at least something that very closely resembles it and sells for $2500+ at retail. look at how many trek carbon fiber madones were sold to enthusiastic amateurs during the peak armstrong years.
- jacquesm 5y ago'Cambio Corsa' -> exchange while on the course, in case you were wondering. The lack of idler gears is the interesting part because that makes this a very efficient system. Once it is in a particular gear there is no difference between just having the one gear other than a little bit of extra weight. Derailleurs with idler gears were already in use in the TDF long before this. The lack of a detent before the rear wheel can drop out would give me the willies about operating this system at any speed, you are supposed to peddle forward while changing the gear to a smaller gear ratio (larger rear gear), and backwards when gearing 'up' to maintain constant chain tension. Modern idlers are quite efficient, but back then the materials science that allowed both a light weight idler wheel yet strong enough and friction free to be 'in play' all the time wasn't really there yet, derailleur itself had been invented decades ago. But that didn't take all that long though, a few years later technology had caught up. See: https://www.velonews.com/gear/road-gear/how-tour-de-france-embraced-derailleurs/ https://www.velonews.com/gear/road-gear/how-tour-de-france-e... Which I think is a much better article on the subject. https://www.disraeligears.co.uk/site/who_invented_the_derailleur.html#Derailleurs https://www.disraeligears.co.uk/site/who_invented_the_derail...
- Cockbrand 5y agoBicycle gear shifting technology has come a long way since then, with very reliable, even electronic systems. But we're still messing with dirty, grubby chains that need to be maintained properly and are worn out after 5000km at best. I think that the bicycle drivetrain is quite rife for disruption. Someone has yet to solve the problem of efficiency - a new drivetrain is supposed to have less than 1% power loss. But a new concept could really change the entire industry, and it's quite a big industry.
- 1-more 5y agoI just waxed my chain this morning. I hear it makes you way less prone to picking up road grit. Will report back.
- 1-more 5y agoWhy aren't chains sold with wax on them?? This is so much better!!
- top_sigrid 5y agoTotally agree. Drive belts are becoming a thing more and more, which I would deem to be a disruption. Far less maintainence is needed, no oil involved, no chain links, they last way longer than chains etc. But these obviously only work on single speeds or enclosed-gear hubs. For derailleur-style gearing a change away from chains with the properties you described would actually really be a good thing, although I do not see it coming. With regards to power loss, chains get better and better, though.
- jgys 5y agoThey also only work with frames that have been specially designed to allow fitting a belt, as I understand it. Chains can be easily broken and joined in the shop (or even on the roadside), but not so with belts, so the frame must come apart to get the belt going through the rear triangle, which substantially complicates frame building and design. I don't mean to suggest this tradeoff isn't worthwhile to people who want clean, low-maintenance bicycle drivetrains for working or commuting, but the extra cost of manufacturing makes it harder to persuade cost-conscious consumers.
- CalChris 5y agoMy favorite modern shifting tech is SRAM's Force 22 Yaw front derailleur. Well ok, index shifting is there too. Yaw rotates the front derailleur cage slightly as you shift rings. This keeps the cage inline with the chainline and makes for a quiet FD with no trimming necessary. It's supposed to be Force 22 specific but I have SRAM SL700 2x10 and Shimano 105 10s cranks on that bike. I installed it but then had my LBS adjust it. It is the first FD I've ever had that I like.
- usrusr 5y agoPardon the climb nerd-out, but about that historical photo that claims to show Bartali climbing Galibier in the 1948 Tour de France: the horizon line in the background doesn't strike me as any you could see on the Galibier ascent. And according to that year's stage plan, Galibier was the first climb of the day and you'll have a hard time finding any spot in the climb were the rider would climb left to right through a view like that with the morning from that angle.
- prova_modena 5y agoI own a late 40s Italian bicycle equipped with Cambio Corsa. It's now a display piece because I don't want to maintain the glued on tubular tires or risk breaking something irreplaceable. However in the past I have taken it out on a couple short, flat rides to test the system, enough to make a couple observations about using it. When changing gears, it doesn't feel like there is much risk of the wheel slipping forward out of the dropouts. The dropouts themselves are angled up and back, which helps prevent that. Also, when changing gears you are sitting back, putting weight on the seat and changing the weight distribution of the bike to favor the rear. This also counteracts the tendency of the wheel to come forward. The action of the chain only pulls the axle forward in the dropouts when shifting to a lower gear (higher tooth count cog on the freewheel, closer to the wheel spokes). There isn't much risk of "overshifting" the chain to a point where it will pull the axle out of the dropouts, simply because the chain would just contact the spokes or a spoke protector and slide back down into gear (unless something is really broken). Also, you can see from the photos in the article how differently the dimensions of racing bicycle frames were fitted to riders back then. Modern racing bikes tend to have a lot of seatpost extension and longer handlebar stems, which shift the rider's weight forward on the bike. A simplified explanation is that this improves aerodynamics and certain handling characteristics, at the cost of requiring the rider have better core strength and flexibility. In contrast, the photos in the article show typical mid-20th century bicycle fit, with much less seatpost extension and shorter stems. Compared to modern racers, Coppi and Bartali sit father back, with their butt closer to the top tube. This puts the Cambio Corsa system in closer reach and the weight distribution has a more stable, rearward bias. The action of reaching back to change gears would feel treacherous and destabilizing on a modern racing bike, but would be a bit more comfortable on the bikes of the time. This is all said with the big caveat that I have never ridden my Cambio Corsa bike in a long distance or competitive scenario. Undoubtedly it's still a challenging system to master. I can imagine the extreme difficulty of operating it on the unpaved, bumpy climbs typical of that era. Edit: Here is a link to scans of the original patent drawings for the Cambio Corsa. It shows the mechanical details- click on the "Pages" tab to see all the scanned pages of the patent. https://www.disraeligears.co.uk/site/french_patent_899402_-_campagnolo.html https://www.disraeligears.co.uk/site/french_patent_899402_-_...
- jamesfisher 5y agoYet another website to add the user-scalable=0 sin bin