3 ms·
How do you get the SLBMs? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Submarine-launched_ballistic_missile https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Submarine-launched_ballistic_m... Fi
by dragontamer 5y ago
How do you get the SLBMs? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Submarine-launched_ballistic_missile https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Submarine-launched_ballistic_m...
First-strike only works if you eradicate _all_ of the opponent's nuclear forces. Otherwise, you're left with a few extremely pissed off submarine Admirals / Captains with nuclear-retaliation abilities.
----------
Like, you're skipping a major step here. If you destroy comms and launch a nuclear first strike before the submarines are down, you're screwd.
You're basically saying you have confidence that some adversary can 100% detect all of someone else's submarines simultaneously, across the world, with high confidence. Sure, submarine detection has gotten better, but I'm not even sure if you can pinpoint all of the USA's __carriers__ (and near-carriers, like the Marine's Wasp Assault Ships) right now (let alone the USA's submarines).
--------
I have severe doubts that anyone in the world has enough satellites in the air for 100% ocean coverage. We don't even have enough satellites in the air for 100% ground coverage. The sea is a very large place.
If the technology you allege to exists really does exist, then the MH370 probably would have been found by now. But no: satellites don't fly over 100% of the sea, our computers aren't fast enough to scan everything our eyes-in-the-skys see even if we could scan 100% of the ocean.
Furthermore: Satellites are floating up there in the sky. I'm sure the military is just watching each-other's satellites and knowing when they pass by or not. If a Satellite can see you, you can see the Satellite. If you can see the Satellite, you can tell your Submarines where to hide.
- lumost 5y agoThe biggest risk to the above is that with modern precision weapons a nuclear first strike to remove a nations nuclear retaliation capability. It's debatable whether a large and successful conventional first strike would trigger a retaliatory nuclear strike.
- yccs27 5y agoI don't think cameldrv is saying that a first strike is really feasible right now. It's just that in the past, the second strike capability had layers upon layers to make 100% sure no war-hungry commander could delude themselves into thinking they had any chance of disabling it. Now all of the 7 points have eaten away at this certainty. For now, it looks like the equation is still in favor of MAD, but it with a smaller margin. But what if Russia or China has some trick/secret weapon to disable the SLBMs? Or maybe they are just waiting until they know the locations of all carriers/subs - they have many years, and it might only take one random moment of 100% detection! I'm sure the odds are very low, but I'm not comfortable with a gamble when nuclear annihilation on the line. The fact that the dominant military doctrine hinges on some increasingly uncertain calculations is terrifying to me.
- dragontamer 5y ago> But what if Russia or China has some trick/secret weapon to disable the SLBMs? Then do they have a secret / trick to disable all briefcase bombs? The Davy Crockett nuke is under 50lbs and was designed for infantry to use (in a almost certainly suicide manner). And then plenty of other types were invented as time went on. If you can't get them with the big guns, you get them with the small ones, which are still devastating. There are still layers-upon-layers to ensure MAD, as far as I can tell. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atomic_demolition_munition https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atomic_demolition_munition And let me remind you: the pipebomb guy from Jan6th hasn't been found yet, despite modern surveillance methods and nearly a year of FBI searching and interviews.
- hunterb123 5y agoGenerally the smaller the bomb the easier it is to sneak it past defenses. You couldn't do enough damage for it to matter on a country scale. You'd have to sneak many small payloads by which would be easier to detect, at that point a larger single payload would be easier to sneak in. Radioactive payloads are harder to sneak in as ports are scanned with geiger counters, easier to do pipe bombs or fertilizer bombs, etc, but less effective. To do real collateral damage you have to deliver the payload via the air. Off-topic nitpick, the pipe bombs were planted on Jan 5th near the DNC and RNC headquarters. There's no known relation to the Jan 6th capitol protest.
- lb1lf 5y ago> To do real collateral damage you have to deliver the payload via the air. -My pet scenario is you just use DHL and ship the thing in a container. Imagine a handful of nukes going off in, say, the Suez canal, in a lock in the Panama canal, Shanghai, Singapore, LA and Rotterdam. You don't need to kill billions to bring the world to a halt. We'd face shortages of pretty much everything for quite a long time, with all the difficulties, suffering and general havoc that would bring with it.
- laurent92 5y ago- Can a state drop enough radioactive contaminants from the air that it would be impossible to detect a Davy Crockett bomb (20kt) in a container?
- geomark 5y agoIf the technology you allege to exists really does exist, then the MH370 probably would have been found by now. Keep in mind that the spooks are loathe to reveal their best technology so would never reveal it for something like finding the MH370.
- fennecfoxen 5y ago* loath
- geomark 5y agoYou're right!
- jhugo 5y agoThey don't need to. "Our proprietary modelling of sea currents suggests this search area", which just happens to include the known location of the wreck.
- snypher 5y agoThis sounds like "just looking for the Titanic"
- dragontamer 5y agoWell, imagine if the Titanic was constantly on the move and much much smaller. And imagine if it used a nuclear reactor so that it left no debris (smoke or whatnot) behind. And that's roughly the difficulty of finding a submarine. If anyone is seriously thinking that they can find all of an advanced nation's submarines and disabling them in a first-strike style attack... well... yeah. Its just not feasible with current technology.
- cameldrv 5y agoAt any given time, only about 3-4 SSBNs are out on patrol. The rest are in port or undergoing refits. Step one is to hit the ports, so you only have to worry about the 3-4 that are out. The subs patrol in defined patrol boxes which are roughly known to everyone. Then you knock out the E-6s, E-4s, and all fixed VLF transmitters to remove VLF comms capability. Then you knock out, at minimum, the AEHF and Milstar satellites, but I've heard the SSBNs now can send up an Iridium buoy, which is good, that is a lot of satellites to take out. I don't know the feasibility of that. This buys some amount of time before a launch message can be received by the sub. Now we would presume that before such a strike, the locations of the patrolling SSBNs are known. There are a number of new types of sensors such as green lasers, enhanced sonars, satellite wake detection, even antineutrino detection, about which some has come out in the open literature. There is also the emerging possibility of swarms of sonar equipped underwater drones that could aid in detection. As for destroying the submarines, that could be any combination of attack submarines, underwater drones, aircraft with torpedoes, or aircraft with nuclear depth bombs. It's also instructive to think about how a potential pause due to comms unavailability could affect deterrence as well, since an adversary could launch a first strike limited to military targets, and if the SSBNs were alive but out of communication, an adversary could threaten a follow up attack on cities if the remaining SSBNs did not surrender, and this would be an extremely difficult ultimatum to refuse.
- dragontamer 5y ago> Then you knock out the E-6s, E-4s, and all fixed VLF transmitters to remove VLF comms capability Okay, so... explain to me how Russia and/or China plans to to destroy an E-6 stationed in Nebraska before a second-strike is launched by the USA. It takes something like 20 minutes for a missile traveling at Mach 20, launched in Russia, before it reaches Nebraska. And the whole world will know that an ICBM was launched because those things aren't exactly subtle. And once you figure out how to kill the one in Nebraska, then you have to tell me how you kill the one in Kentucky. I guess you launch both missiles simultaneously, but... I'm sure you can see where this is going. You're gonna have to launch hundreds of ICBMs simultaneously, and then wait 20 minutes, and then hope the entirety of the USA's defense is caught sleeping on their job for 20 minutes.