5 ms·
> A few students came to me asking if I had any ideas for a software project that they could work on outside of class. > I explained an idea for a utility that
by Jensson 5y ago
> A few students came to me asking if I had any ideas for a software project that they could work on outside of class.
> I explained an idea for a utility that I had been wanting: A desktop program that monitors my clipboard for URLs and logs them automatically.
I think this person misunderstood the students, the student wanted a project to practice programming, not a project to practice project management. The programming parts of this would take 2-4 hours, it isn't a terribly hard thing to code. All the project management parts would take days or weeks or even months or years depending on how polished you want it to be.
Giving them a project management project because in your mind project management is more important just to prove a point doesn't help them at all.
- kaishiro 5y agoI've often felt the difference between a junior developer and a senior developer is that a junior developer believes anything that isn't in-the-seat, headphones on, IDE cranking isn't "real development".
- Jensson 5y agoBut you need some level of technical skills before you should start worrying about user concerns, so junior engineers should first and foremost think about the technical parts while the seniors who are more skilled can take a bigger picture view.
- kaishiro 5y agoSounds like a good way to ensure your juniors never grow.
- Jensson 5y agoWhy wouldn't they grow? Once a junior has good technical skills they can start worrying about user concerns and therefore grow in other areas. I see no reason why this would limit them in any way.
- scollet 5y agoI agree with you with a tangential perspective. I think any non-trivial task is going to surface technical limitations which might feed back into the stakeholder decision making process. A junior might be alienated if they are outside that process, but if they approach it with a problem-solving mindset they'll likely have a more intimate knowledge of the closed loop.
- logfromblammo 5y agoThe minimum viable product would take 2h-4h. A professor shouldn't be teaching students to prematurely optimize or to gold-plate their first effort. Deliver version 1 before starting version 2.
- PragmaticPulp 5y ago> The programming parts of this would take 2-4 hours This is, literally, the error that the entire article works on dispelling. Anyone can write a rough command line tool that monitors the clipboard and prints to stdout. Writing a usable GUI application is a lot more work. That’s not project management, that’s coding work. The ratio of project management work to coding isn’t 10:1 or even 100:1 like you’re suggesting.
- kbutler 5y agoGood project management would prioritize the feature list, cut out 95% of the effort to define an MVP that could be delivered with 2-4 hours of coding, and delivered to the user to find out if it's worth doing anything more.
- Jensson 5y agoI could write it to properly log it to a user file, with reasonable default limits and take some of those as command line parameters etc, in a few hours. Running the program at start isn't programming, it is putting it in a "run on start" location, helping users do that is a part of managing the project and not programming. Figuring out what settings a user would want for it is also project management and not programming. Starting/stopping is just starting and stopping the program, every OS already provides that functionality. Maybe someone would want a better UX, but then you are doing UX work and not programming work. So I don't really see it, almost all of the "gotcha" cases he talked about aren't programming problems.
- azhenley 5y agoBut I didn’t give the students a programming problem. I gave them a software project to solve a problem I have, which involves UX and PM work along with some coding.
- Jensson 5y agoRight, but was that what the students asked for? I doubt they thought that they could launch a successful product in 2 hours worth of work.
- alasdair_ 5y ago> I think this person misunderstood the students, the student wanted a project to practice programming, I think you misunderstood the students. The person whose was actually present at the time the words were spoken says the students wanted ideas for a “software project”, not some extremely minimalistically defined “programming problem” It’s completely reasonable to assume they wanted to practice real world software development, not just how to implement the most pedantic set of requirements possible.
- Jensson 5y agoA software project could be "write a web browser" or "write a bug tracker", those are much better since the interface is then an inherent part of the problem to be solved. > It’s completely reasonable to assume they wanted to practice real world software development, I've written real world command line utilities used by other programmers. It takes like an hour, I write the code and document how to use it in a readme, then if they have questions they just ask me. A lot of the time trying to do something complex big design up front kinda thing as suggested in this article is just a waste of time. Fiddling with UX on a project that will only ever get used by a few programmers is a waste of time.
- taneq 5y ago> A lot of the time trying to do something complex big design up front kinda thing as suggested in this article is just a waste of time. This is one of those things that comes with experience. A junior programmer will make a meal of the simplest task. An experienced developer will, if possible, interpret the problem in a way that makes the implementation trivial while still solving the user's problem. Sometimes this doesn't actually involve writing any code at all.
- aaron695 5y agoYep, I remember telling a interviewer the multiples of 15 on FizzBuzz was project management not programming which is why it didn't do it. Its like the programming parts of Facebook is only a weekend, the hard bit is the project management. I assume, since I don't do project management I can't calculate how long the programming parts of Facebook would take.
- that_guy_iain 5y agoReally, I think it was more about showing off how much smarter and knowledgable than their students they are. "My students think it'll only take this long but I've got a bunch of requirements that I never mentioned that make this harder. For example, the no logging feature, that wouldn't get used. Encryption feature, pointless. Syncing with the cloud? Jesus, at this point you're talking about a fully fledge product that wouldn't only add these after multiple rounds of user conversations.
- Gatsky 5y agoAgreed. Very annoying and condescending post. Typical of a high priest (or academics as we like to call them these days).