5 ms·
Complaints from GNOME team caused System76 maintainer stop work on Linux desktop
- edude03 5y agoI've been hearing people take sides in the GNOME vs POP_OS "debate" and have seen mentioned of what happened to Linus - and until reading this I had no idea what was going on. I will say that as much as I like twitter, the biggest challenge I have with it is knowing what people are referring to in these big public debates.
- torstenvl 5y ago> "I do not feel like it is worth my time to engage with System76," said Davis. It seems extremely unlikely that this attitude will contribute to gains in the Linux desktop space.
- rob_c 5y agoWish redhat had supported multi-DE's officially I fear the "Gnome as default" has made them reluctant to give as much as other DE's have in the name of cross-compatibility...
- rob_c 5y agoUnfortunately for gnome there is a growing "let it burn" crowd building against them. Shame KDE is missing the polish it used to have. (I remember kde3). Don't get me wrong I use kde5 a lot and its recently started getting better faster imo. At this stage I'm backing KDE apps on lxqt as the best desktop for me.
- md8z 5y agoThat crowd is not new. There are numerous other desktops and they've been around for quite some time. In my view, none of them have ever come close to GNOME or KDE in terms of velocity. Also, it seems that few of them are even trying to provide a comprehensive app platform, or if they are, it consists mostly of repackaged things from GNOME or KDE.
- rob_c 5y agoyes, but recently the gnome devs are effectively handing them pitchforks in the hopes they will go away. The Gnome-DE has made some brutal horrible design decisions _IMO_ in the last few years (more than just the horrible pastel colour scheme). That's not to mention the Gnome-foundation who seem to have split focus as to what their primary goals should be.
- xupybd 5y agoTwo parties have different goals and too many conflicts led to them going different paths. It's not really that surprising.
- md8z 5y agoThat isn't really true IMO. I don't think anything they are trying to do would be impossible with GNOME or KDE. But I get it, people need to put in the time to work with upstream, and for some who just want to ship products, that's not convenient.
- hsbauauvhabzb 5y agoGnome has consistently taken an arrogant, developer hostile approach. I really hope the new UI blows gnome out of the water and forces them to reevaluate the way they treat people who haven’t drunk their Apple-wannabe approach to features and pull requests.
- md8z 5y agoI really can't agree, the GNOME stuff I've used as a developer has been great for me. Keep in mind that no software project will ever be able to accept all possible feature requests or pull requests, for example I wouldn't expect System76 to accept everything that comes their way either. They have a specific design they're trying to meet too and that requires focusing on some things and disregarding others. I don't think they are trying to aim for something that is so good that it obsoletes everything else, that's unrealistic, you would have to invest a really large amount of money to even have a chance of doing that.
- hsbauauvhabzb 5y agoMy particular gripe is with GTK readahead (or type ahead, idk), which was added with no ability to disable, permanently changing the behaviour of open dialogs. Patches were submitted with added a configuration to the registry (or whatever it’s called in gnome land) which we’re ignored. I know at some point torvalds raised similar patches for UI element placement and was ignored. Obviously they have no obligation to do things that subsets of users want, but the result of that is people like me, who will laugh when they become obsolete.
- md8z 5y agoAll patches have a maintenance cost, different projects have different thresholds for what they will accept and what they won't, that's completely ordinary. Not anything I've seen specific to GNOME or KDE or any other project. You can shop patches around to see if various other people want it but if nobody wants it, then maybe it's a problem with your patch. Some features I used have been dropped too, I just adjusted my workflow to the new way. It's not hard to do, especially if you are already used to switching desktops. IMO it is bad form to laugh at developers and hope a project becomes obsolete, I doubt you will win any friends or change any minds that way. It's not personal against you if someone declines to implement a feature.
- korginator 5y agoFrom what I've been reading, System76 takes security seriously, they're already using gtk-rs that's a bridge between the Gnome libraries and rust, and this effort by System76 appears to be a natural direction for future development that further decouples their work from the Gnome ecosystem. If they decide later to build their own "gnome-like" core libraries in Rust, it should be straightforward for them to switch to this code. In 2021 I'd rather see investments in security-focused libraries, frameworks, tools and languages, and that's not going to happen with Gnome with its legacy C code base. We use System76 desktops and laptops at work, they've been great, and the company remains very responsive to any issues. I'm pretty confident that whatever they come out with will be well designed. I'd bet on their desktop over Gnome any day. As an aside, it's been a while... but the last time I had to build a cross-platform application with GTK+ was painful. There were so many API changes and things breaking across minor versions, we gave up after supporting our code for 2 years and switched to QT for new work.
- md8z 5y agoIt is actually not straightforward to switch the code. In general, you cannot really just swap out a GUI toolkit, that influences the design of the entire program. If there are good security focused libraries that work here, and there is a reasonable upgrade path for them, then I would expect GNOME to also start migrating towards that too. I personally wouldn't bet on their desktop, in the past few weeks their developers have made a number technical statements that seem very bizarre and confusing to me, and have openly said they don't really have the manpower to keep up with GNOME.
- emptyparadise 5y agoWhy is it always GNOME?