17 ms·
Image file formats that didn’t make it
- marcodiego 5y agoFrom time to time I take a look at https://wiki.multimedia.cx/index.php/Category:Undiscovered_Codecs https://wiki.multimedia.cx/index.php/Category:Undiscovered_C... and https://wiki.multimedia.cx/index.php/Category:Undiscovered_Game_Formats https://wiki.multimedia.cx/index.php/Category:Undiscovered_G...
- nashashmi 5y agoShould vml be included as a vector markup image format? Msft was forced to abandon vml in favor of open svg.
- ReleaseCandidat 5y agoSGIs RGB files are missing. http://paulbourke.net/dataformats/sgirgb/sgiversion.html http://paulbourke.net/dataformats/sgirgb/sgiversion.html Had been heavily used on SGIs as their 'native' image file format.
- daemin 5y agoI guess I'm old because I've written loaders and savers for at least 3 of those formats listed there. Granted it was when I was still learning, but many of those formats are pretty simple to code up a good first approximation loader for. I don't know if I'd want to try and write a loader for JPEG or PNG these dats for example.
- iliketrains 5y agoI find TGA very useful when in need of image output and without easy access to a proper image lib. TGAs are trivial to output just by writing RGB values to a file with a simple header, no encoder needed. I am so glad that many image viewers/editors still load TGA, my computer has gigabytes of them! Spec here: http://www.paulbourke.net/dataformats/tga/ http://www.paulbourke.net/dataformats/tga/
- pajamanaut 5y ago>bmp >tiff
- nicholasmoser 5y agoI agree that I am surprised by the inclusion of those two formats. I work with images and we still see BMP and TIFF all the time in medical contexts.
- ape4 5y agoIs it crazy to fondly remember some of those formats
- sysadm1n 5y agoAnecdotally, the first time I heard of TGA was in Tomb Raider. The Tomb Raider games of old had a screenshot feature that outputted TGA files of gameplay and were useful for making walk-throughs for other people (you would typically convert them to JPG when sharing on the web). And I still see BMP files being used even in modern games. Yeah: PNG is better, but BMP has its uses.
- ginko 5y agoBMP and TGA have the advantage that they're uncompressed, so it's mostly trivial to dump the contents of your framebuffer to a file without any major dependencies.
- edflsafoiewq 5y agoYou can write an uncompressed PNG IIRC.
- georgemcbay 5y agoSort of but not really. You can write out PNG files with deflate blocks that aren't compressed, so in that sense they are uncompressed PNG files, but all of the complexity of supporting compression is still there in the data format in a way that is not fully avoidable even if you don't actually compress the data. BMPs on the other hand are simple to write, only a very small portion of the header data is required and then you can dump the image out as its raw pixel data in a way that they are probably already being stored in memory, making it a very easy format to support the writing of and a pretty easy format to support the reading of.
- edflsafoiewq 5y agoBMP is quite complex and poorly documented (it's a bunch of random Microsoft structs and #defines), more so than PNG. BMP has compression too (RLE and Huffman). PNG is simpler here since you can just drop a DEFLATE library straight in. Images are usually stored in memory as RGBA in scanline order. You can dump this representation straight to a PNG file (edit: this is wrong, you can't). BMPs are typically written with pixels in packed BGR order, rows going bottom to top. But not always. I think they go top to bottom if you give a negative height, and you can supply masks defining which bits the RGBA come from.
- enriquto 5y agoTiff is very much not dead. It is likely one of the image formats more widely used today. Terabytes of new tiff images are prodced every hour and distributed by many remote sensing operators. It is a really flexible and robust format also. How else are you going to store a floating-point multispectral image of 8 bands and 50.000 x 50.000 pixels, arranged tile-wise for easy cropping?
- iscrewyou 5y agoGeo-tiffs are the go to standard in GIS integration of any property map. Photoshop works really well with tiffs.
- NelsonMinar 5y agoWas going to say the same thing; GeoTIFFs are common. But they are a "specialist" format in the way the article is talking about. Why is GeoPNG not a thing? PNG is based on TIFF's design with various chunks allowing all sorts of metadata storage. It'd be pretty easy to translate GeoTIFF's GIS stuff into PNG. Has that been done?
- NelsonMinar 5y agoI asked some GIS experts on Twitter and GeoPNG is not a thing. Most folks seem to think GeoTIFF does just fine so there's no need for it. TIFF's support for more than 3 channels of data is a big help for multispectral remote sensing.
- Isthatablackgsd 5y agoYea, I was confused when I saw TIFF in the list. I get email attachment with TIFF occasionally through my job. I know TIFF is still common in other fields. It is possible the author is in the fields that don’t encountered TIFF enough and went with the assumption that it is forgotten format.
- zwieback 5y agoThat was my reaction. To be fair author says: "Of the formats listed here, TIFF is probably the one most likely to still be in wide use, but it has evolved into a more specialized format for professionals, in comparison to something like JPG."
- leiserfg 5y agoIs not bmp the default file-format of paint nowadays?
- fredoralive 5y agoIt uses PNG as default. Can also do BMP, JPEG, GIF, HEIC and TIFF on Windows 10.
- theandrewbailey 5y ago> Today’s Tedium discusses 10 image formats that time forgot. > (list includes BMP, TIFF, TGA) I remember seeing lots of software using Quicktime PICT files, even on Windows, but I've never seen anyone break it down (Wikipedia does a bit[0]). Did everyone mostly use it as a container for JPEGs? [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PICT https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PICT
- jsrcout 5y agoPICT, there's a blast from the past. Way back at my first job I ported our visual graph editor to the Macintosh. Scrolling was very slow at first due to continuously redrawing the graph, until I started saving it to a PICT as a sort of cache. Worked great, the Mac could draw a PICT very quickly.
- duskwuff 5y agoPICT was a really weird format. It's a stream of drawing instructions for Apple's old QuickDraw graphics layer. This could include bitmap graphics, but could also include (semi-)vector operations like drawing lines, circular arcs, polygons, or text.
- jandrese 5y agoOf course this means making a third party reader means re-implementing QuickDraw and probably getting some nastygrams from Apple's lawyers.
- duskwuff 5y agoApple wouldn't care. QuickDraw doesn't exist in current versions of macOS -- Preview.app can't even display them. I've actually toyed with the idea of a PICT to SVG conversion tool. It's potentially useful for viewing certain old documents in the (long obsolete) Apple DocViewer format.
- mosdl 5y agoWasn't VRML support in browsers usually plugins and not native?
- lostgame 5y agoI distinctly recall installing QuickTime to view some VRML stuff in the mid/late 90's.
- giantrobot 5y agoQuickTime's QTVR wasn't the same as VRML. While VRML was a fully 3D world/object, QTVR was pre-rendered scenes with custom navigation controls. There was an "object" view which was basically a bunch of still images of an object from different angles. The cursor moved a virtual camera that just displayed the still frame for the appropriate angle. The "panorama" view was a panoramic image mapped to view angles from a central point. Images could be cubic or spherically mapped IIRC. Both types supported hyperlinks. So clicking a linked region could load another scene which could have yet more links to more scenes. The Star Trek Interactive Technical Manual was a famous use of QTVR. It enabled visual fidelity a real-time 3D rendered of the era couldn't deliver. It was made by actually photographing the Star Trek production sets.
- kalleboo 5y agoThere was also QuickDraw 3D (not QuickTime, and not cross-platform), Apple's 3D graphics API, which used actual 3D rendered objects. Classic MacOS had pretty well-integrated support for QuickDraw 3D Metafiles, they could be dragged and dropped, you could embed 3D objects into a word processing document or presentation or something and manipulate and explore them in there. Kind of mirrors what Apple is doing with USDZ these days (you can send a USDZ model in iMessage and the recipient can manipulate it right there in chat)
- drdeadringer 5y agoWhen I used it it was through a browser. I would create the files in a txt editor and then explore the world-space created via browser.
- NikolaNovak 5y agoHmm; Tiff is still the default universally-readable format for many lossless purposes. It also seems to be used automatically in places: e.g. in Lightroom, clicking "External Editor" sends a TIF file to the external editor and imports it back by default. I thought it was also used in some scientific/analysis scenarios as well. I thought I also saw BMP in a lot of games for some reasons (not to mention it's default output for the default image program on the effectively default consumer PC OS :)
- ryandvm 5y agoGeoTIFF is an interesting extension of TIFF that seems to serve a niche that other image formats cannot. It doesn't have the compression of say WebP or PNG, but the fact that it can have rich geographical metadata (projection, coordinates, etc.) makes it incredibly useful for GIS applications.
- kylebarron 5y agoGeoTIFF does have internal compression support. In fact you can compress your GeoTIFF internally using WebP [0]. [0]: https://gdal.org/drivers/raster/cog.html#general-creation-options https://gdal.org/drivers/raster/cog.html#general-creation-op...
- riedel 5y agoAlso DICOM for medical imaging is afaik based on TIFF
- sairahul82 5y agoDICOM is a container. It can contain any format including jpeg, tiff, png etc.
- yread 5y agotiff is also just a container it can contain lz compressed data or with some lossy compression
- egfx 5y agoI’d like to nominate aPNG. It works only on Firefox unfortunately.
- mixmastamyk 5y agoLooks like times have changed: https://caniuse.com/?search=apng https://caniuse.com/?search=apng
- CountHackulus 5y agoI should pull out my VRML2.0 Sourcebook again, that was a really fun time.
- p_l 5y agoI remember enjoying virtual walk on the ISS using VRML ~2001. Worked great on 512kbit link and with quite low resource usage :)
- ahartmetz 5y agoJPEG2000 is a big one that seems to be missing. It is used in medical imaging or something, because laws? But its visual quality is worse than old JPEG, despite a PSNR advantage. Apparently, compression researchers used to think that people care about PSNR.
- SavantIdiot 5y agoIsn't DiCOM a popular image format for medical imaging too? Or does DiCOM use Jpeg2000 under the hood?
- bick_nyers 5y agoIn DICOM you have the notion of a transfer syntax, so you can choose your compression scheme (from a list of Dicom supported transfer syntax), such as JPEG2000. You can also just leave the images uncompressed as well. That being said, any images of sufficient size are very likely to be compressed, J2K being one of the most popular. IMO, the flexibility provided by the container is not worth the development/support effort. It's better to do one or two things really well rather than have hundreds of edge cases.
- acdha 5y agoJPEG-2000 was held back by intellectual property restrictions: patents but also the fact that the spec cost $1,500. A lot of the parties involved appeared to think that the technical merits made adoption inevitable and so they didn't spend time making it appealing with things like a test suite or high-quality open source implementation. That had several impacts which scarred a lot of people I've worked with: 1. The commercial implementations were not interoperable and people get VERY nervous when they periodically get images which won't open correctly in one tool or, worse, have defects which one tool hides. 2. Many open source tools either didn't support the format at all or used Jasper, which just didn't get enough support to be fast or compliant. 3. Performance was quite slow for a while and people who weren't starting with Photoshop or native Mac apps (ImageKit uses the Kakadu codec, which has decent performance) were probably hitting Jasper or the Java implementation, both of which were orders of magnitude slower. People will forgive a certain performance hit for better compression but, especially as network bandwidth and storage capacity went up so much, the savings just weren't worth it if you could transfer and decode a JPEG in less time than it took just to decode the JP2. 4. All of that combined to mean browsers never really implemented it, other than Safari which picked it up via the standard image framework. The complexity meant that getting acceptable performance and security would be expensive and the demand just wasn't there. 5. The complexity of the format and low encoding performance meant that many JP2s were not encoded with optimized settings, which reduced the benefits to supporting it. This makes me a bit sad because technically it was the only format for a long time which supported a wide range of colorspaces, bit depths, etc. and the way you can progressively decode a stream would have been a really neat option for responsive images in HTML — imagine if all your srcset had to do was say “Range-request bytes 1-x for 512x512, 1-y for 1024x1024, …” and the server + CDN could host & cache a single file for every client. There are certain scenarios where the progressive / tiled decoding can make up for the friction (medical imaging and archival storage in libraries/archives) but they're not widespread enough to establish an entire image format. The open source situation has never been better with OpenJPEG but there just doesn't seem to be a high likelihood of significant increases in demand at this point.
- fredoralive 5y agoI want to be pedantic and point out the Nokia 3310 used to illustrate WBMP didn't support WAP. It should be the 3330, which has a reversed (white with blue details) case. (I know the "XpressOn covers" are swappable, but it's clearly a PR shot not someone's random phone).
- paulpauper 5y agoWindows Metafile
- whoopdedo 5y agoI wish the author provided more information about the strangeness of some of these formats and why they're now obsolete. PCX being one of the oddest because it's ordered by planes. So the red, green, and blue components are split. What this list is missing is WMF/EMF which were basically direct serializations of Windows drawing primitives. > BMP files are usually not compressed and, therefore, are not well suited for transfer across the Internet When BMP files were compressed they'd typically be given the extension .RLE.
- mnw21cam 5y agoMost of the IFF images produced on the Amiga were also ordered by bitplanes, but that's bitplanes of an n-bit number for each pixel, referencing a colour lookup tables.
- willis936 5y agoEMF is still widely used. Word no longer imports .eps files as of about 4 years ago, so .emf is the next best option when generating plots in MATLAB or python. PDF embedding would be a dream, but that really doesn't work. svg is also reasonable, but word handles emf better. I use LaTeX for my personal stuff, but employers don't touch such things with 20 foot poles.
- user2994cb 5y agoVRML is still used as an input format for colour 3d printing, eg. https://www.stratasysdirect.com/resources/design-guidelines/polyjet-multi-color#vrml https://www.stratasysdirect.com/resources/design-guidelines/...
- kps 5y agoThe Amiga (EA) IFF format was adopted by Microsoft as RIFF (essentially the same format but with little-endian numbers for x86), which is the basis of WAV and AVI, among others.
- Findecanor 5y agoIFF (Interchangeable File Format) is a container format that can contain different types of data. ILBM (InterLeaved BitMap) was the image encoding inside the IFF. The Amiga had bitplane-based graphics. The "interleaved" part was that an image was stored by line first, bitplanes second instead of one whole bitplane after the other. Games often used the "interleaved" graphics layout in memory because it allowed blitting a sprite with a single Blitter operation. (... and EA who made DPaint was a games studio first)
- zwieback 5y agoAnother one that didn't make it: writing a packed binary file where the first two shorts are the width and height and then just 8 bit grayscale values. That was my favorite way to serialize images but I never had the foresight to add enough header or versioning info to make it backward compatible. Now after 30+ years of programming the first thing I add to any homebrew file format is enough info to make it extensible.
- bigbillheck 5y agoSounds a lot like a PGM.
- kbelder 5y agoJust store the width. You'll know the height when you're done drawing it, and it saves you two bytes. You never get over learning to program on a system with 3.5k ram.
- LocalH 5y agoIFF (or IFF-based formats) is a lot more widely used than some realize, just not usually with ILBM content nowadays. Microsoft RIFF (largely WAV and AVI, although animated Windows cursors also use RIFF), Apple's AIFF audio, Maya uses an IFF variant for raster image data, and even The Sims uses an IFF variant for many of its data files.
- lstodd 5y agoPNG is actually a cut down and then extended IFF.
- coldacid 5y agoYeah RIFF is essentially IFF with opposite endianness. Regarding IFF usage in The Sims, it's not surprising given that EA designed the format. I believe that SimCity 2000 cities and scenarios are also IFF.
- __david__ 5y agoIn fact I'm pretty sure it stands for "Reversed IFF", as in byte-reversed.
- ZoomZoomZoom 5y agoCan we write FLIF off, or does it still have a chance at wider adoption? I remember quite a positive reaction on release, but don't see it in the wild, unfortunately. https://flif.info/ https://flif.info/
- whoopdedo 5y agoI thought you were talking about FLIC[1] at first. Now there's a name I've not heard in a long time. [1] https://www.compuphase.com/flic.htm https://www.compuphase.com/flic.htm
- TylerE 5y ago"FLIF development has stopped since FLIF is superseded by FUIF and then again by JPEG XL, " Smells very dead to me.
- a_e_k 5y agoI believe that the developer of FLIF integrated much of the tech into JPEG XL. It seems to happen a lot with codecs (e.g., Xiph's Dalaa tech merging into AV1, or Xiph's CELT and Microsoft's SILK merging into Opus). I see FLIF as the prototype and JPEG XL as the production version.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- yboris 5y agoThere was also an update to it called FUIF - Free Universal Image Format https://github.com/cloudinary/fuif https://github.com/cloudinary/fuif But it too got superseded by JPEG XL (.jxl) https://jpegxl.info/ https://jpegxl.info/
- avmich 5y agoI'd like to see a mention of FIF, fractal format from Iterative Systems, something quite different from other approaches to store images.
- sprash 5y agoThis format was very interesting because it was essentially "resolution independent". You could zoom in further and further and see nonsensical made up details by the fractal algorithms without getting any blurriness or interpolation artifacts.
- Isthatablackgsd 5y ago> This format was very interesting because it was essentially "resolution independent" When I read that, I thought it is because it is a vector type. Usually "resolution independent" images, from my understanding, are commonly vector type since it can scale infinitely like SVG. However, I couldn't find information online whatever .FIF is a raster or vector type. I saw one that said it shares similarly to vector images, that didn't confirm anything for me. So I would incline that because .FIF is a vector type, please correct me if I am wrong. It so hard to find this information and wondering if my google-fu is getting rusty. EDIT: Whelps, it turn out my google-fu is getting rusty. I managed to find the information and I am wrong. It is a raster type[1]. [1] http://fileformats.archiveteam.org/wiki/Fractal_Image_Format http://fileformats.archiveteam.org/wiki/Fractal_Image_Format
- sprash 5y agoYour link contains is a nice article [1] how the resolution independent "raster type" looks like when zooming in including ancient Windows software to try it yourself. Sadly wine crashes when I try to start it. 1.: http://users.senet.com.au/~mjbone/Fractals.html http://users.senet.com.au/~mjbone/Fractals.html
- bluedino 5y agoPCX! It's such a simple format. I remember reading about it as a kid, punching in some code to read the header, then the data, then the palette, having an image appear before my eyes. Fixing the bugs in my code made the image appear correct, what a great intro to debugging and seeing the results. It seemed like magic at the time. Taking this binary data that was gibberish when looking at it with EDIT.COM and making it appear on the VGA screen https://nambafa.com/tutorials-computer-graphics.php?series=denthor&part=18 https://nambafa.com/tutorials-computer-graphics.php?series=d...
- Sharlin 5y agoYep. In fact, I've been planning to write a PCX codec for my retrogaming/gfx project. The RLE scheme is simple but still reasonably effective.
- interroboink 5y agoRight there with you (: I wrote a PCX reader in QBasic. I can still remember seeing that image of a red rose finally appear in all it its 320x200 pixelated glory.
- mpyne 5y agoYeah, a PCX image reader was one of my first programming accomplishments. I wish I still had the code somewhere (same with the Mandlebrot fractal generator I had back then).
- sabujp 5y agoTIFF is not dead, still used heavily in bio sciences, imaging, etc. VRML is still a lowest common denominator for transfering 3D
- drdeadringer 5y agoIn a summer tech program for pre-college high school tech-interested//inclined students, my group of three created four different VRML world-spaces. We each made our own, and I made the "gateway" world-space where you would enter a Parthenon-like structure with three hyperlink objects inside which you could click on to travel to each of the other places. Each place had a similar hyperlink object to get back to the Parthenon. I enjoyed it. I probably still have the VRML 2.0 book around somewhere.
- giantrobot 5y agoVRML Sourcebook [0]. I did a similar little project in VRML. I took the general organization of my homepage and VRMLized it. Authoring it was such a pain in the ass. I loved the concepts behind VRML, and still do. Unfortunately all of the implementations around it were terrible. When it was in vogue PCs weren't powerful enough to handle anything but the most trivial models. Dial-up was entirely insufficient to deliver anything but the most trivial models as well. [0] https://archive.org/details/vrml20sourcebook00ames https://archive.org/details/vrml20sourcebook00ames
- drdeadringer 5y ago> I loved the concepts behind VRML, and still do. Unfortunately all of the implementations around it were terrible. Being ~18 years away and therefore memory is skewed, may I ask regarding how the implementations were terrible? Honest question.
- giantrobot 5y agoOn the playback/viewing side many VRML viewers were browser plugins. The idea being you might navigate from a web page to a VRML space or embed a 3D object in a web page. These were (as I remember) very sluggish and crash prone which took down the whole browser. Even dedicated VRML browsers weren't all that great. I don't remember any without awful skeuomorphic buttons and view borders. Their navigation UIs also tended to be terrible. Most I ever tried aped 3D modeling apps using the mouse (a workstation mouse with three buttons) to fly through a scene. But with the typical PC mouse having two buttons (and a Mac with one) you had to use modifier keys to switch between fly and "look". VRML supported world gravity (intensity and a normal) so a viewer program could just navigate like a FPS game but I don't remember any that did. Another issue I remember but may have just been my PC, because WRL files don't embed any linked content they've got to go fetch every resource referenced like on a web page. On my systems at least this led to a lot of pop-in as I moved through scenes, even locally. On dialup it's was a thousand times worse. So modulo actual hardware performance, or lack thereof, you had poorly performing software with very alien feeling UI. While that is more than 20 years of time between me trying VRML and now those are things that stand out to me. Maybe none of these problems existed if you were blasting around on an SGI O2 workstation or knew just the right software to use. I had neither so I just stumbled around playing with stuff.
- godshatter 5y agoIs bmp really dead? It's my go-to file format when playing around with graphic image programming (just stupid hobby stuff). It's easy to pick a format and write one out, and most everything reads it as a format that I've used, even on linux. It can be tricky reading one created by something else, but if you make assumptions based on the header sizes and the fact that you rarely run into one that not a simple 24-bit pixel array, its' not too bad. I do only use it as an interim format, though.
- linuxlizard 5y agoYou should take a look at tiff (also on their list for some reason). I used bmp in my imaging work because it's lossless and uncompressed (I got tired of waiting for 500M png files to open). But tiff is quite simple to understand and is a little more future proof than bmp.
- godshatter 5y agoI thought about looking into the tiff format, but never have. If it avoids the format versioning trouble that bitmaps have, then I'm all for it. I remember using it back in the day as an output format for the povray ray-tracing program (I think?). Maybe DKB.
- selfhoster11 5y agoIt's as dead as you want it to be. IMO, I prefer it when I have to deal with lossless uncompressed images because it's familiar to users of old versions of Windows.
- lizknope 5y agoMost RAW camera files like Nikon NEF are based on TIFF with a lot of proprietary extensions to the format.
- yboris 5y agoThe successor to JPEG is going to be JPEG XL (.jxl) https://jpegxl.info/ https://jpegxl.info/
- mixmastamyk 5y agoWhat about webp, avif, and the like?
- ksec 5y agoWebP hasn't shown any significant advantage in real world test, and AVIF only wins in low bpp usage with a huge trade off on encode and decode speed. It is listed in the JPEG XL comparison table.
- a_e_k 5y agoThe interesting thing to me is that compared to WebP and AVIF, JPEG XL is the only one that isn't just largely based on a video codec's I-frame compression.
- jeroenhd 5y agoInteresting, most websites that convert user media to WebP load quite fast for me whereas conversions to JPEG are fast but still a bit slower/lower quality in my experience. WebP suffers from lack of support in outdated browsers, but that's the only problem I've found with it. AVIF is kind of a silly format, but for some use cases it works quite well. JPEG XL has very little tool support, isn't (as) free as the alternatives and browser support is practically non-existent. Nobody wants to adopt the format either, because the JPEG group made the same problem Nintendo made when naming the Wii U: JPEG XL sounds like a JPEG file with something special going on inside, while in fact it's actually a completely new format.
- ksec 5y agoStill waiting for browser and industry wide support. So far no one seems to care much.
- tdeck 5y agoI wish they'd mentioned my favorite image format: XPM. Open one of those in gVim and prepare to be amazed.
- mixmastamyk 5y agoFound VRML in there unexpected. But was expecting MNG but didn't find it. Interesting history with that one, a few browsers implemented it but then removed it. Leading to a lot of geek angst. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multiple-image_Network_Graphics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multiple-image_Network_Graphic...
- jandrese 5y agoI was never sure why MNG failed so spectacularly. Eventually it had to be replaced by full up H.264 videos and a lot of places are still using old fashioned animated GIFs because firing up a full fat video codec for a 32x16 animation with a dozen frames is silly. Was it really just the lack of interest from browser makers preventing people from using it?
- powerpiglet 5y agoI remember being excited about MNG, but finding the open-source libmng a pain to use. It was all based around callbacks with the library driving the animation cycle. Not a great fit if you were interested in using MNG for things like sprite animation.
- dvhh 5y agoTool support was also an issue, I don't remember using any software that supported it out of the box and even less generated one, only a couple of dedicated image viewer/converter.
- mixmastamyk 5y agoMy limited understanding was that the spec was too big and too difficult to implement. Too many features apparently. A simpler version called APNG was advanced instead. Until today I had no idea it is supported about everywhere except IE11. No one seems to know... spread the word. ;-) https://caniuse.com/?search=apng https://caniuse.com/?search=apng
- Macha 5y agoMy understanding is that the video codecs are pretty clearly ahead for lossy compression, even for small numbers of frames. Image codecs got stuck in the jpg/gif/png local maximum, hence why a lot of the new image codecs (webp, heif, avif) are conceptually "one frame of a video codec" (vp9, h265 and av1 respectively)
- MilStdJunkie 5y agoCGM YEEEEEHAW Ha ha ha I work in an image format so forgotten it doesn't even make the forgotten list. Computer Graphics Metafile bitches! My god how I loathe that thing. It's kept alive in specifications purely by the efforts of a single software company flooding all the WGs with cheerleaders. "No, it's not obsolete, SVG is just a thing used by hackers and programmers"
- h2odragon 5y agothis? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Computer_Graphics_Metafile https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Computer_Graphics_Metafile you poor, lost soul. tell us where it hurt you.
- gred 5y agoFunny, I just implemented a PCX writer today... but only to be able to embed images in Intermec Direct Protocol (an obscure print language).
- upofadown 5y agoNAPLPS didn't really have much of any syntax. Pretty much anything was valid. I used to fix Telidon terminals back in the day. A favourite pastime was to send a terminal some wildly inappropriate data so as to enjoy the wild and trippy vector madness that would ensue.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y agoDoes anyone know of a method for extracting images from the FlashPix (.fpx) format. I think user-friendly support for the format was lost when Kodak went bankrupt. However is the format itself overly-complicated.
- jandrese 5y agoImageMagick may have support: https://github.com/ImageMagick/libfpx https://github.com/ImageMagick/libfpx
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y agoThank you!
- NelsonMinar 5y agoI was kind of hoping to see PNM referenced here. That's the very simple format that comes in PBM, PGM, and PPM files made popular by Jef Poskanzer's PBMPlus (and later, NetPBM). The core insight was great: have one generic lossless simple raster format and make lots of command line image processing tools for it. Then have a bunch of converters. For many years I got a lot of work out of things like xpmtoppm icon.xpm | pnmscale 3 | ppmtogif > icon-big.gif. It helped the format was so simple you could easily create images in C code, too. (These days we use Imagemagick or derivates instead.) One interesting thing about PNM is very few images were ever stored in that format itself. It was intended mostly as an intermediate format for process.
- jug 5y agoI also find ASCII image formats like PBM and XPM amusing. Simple images viewable in a mere text editor as a budget option. :D
- secondcoming 5y agoICO? Window's icon format. IIRC it was really two images baked into a single file; one a colour bitmap and another mask that's used for transparency.
- authed 5y agoDon't a lot of favicons still use that format?
- secondcoming 5y agoPossibly. There was this HN news article from a short time ago [0] "The vast majority of the favicons offered up by websites are PNG. 71.6% of <link rel=”icon”> images are PNG. 21.1% of /favicon.ico files are secretly PNGs, including Reddit’s. Strangely, only 96.1% of Apple touch icons are PNG. Presumably the other 4% are broken." [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28933391 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28933391
- laumars 5y agoGiven the title I was expecting a lot more obscure entries. I’d be shocked if many people reading that kind of article hadn’t heard of at least half of those formats. Or maybe I’m just getting old…?
- jl2718 5y agoFIF - although google earth looks like they used a similar algorithm.
- qubyte 5y agoThis article has some... interesting entries (as noted elsewhere in the comments here), but it came up at an interesting moment for me. I spent last weekend poring over the PNG spec because I wanted to make QR codes real small [1]. I'm completely obsessed now. I'm going to dig into some other formats... [1]: https://github.com/qubyte/qrcode-png/blob/main/index.js#L6-L118 https://github.com/qubyte/qrcode-png/blob/main/index.js#L6-L...
- Mountain_Skies 5y agoRIP came a year or two too late. It was a nice leap for BBSes but the Web came along and started the decline of BBSes. There were some neat apps written for RIPscript but I'm going to guess that the RIP version of Legend of the Red Dragon was its highest use.
- pepoluan 5y agoSorry if this is tangential, but I just love this discussion. Rather than debating about things, this discussion thread is full of informative tidbits, and fond (or not so fond) reminiscences of image decoding programming.