6 ms·
How do people on HN deal with the potential disappearance of work altogether ? physical labour -> boston dynamics office labour -> ~cloud + smartphones (i'm i
by agumonkey 5y ago
How do people on HN deal with the potential disappearance of work altogether ?
physical labour -> boston dynamics
office labour -> ~cloud + smartphones (i'm in an office job right now, and it's near zero work, it's full on redundancy, ambiguous and contradictory information, political friction.. any computer could replace the entire building and operate faster 24/7)
it's really not a huge stretch to predict 90% of tasks will just vanish
and i'm saying this with a human life approach. How do we organize cities / nations around that. Do we plan for smooth transition, say 40 years of gradually smarter tooling so people stay in charge but with advanced assist ? do we go UBI ? do we convert every human as a space tourist ?
- beckman466 5y ago> i'm saying this with a human life approach what does this mean?
- agumonkey 5y agoThat I mostly care about people existence and well being, above the contemporary economic systems (because some can say, we can't sustain GDP without that style of work and that I believe our system is quite unhealthy and that deviating from it can lead to very different but better lives)
- jiggawatts 5y agoI'm not worried in the same way because I think all such work automation is subject to Jevon's Paradox: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox What I've seen is that increased efficiencies have massively increased the amount of "things" being done by the same number of people. As a random example, I'm dealing with a large government department on a semi regular basis as a consultant, so I get to see lots of parts of their business and in some ways I know them better than their own staff do. It's madness. They have the same sized team of admins in charge of an exponentially growing set of business applications. Decades ago large enterprises like this department would have had maybe 2-3 core applications, typically running on a mainframe. Then they'd have a few dozen peripheral applications in the sense that "email" counted as one of those apps! Now? Their single sign on system has hundreds, and that's not including hundreds more non-SSO applications. They're almost certainly over a thousand if you count things like Google Maps (which they use heavily!) and the long tail of developer tools, system admin platforms, and whatnot. In the past, people like me would have had a dedicated secretary. Now? I'm expected to not just manage my own calendar, but do my own project management, organise my own hotel rooms, and so forth. It has become "so easy" that "anyone can do it", so everyone does. This just means that instead of one or two meetings a week, now we have many per day. Being able to organise a meeting doesn't mean that the same number of meetings have less organisation overhead. It means many more meetings. Work hasn't be reduced. We're doing more of it than ever before...
- ocschwar 5y ago> How do people on HN deal with the potential disappearance of work altogether ? Thanks to peak oil and climate change "solving" this problem, I don't really think too much about that prospect.
- nyx_land 5y agoDavid Graeber already had an answer to this with his idea of "bullshit jobs", wherein as the labor that is necessary to keep society running is slowly reduced or automated away entirely by technological advancement, more jobs are invented that serve no practical purpose other than to keep people performing the wage labor ritual of selling their time to capitalists (keep in mind Graeber was a left-wing anarchist) in order to justify having access to resources. Even if there's absolutely no basis in reality for people to continue working, people will be made to think that they need to continue working and will be kept under the threat of work or starvation no matter how abundant resources and labor power are unless they simply refuse to continue to do so like we're seeing right now with the Great Resignation, which is essentially just people waking up to the realization that most of the jobs available to people today (especially young people entering the workforce) are bullshit jobs.
- agumonkey 5y agoI assumed that his views represented the previous post ww2 world where work, companies, careers were all things to pursue but since this decade I think there's a mismatch as we can indeed see in the great resignation. Maybe it will push back people to pursue passion, excellency and social bond (I will do things of high value for me and others so we're all happier).
- JasonCannon 5y agoAll Anarchists are left wing. AnCaps aren't anarchists. Anarchism is inherently socialist.
- aspenmayer 5y agoWhy do AnCaps present themselves as anarchist? Is it a name recognition marketing strategy? Are they themselves mistaken, or are they trying to convince others of them being anarchist? I see this a lot, where ancaps present themselves as anarchist, and believe that they are left wing, but when asked are shown to be ancaps by their answers. I don’t know what the endgame is in these conversations, for them or for me, as I’m mostly asking exploratory questions and have no agenda in asking per se.
- skybrian 5y agoThe disappearance of work seems greatly exaggerated. Education and healthcare are a big chunk of the economy and nowhere near automated. Also consider that we’ve been talking about driverless cars for over a decade, and this is something that should be well under way by now, but it’s slow going.
- socialdemocrat 5y agoI used to think this as well until I read Bullshit Jobs. The point Graeber makes very well is that as jobs have gotten automated a way they have been replaced by a huge number of meaningless office jobs. And this isn’t based on him judging particular jobs as pointless but rather a huge number of people writing to him and explaining just how pointless their jobs are. So why don’t these people quit their jobs? Because a lot of nonsense jobs pay well and people don’t want to be unemployed because society is not setup to pay people to not work. Yet society is ironically happy to pay people to do nonsense. Economists have a hard time believing this can be true. Things like efficient market theory suggests that companies want to be as efficient as possible. Yet they fail to see the tribal nature of humans. That is partly what Graeber exposes: How many CEOs will keep around people they don’t need because what is the point of being a boss of you got nobody to boss around? CEOs are a bit like kings of old. Importance is shown through the number of retainers you have. And often it is just self preservation. When management realize their whole division is full of people with no useful tasks to do they realize that they themselves risk getting fired. Why have managers and VPs if there are nobody to manage?
- skybrian 5y agoI don’t doubt such jobs exist, though I haven’t read the book. I don’t know how prevalent they are, though? A sibling comment casts some doubt on it [1]. But what we can say, thanks to the pandemic, is that many parents and children are very unhappy when schools close, and that there is a shortage of medical staff. There also seem to be shortages of various kinds of workers that are “essential” but not well-paid. Arguably they should be paid better. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29195047 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29195047
- 5y ago
- Robotbeat 5y agoI think we should do UBI. Child Tax Credit is essentially a pro-natalist UBI. I think, however, that there’s plenty of worthwhile work to do.
- crabmusket 5y ago> it's really not a huge stretch to predict 90% of tasks will just vanish You may be falling for AI propaganda: https://monroelab.net/attack-mannequins-ai-as-propaganda https://monroelab.net/attack-mannequins-ai-as-propaganda
- agumonkey 5y agoNo, not at all, I just see so many jobs where things are impossibly inefficient, bad software, bad education, bad management, bad everything. A lot of it due to the mismatch of old paper practice and human interfacing between lame digital UIs and printers. It's so bad that people are faster writing down documents instead of using software. Now if you go full digital.. what takes 15 min is now 15 ms. Same goes for a lot of operations across society.
- advertising 5y agoThe book - Fabric of Civilization takes an informative dive on what happened as cotton/wool fabric technology evolved and different bottle necks in the process changed, along with who was compensated more and who lost their jobs in the process.
- agumonkey 5y agoI didn't read that book but remember the topic a bit. But things have changed, a lot less people back in the days and a lot more limited technological capabilities.. now tech can really cover most of what people do. There's a shift IMO.
- imtringued 5y agoIf 90% of tasks will just vanish then there are three options: People work the same amount and demand ten times as many products and services. People demand the same amount of products and services but every person simply works 90% less. 10% of the people work and voluntarily give away their surplus to those who don't work. The first one is called consumerism. The second one is called work sharing. The third one is called income sharing. My personal favorite is work sharing.
- panick21_ 5y agoThe largest potential for disappearance of works has already happened. It was called the industrial revolution, and literally since then the smartest intellectual have predicted mass unemployment and the disappearance of work. Endlessly the same prediction with endlessly the same argument only to be proven wrong over and over.
- agumonkey 5y agoI really don't think that applies. Industrial couldn't address the same area as tech can do today.
- panick21_ 5y agoBut the argument is always the same. The largest amount of labor used to be farm labor. Used to be 95% of the population. No innovation today comes even remotely close disrupting that large a % of the population. One of the most labor intensive things humans did for 1000s of years was making of cloth, an absurd amount of work. That was as well disrupted. The pace of labor disruption today is WAY slower and the dynamic economy is WAY faster at producing new uses of labor. Hence why we have not actual seen this supposed collapse in the amount of required labor despite an endless parade of supposedly smart people predicting it for 200 years straight.
- agumonkey 5y agoI still don't agree about the similarity today. Every step in the past created a new layer (if I get your point), by virtue of being new, couldn't be solved so humans were involved to do it. But what's new to be done now ? Technology is wrapping around all layers of the pyramid, from mechanical to factories to information to "intelligence" (to an extent). I honestly fail to see what it won't be able to handle. Especially considering how lame most jobs are today[0] I don't think it will hold long. [0] I've ranted about it so many times but it reaches absurd levels .. people are not doing much, and the few that is asked of them is ridiculous. Plus it's often done through coercion by mediocre management that nobody respect (causing immense political friction, paranoia and misery.. most of my colleagues delay work and watch tik tok .. after talking to them the main reason is that nothing is working right nobody care, thus nobody wants to work anymore).