7 ms·
Blind people won the right to break eBook DRM, but they'll have to do it again
- bserge 5y agoLegally, I guess. Because thankfully, it's not hard to create PDF copies of any ebook even in 2021.
- JakeWesorick 5y agoWhere can I get these DRM free eBooks?
- Cthulhu_ 5y agothe pirate bay & friends.
- thaumasiotes 5y agolibgen for books. The pirate bay theoretically covers everything, but good luck finding books there.
- helloworld11 5y agoLibgen is great for older literature and non-fiction books of all kinds, but for modern fiction it sucks.
- hkt 5y agoReally? What have you struggled to find? I've found libgen enormously helpful.
- helloworld11 5y agoMaybe it's just my pop fiction preferences but if I search for any sort of modern horror or sci fi fiction, I just can't seem to find any content. Pirate bay on the other hand? No problem. Like I said though, almost any modern non fiction and a great deal of older fiction literature is definitely there, so I'm definitely not criticizing libgen. It's mostly wonderful, though one worries about malware luring in downloads, but on this maybe im just being paranoid.
- xiconfjs 5y agoTry these Libgen proxy/mirror links: http://libgen.gs/ http://libgen.gs/ (NEW – November 2020) http://gen.lib.rus.ec http://gen.lib.rus.ec http://libgen.rs http://libgen.rs – (NEW – October 2020). https://libgen.is https://libgen.is – (Working Again – May 2021). http://libgen.st http://libgen.st – (Re-directs to www.libgen.rs). http://libgen.li http://libgen.li https://libgen.lc https://libgen.lc http://libgen.io/ http://libgen.io/ (No longer working). https://libgen.be/ https://libgen.be/ (NEW – September 2020 – Search proxies to www.libgen.rs). https://libgen.nl/ https://libgen.nl/ (NEW – September 2020 – Search proxies to www.libgen.rs). If you are having trouble reaching with above Libgen URLs, try http://93.174.95.27 http://93.174.95.27 or http://185.39.10.101 http://185.39.10.101.
- rrrrrrrrrrrryan 5y agoI've literally always just grabbed the latest working URL from the Wikipedia article's sidebar. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Library_Genesis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Library_Genesis
- Klaster_1 5y agoBesides TPB, is there a libgen for audiobooks? Audible blocks lots of books here and the prices are honestly quite steep. TPB often doesn't have what I was looking for, not even something obscure.
- sbst32 5y agoNot actually a joke: audiobookbay.ws
- paol 5y agoThe Calibre ebook managemet app has plugins available that can strip both Amazon and Adobe DRM.
- causi 5y agoOr it used to. Last time I tried it wasn't able to do Amazon anymore.
- salamandersauce 5y agoIt still works for Amazon but it doesn't really work for books in their newer KFX format. It's best to use an older version of Kindle for PC or use their download and transfer to USB if you have a physical eInk Kindle to get an AZW3 file which should unlock no problem.
- AdmiralAsshat 5y agoInstallers for older versions are becoming increasingly elusive, I've found. Anything newer than Kindle for PC v1.26 and DeDRM can't break the encryption. Installers for v1.17 or v1.19 can still be found, but on Linux those versions can't connect to Amazon because one of the SSL certs used by the app has expired. That leaves v1.21 as the "sweet spot", but most of the sites that used to host that installer EXE have mysteriously disappeared.
- Jiro 5y agoYou can get the missing certificate from the links in https://forums.linuxmint.com/viewtopic.php?f=47&t=342186&uid=248652 https://forums.linuxmint.com/viewtopic.php?f=47&t=342186&uid... .
- criddell 5y agoThat workaround gets you the text but it's missing a lot of the recent typographic improvements. It's fine for extracting text for TTS, but isn't ideal if what you are trying to do is maintain a DRM free archive of books you've purchased. It's like saying you can break BluRay DRM by recording the screen with your phone camera.
- thanatos519 5y agoTor: https://www.tor.com/2012/07/20/torforge-e-books-are-now-drm-free/ https://www.tor.com/2012/07/20/torforge-e-books-are-now-drm-...
- sohkamyung 5y agoLibreture maintains a list of DRM free stores [1]. [1] https://www.libreture.com/bookshops/ https://www.libreture.com/bookshops/
- unhammer 5y agoThat's a good list. I've found some stuff I was looking for at Bloomsbury. Tor is probably good if you're into sci-fi/fantasy. But if you're looking for a specific book in English it's typically very hard to find a place to pay for a DRM-free e-book. A search engine that covers all the little sites selling DRM-free books would be nice! (Publishers of Norwegian books fortunately tend to have just do watermarks, which is fine – you can read the book on whatever device you want, and your copy has a little note saying "ex libris Your Name" or something)
- sohkamyung 5y agoKobo [1] and Google Play Books [2] also sells some books DRM free. You have to check the book details to see if it says 'DRM free'. [1] https://www.kobo.com/ https://www.kobo.com/ [2] https://play.google.com/store/books https://play.google.com/store/books
- magikabula 5y agoThe best source for ebooks if definitely eMule
- makeworld 5y agoZ-Library is the best.
- helpfulmandrill 5y agoGreat. Now how about the rest of us?
- werkjohann 5y agoThis is terrible, and while IANAL I’m confused why it doesn’t fall under ADA requirements to provide accessible versions of materials - especially school materials. Also, can people really claim with a straight face that running a book through text-to-speech is the same as a real audiobook (that’s often a voice actor, right?)?
- matwood 5y ago> Also, can people really claim with a straight face that running a book through text-to-speech is the same as a real audiobook (that’s often a voice actor, right?)? TTS is quickly improving. While it's not quite there yet, there are already ways to have any text read with anyones voice. There also comes a point where even if it isn't perfect, it doesn't matter to the consumer who just wants the book read to them. Meanwhile, the publishers want the revenue from selling both versions of the book.
- slaymaker1907 5y agoIt's not really all that grating anymore, just a bit dry in delivery. On a separate note, I think it's really dumb that voice actors can't easily record works without explicit, particular permission from an author. They should license it from the author with some sort of profit sharing per copy, but the current system means there is often only one audiobook version unless a work is public domain. And when I say license it, I mean some sort of form contract available to anyone without huge legal fees.
- bryanrasmussen 5y agofor books popular enough to get that treatment sure, I used to do volunteer reading to make audiobooks but had to quit when someone handed me the most pseudoscientific rubbish to read - it really felt like taking advantage - some book selling a lifestyle advice thing that would lead to immortality!!
- zozbot234 5y agoLibriVox is a well-known project in this space that by and large focuses on worthwhile stuff, not pseudoscientific rubbish.
- laserlight 5y ago> Although the exemption protects people who circumvent digital copyright protections for the sake of accessibility — by using third-party programs to lift text and save it in a different file format, for example — that it's even necessary strikes many as a fundamental injustice. This is not only an injustice, but also a stupidity. What I do with something I paid for should concern only me as long as it's within my personal bounds (no redistribution, no profit, no business, etc.) Breaking DRM for personal use should not and cannot be illegal.
- matheusmoreira 5y agoYeah. This is what happens when laws are bought and paid for by corporations through lobbying. Their concerns just override all common sense.
- slightwinder 5y agoNobody really cares what people do locally on their own. But companies do care when people share this local work with others. And any tool for accessibility can be used for this in one way or another. This is simply a problem of two opposing forced where both have legitimated reasons for their demand. And so far the weak side is losing. It would be better to find some compromise. Having tools and readers with official support for blind people should be the obvious solution. Why do they even need to fight against the publishers, instead of working with them together?
- mattnewton 5y agoIf companies care when people share the work with others means that the act they want to prevent is breaking copyright this way, and it becomes a question of enforcement. I understand its basically impossible to enforce all cases once they have the raw digital text, but does that mean we should ban OCR software and limit the access to high quality scanners in case they are used for copyright infringement? That seems an absurd cost to protect the existing business model. But is also the conclusion to banning DRM circumvention efforts. I think instead we can just go after people selling large number of copies like we always have and publishing will survive. If your business model requires you to break other people’s property rights to something that you ostensibly sold them, in order to enforce it, it usually isn’t a viable business model! Except when you have a massive army of lawyers apparently.
- helloworld11 5y agoFuck having to ask for the "right". If they bought their digital books, they should absolutely be free to do whatever they like with them for personal usability. I can understand the legal rights position here, revolving around bringing attention to the issue of these idiotic rules, but if I buy ebooks, i'll just go ahead and strip their DRM without giving a damn who says no. The absurdity of DRM laws is really made visible again.
- matheusmoreira 5y agoIndeed. What an indignity. People "buy" books only to be forced to beg authorities for access to the items they paid for. It should be the other way around. It should be illegal to prevent this access.
- patrec 5y ago> but if I buy ebooks, i'll just go ahead and strip their DRM without giving a damn who says no Yeah, dream on. How long do you think this option will stay available to you? I sometimes get the impression that intelligent technical people on HN can't see ahead 5 minutes into the future, because being a peon without rights is something that conflicts with their self image as some technical sophisticate not subject to the same insults by our overlords as lowly non-techies. But your relative technical sophistication just means you'll lose some basic control over your privacy, data and possessions at t+ε rather than t.
- Kye 5y agoAsking as a non-sophisticate who has a mental block on most math education beyond 2nd grade: what does t+ε mean? edit: HN would rate limit me if I tried to reply to each explanation with thanks, so: thanks!
- cyberbanjo 5y agoTime + Elapsed Time. AKA not now, but eventually
- DavidPeiffer 5y ago>Even ebooks that are formatted correctly for TTS can have other issues. Math and science are the worst. Textbooks may be formatted for 100 percent accurate text-to-speech, only to falter when it comes to formulas, equations, charts, and tables. Those are typically rendered as images in an ebook, which would require publishers to take an additional step to record "alt text" for each individual figure—audio that would describe the image once encountered by a screen reader. My now wife and I spent hundreds of hours during undergrad converting text and graphs to plaintext for a grad student. Truly nasty formulas, with multiple integrals, fractions with many factors above and below the line, exponents all over. While the legality was questionable at the time, I broke the DRM on the PDF of the book, copied everything to Sublime, removed line breaks, formatted footnotes with [1] formatting, labeled graphs. Then I fired up GIMP and translated the images. When embossed on paper, braille is much larger than normal text, so I had to greatly simplify things. The frustrating part was, on math books, there's a good chance it was LaTeX to begin with. The format we converted formulas to was almost identical to LaTeX. Additionally, surely for undergrad level classes, multiple colleges were each paying undergrad students $1,000+ per course to make the materials accessible. A website where School 1 could see that School 2 had already converted Calculus 1 to braille and allowing payment to reimburse a proportional amount of the cost would be incredible helpful and maybe legal. In essence, $1,000 would be paid by School 1 to do the initial work, School 2 reimburses $500, then School 3 pays $333, split to the other two schools so ultimately, they're all in it for $333 rather than $1,000. ---- I also worked with another student to build a molecule generator for 3d printers. Extensive use of the Blender Python API. Each bond type was a different shape connector, and the periodic table was divided by row and column to form a unique combination of scale and shape. MacMolPlt [1] generated plaintext files that contained the position of each atom, bond connection types, and a list of coordinates for the electron clouds which could also be generated on top of the molecular structure, all exported to .STL for 3d printing. It was a neat project, definitely opened my eyes to disabilities, and I became a more empathetic person because of it. Through some weird stuff with funding, it's sort of in copyright gray area. The disability office was paying to make things accessible for the student, not necessarily to build a tool that would be released to the greater world. It wouldn't be hard to replicate though. Back in 2011, I knew every 3d printer on campus and was kinda begging to print stuff while we tried things out. Now printing is trivially cheap and capacity is abundant - it would be 10x as easy and helpful. [1] https://www.swmath.org/software/7039 https://www.swmath.org/software/7039
- Finnucane 5y agoSome years ago, I wrote the code specification for our ebook conversions. I made a priority of specifying good semantic structure, employ ARIA tags where needed, etc. I work for a university and there was yet no mandate for it, but it seemed only a matter of time. In the long run being a little ahead of the curve aid paid off, but now I need to go through and revise things to account for changing standards, and my own improved (I hope) understanding of what's needed. I'm also reminded of an incident years ago when I was working in a New York, and an agent (for a popular, well-paid writer) called our contract department from my desk phone to insist they remove the clause allowing the LOC to make audiobooks for the blind. As agent crimes go, it might not be the worst, but it always struck me for how egregiously petty it was.
- phendrenad2 5y agoIf a book is printed, and someone asks for a braille version, are you required to provide it?