8 ms·
I live in Cambridge (across the river from and on the same subway system as Boston). In theory Amtrak should be able to attract my business for trips to NYC. Pr
by sokoloff 5y ago
I live in Cambridge (across the river from and on the same subway system as Boston). In theory Amtrak should be able to attract my business for trips to NYC. Prior to COVID, about twice as often I flew to NYC as took rail. The times I took rail, the train literally never arrived on time at either end of the journey. We’d sit for an hour waiting for some track or switch problem to be fixed. Or we’d sit for a few 15 minute stretches for no apparent or announced reason.
If I could count on the arrival time, I could use the train for business meetings near the train station. Since I can’t, I fly in and Uber over which, even if it takes longer per the published timetable, has less tail-risk of being late.
No one needs hourly rail service between city pairs (as the article implicitly calls for) while the variability is -10 to +150 minutes.
Looking for a Nov 15-19 trip to NYC, Amtrak is $306 on Acela and I could plan to start working around lunch on Monday and work a full day on Friday if I was willing to arrive home around midnight. On Delta, waking up around the same time, I could reliably attend a 9AM meeting on Monday and working the same full day Friday, get home in time to say good night to my kids. That would cost $157 plus two Ubers. That’s with spotting Amtrak the advantage of a meeting walking distance from Penn Station and riding on the crown jewel of the Amtrak network: Northeast corridor Acela.
- ardit33 5y agoI am the opposite of you. I live in NYC and my parents in Boston, and I take the train all the time. Flying is very unpleasant, as you still have to deal with getting in and out of airports, the whole stay in the TSA line, remove your shoes and belt thing. You are completely omitting the security crap you have to deal with air travel. Meanwhile the train trip starts and ends in downtown. (I live in manhattan and can just walk to the train station). Also, just the taxi fare from JFK to Manhattan is about 70+ tips. Sure, you can take the subway ($8), but that will add another 1hr to your trip.
- carbocation 5y agoDoesn't really strike me as the opposite. If the GP post is talking about being on time for specific meetings and you are talking about visiting family, you're optimizing for different objectives. Personally, I use the train vs fly to NY from BOS depending on my objective.
- lddemi 5y agoyour air travel could be significantly optimized with TSA Precheck ($20year) and Clear ($120/year) to effectively eliminate security headaches
- samstave 5y agoAnd into what little database are my deets being entered for eternity by using either of these options, and to whom does the visibility to this data go?
- iso1210 5y agoPresumably the same database your details go in anyway, just with less security theatre.
- Scoundreller 5y agoYeah, we can’t make it look like we’re relaxing security, but if we charge you an application, sit on it, and make felons lives worse, that’s cool.
- sokoloff 5y agoLooking over the felonies for which TSA PreCheck is unavailable, it doesn’t appear to a thoughtlessly compiled make-felons-suffer list: https://www.tsa.gov/disqualifying-offenses-factors https://www.tsa.gov/disqualifying-offenses-factors
- Kye 5y agoI can see it for Part C, but why A and B? If someone's been charged and done whatever was required to be free enough that they can fly, then that should be the end of it. Especially things on that list. If treason isn't enough for the government to execute them or lock them up and throw away the key, then it shouldn't matter to the TSA.
- samstave 5y agoI remember one time, before Uber existed, I was flying to LAX from SFO. The cab from my apartment on Upper Market, in SF to SFO was $65 before 'tip'. 13 miles. The FLIGHT from SFO to LAX was $99. https://i.imgur.com/uXCj3MR.png https://i.imgur.com/uXCj3MR.png After this, I had several Black Cars that I made contacts with the drivers - and would call them for rides to SFO (I flew out every sunday morning at 7am - and it was a nightmare getting cabs (I was banned by several taxi companies in SF because I would call three diff taxi services and 2 out of 3 would never show up... but apparently they shared dispatching info because the dispatchers knew that my number was calling multiple taxis... and the guy told me "your banned for calling multiple cabs!" to which I replied "because you never show up and I need to get to the airport (said in a George Costanza voice)) Then Uber was born...
- asciimike 5y agoI paid $65.28 (before tip) for a Lyft from downtown to SFO last night (14.27 miles), for a $120 flight to DEN. I'd like to think that Uber/Lyft changed the industry for the better (and in many ways they did: app is easier, upfront pricing, easier/safer payment, more accountability through location tracking and ratings), but I don't think that the underlying economics have changed all that much (other than the period of time where Sand Hill Road was footing half the bill).
- clairity 5y agowhy not take bart, especially anywhere near market? it's roughly $10 to either sfo or oak and pretty reliable. in LA, the flyaway is affordable and relatively reliable too, if your destination is near downtown, or on the red or orange lines.
- samstave 5y agomy flights were early on sunday mornings.... bart is not an option at my timings.
- systemvoltage 5y agoPeople from the 1950's would be shocked at today's infrastructure progress in the US. "What!?? You guys are still traveling at the same or worse speeds 70 years later!? What happened?" Also, it took 2x the cost and 8 years to build an access bridge to Golden Gate bridge than it did to build the bridge itself (3.5 years in 1930s) accounting for inflation. Our government is so dysfunctional, it is hard to imagine where my taxes are going. I live in Bay Area - No solution to homelessness here, pot holes everywhere, trash on highways that sometimes make me wonder if I am in a developing nation, new construction is a forgotten concept, complete gridlock in the CA gov for issuing permits of any high rises or building new subway systems, security and crime through the roof, etc. I am extremely against everything about CA government. It is rotten to the deepest core. Anything it does bites dust. The entrepreneur spirit and its natural beauty is what's keeping it relevant. There is no point in voting any of these people out, because the replacement is exactly the same kind of people. Besides the tech industry, people here have no optimism, they're more pro China than pro US, mostly busy destroying this great state.
- iso1210 5y ago> There is no point in voting any of these people out, because the replacement is exactly the same kind of people So why don't you stand?
- LeanderK 5y ago> So why don't you stand? I am not an american, so I wonder whether it's realistic? I imagine the US as a 2 party system, so if you're unsatisfied with the performance with one party and unable to vote for the other because of their actual political stance...what are you're left with? In germany we have a spectrum of pasties and therefore i have second choice, a choice to build up pressure against the party I am unsatisfied with even if I feel like I belong to this party. What do you do? Vote for independents? Do they even stand a chance?
- sokoloff 5y ago> In germany we have a spectrum of pasties and therefore i have second choice That’s obviously a typo but, in this context, it’s hilarious.
- diebeforei485 5y agoI usually took LIRR from JFK when I visited NYC, which is faster and more comfortable than the subway and often faster than Uber/taxi. Penn Station is convenient for most of Manhattan, and Atlantic Terminal is good enough for the parts of Brooklyn I typically stayed at. A bit more expensive than the subway, especially during peak hours, but worth it IMO.
- fennecfoxen 5y ago> $70 plus tips LIRR into Penn. $16 air train + peak direction ticket (you can buy the latter on your phone) and much faster (20 minutes after you catch it at Jamaica). Less annoying going into Penn than going out, at least.
- iso1210 5y ago> No one needs hourly rail service between city pairs (as the article implicitly calls for) while the variability is -10 to +150 minutes. While there's always a risk for delays (I've been stuck at Heathrow for 3 hours before thinking "If I'd have taken the train I'd be there by now"), you should be aiming for a network at 95%+ of services arriving within a few minutes of the arrival time. I understand that US passenger trains don't have priority, and thus this isn't workable. On that assumption, given the distance and size of Boston/NY/Philly/Washington, I'd expect at least a 30 minute service, taking well under 4 hours (should really be under 3) from Boston to Washington (with stops in NY, and maybe Phillidelphia). It's only 400 miles, that's like Paris-Marseille, and far shorted than a 4 hour 560 mile Tokyo - Hiroshima trip)
- xxpor 5y ago>I understand that US passenger trains don't have priority, and thus this isn't workable. This is largely true, but isn't on the NEC. It's one of the few corridors that Amtrak actually owns.
- Redoubts 5y agoMostly. They don’t own the stretch through Connecticut for example, and the train will come to full stops between stations as a result.
- PLenz 5y agoThis stretch is owned by another rail network (ConnDot) that prioritizes other passenger trains (Metro North and Shoreline East)
- iso1210 5y agoThere's a large advantage to passengers having a nationally organized network - same as with air traffic control (provided by government), or highways (provided by government). Of course track segregation between non stop services and local services would be better.
- jghn 5y agoI like the idea of the BOS-NYC Amtrak. When there aren't delays it's fantastic. More pleasant trip than flying, no security theater, and I'm right in the middle of the city when I arrive. But to your point, more than half the time I take that trip there's some delay on the rails, usually in the CT corridor.
- sokoloff 5y agoThe idea is fantastic. The reality is not.
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoThe reality is so bad that people would rather ride the Fung Wa bus.
- hawaiianbrah 5y agoOh man! I remember riding fung wa over a decade ago. Wow, time flies.
- jghn 5y agoI have some "fond" memories of the Fung Wah circa 2002-2005. I use to take it roundtrip about once a week during that time period. There was the time that we broke down on the Triborough Bridge and were stuck for hours. Or the time that a woman managed to lock herself in the bathroom without anyone else knowing. And there were no lights on in there. And it was night. So she spent a few hours screaming for help in a stinky bus bathroom, with no help to be found.
- micromacrofoot 5y agothey’re also speed limited in that CT area because it’s a residential area iirc, so it’s not even full speed service
- bobthepanda 5y ago
- checkyoursudo 5y agoI just looked for an approximately similar trip in terms of distance and dates in Germany. On Monday morning Nov 15, you could take a train from Munich to Heidelberg starting at 23.90 euros (one way), while the first-class ticket (one way) appears to be 33.90 euros. Why are Amtrak tickets so expensive?
- sokoloff 5y agoI suspect largely because the ridership is so low. There were 3.5 million total Acela passengers in 2019 (chosen to avoid COVID effects on volume). Acela is only part of the Amtrak service offering, but it’s the part they tout as being the best Amtrak has to offer. Total Amtrak volume was around 32.5 million trips in 2019 (unclear if a round trip is 1 or 2 trips, but I assume 2). In any case, that’s slightly under 1 train trip (however they are counting it) per 10 US residents per year. From quick googling, the German comparables seem to be 151 million long-distance train trips for around 83 million people, or around 5x the total usage and 20x the per-capita usage.
- bobthepanda 5y agoAmtrak charges the market clearing price. There is quite frankly a fuckton of demand in the Northeast corridor with its 52 million residents along the one line, and not a whole lot of rail capacity due to the fact that Amtrak barely has money to keep the lights on and the NEC is 100+ years old and in need of significant capacity upgrades. (There are only two tracks connecting New York to the entire south and west of the country, for example.) Even at the very high Amtrak prices the trains run full.
- spicybright 5y agoIf you converted Euros to USD based on today's exchange rate, that's 23.90 EUR = 27.61 USD 33.90 EUR = 39.16 USD As an american that's the lowest I've seen any kind of train ticket regardless of distance.
- cozzyd 5y agoChicago to Milwaukee is ~$25, though that's only 90 miles.
- hakfoo 5y agoI think the Acela is comically more expensive than conventional Amtrak though. They only offer the premium class seats with comical levels of legroom. I took it once in 2016 (Washington-Baltimore) and it was $45 one way, and the conventional, ACS-64 and Amfleet coaches return trip was $15.
- matthewdgreen 5y agoConsider the fact that selling an Acela ticket from DC to Baltimore means Amtrak can’t sell that seat to someone who wants to travel on the popular DC-NYC segment. They price highly to discourage this usage. $15 on the Regional trains is a steal: the MARC commuter train is around $7.
- _delirium 5y agoInteresting, my experience for NYC-DC is completely different. It's pretty much always on time, at most 15-20 minutes late, at least if you buy NE Regional or Acela. I do avoid buying northbound tickets on long-distance routes that originate way off (e.g. the Crescent from New Orleans, or Palmetto from Savannah), since they can get delayed way before they get to DC. I've been taking it every other week or so since August. I didn't realize NYC-Boston was that much worse. I also buy my tickets way in advance (my schedule is predictable, and Amtrak is offering free changes currently anyway) so usually pay around $30 for the NE Regional or $70 for the Acela each way, which is an amazing deal compared to flying (or even driving).
- bink 5y agoMy experience was similar to yours. It's been a few years but I used to commute weekly from DC to NY. Sometimes I'd take the Acela and sometimes the regional, depending on price. I never had an issue either way. My biggest inconvenience was the shitty waiting area and mob of people at Penn Station, but even that was better than the TSA lines at the airport (or the dreaded Dulles people mover shudder).
- namdnay 5y agoThe solution seems quite obvious: a big tax on flights, reinvested in rail infrastructure. At some point we have to help the market find lower carbon solutions, what better way than replacing short haul flights with trains?
- sokoloff 5y agoIf you want to tax net carbon emissions, I’m all ears and, unless you work very hard to come up with an intentionally terrible plan, I’m very supportive. If you instead want to tax specific conveniences to help inconvenient services survive despite their inconvenience and lack of improvement, well, let’s just say that I’m significantly less receptive.
- crooked-v 5y agoMost of the major issues with Amtrak in the US come down to not actually having control over the track that's in use, and that's never going to be fixed without a real big money infusion.
- namdnay 5y agoI want to tax something that is very bad for the environment and fund something that is very good. The free market is great for many things, but not for core infrastructure. What’s missing in the US is a basic passenger rail infrastructure. Once you’ve built that, fine, let operators work in a free market environment
- sokoloff 5y agoIf you’re still talking about the environment at the end of your first sentence, rail is not “very good”. At best it’s “less bad” for the environment; to that end, it seems like a broad carbon emission tax provides a better balance (and is easier to ramp up on a schedule needed to effect change) than a quilt work of individually targeted taxes against things you don’t value. Everyone emitting ancient carbon is a problem; tax it all.
- jcranmer 5y ago> riding on the crown jewel of the Amtrak network: Northeast corridor Acela. It is worth pointing out that it's unanimously agreed that the worst part of the NEC is the Connecticut segment, especially New Haven-New Rochelle, as Metro North is responsible for the dispatching there and they do not do Amtrak any favors. Every time I'm riding Amtrak on that segment, it feels like the train is stuck behind some pokey local commuter rail rather than expressing around it, and this is not something I ever felt on the MARC, SEPTA, NJT, or MBTA portions of the line.
- dantheman 5y agoIt'd be great if Amtrack could improve its only profitable line instead of using it subsidize all the ones that lose money.
- addicted 5y agoCompletely agreed. The only thing I will add is that it’s not only it’s only profitable line, but equally importantly, it’s only useful line. Amtrak, as the original article points out, is simply not useful in much of the rest of the country.
- jonas21 5y agoA few years back, I commuted almost every week between Boston and NYC on Amtrak (~80 trips total) and had a very different experience. I took the NE Regional instead of Acela because it was $49 each way and only ~30 minutes longer than Acela. With the exception of blizzards (which wreaked havoc on everything), there were only a handful of times the train didn't arrive within 30 minutes of schedule (a delay of 10-20 minutes was pretty normal - but I just factored that into my schedule). In that period, I flew the same trip maybe 5 or 6 times, and that was more unpredictable. Once, my flight was delayed by over an hour. Another time, I spent almost two hours in a Lyft getting from JFK into Manhattan due to construction. Plus, there was the stress of trying to get to the airport on time on both ends. And worrying about whether there'd be a line at security, and trying to figure out what I'd do if I missed my flight. On the other hand getting to South Station and Penn Station was easy, I could walk right onto the train, and if I thought I was going to miss a train, I could just switch my ticket to the next one.
- bwanab 5y agoYour experience in flying between NYC and Boston on a Friday afternoon/evening flight must be really different from mine. I’ve spent hours in one or the other airport at times waiting for god knows what “equipment” to become available. The other side of the coin is that I find I can get a lot of work (or book reading, or movie watching) done with a beer in my hand on the train. Obviously different people have different preferences, but I wonder sometimes if our preconceived preferences affect our perception of the real events we’ve experienced - that includes my own to be sure.
- dylan604 5y ago>That would cost $157 plus two Ubers Depending on market, those two Ubers could nearly double the ticket price. I just checked my app, and a ride to the airport is $53. It won't be any cheaper coming home. Just a reminder that you can't really just write off the cost of the Ubers. nevermind the hassle of just dealing with airports
- Talanes 5y agoGP does have $149 worth of wiggle room to fit those two Ubers in and have their point still work, so I think not trying to exactly estimate their prices was fine.
- dylan604 5y agoYes, I can do the arithmetic. $300 for a train ticket or $150 + $50+ + $50+ is only ~$50 off. Plus, the hassle of TSA x2 airports twice. My point is that, all things considered, the price difference really isn't that great and can be even smaller depending on the flex pricing of Uber. I wasn't trying to quibble over a couple of dollars.
- Talanes 5y agoBut their argument also priced in such massive time savings on the flying route that even an equal price is clearly in the flight's favor.
- adrian_b 5y agoI do not know if this was also true in USA, but in many European countries, more than one hundred years ago, but still also when I was a child, in the rural areas people used to set their clocks at the correct hour when they heard the train passing. For some reason, unlike in the old times and despite the advanced technology that we have now, wide variations in the train arrival times have become common in many countries, even if not so extreme as in USA. (Even in Germany, which in the past had a reputation for punctuality.) Perhaps the train companies have become too greedy and they no longer allocate the appropriate funds for maintenance, like in the old times.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- midasuni 5y agoIn europe the infrastructure is run far more intensively than in the past, a 60 second delay at a station while someone holds the doors has a knock on at a busy junction which leads to 20 minute delays 100 miles away for the next few hours, just like someone cutting in on an interstate can cause a brake wave causing delays an hour later 20 miles away. This intensiveness is to transport the largest number of people possible.
- throwawaysea 5y agoAre these shared rails with freight priority? I think that is a key issue with Amtrak service in most of the country. It is a halfway investment that deters further investment due to its poor quality of service but with dedicated infrastructure it would be very different in performance.
- addicted 5y agoAmtrak milks the North East Corridor to subsidize its woefully expensive and useless service in most of the rest of the country. There is absolutely no reason anyone should be driving to and from Boston/NYC other than Amtrak being a shit show. Boston to NYC should be a little more than an hour on real high speed rail. Even assuming you can’t do real high speed rail it should not be more than about 2.5hrs. And it should be running every hour at most.
- dreamcompiler 5y agoAnd Acela is the useful Amtrak train. Outside the NE corridor, Amtrak is often many hours late. It's really only used by people afraid of flying, railfans (like me), and Amish people. That's just not a big enough customer base to support a train service. Their service has degraded so much in the last 10 years that even I am considering never riding Amtrak again outside the NE corridor; it's just not fun any more.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]