5 ms·
I feel genuinely conflicted about these topics. Part of me says “I agree with the letter authors completely. People should experience equal opportunity, equal J
by sokoloff 5y ago
I feel genuinely conflicted about these topics. Part of me says “I agree with the letter authors completely. People should experience equal opportunity, equal Justice, and equal responsibility.” Another part of me says “that’s literally impossible (or incompatible) with different families raising their children with different circumstances.”
Overall, I lean pretty strongly towards individual families raising their children as best they can with all the benefits and drawbacks that come from that system. But I think it’s fantasy to believe that that results in even approximately equal opportunities.
My kids will get way more comp.sci and math from me and more biology from my wife than average. Other kids will get more music, art, writing, foreign language, sports or other exposure from their family. If it turns out that one of those is more valuable, well the different kids didn’t have equal opportunities. Other kids worried about nutrition, whether one parent would beat the other, or grow up with a parent in jail. Clearly not equal opportunity.
- anonair 5y agoyes, but the system, where we tend to equalize the outcomes is easier to abuse.
- tim333 5y agoOne of the problems with wokeness is I think it started as perfectly reasonable stuff like you mention, but then the activists / priests of wokeness let power go to their heads and get more concerned with having anyone who criticises them fired than helping the underprivileged.
- throwawaymanbot 5y agoSo wokeness is SYSTEMD ???
- RattleyCooper 5y ago>If it turns out that one of those is more valuable, well the different kids didn’t have equal opportunities. Other kids worried about nutrition, whether one parent would beat the other, or grow up with a parent in jail. Clearly not equal opportunity. You confuse equal opportunity with equal circumstances. All we can do is give people equal opportunity under law, so that nobody is restricted from opportunity from a legal perspective. Trying to solve the problem of equal circumstances will always result in the violation of human rights. We should do our best to give people the tools and education they need to succeed so that these other factors do not influence their life as much, and they can overcome the obstacles that they've been presented with.
- markus_zhang 5y agoI think to achieve equal opportunity it makes sense to make education equal. But how to make education equal? Instead of setting up quotas maybe we should simply switch teachers. Let the teachers rotate among schools so that every kid gets a random selection of teachers and every teacher gets a random selection of students. At the same time, should also try to minimize the number of private schools, either through legislation or tax. I guess it still won't work perfectly because teachers can simply go private by themselves. Meh. Whatever.
- sokoloff 5y agoEven that won’t do it. Kids show up to kindergarten with wildly different abilities to even “take turns” and participate conversationally. Kids who had less adult conversational interaction as toddlers won’t get the same out of school even with the teachers being in rotation. There’s disagreement as to whether the gap is 30 million words, but it seems quite likely to be well into the millions. https://www.edutopia.org/article/new-research-ignites-debate-30-million-word-gap https://www.edutopia.org/article/new-research-ignites-debate... It’s hard.
- Pensacola 5y agoAll of these replies seem to co-mingle the concepts of equal opportunity and equal outcome. The foundation of a free society is personal responsibility. Personal outcomes in such a system are pretty much guaranteed not to be the same (equal), since different people will use their freedom in different ways. Sucks for kids of irresponsible parents, who truly don't have self-autonomy. But then again, our society is full of compassionate safety nets for such kids.
- sokoloff 5y agoYou raise a very fair question of “when does someone have the responsibility for turning their opportunity into their outcome and how quickly does that responsibility ramp from 0% theirs to 100% theirs? Could it ever begin before conception? Could it ever begin before birth? At 6 months of age? At 1, 2, or 3 years of age? Is it 100% “on them” at 12, 16, 18, or 21?
- ipaddr 5y agoThe answer and the future is kids will be raised by the state and given an equal playing field. This frees parents to work/spend and ensures the only advantage exists at the gene level. We can selectively breed those traits away . The problem is we sent kids to school in the first place and ask them to follow a system designed for the average student but not the most typical.
- molbioguy 5y agoThis is "Brave New World" (Aldous Huxley, 1931) in a nutshell!
- Pensacola 5y agoThis was written by a non-parent.
- rkk3 5y ago> future is kids will be raised by the state and given an equal playing field. This seems dystopian...
- swader999 5y agoCanada tried that. It didn't go so well. Probably the worst thing you can do for society.
- jimbob45 5y agoFeel free to expand. As a US-based individual, I’m not likely to ever get the perspective of a Canadian on this topic.
- 908B64B197 5y agoThe British and later Canadian (of British descent mostly) Administration had native children raised by the state. The end results are, well, let's just say it makes what's happening to the Uighur look not so bad in comparison. [0] BTW these "schools" were still around when their current leader's father (Trudeau) was in office. [0] https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-57592243 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-57592243
- smitty1e 5y agoThere is nothing defensible regarding the collapse of higher education in the U.S.
- _57jb 5y agoThis feels like a really well explained point. It may be a stretch but I feel nature plays dice where certain events exploit advantages. It feels like something that is futile to balance against. Perhaps understanding our tribalism and need to differentiate by color, sex, nationalism, etc. It feels like there are moving parts we are not discussing whether because of sensitivity or because we just don't fully understand.
- ankushnarula 5y agoWhat’s the limiting principle or boundary condition of “equal opportunity”? Is every social institution required to compensate for all external inequalities? If so, how can each institution subjectively compensate for social inequalities without diminishing their respective core functions? The point here is that institutions must provide equal opportunity within their own functional scope. But simultaneously, institutions must also maintain enough filtering criteria to ensure they do not abandon their core function. MIT best serves general social questions of equal opportunity by accepting individuals based on some standard quantifiable baseline filtering criteria, and tackling such vast social questions through open and honest inquiry & research. As a side note, perhaps institutions that are closer to problems like social inequality are best suited to serve them.