5 ms·
Has LIGO ever responded to Sabine Hossenfelder's claims? http://backreaction.blogspot.com/2019/09/whats-up-with-ligo.html http://backreaction.blogspot.com/2019/
by dekhn 5y ago
Has LIGO ever responded to Sabine Hossenfelder's claims? http://backreaction.blogspot.com/2019/09/whats-up-with-ligo.html http://backreaction.blogspot.com/2019/09/whats-up-with-ligo....
- DrBazza 5y agoI thought that 2019 article is now "answered" by the fact that we have multi-messenger observations of gravitational wave events that confirm fading light curves.
- dnautics 5y agoI believe we still only have one multi-messenger observation. One observation has infinite variance =P. They're ALSO not independent observations, though. The LIGO observation was made, and then the directive was "go look for correlating events". That's a dependent observation. To be truly independent, they would have to inject synthetic data (say 3x) into the observation reports and make sure that the multi-messenger results don't correlate with the synthetic data, much like GP says they did "at the beginning of LIGO" with internal (non-multimodal) signals. This would have the side benefit of making the analysis pretty simple to do (just a chi-squared analysis) and you don't have to have a PhD in signals analysis with a specialization in the filters used by LIGO to believe with a high confidence that 1) GWs exist and 2) LIGO is actually measuring GWs.
- PhantomGremlin 5y agoI have a basic problem with Sabine's claims. In a response comment she says: "No signal analysis can confirm that the signal was of astrophysical origin." I know nothing about the actual hardware. But I can reasonably speculate that LIGO can afford to have local atomic clocks. So they can timestamp their observations to nanosecond precision. Given the finite speed of light, the candidate astrophysical events are necessarily detected many milliseconds apart. There can only be two ways these potential events would correlate: 1) there are so many many possible false positives constantly happening that there is some reasonable probability of this correlation occurring by chance. or 2) a highly sophisticated "goof" or fraud. Someone could presumably set up some local source near each detector and spoof a signal. E.g. carefully "wiggle" large masses, each only a few km away from each detector. So, if it's not astrophysical, can Sabine tell us which it is? False positive? Goof?