7 ms·
I hope they prove to be extremely popular, and car makers realize what a stupid idea touchscreens in cars were in the first place, and give up the idea complete
by h2odragon 5y ago
I hope they prove to be extremely popular, and car makers realize what a stupid idea touchscreens in cars were in the first place, and give up the idea completely.
...and then there will be unicorns and flutterbugs and cotton candy, and everyone will be happy and nothing bad will ever happen again.
- mc32 5y agoI hope all that goes the way of most digital speedometers and tachometers from the 90s where most are back to analogue dials and a testament to tackiness.
- bruce343434 5y agoI actually enjoy digital speedometers, they are quicker to read than a "clock" dial
- FDSGSG 5y agoWhy are you posting this under an article about BMW? They've done the best job at this out of all the carmakers. You can go buy a brand new 7er, all the important things have physical buttons. The screen is really only there for navigation and more complicated settings.
- pw6hv 5y agoTotally agree with you. However, some times I think most of the people take what they're given and the 'radicals' are just a small percentage of the total. Manufacturers simply decide to make what is cheaper for them (see for example 16:10 vs 16:9 for monitors).
- Gargyle 5y agoWhen I got a coin everytime I watch people in newer SUVs being entirely confused why the damn thing doesn't start now completely stunned by the sheer number of stuff on the dashboard and middle screen. Or tell their passengers to go fiddle with the aircon system because the cognitive load is too high while driving. Old cars with knobs you learn it once and you can use it without eyes.
- Waterluvian 5y agoPerhaps it’s not that most people take what they’re given but that the manufacturer does a good job discovering what people want.
- DavidPeiffer 5y agoUnfortunately I think it's more driven by cost motivations. As noted in the Mk8 VW GTI review [1], the interfaces are often straight up awful, this being a particularly bad design. They're the biggest source of complaints/issues shortly after buying, and three years later. Additionally, distractions are already abundant in a vehicle. A crappy user interface, which most are, is a safety concern. At minimum, lag between screens loading should be extremely minimal. Staring at a screen for an extra second or two while it registers that you pressed a button and updates the screen is incredibly dangerous and has surely lead to some number of deaths. Two years ago Mazda announced they were moving away from touchscreens, which was very well received on HackerNews. [2] And I can't find the thread right now, but 1-3 years ago there was a really good discussion on here about an eye tracking study in a variety of car models. Touchscreen-only interfaces in cars are kind of like electronic-only voting machines. Technical people who know about computers breath funny thinking about it and see issues left and right while large swaths of people really want it. [1] https://youtu.be/XGbPHp6QfkQ?t=6m45s https://youtu.be/XGbPHp6QfkQ?t=6m45s [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20200335 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20200335
- q-big 5y ago> Unfortunately I think it's more driven by cost motivations. As noted in the Mk8 VW GTI review [1], the interfaces are often straight up awful, this being a particularly bad design. The car producer could save even more money if they released the non-security critical user-facing parts of the software as open source and let car enthusiasts fix the bad user interface.
- DavidPeiffer 5y agoI'd be good with that. I casually started looking at adding openstreetmaps in place of my outdated maps on my 2009 CR-V. From what I can tell, it's a proprietary system with proprietary formats. It doesn't look like it'll work, but I'd love to achieve it.
- jcims 5y agoI don’t mind a touch screen for GPS/CarPlay. But control of the vehicles operation, environment and entertainment systems should have robust, tactile and intuitive physical input devices that don’t require eyeballs to use. Not to get too far on a tangent but one of the best ways to increase intuition of a control is to provide haptic feedback. This guy has a few projects related to that, this video summarizes them pretty nicely. https://youtu.be/9Eh1p_rUQMA https://youtu.be/9Eh1p_rUQMA
- romwell 5y agoIn the world of unicorns and ponies, sure. In the real world, once you put a screen anywhere, that's where the entire UX will go. The temptation to do so it's seemingly irresistible.
- jcims 5y agoOh yeah I totally agree. You're going to need a brand manager with brass balls and knuckles to match to maintain that separation.
- FDSGSG 5y agoYou can look at literally any non-electric BMW to disprove this. Everything important has physical controls. BMW doesn't exist in some world of unicorns, it's a very real carmaker.
- rjzzleep 5y agoI rented a car in Germany ones but unfortunately I dont remember if it was a BMW or Mercedes. It had a fancy but horrendous touch nob and I just couldn't figure out how to move the car. Car makers consider everything touch a premium feature. The more touch the better/expensive. But to be fair I'm also extremely turned off by how Tesla "reimagined" the door knob.
- FDSGSG 5y agoBMWs have a touch nob clickwheel thing, there is no part of the UX that requires or even strongly encourages you to use the touch functionality.
- op00to 5y agoAlso everyone clapped. Really this time. I think I would much prefer a controller than a touch screen.
- ahartmetz 5y agoI have worked on touchscreen UIs for cars. I have a car with touchscreen UI. As a user, I hate them. They are unergonomic and irresponsible.
- nextaccountic 5y agoHere's a way to stop them: make it illegal to have car controls without tactile feedback. Changing volume or radio stations, changing AC, everything the driver might do in the car, should never be done only through a touchscreen, which is too distracting and unsafe.
- throaway46546 5y agoIt's illegal to use your smartphone while driving, but somehow if you integrate the same technology into the car it is perfectly fine.
- foxfluff 5y agoMaybe they can start selling a hands-free add-on kit for the car's controls..
- seanmcdirmid 5y agoDon’t most of these systems support voice control?
- FDSGSG 5y agoIn many EU countries it's definitely not illegal to use your smartphone while driving. Distracted driving is illegal, but using your smartphone doesn't automatically mean that you were distracted any more or less than using your car touchscreen would. The real truth is that enforcement is non-existent and almost nobody gets in trouble for using a phone while driving even if it's specifically forbidden.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- midasuni 5y agoTouch screen for CarPlay stuff - changing map to overview, selecting a different route when you’re stuck in traffic, pressing back 15 on Spotify etc, that’s great. Non essential stuff, alternate is a phone in a cradle with a worse touchscreen.
- mschuster91 5y ago> and car makers realize what a stupid idea touchscreens in cars were in the first place, and give up the idea completely. Why such a binary view of the world? Agreed, putting everything sans turn light and wiper control behind a touchscreen is a pretty reckless form-over-functionality idiocy, as you cannot operate vital functions of your car safely while driving. But that does not mean a touchscreen does not have its uses: Navigation, for one - a proper keyboard to enter addresses and phone numbers instead of that awful rotary thing (or the embedded write-a-single-letter touch thing) that BMWs use is so much faster to operate. Speech recognition is outright unusable outside of the English-speaking world or if you have children or a loud party going on in your car. Not to mention that it is insanely practical on a phone to be able to quickly rotate and zoom a map view for complicated intersections, and having that as a proper part of the car would be perfection. Media is the other major case - there absolutely need to be rotary dials for volume, station change and muting (e.g. if you get in a police stop and your music is blasting, or you hear sirens and need to know from where they come), but playlist selection and creation is so much better on a well-designed touch UI than (again) using knobs of any kind.
- h2odragon 5y agoI'll expound further: Any user interface that requires removing attention from the road should not be in reach of the driver while the car is operating. Let the passenger run the laptop that controls the media center and engine profiles and flamethrowers. Have a "next track" "off" and "volume" buttons for the driver.
- Wowfunhappy 5y agoUnfortunately, in this case it sounds like the alternate input is a touchpad, which is no more tactile and clearly worse.
- samjmck 5y agoBMWs actually use a dial that you can rotate in the centre console of the vehicle. It's actually very intuitive and easy to use, and a _lot_ less distracting than a touchscreen is.
- FDSGSG 5y agoWhen do you need to use that dial while driving? It's exclusively useful for things that you should only do while stationary.
- rad_gruchalski 5y agoYou know that this dial has a touch screen on top and you can draw with it? For example, it supposed to ocr letters for nav location. No idea who uses that...
- snarfy 5y agoYou might want to buy a Mazda next time. [1] - https://www.motorauthority.com/news/1121372_why-mazda-is-purging-touchscreens-from-its-vehicles https://www.motorauthority.com/news/1121372_why-mazda-is-pur...
- vardump 5y agoI can't understand why no one mentioned voice control. Isn't that safer than both physical knobs or touch screen?
- rad_gruchalski 5y agoIt's awful. I don't want to talk to my car to change stuff. I don't want to wave at it. Just give me a button.
- moron4hire 5y agoI had my heart set on a Toyota RAV-4 hybrid, until I actually sat down in the thing and saw the touch screen. Drove it around, other than the touchscreen it was nice, thought I might just have to suck it up and learn not to change settings while driving. On a whim, I checked out the Mazda CX-5. I'd never considered buying a Mazda before, but I found out they had institutionally banned touchscreens in their cars. And the CX-5 was so much more of a joy to drive than the RAV-4 that it made for a pretty easy decision.
- javajosh 5y agoI'm glad I'm not the only one that feel strongly anti-screen in the car. I feel so strongly about it that I drive an old car. I want an electric car eventually, and I hope that the automakers start building all cars, including electrics, with fully tactile control surfaces (didn't Honda say they'd eliminate screens in their cars? What happened with that?). It looks less Star-Trek sexy, but it also works 50x better. You know who gets this? Airplane pilots. They use screens but with a great deal of care.
- chrisseaton 5y agoThey aren’t removing the screens - they’re removing the touch functionality of the screen. Screens are vital for safety - how do you back-up safely without a screen to show you what’s behind you? Aeroplane pilots use an absolute ton of screens, front and centre.
- prepend 5y ago> how do you back-up safely without a screen to show you what’s behind you? Turn your head and look behind you.
- chrisseaton 5y agoYou have blind spots doing that - that’s how children get run over and why it’s illegal to sell a new car without a screen these days.
- prepend 5y agoNot if you move properly. The idea is to know where a car’s blind spots are and to move your head to look around. It’s tragic how kids get run over, but it’s a tiny amount out of a country of 300 million. When I had toddlers, I would make sure I could see them in front of the car before I would back out. If I didn’t know where they were, I didn’t back up. Not a perfect system, of course. But the idea that rear cameras are a necessity is silly.
- 5y ago
- BoorishBears 5y agoBMW does it right though Originally their interface could only be controlled by a knob, so the knob is a 1st class citizen in navigation. The touchscreen is there, but you never need to use it to navigate. My 124 Spider uses a Mazda infotainment system, and that takes it a step further by only enabling the touchscreen at a standstill. Once the car is in motion only the knob works
- shostack 5y agoI'm curious how touch screen glass cockpit pilots feel. Flying and messing with a touchscreen seems a lot more risky and dangerous on the surface, not to mention more difficult in turbulence thanks to bouncing around in three dimensions. In an industry arguably more obsessed with safety (from regulators down to pilots), surely this would be a more heated debate in that space?
- theshadowknows 5y agoI’ve got a 2016 civic and the entire touch screen is taken over when you make a right turn or go into reverse. And it takes several seconds for the system to boot when you turn the car on which is especially irritating in very hot or very cold weather. That and the response is laggy and slow. And sometimes it just stops responding entirely and you have to reboot the touch screen. It’s very annoying “feature” of an otherwise lovely car.
- m-p-3 5y agoAgreed. Your not supposed to even touch your smartphone while driving, how is operating your car touchscreen-based head unit any safer?! Dials and buttons provides a tactile feedback that allows you to keep focus on the road and can be operated even with gloves, which is great in Canada winter season.