5 ms·
SpaceX shut down part of Dishy's API
- KingMachiavelli 5y agoVery cool project. Good thing on Starlink for only removing the potentially sensitive API. Once I'm back to where my Starlink is I'll have to update my system to report to this as well.
- staunch 5y agoIt's fun to see the data and it is a cool project. But running speedtest every 15 minutes sounds like a bad idea. It's going to fully saturate the connection for ~1 minute and is likely to interfere with whatever the connection is being used for. Things like gaming/streaming/video chat are likely going to suffer. Running the status check only during the night would probably be a better idea, and would probably generate data that was still useful. */15 2-6 * * * ~/path/to/starlinkstatus_client.sh -k 'YOURAPIKEY' -s -d >/dev/null 2>&1
- habitue 5y agoYeah but you don't want night only data. You want to know what the speed is while people are actually using it
- smcnally 5y agoAlso, when is night for a global satellite network?
- SECProto 5y agoAs the network doesn't have any satellite interlinks yet, and each bird covers something like a 1500km (if I recall correctly) diameter ground circle - local night is very easy to determine.
- robbedpeter 5y agoA combination of periodic speed tests to multiple reliable endpoints and local netflow statistics are needed to understand network performance. It's relatively easy to set up things like librenms, cacti, and iperf hosted on a vps with dedicated throughput. There's a slew of open source and easily accessible software available. Public speed tests are inaccurate at best, and very often downright misleading. They're good enough for a quick test to see if you're online and a very rough indication of throughput. Even repeated tests to higher quality services though, like fast.com, are not a good benchmark. Set up your own network monitoring stack - once you've built that, you have an anchor point for your home networks that you can riff on instead of being dependent on your isp's default setup. In this case, you could track real-time performance of starlink and be able to trust the data without wondering if there's congestion between fast.com or speedtest.com servers and the local starlink ground station. If you can talk to the datacenter owners in your local fiber hotel where the starlink ground station connects to. They may have an iperf server, or allow you to host one there, giving you another test point when diagnosing an issue.
- cbhl 5y agoIn my personal opinion, you could consider using passive bandwidth estimation approaches, like in Chrome's Network Quality Estimator. See, for example: https://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-networks-ig/2020Jan/att-0003/Network_Quality_Estimation_in_Chrome.pdf https://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-networks-ig/2020... (This is my opinion and not that of my employer.)
- Dylan16807 5y agoFast.com goes for 15 seconds and speedtest.net goes for 15 each way, and you can get reasonable values from a 5 second test if you're worried about causing congestion. It could cause a slight annoyance but the connection's imperfect to start with and I'm sure a lot of people on this beta are interested in the info.
- robertoandred 5y agoShould be "shut down", two words. One word makes it a noun and makes the title confusing.
- akmarinov 5y agoHe’s not a native speaker, dude, chill.
- fortran77 5y agoThe rule on HN is to use the original title.
- HWR_14 5y agoThe rule, as I understand it, is to avoid editorializing/putting a spin on it/misleading people. Not fixing grammatical errors. But I could be wrong.
- causi 5y agoI regularly see people completely change the meaning of the title in the name of fixing what they think is a grammar error. I'd much rather everyone just use the original title and put a [sic] if they feel like it.
- oceanplexian 5y ago> You could also triangulate ground stations with data from enough Dishys etc. what can all be used against them The ground stations locations are public information since they require FCC licenses so this is a bit of a moot point.
- virtuallynathan 5y agoThey aren’t all public globally — there seems to be at least one in Austria based on this data, the location of which is presently unknown.
- aurizon 5y agoA station in China might be able to bypass the great firewall using this now it is gone? Makes me wonder if there were ever any anonymous clandestine stations or is that precluded, or does any data draw get fed to reduce latency? Or would Starlink know and preclude their operation?
- JoshTriplett 5y agoFuture versions of this technology are working towards not needing the ground stations, by transmitting satellite-to-satellite. That would (theoretically) make it technically possible to use a dish in a country with no ground stations.
- mike_d 5y agoA station in China would be _behind_ the firewall. If Starlink had a downlink station in China it probably would have been for factory testing. Companies like Iridium and Inmarsat have already played this game and figured out that it is best to just not sell devices in countries that don't want it. Downlink frequencies are well known, and repressive countries tend to jam transmissions they don't like. This negatively impacts users in the same region.
- aardvarkr 5y agoI can’t say I’m surprised… they probably aren’t too happy to have enthusiasts data mining their high profile internet service.
- jcun4128 5y agoI was kind a curious of the security they have on these satellites. What if you made a worm that spread from satellite to satellite. Spoof the handshake/take control... be interesting. I'm not in the space of pentest or anything but seems like more and more of these satellite constellations for internet are going up.
- akerl_ 5y agoThis seems more like the plot of Swordfish 2 than an actual attack vector.
- KMnO4 5y agoThe Air Force actually sponsored a CTF at Defcon (a hacker conference in Las Vegas) where the goal was to hack a live satellite: https://www.wired.com/story/air-force-defcon-satellite-hacking/?intcid=inline_amp https://www.wired.com/story/air-force-defcon-satellite-hacki...
- jonplackett 5y agoYeah also curious how they can keep this secure. I guess there must be a reliable way all sat makers have figured out for this.
- KennyBlanken 5y ago> Many people, especially competitors of Starlink, could try and use that data to do things against SpaceX, what would be bad for all Starlink users. Oh no, one of the most visible, outspoken libertarians of the day might face some competition...and somehow that competition will hurt starlink users? This is some strange pearl clutching. I doubt the API was revealing anything not already known by researchers both academic and commercial. Probably half of it is in some FCC filing somewhere.
- edrxty 5y agoYeah this whole post makes absolutely no sense. None of this information is problematic in any way and none of the explanations as to why the author thinks it could be bad are at all sound.