5 ms·
If you read the comments, two commenters (one claiming experience piloting quite a few different plane types as a skydiver pilot, as well as plenty of hours on
by kelnos 5y ago
If you read the comments, two commenters (one claiming experience piloting quite a few different plane types as a skydiver pilot, as well as plenty of hours on King Air planes) suggest that the pilot here was doing it wrong, and that there's no need (and it's dangerous) to throttle back the engine on the side that the skydivers jump out of. Anyone here experienced enough to comment on this claim?
- nemetroid 5y agoI think the commenters are saying that both engines should have been throttled back.
- speedbird 5y agoYes, and accept that the aircraft will lose some height. Asymmetric thrust, flaps down, large group disrupting airflow over horizontal stabilizer and creating a substantial CofG shift to aft, what could go wrong ...
- jillesvangurp 5y agoNot a pilot, but my interpretation is that the pilot probably tried to slow down to make the jump easier. That got him closer to the stall speed. Having one engine with less thrust is something twin engine pilots train a lot for (engine out scenario) but also something that puts you closer to stall speeds. The rudder is the primary way to control airplane direction when you are close to stall speeds because you lose aileron controls around that time (they don't do much when you stall). It's also what you use during engine out and what can trigger a spin during a stall. Now having the center of gravity change would be dangerous under those circumstances. Stall recovery is also something pilots train for as that is highly dangerous during takeoffs and landings. A landing is basically a controlled stall. Spin recovery is less commonly trained for because it basically means you messed up the stall recovery, which should not happen. Sounds like the pilot did the correct thing (eliminate async trust and nose down). So, not a good incident but it happened at an altitude where there was plenty of time to recover.
- zeusk 5y agoLanding is definitely not a controlled stall. A stall during flare can damage airframe.
- VBprogrammer 5y agoAt some point during landing the wing has to stall. Certainly a 3 point landing in a taildragger is taught as an uncontrolled crash from 2 inches above the ground. The reality is more complex as different parts of the wing will be experiencing different conditions and different wing features (flaps, steps, bugs, dings etc).
- zeusk 5y agoControlled descent and touch down does not require stall. Not sure where you’re getting that but in my type (sr22), touch down is at speeds considerably above stall speed in landing configuration. Ref Approach (100% flap) -> 85-90kt Stall (100% flap) - 59kt And documented stall speeds are when the wingtips and ailerons start losing effectiveness - the wing still generates plenty of lift.
- krisoft 5y agoThis might be a different schools of thought then? The way my flight instructor explained to me (Cessna 150) that you can land very smoothly without stalling, but if your airplane has the energy you are still flying. Just you are doing it 0 inches above the runway. If any outside disturbances increase your energy or redirect you (such as a gust of wind, or a bump on the grass field) you become airborne again and the chances of messing things up increases from there. (bunny hopping etc...) So he expected this stall from 4 inches from me, and told me off if he couldn't hear the stall warning whistle come on at the last moment just before touchdown. That being said I also heard that this is absolutely not how one should land an airliner. This type of landing would cause a tail strike there. So who knows. Maybe my trainer was old school. Maybe what is correct on a Cessna 150 on a grass field is not correct on your type or airfield.
- AdrianB1 5y agoPilot here, but not qualified to launch skydivers: that commenter is right. He explained as much as possible in less than 2 pages of text.
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoYou don't "need to" but reducing the prop wash is a nicety. It's the kind of thing the pilot does in commercial operations (to improve the customer experience) when there's textbook perfect VFR conditions and 10k of margin below you if you run out of power/lift and have to dive out of a stall. It suffices to say marines jumping out of the back of C17s and C130s are not getting that kind of polite treatment. Even if you've got a bunch of well practiced skydivers, having them all get out of the plane quickly and close together is going to make for a much better experience for them. Everyone is gonna pearl clutch about it being "dangerous" but prop washing the crap out of your skydivers also carries some danger. As the video indicates a stall at 10kft isn't really a big deal for a halfway competent pilot. I wouldn't call it a daily occurrence but elevator pilots (skydive pilots) recover from a stall far more than most because they're constantly climbing as fast as possible (because that's the most economic way to run a skydive operation). Considering the kind of pilots who wind up doing skydive operations I think a lot of them would have been tempted to just take their hands off the controls and see if the plane recovers itself (it should) and then intervene if it doesn't. There is no real "answer" here because the activities involved have some baseline danger to them and at best you can just shift it around between parties. Imagine the fallout if someone bumps the horizontal stabilizer on the way out the door and does even the slightest damage to it or gets a minor fracture or something. It's a big f-ing mess. A stall and a bunch of hand wringing is clearly the better outcome for all parties.
- Aeolun 5y ago> I think a lot of them would have been tempted to just take their hands off the controls and see if the plane recovers itself That kind of seems to be what happens in the video? I’ll be the first to admit I know nothing of planes outside of games, but if they’re even marginally accurate being gentle is very important.
- labcomputer 5y ago> As the video indicates a stall at 10kft isn't really a big deal for a halfway competent pilot I don't know about that. I count at least two secondary stalls while the pilot was trying to recover. Or maybe you are saying the pilot is not halfway competent?