4 ms·
> [a possibility is suggested] that some people can clear a nascent SARS-CoV-2 infection from their bodies so quickly that they never test positive for the viru
by mdp2021 5y ago
> [a possibility is suggested] that some people can clear a nascent SARS-CoV-2 infection from their bodies so quickly that they never test positive for the virus nor even produce antibodies against it
The shock sounds shocking: some of us have proposed since forever the question: "how is it possible that people work in high flux supermarkets, where many infected per day must pass, and yet do not either seem to get infected nor to develop antibodies?" However you answer it, the question is urged and present.
Also, marginally, one facetious note (relevant to how tiring these times are... And also relevant to the topic of urging questions): «“I’ve never seen anything like that...” says Shane Crotty, an immunologist at La Jolla Institute for Immunology in California, who was not involved in the research». The last time I have read a similar construction was on Woody Allen.
- dragontamer 5y agoBut who are these "some people" ?? We __know__ that asymptomatic COVID19 is one of the biggest challenges. Its somewhat a blessing that a large minority of people are so effective at fighting COVID19 that they won't even get symptoms. But without knowing "who" those people are, there's no way to really make a policy decision around their apparent immunity to this disease. There's also questions about whether or not these asymptomatic people spread the disease. (Much like how vaccinated individuals can stave off the symptoms but still spread it around). Well, I guess that's not a "question" as much as certainty at this point... but understanding the why's and how's would be very useful.
- adventured 5y agoWe know who they are. They're staffing Walgreens, CVS, Walmart, Target, Costco, Kroger, etc. by the hundreds of thousands and have been throughout the entire pandemic. It's not their little trivial masks that have been protecting them from a daily bombardment of SARS2. It's pretty obvious where to look if we want to know more.
- dragontamer 5y ago> t's not their little trivial masks that have been protecting them from a daily bombardment of SARS2. Are you sure? What if the reduction of viral load, such as social distancing or masks, is what's causing them to have COVID19 resistance? A cotton mask has 60% filtration. An N95 mask has 95% filtration. If you "breath" in 1000 virus particles, someone with a cotton mask would only breath in 400 of them, while the one with N95 would breath in 50 virus particles. I have to imagine that viral load would cause some kind of change. Maybe there is a big difference between breathing in 1000-particles vs breathing in 400-particles. There seems to be no controversy that N95 works (aka: the reduction from 1000 particles down to 50-particles). But cotton masks are still an order-of-magnitude drop (at least, a binary-magnitude).
- coding123 5y agoIt's been a theory of mine that people wearing better masks ARE getting minuscule amounts of the virus and it preps their body differently than people that get it dumped on them.
- quesera 5y agoIndeed, there is a clear connection in published research between viral load and incidence of symptomatic infections. This is why masks "help", which is their job. Do not be misled by those who argue that less than 100% effectiveness means that masks do not "work".
- twofornone 5y ago>A cotton mask has 60% filtration. An N95 mask has 95% filtration. If you "breath" in 1000 virus particles, someone with a cotton mask would only breath in 400 of them, while the one with N95 would breath in 50 virus particles Do you have a source for this? Because from what little I've been able to find, filtration efficiency for particulate in the aerosolized size range are practically negligible with cotton masks and even surgical masks. Which makes sense considering that aerosolized particles are around 2-3 orders of magnitude smaller than pore sizes in cotton and surgical masks, putting such masks in the realm of security theatre. I suspect studies which show cotton masks having an effect on transmission (in contrast to studies near the start of the pandemic which showed no effect) are failing to consider secondary effects of masking on behavior, namely that masks indirectly remind people of the pandemic and influence their social distancing behavior
- mdp2021 5y ago> some people Members of the public posing basic questions. In supermarkets where many thousands per day pass, when the infected are measured as several per thousands, the arithmetic product returns """many several infected per day""" with some contact with the supermarket personnel. Such image creates a difficulty in conceiving a model for transmission, model which people want to form as a basic operation when told "there is an epidemic". The tentative answer "some are probably able to block it earlier than full response" was informally circulating as an answer to the said basic question. ("Informally": when you ask your practitioner, your friend in the lab etc.) This article is a proposal for a formal answer. > asymptomatic covid19 Covi_D_19 is the Disease. These cases are not cases of diseased - they are much more "at ease" than the asymptomatic diseased. They get their share of virions but block the infection immediately: they do not result as "having been infected" upon test.
- bradknowles 5y agoThey are carriers. You know, like Typhoid Mary?
- mdp2021 5y agoYou seem to have misunderstood what it is talked about: masses of common people who during their day have some interaction with many infected, yet do not develop the disease, nor show specific antibodies against it. How is the category you describe even overlapping to them.
- hijodelsol 5y ago> and yet do not either seem to get infected nor to develop antibodies One aspect that's worth mentioning imo is that while a percentage of people has been reported not to develop anti-spike antibodies at a measurable level [1], other factors come into play as well. - Antibody levels after natural infection wane [2] with seroreversion (like seroconversion but the other way around) being common - Some tests used by researchers have low sensitivity (especially many weeks after infection) - Qualitative assays may return negative results even though antibodies may be detected through other methods [3] - There are multiple targets that people may develop antibodies against, testing only for one target like N or S is not conclusive [4, since I can't seem to find a better study on this topic I saw earlier this week] [1]: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34716320/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34716320/ [2]: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-021-94453-5 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-021-94453-5 [3]: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34213733/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34213733/ [4]: https://insight.jci.org/articles/view/142386 https://insight.jci.org/articles/view/142386
- JPKab 5y agoA big theme that I see in all of this is the fact that we have public health officials making proclamations with high certainty like "Natural immunity is inferior to vaccine induced immunity and therefore you need to get vaxxed even if you recovered from a previous infection" in a specific area of study that is ongoing and in constant flux. It's clear to me that we are only scratching the surface of understanding the immune system. Maybe they are right when they say this, but I don't know, and I strongly suspect the scientists don't know yet either, considering how much research is still on-going. I was being told with absolute certainty by friends that natural immunity is less effective than the vaccines, while simultaneously a high-N longitudinal study from Israel is showing a rate of reinfection far lower amongst previously infected vs. breakthrough infections in the vaccinated. I think that the certainty of this conclusion is driven by antibody measurements, but not taking into account some of the things this study is mentioning, like memory T-cells. One of the assumptions that is pretty baked into the public health folks that the scientists are definitely not certain about is the spike protein being the ideal binding target for MRNA vaccines. This article is indicating that they are searching for other targets to create a vaccine that functions, in effect, like what this initial one was SUPPOSED to do: Not be leaky. My suspicion is that the second generation COVID vaccine will be a one and done shot, with no boosters needed. At least I hope so.
- dadrian 5y agoWhat in the world does this have to do with Woody Allen? Why are you dog whistling?
- bryanrasmussen 5y agoI don't think they are dog-whistling, they are saying it is a funny construction to say 'I have never seen anything like this' said by a guy who was not involved in the study - because if they were not involved in the study it would make sense they had never seen anything like this.
- tasty_freeze 5y agoI normally don't comment on misuse of idioms, but I will this time because you did the same thing twice. "Begging the question" means to presuppose the answer to the question which is being asked while answering it. Eg, "I know God is real because the Bible says so, and since God wrote the bible and doesn't like I know it is true." What you probably mean is "raises the question."
- mdp2021 5y agoThank you! You should provide comments and potential corrections (if only for clarification). As I hinted in the post, I am currently very tired, hence the writing will be unfortunately of subpar quality. I corrected the post - proper or improper formula, it is now rephrased to remove ambiguity. (The intended meaning was that the question is "pressing".)
- tdeck 5y agoFWIW most usages of the phrase "begging the question" in modern English seem to mean what OP meant, rather than the classical meaning. Perhaps this is because the classical meaning is based on a bizarre translation from Latin in the 16th century, leading to a very unintuitive phrasing in English: > The term was translated into English from Latin in the 16th century. The Latin version, petitio principii, "asking for the starting point", can be interpreted in different ways. Petitio (from peto), in the post-classical context in which the phrase arose, means assuming or postulating, but in the older classical sense means petition, request or beseeching. Principii, genitive of principium, means beginning, basis or premise (of an argument). Literally petitio principii means "assuming the premise" or "assuming the original point" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Begging_the_question#%3A%7E%3Atext%3DThe_phrase_begging_the_question%2Cfor_%22assuming_the_conclusion%22.?wprov=sfla1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Begging_the_question#%3A%7E%3A...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]