3 ms·
> It just strikes me as such an opportunity to create a place for these people the problem is finding and filtering the applicants that come to such a place. H
by chii 5y ago
> It just strikes me as such an opportunity to create a place for these people
the problem is finding and filtering the applicants that come to such a place. How do you tell the difference between somebody who just phones it in, from somebody who would actually produce some valid research breakthroughs?
Unless you have unlimited resources to spend, this is a difficult problem to solve.
- dredmorbius 5y agoVery good question and a hard problem of itself. "Success leaves clues" affords some possible hope, though there's also a long history suggesting progress and individual attribution are limited and difficult to assess. There's a history of major research institutions, public and private, including those of Edison, GE, Dupont, AT&T Bell Labs, Xerox, IBM, Microsoft, Google and other companies, as well as the Manhattan Project, WWII signals and computing research (see especially Norbert Wiener's account), the space race and Apollo project, the Santa Fe Institute, and more. These should afford guidance. Often one clear trend is that results follow something of a sigmoid curve --- slow initially, a period of strong progress, followed by a decline. Much engineering trends toward an optimum, not some unlimited potential. Even Moore's Law likely ultimately follows this path.
- DrHedgehog 5y agoI think this is such an interesting question! Perhaps a new science of creative management. I guess there were a few places that presumably seemed to do this successfully (e.g. bell labs :)). There is probably a 51% problem somewhere in there, where the institution would need to make sure it isn't captured by those who would 'phone it in'. Maybe you could pay people a healthy sum to quit at any time. Managing a process which has no defined outcome, but whose local quality and direction can be measured seems like an interesting research path in itself. I think the institute would have to be bootstrapped and a lot of learning would have to take place to make a sustainable version of it. Also, as you say hiring would be challenging (though maybe no more challenging than hiring professors). However, I'll say that I can recognize at least one phenotype of researcher reliably who would thrive there.