6 ms·
I don't understand why America, long a champion of immigration, doesn't open the floodgates back up. We could onshore factories and staff them from all over th
by echelon 5y ago
I don't understand why America, long a champion of immigration, doesn't open the floodgates back up.
We could onshore factories and staff them from all over the world. Pay workers wages comparable to what they would get from working in factories at home (ie. not "US wages" since we can't compete on cost with China, Vietnam, etc.), but give them decent hours, a housing stipend, education for their kids, and a promise of US citizenship. Also offer them courses on American culture, English, etc. "Melting pot" rather than unsupported labor. We could make it really comfortable and attractive.
To incentivize business, we could offer zero taxes over the next fifty years to run factories domestically. Start with the critical pieces, and then build everything.
Growing beyond 300M would also dramatically increase our consumer base.
To keep natural born citizens from getting angry, we can offer tax incentives for people having children. We can pay kids $20/week to study and get good grades (not a bad idea - it especially incentivizes poorer kids!). We can also grant credits for kids that excel in math/science, music/art, sports/club, etc. Keep them engaged and growing.
- markdown 5y agoThis sort of radical idea just can't get off the ground in the US two-party system. It would be too risky to invest in something so controversial that it could be reversed in less than four years.
- someperson 5y agoOK so you get 50 million people from Africa, India and other parts of Asia. Then what? What if half choose to immediately move to New York or Los Angeles to find a better job? Are you planning on keeping the 50 million factory workers imprisoned as second-class citizens in mid-West factories for the first 5 years? 10 years?
- zeusk 5y agoisn't that what H1B does? Tie a person to their employer?
- guidedlight 5y agoYou’re solution sounds similar to what places like Dubai are known for. i.e. Paying foreign impoverished wages in a wealthy country in exchange for work, housing, etc. Companies generally have a poor track record of investing in their employees.
- 0xy 5y agoBecause the US didn't have a giant welfare system when the 'floodgates' were open. Immigrants moved to New York or other places, and worked exceptionally hard to provide for themselves or were forced to return home. Now, they can move to San Francisco and have the city spend thousands of dollars on them for free. It's nearly impossible to starve on US streets today, because there's free food on nearly every street. This fact naturally attracts low intelligence economic migrants who don't have the conscientiousness or work ethic of early New York immigrants. We've seen it in Europe. The vast majority of the migrants (who settled in the places with the best welfare systems, not the closest safe country) do not work and do not contribute to society. There's also evidence they push crime up, as well as having values that are fundamentally illiberal (for example, wanting to criminalize homosexuality and supporting terrorist groups).
- vagrantJin 5y agoThis is a hilarious comment. Granted this forum has an over-abundance of the so-called academic elite and so phrases like "low intelligence" and "work ethic" can be passed around with impunity. But what I cant look past is the audacity to suggest and eveb imply that historical migrants from Europe(mostly) worked hard and had some magically higher IQ. What? If even the academic elite, who pride themselves in their rational objectivity, can whitewash history to that extent - it is worrisome. Truly frightening. Just chalk it up to being the worlds pop cultural, economic center - and deal with it. People have always migrated to the country/state where the opportunity to prosper is greatest. It's osmosis and you can't really stop it until and unless the US becomes a third world country devoid of wealth, freedom and opportunity.
- 0xy 5y agoEuropeans do have a higher average IQ than places like Sudan which has an average IQ in the 70 range. To put this in perspective, the US Army generally doesn't accept people below 85 IQ because they are ineffective in any position (yes, they are considered inadequate to be a janitor). You also didn't address my point about values or crime, both of which are proven. Particularly, some immigrant groups have huge portions of support for groups like ISIS. [1] That's before we get into the homophobia and abuse of women. [1] https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2017/08/09/muslims-and-islam-key-findings-in-the-u-s-and-around-the-world/ https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2017/08/09/muslims-and...
- arcticbull 5y ago> I don't understand why America, long a champion of immigration, doesn't open the floodgates back up. America has never been a champion of immigration, and honestly I don't really remember a time that the 'floodgates were open' so to speak, and it's not even a partisan issue. The last major immigration tightening was Bill Clinton with IIRAIRA in 1996 while the last amnesty was Reagan in 1986. Don't take my word for it, here's what Benjamin Franklin, founding father, had to say. "Those who come hither are generally of the most ignorant Stupid Sort of their own Nation, and as Ignorance is often attended with Credulity when Knavery would mislead it, and with Suspicion when Honesty would set it right; and as few of the English understand the German Language, and so cannot address them either from the Press or Pulpit, ’tis almost impossible to remove any prejudices they once entertain." - Benjamin Franklin, 1753. Tell me that's not a highfalutin 1700s take on "they're not sending their best, folks." > We could onshore factories and staff them from all over the world. That doesn't need people, it needs robots. The factories of the future have zero people inside.
- tasogare 5y ago> America has never been a champion of immigration 97.91% of US citizens have immigrant ancestors, if that's not championing immigration nothing is.
- arcticbull 5y agoImmigrants have a way of wanting to close the door as soon as they get through it. For sure after the first wave, even if nobody else had been allowed in, you could still wind up with the same percentage of folks with immigrant ancestors.
- kelnos 5y ago> I don't understand why America, long a champion of immigration, doesn't open the floodgates back up. The US is not, and has never been, a champion of immigration. Immigration has been seen as "people taking our jobs" pretty much since the founding of the country. Immigration has always been tolerated as a "necessary evil" by policymakers. > We could onshore factories and staff them from all over the world. Pay workers wages comparable to what they would get from working in factories at home (ie. not "US wages" since we can't compete on cost with China, Vietnam, etc.), but give them decent hours, a housing stipend, education for their kids, and a promise of US citizenship. Also offer them courses on American culture, English, etc. "Melting pot" rather than unsupported labor. We could make it really comfortable and attractive. Where does all the money for that come from, though? Existing citizens will not tolerate the tax hikes. And if the companies are paying "home country" wages, the people who come here won't have any purchasing power. You're basically importing poverty if you do that, and are creating a weird hybrid of a "company town" system, which we know leads to abuse and exploitation. > To keep natural born citizens from getting angry, we can offer tax incentives for people having children. We can pay kids $20/week to study and get good grades (not a bad idea - it especially incentivizes poorer kids!). I don't think these suggestions are politically feasible. Many of the people who hate immigration would also see a bunch of that stuff as "welfare" and "handouts" and wouldn't want it.
- seanmcdirmid 5y ago> The US is not, and has never been, a champion of immigration. Immigration has been seen as "people taking our jobs" pretty much since the founding of the country. Immigration has always been tolerated as a "necessary evil" by policymakers. That isn’t true at all, if only because the US isn’t some homogenous being with one opinion. Immigration as a “necessary evil” is still pro immigration, vs a place like China where getting even a green card if you aren’t Han requires an act of god.