4 ms·
Exactly. People sell cars to CarMax for less than they could otherwise get because it's easy, fast, and certain. People buy cars from Carvana over the lowest pr
by sokoloff 5y ago
Exactly. People sell cars to CarMax for less than they could otherwise get because it's easy, fast, and certain. People buy cars from Carvana over the lowest price they could pay elsewhere because it's easy, fast, and certain.
I think there's a lot of money to be earned by turning a slow, tense process into a fast, lower stress process.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoWhat market making opportunities do you see that aren’t currently aggressively competed for?
- sokoloff 5y agoI'm no expert, but as a homeowner and someone who as a result has to employ contractors to fix things, I'd love to see someone make home repairs easier, more certain, and lower aggravation. I think there are probably thousands of other industries/segments where an aggregate hundreds of millions or billions of dollars are spent annually and where people would spend 1 to 2.5% extra if friction were noticeably reduced. That used to be flights, hotels, and cabs that have been made easier in the last 2 decades.
- gruez 5y ago> I'm no expert, but as a homeowner and someone who as a result has to employ contractors to fix things, I'd love to see someone make home repairs easier, more certain, and lower aggravation. While it's definitely possible to improve the experience around that, I don't think it really qualifies as market making. Specifially, look at wikipedia's definition: >A market maker or liquidity provider is a company or an individual that quotes both a buy and a sell price in a tradable asset held in inventory, hoping to make a profit on the bid–ask spread, or turn. You can't really hold "renovations to be done" as an "asset in inventory". It'll be something like uber, ie. a marketplace, not a market maker.
- sokoloff 5y agoThat's fair and I agree that it's friction-reducing but not market-making.
- nradov 5y agoExcept for really basic stuff like snaking a toilet, home repairs and remodeling are all different. It's not a standardized commodity service like flights, hotels, and cabs where the majority of customers all want pretty much the same thing.
- JAlexoid 5y agoAll home repairs - it's a damn nightmare. Home building - complex, slow and expensive RE agencies, seem to compete... but it's an oligopoly market. (just to stay in the RE segment) And all three have severe government monopoly powers and competition killing regulations.
- gnopgnip 5y agoSome would say the real estate brokerage market isn't that competitve. The national realtors association keeps prices artificially high, there is room for ibuyers or market makers to offer a better service, and charge less than 6%
- anonAndOn 5y agoExcept, it never works that way for houses. Banks are reluctant to give mortgages when the roof is EOL, or the siding has dry rot or there is some black mold basically anywhere, etc. Giant Corp may be able to buy quickly and efficiently but Joe Homeowner can't get his loan approved until A, B, and C are fixed. Good luck getting 3 different contractors lined up quickly and under budget while in escrow.
- gruez 5y ago> Banks are reluctant to give mortgages when the roof is EOL, or the siding has dry rot or there is some black mold basically anywhere, etc. but used cars seem to do fine, even though they can be similarly damaged?
- amerkhalid 5y agoUsed cars loans tend to have higher interest rates though.
- pille 5y agoMaybe because used cars cost/risk about 1% as much as houses?
- bena 5y agoAlso, every car has scrap value. Houses don't have that.
- gruez 5y agoThe equivalent for houses is the land they sit on. In metros that could easily be worth more than the house, and in most cases it's worth more (in % terms) than the scrap value of a car.
- gruez 5y agoWhy? because the unit price is lower? Can't zillow just... buy less houses? I don't see anything different between zillow buying a $500k house and one hundred used cars worth $5000 each.
- cwilkes 5y agoAlso the downsides are vastly different between buying a lemon of a car (although I’m those two cases I bet the companies offer a money back guarantee) that you might lose $1-2k on in repairs vs tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars in buying a bad house.