7 ms·
You ascribe far more rationality to the process of developing drugs than is actually applied. Pharma mostly avoids low-profit avenues, but at least partly beca
by dekhn 5y ago
You ascribe far more rationality to the process of developing drugs than is actually applied.
Pharma mostly avoids low-profit avenues, but at least partly because that would be a good way to go out of business. However, to suggest that they intentionally suppress researchers with the goal of reducing costs seems a bit far-fetched.
- whatshisface 5y agoI don't understand the difference between intentionally suppressing researchers, which they are obviously not doing (that would be ghastly) and directing research towards the most profitable drugs, which they are obviously doing (to do otherwise would be bad business).
- dekhn 5y agothe former is an ethics violation, the latter is just a good strategy to win against the multi-armed bandit (which is how resource portfolios are managed at pharma). many pharma do invest some of their portfolio into things that are unlikely to have short-term or any payoff, and many of them also maintain compassionate programs to get expensive drugs to people who wouldn't be able to otherwise afford them. They do this because they are highly profitable, which unfortunately is as much explained by their marketing acumen as much as it is by solid research and development.
- whatshisface 5y agoOkay, so if I'm getting this straight, instructing researchers to not research unprofitable drugs is an ethics violation, while instructing them to research profitable ones is good strategy.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoIf you have finite budget and finite researchers, you allocate them where are the most ROI is. Researchers aren't settling sitting idly by.
- toyg 5y agoI'm really not suggesting active suppression, but rather simple, Occam-compliant inaction. COVID19, for example, is not really the first of its kind - just the first that was clearly going to produce profits if addressed. And lo, magically, it was. Mine was not a conspiracy-innuendo, but rather a simple critique of profit-driven research in health-related sciences. Humans can do wonderful things when they work together, so it's rather sad that we seem to do that only when there are riches on the line.
- rewq4321 5y ago> but rather a simple critique of profit-driven research in health-related sciences But as a private company they need profit to fund the science. They'd go out of business if they weren't making a profit. It's largely the role of government to fund public goods (e.g. by providing grants to university researchers). We can't expect the scientists and engineers to work for free.
- nickthemagicman 5y agoit seems like kind of a false dichotomy. 1. make drugs without a profit margin available to consumers and researchers 2. go out of business. It seems like there's plenty of grey area in there.
- toyg 5y ago> But as a private company they need profit to fund the science. Yes, as a private company. In my opinion, it's not like everything has to be a private profit-driven company, precisely because incentives are not necessarily aligned to the public good.