8 ms·
I don’t think I understand what the motivation is for consumers to install Windows 11. It seems like exclusively new requirements and zero new features over Win
by loeg 5y ago
I don’t think I understand what the motivation is for consumers to install Windows 11. It seems like exclusively new requirements and zero new features over Windows 10. With that understanding, other than for a fun intellectual exercise, I’m not sure why you would try to install it by bypassing Microsoft’s requirements list.
- habeebtc 5y agoI mean. It goes to 11! You might wonder, why they don't just make 10 louder. But it goes to 11!
- invokestatic 5y agoI actually completely agree after upgrading. Very trivial differences over 10. At least it forced me to upgrade from MBR to GPT and UEFI boot.
- Someone1234 5y agoI'm running it right now, and I cannot tell you why. It has a lot of incomplete ideas and feels really unfinished. I think Windows 11 could be worthwhile next year after it is more finished/polished and the Amazon/Android app store is available; but as of today you're just volunteering to be an unpaid tester for unfinished software. Pretty obvious Microsoft just rushed it out in time for Christmas, so their OEM partners could sell "Windows 11 Compatible" PCs. Feels like they didn't learn much from Vista in that the stigma an OS ships with hangs around its neck forever.
- jhanschoo 5y agoGoing on a tangent here, the decision for a consumer whether to adopt Win11 aside, it seems to me the whole raison d'être for Win11 rather than continuing to build on Win10 is exactly the additional requirements. They likely want laptops being sold running Win11 to have sane security capabilities for corporate use out of the box. Other that that there's no reason why they can't continue building on Win10.
- _Understated_ 5y ago> They likely want laptops being sold running Win11 to have sane security capabilities for corporate use out of the box Corporate security has been fine for years: TPM 1.2 (if I remember the versions correctly) alongside bitlocker and sensible corporate policies render computers all but impervious to everything. However, this implies a competent IT division in your company... I've worked in plenty without them! Social engineering or clicking a dodgy link/download is probably a bigger threat than someone hacking your computer and that can be mitigated to a huge extent by restricting access to only the things that the user needs, locking down apps, running with low privileges, auditing relevant things etc... again, competent IT division needed for this too. Now, if your threat matrix includes nation-states then one could argue that any device is hackable. My take is that hardware vendors saw the writing on the wall with the pandemic-buying about to ease-up and worked with Microsoft (or pressured them...) to help out. We're already seeing Chromebooks on the wane[0]. From my perspective (long-time Windows guy now on Fedora) I see nothing of value in Windows 11 that 10 didn't have already. Edit: Forgot the answer I was gonna write :) [0] - https://chromeunboxed.com/canalys-report-chromebook-sales-down-q3-2021 https://chromeunboxed.com/canalys-report-chromebook-sales-do...
- bitwize 5y agoWhat they want is to sneak Palladium in through the back door. The future of the x86 platform is a signed code path from power-on to application code. Even Linux thought leaders, like Lennart and Matthew Garrett, are on board with this idea. The problem is, as we learned with ActiveX, code signing cannot attest that code is safe, only that it came from a particular place. But then again, the goal of verifying where code comes from is not safety, it's control over who gets to run code on the platform. And who has that control? Who is the only CA recognized as authoritative by hardware OEMs for Secure Boot purposes? Microsoft. Remember, you run Linux on modern hardware only because Microsoft allows you to. Microsoft signed the Red Hat shim, and if you disabled Secure Boot, it's only because a Microsoft policy gave you the ability to disable it -- a policy they can later reverse.
- warkdarrior 5y agoToo true. This is why I hate that both Debian and Ubuntu sign their packages. They're trying to control us, man! /s
- __s 5y agoUpdate last night updated Outlook's UI, now the top bar is taking up way too much vertical space that I had to configure ribbon to autohide to not have 20% of vertical space eaten up. Just adds on to start bar being stuck at bottom as opposed to the left where I liked it. No respect for vertical space
- craftinator 5y agoI had to install windows to get access to some CAD programs, but comments like this really reinforce my decision to not use it as my main OS. There are so many things that are anti-user, and extremely difficult to modify. What are some of reasons to use windows, other than for niche applications that don't work under wine?
- neltnerb 5y agoI have not had great luck with speech recognition on Linux, but I suspect that will be solved before there's a compelling reason to use Windows other than having no other choice due to niche applications.
- ricardobayes 5y agoIf it wasn't for running AAA games natively, I would happily ditch windows. The day most AAA games come out on Metal API for mac, I'll gladly switch.
- kadoban 5y agoIf it's only AAA games, you should be able to get by on Linux _quite_ well these days, if that strikes your fancy better than Windows. I actually can't remember the last game I tried that didn't work. You may want to look up the compatability of the last few you played though just to make sure your genre(s) won't get a lot worse milage than what I play.
- ricardobayes 5y agoGenshin is a famous example these days, even though I don't play it.
- comeonseriously 5y agoThey have to keep up the streak of flubbing up every other release of Windows.
- ricardobayes 5y agoWhat's really frustrating, is it broke most games. Valorant straight out doesn't run, csgo crashes like crazy. It feels like a beta.
- filiphorvat 5y agoFrom my perspective, it has some great new features. WSLg and WSA, for example.
- ChuckNorris89 5y ago>It seems like exclusively new requirements and zero new features over Windows 10. I'm confused by your statement. Were you trying to be snarky or were you commenting without actually informing yourself regarding the two OSs? Because the difference in features between Win 10 and 11 is just a quick Google search away. Most proeminent features for Windows 11 are an updated scheduler tailored to big.little architectures like the new Alder Lake from Intel and Direct Storage for games, a rebranding of the same feature from Xbox One and PS5. Yes, Windows 11 is pretty useless over Windows 10 if you have a previous gen system, but if you're buying a brand spanking new PC with Alder Lake or Direct Storage and are a hardcore gamer then it makes sense to go directly to Windows 11 to get the new shiny features (provided you experience no bugs on 11 that haven't been ironed out yet). There are some other nice touches in Win11 like WSLg and the OS restoring your windows positions on multi monitor setups as they were between an undock - dock cycle of your laptop.
- _Understated_ 5y ago> Most proeminent features for Windows 11 are an updated scheduler tailored to big.little architectures like the new Alder Lake from Intel and Direct Storage for games, a rebranding of the same feature from Xbox One and PS5. Let's be honest here though: those could easily have been added to Windows 10 as they will be on the same kernel... they added them to Windows 11 so that people would buy the new shiny! I'm not saying it's wrong, companies need to get new money in to keep going, but those features hardly merited a "new" OS :)
- ChuckNorris89 5y ago>Let's be honest here though: those could easily have been added to Windows 10 as they will be on the same kernel... they added them to Windows 11 so that people would buy the new shiny! Well yes of course, obviously, but I was not trying to defend Microsoft's choice here, just pointing out the feature difference between them as great-grandparent was being vocally critical without doing any prior research beforehand or he was just being intentionally snarky to score karma points from the Microsoft/Windows 11 hate mob.
- 5y ago
- vanchor3 5y agoI installed it exclusively for WSL2 CUDA/GPU support (for ML). This was previously only available in an Insiders build of Windows 10, and I got tired of waiting over a year for Microsoft to keep delaying it. It probably wasn't worth it, since now I just have a worse version of Windows 10.
- lostmsu 5y agoWhy can't you just do ML in Windows? All common Python packages are supported. WSL2 CUDA probably gonna come with some overhead.
- vanchor3 5y agoI'm sure it's possible, but I was trying to use Stylegan2, which I spent way too many hours fiddling with trying to get it to work in Windows. I'm sure it was something simple I was doing wrong, but everyone I asked just went "just use Linux, Windows isn't recommended".
- idatum 5y agoMy laptop was capable of upgrading to Win11 and WSLg was my main motivation. I like the mix of Windows and Linux and having Linux graphics and pulseaudio mixed in with native Windows. This most likely wouldn't be described as a "consumer feature". More important for me are some opencv projects I have: You get access to your GPU compute. I can install CUDA+DNN on my WSL2 Debian. This is compelling IMO. An option you can consider by sticking with Win10 is to either wait for Win10 21H2 or join the Insider Program Preview to get it now. Win10 21H2 gives you GPU compute access (no graphics or pulseaudio). On an older machine, I was able to build opencv-4.5 and leverage CUDA+DNN just like on Win11. EDIT: Win10 21H2 should be released this month. The fact that it is in the Preview Channel means it's most likely a final build.
- zamadatix 5y agoAuto HDR is nice. New Microsoft Store isn't doomed to fail like the original "new app types only" mess but it's severely limited in increased utility until they finish the Android portion they promised which didn't make the initial release. The native window tiling and set options are much improved, especially for larger displays. The redesigned Settings app feels like an actual improvement on Control Panel rather than just a touch focused replacement. Also support for new hardware designs like performance/efficiency core sets coming out now. But if you're looking for groundbreaking features you just have to move over for there aren't any. It's really more a "standard 6 month Windows update that happens to represent the next compatibility/support group" than "a brand new Windows version after the last one sat stale for many years" type upgrade. As Windows 10 nears its end of life I suspect the disparity will grow more but as of now I'd take Windows 11 as heralding what is going to be supported for new features for the next 10 years not as an instant revolution in features you're missing out if you don't jump to it immediately at release. As such these projects will become much more useful/interesting in about a year or two but it's good they have been started now.
- eins1234 5y ago> The native window tiling and set options are much improved, especially for larger displays. This is the killer feature IME. I'd pay for a new license even if this was the only new feature since I get so much mileage out of it in my setup.
- gpm 5y agoI installed it to be able to mount my Linux partition in wsl (note that this requires it to be on a separate disk btw). It's been smooth sailing, apart from that they reorganized the UI a bit, mostly in nice ways, and upgrading didn't seem that much different from a normal windows update.
- randombits0 5y agoMicrosoft isn’t certain they can leverage TPM the way they want so they are not inclined to spend money promoting it yet want to get it established as quickly and deeply as possible. I expect they will end up with what they deserve, i.e. nothing.
- rnd0 5y agoDear god, I hope you're right ...
- randombits0 5y agoThe curse of Microsoft is having piss-poor timing, early or late. This shot is way too early. Don’t worry, they saved a shit-ton of money by not betting big on TPM yet. Even if it’s a boring roll out with a slow adoption rate, they can run the clock. They are in no hurry as long as they set the direction.
- anonymousab 5y agoI've noticed a couple of bug fixes that were in Windows 10 insider builds were recently touted as Windows 11 exclusive improvements. So if one of those bugs affect you, that's a reason. Otherwise, it's the same as it always is: new software or new modes for software will increasingly become incompatible with Windows 10 and earlier over the next few years. Some future directx feature will be win11 exclusive and will be critical to performance sooner or later.
- rnd0 5y agoI'm running it, and most of the things I like probably fall under "consumer" than not. The biggest things I like are cosmetic; the rounded windows, smoother (easier to read? seems like it) fonts, there's changes to the right-click menu and other places with explorer that make more sense (to me) than Windows 10 once you get used to them. I thought I was going to be a die-hard 10-or-linux person but then when I learned that rufus has an install option to by-pass the checks I decided I wanted to try it out and I continue to use it because of cosmetics, and because I'm assuming it will be supported (at least for security -that's all I care about) longer than windows 10. 10 will expire before 11 so I'd rather get used to 11 now. The WSL graphics capability is nice too -in theory. In practice I haven't used it ...yet.
- comeonseriously 5y ago* It's different, so it's better. * FOMO. * "Modern"
- fortran77 5y agoWell, I guess Windows 11 isn't for you! I'm glad you're happy with Windows 10, or perhaps another operating system that runs on Industry Standard platforms. For the rest of us, this is an interesting option.
- farmin 5y agoWSL available in Windows Explorer and other WSL related updates are nice.
- gertrunde 5y agoAnd regarding the new features that are there (i.e. the stuff that's not pointless UI fluff), the most useful ones (for me personally, the WSL improvements) are being backported to 10 anyway.
- ricardobayes 5y agoPretty pixels
- jakebasile 5y agoI installed it on my 4 year old top end gaming PC because Microsoft told me not to. Simple as that.
- Anunayj 5y agoWell I am quite happy with some new features, like WSLg, the inbuilt android emulator which isn't that great but works well enough, and possibility of future updates. and then.. they changed the touch keyboard and it is WAY shittier now, the taskbar is constantly weird and ugh. I just wish I could choose what features I want without updating everything