4 ms·
I live in Michigan, and I gotta say that this has been one of the most disappointing cases of state-level incompetence I've ever seen. This took nearly 7 years
by smoldesu 5y ago
I live in Michigan, and I gotta say that this has been one of the most disappointing cases of state-level incompetence I've ever seen. This took nearly 7 years to sort out, in no part thanks to Rick Snyder dragging his feet in the mud the entire way. No matter how you feel about him politically, his treatment of this situation bordered on criminal negligence, and stands as a testament to how little your representatives actually care about your well-being. I fear that there is no way to prevent this from happening again if commercial interests continue to mar the goals of public office.
- bpodgursky 5y agoI mean, yes, but... we only got here because Flint itself failed so utterly it could not even provide even basic services like running water to its residents, so the state took over. The state should have done better. But in reality, cities should not abdicate all responsibility for their own municipal services and expect anyone else to do it better.
- jandrese 5y agoThe disaster happened only after the state took over. It was caused by a cost cutting measure on the state's part and ultimately ended up being way more expensive than the anti-lead leeching additive they decided to not use.
- bpodgursky 5y agoYes. But the state took over because Flint was not financially able to run their own municipal water supply. I'm not saying the state was right. They were very wrong. Lead is awful. But if Flint had been a functioning city, we'd never be here. A state or federal government is never going to care as much as you do about your own lives and children. If you abdicate that responsibility and assume that "someone up there" will take care of you, you'll be bitten. It sucks, but it's reality.
- lotsofpulp 5y ago> If you abdicate that responsibility and assume that "someone up there" will take care of you, you'll be bitten. It sucks, but it's reality. Even if that “you” is a poor, less literate, possibly descendant of slaves, whose communities are poorer for obvious reasons and have to work multiple low wage jobs with low income security because cheaper labor from other countries outcompeted you on the price of labor and environmental externalities. Then we find out how much of a “we” we really are.
- bpodgursky 5y agoThere are plenty of majority-black cities in the country which run effective municipal services, and it's kinda racist that you believe otherwise.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoI did not imply that all majority-black cities run ineffective municipal services. I did imply that it might be reasonable to expect a community of people that are tired from working all day and may not have grown up with the best education and influence to have given them the necessary experiences to be able to evaluate a city’s financial situation and vote accordingly. They probably are not spending the couple hours of free time checking government budgets and reading minutes from city council meetings, much less attending them in pre internet days. I even keep up with many of the local political happenings, but quite frankly, I rely on the good will and good luck of the decision makers in my community doing the right thing.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- omegaworks 5y agoIt's absolutely a replicable scenario. A test case to show exactly how minimal the consequences will be of government abandonment of public resources.
- maxerickson 5y agoWhat are you describing? In Flint, the state took over the management of the city and failed to properly operate the municipal water system. There's moving parts, Flint moving from Detroit for water supply to the regional authority, but they are government entities. Is the idea that the switch away from Detroit water wasn't really motivated by cost and was instead motivated by graft or something like that?
- city41 5y agoIt's happening in Benton Harbor. Will be interesting to see how it plays out https://apnews.com/article/business-lifestyle-environment-and-nature-michigan-poverty-12586348a94d5d57de7de6e15df23421 https://apnews.com/article/business-lifestyle-environment-an...
- analog31 5y agoIs BH also state managed?
- bmmayer1 5y agoThe incentives of holders of public office are completely warped. If you represent taxpayers, the last thing you want is for your city / state / county to face a huge settlement bill, so it's all denials, all around. This makes it impossible to fix the underlying problem -- it's the opposite of a blameless postmortem culture that should underlie productive systems design.