5 ms·
People need to decide whether they think this is because of supply chain issues and the demand spike following COVID or if it's because of the Fed.
by AnthonyMouse 5y ago
People need to decide whether they think this is because of supply chain issues and the demand spike following COVID or if it's because of the Fed.
- JackPoach 5y agoClearly the Fed mostly. We'll see it once the supply chain issues go away, but high prices stay high.
- MeinBlutIstBlau 5y agoI remember thinking $50k was an awesome salary when I first started working. Now I think "damn how do families survive off that kind of household income" after seeing essential goods and services cost roughly 1.5x what they were pre stimulus.
- dlp211 5y agoMedian household income has gone up. It's currently the highest it's ever been in real terms. Households are better off today then they have ever been in their day-to-day affordability of goods. You also can't cherry-pick a handful of things that have gone up a lot and then assume that it applies to everything. Some things have gone up in price, others haven't. Inflation is sitting at about 6%, which after a decade+ of sub-2% might seem like such a shock, but it isn't really a big deal.
- MeinBlutIstBlau 5y agoAverage hourly wage near me is like $12/hr. That's basically 50k in a 2 adult household. If anyone is projecting it's you thinking everyone has a middle class job...
- JackPoach 5y agoReal wages have been stagnant since 1970s in the US. Median household incomes have only gone up because some people work in highly paid industries, like IT, plus household incomes include income from stocks and real estate AND most households now are two working adults.
- MeinBlutIstBlau 5y ago>AND most households now are two working adults. This is the one aspect I feel like most people gloss over the most. Most people I graduated high school with are dual income households.
- argentinian 5y agoIt's incredible. It's the same strategy that some politicians use in Argentina: they find any kind of thing to blame for inflation, except for monetary policy. Americans, please don't imitate Argentina, keep a healthy economy.
- BitwiseFool 5y agoI know that if Red Team had won the election Blue Team would be running news stories every day about the dangers of inflation and how it is hurting the middle class. Instead, we are seeing pundits downplay inflation as either something 'transitory' or something beneficial: "Why the inflation we're seeing now is a good thing" -MSNBC tweet that got deleted. Edit: "Yes, inflation is back, and you should probably be relieved if not outright happy." https://www.reuters.com/business/inflation-revival-is-victory-not-defeat-central-banks-2021-10-13/ https://www.reuters.com/business/inflation-revival-is-victor...
- rackjack 5y agoI kind of wish we had near 0% inflation rate like Japan. I understand there are downsides to this, and one of the most concerning ones to me is the need to compete with China for economic dominance, since no other country really comes close to America in terms of economic power except maybe China.
- alphabettsy 5y agoI'm told that NYT, WaPost and others are all solidly Blue Team and yet they seem to be running stories about inflation and how much it's risen daily. It's not a good thing in my opinion, but who's to say it's not transitory?
- systemvoltage 5y agoPeople were flagged on HN just 6 months ago for mentioning inflation. There was relentless suppression on HN about inflation until media started reversing the story. The narrative in the media would be have taken a whole another level - scare mongering, etc if it wasn’t the Blue team in the office. I don’t really trust anything but hard numbers from sites such as TradingEconomics or FT. I have no horse in this race but Blue teams vs Red team is getting really dull and frankly annoying. Everyone seems to be wearing tinted glasses. I have higher standards for media and information that I listen and trust - opinions on HN doesn’t cut the mustard. Usually it’s safe to assume that opposite of the current HN zeitgeist is true (I only joke slightly).
- izzydata 5y agoAren't more products being bought than ever despite the supposed supply chain issue? If there is more stuff and still not enough then shouldn't we assume that there is too much money? It looks like standard inflation by a devaluing of the dollar to me.
- AlexandrB 5y ago> Aren't more products being bought than ever despite the supposed supply chain issue? If there is more stuff and still not enough then shouldn't we assume that there is too much money? This doesn't rule out a "demand spike following COVID" as mentioned by the parent. It's like a cartoon where someone (COVID) steps on the hose and a big bulge of water (demand + extra savings) forms. Now that bulge is working its way through the economy causing shortages (analogy completely falls apart here).
- rsj_hn 5y agoThe snake swallowing an elephant theory of the price level would explain a one time increase in the price level, but not higher constant inflation, and certainly not an increasing rate of inflation.
- acdha 5y agoWhy not? It's not like there's a switch somewhere which instantly restored the entire global economy to 2019. Things like shipping or the semiconductor shortage have widespread impacts which are often not obvious if you aren't following a particular field enough to be aware of the dependency web and they can take months to resolve because that has to happen at each bottleneck and things like contractual agreements and labor shortages are not trivial to resolve. That last part is a key one to remember: the pandemic isn't even close to over. Ignoring the people who are dead or suffering long-term health problems, there are a ton of people who either left the workforce for various reasons (childcare, health, etc.) or switched fields and/or locations. That directly increases costs to businesses which have to pay more in wages but it also will have ripple effects for years anywhere buyers are chasing a supply chain which is limited by worker shortages.
- garden_hermit 5y agoWouldn't the evidence of inflation occurring in other countries suggest that COVID is its primary driver, rather than a specific monetary policy? (though it does seem that the scale of inflation in the U.S. is a little higher than elsewhere) See for example: UK: https://www.reuters.com/world/uk/boe-chief-economist-says-uk-inflation-could-top-5-ft-2021-10-21/ https://www.reuters.com/world/uk/boe-chief-economist-says-uk... Australia: https://www.reuters.com/business/australia-core-inflation-speeds-6-yr-high-q3-feeds-rate-fever-2021-10-27/ https://www.reuters.com/business/australia-core-inflation-sp... China: https://www.reuters.com/world/china/chinas-factory-gate-inflation-hits-26-year-high-2021-11-10/ https://www.reuters.com/world/china/chinas-factory-gate-infl... Germany: https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/german-inflation-could-stay-above-2-through-mid-2022-bundesbank-2021-09-27/ https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/german-inflation-could-... Brazil: https://www.reuters.com/article/brazil-economy-inflation/update-1-brazils-inflation-surges-in-august-on-back-of-higher-food-fuel-prices-idUSL1N2QB162 https://www.reuters.com/article/brazil-economy-inflation/upd...
- seibelj 5y agoUS is world reserve currency. We have the ability to print unlimited dollars. All other currencies are primarily backed by US dollars. Most important commodities like oil are priced in USD. Therefore, US drives inflation globally.
- mywittyname 5y agoNo. If the GBP goes up 10% relative to USD, and oil prices go up by 10% in USD, then oil prices remained flat in countries using the GBP, but increase for those using USD. There's no magic here.
- makomk 5y agoOther countries seem to have been pursuing broadly similar monetary policy to the US, at least in the Western world - even the EU and its member states have got in on it this time around.
- Mikeb85 5y agoPeople just need to look at a money supply chart. Edit - it's true. There's a very well established connection between inflation and money supply. Hell, the entire point of QE is to try stimulate inflation to encourage spending to encourage growth. It's not some unknown effect...
- silisili 5y ago"People", in this case mostly the media I think, seem to just pick something random. I watch the stock market which is even worse for this. Every day you'd see "Stocks down as investors weigh COVID", followed by "Stocks up as investor COVID fears wane". Which may be true, but not alternating seemingly every single day for a while. It's like someone sees something happen, wants to write an article, and the boss says "nope, put something catchy on the title."
- Jeema101 5y agoI'm not sure a distinction really matters at this point. Supply chain issues are complex and not within the direct control of policymakers. The money supply, on the other hand, is. "Inflation is always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon in the sense that it is and can be produced only by a more rapid increase in the quantity of money than in output" -Milton Friedman