4 ms·
>The university initially said that, because it was a public university and faculty are government employees, it would have been a conflict of its interests to
by duxup 5y ago
>The university initially said that, because it was a public university and faculty are government employees, it would have been a conflict of its interests to allow three prominent professors to testify for plaintiffs in a lawsuit over new voting restrictions that Gov. Ron DeSantis signed into law earlier this year. It backtracked slightly days later when it said the three would be allowed to testify if they forfeited any compensation.
What was the conflict?
Don't question the government?
- SketchySeaBeast 5y agoApparently if you don't like what you're employer is doing you need to keep quiet?
- ISL 5y agoWhen you are employed to attempt to ascertain and share the truth to society at large, and your immediate-employer attempts to block that critical societal function, it is okay to appeal to the sensibilities of your employer's boss -- society itself.
- klyrs 5y agoMore like, if you disagree with the politics that your employer's investors have lobbied for, you need to keep quiet. The lawsuit doesn't appear to have anything to do with the operation of U of F.
- dekhn 5y agoMost of the time, yes. But in the case of a tenured professor acting in the interest of the public, academic freedom trumps that.
- ysavir 5y agoSince the law suit is against the state, and as state school professors they are paid by the state and are employees of the state, it's somewhat reasonable to see a conflict of interest for them to testify when the defendant is their employer. That said, it should be up to the lawyers and parties involved in the law suit to evaluate that conflict of interest. There was no reason for the school to interfere there.
- mistrial9 5y ago> it's somewhat reasonable to see a conflict of interest for them to testify when the defendant is their employer this is directly false in the US system of law
- NaturalPhallacy 5y agoWhich law?
- klyrs 5y ago> system of law Your parent said nothing about a specific law. They're talking about the practice of law. But let's turn that around. If this is a conflict of interest, can you identify for us where that is codified?
- robbedpeter 5y agoExactly - government of the people by the people is the relevant concept. Even the president has almost all the rights of a private citizen.
- NaturalPhallacy 5y agoSpecific laws are required in courts. So which law?
- mistrial9 5y ago(I am not a lawyer and I do not play one on the Internet) lets say it is important to notice this is a State-funded school, the students are adults and the Faculty have long and detailed legal protections in law, in addition to Constitutional rights as individuals. yes, as noted, the legal framework of law in the USA
- klyrs 5y ago> it's somewhat reasonable to see a conflict of interest for them to testify when the defendant is their employer. This statement appears to imply that you cannot sue your employer, because of a conflict of interest. I could almost see where you're going with this if the employer is the plaintiff, but when the employer is the defendant, that would be completely absurd.
- throwawaycities 5y agoThere is no conflict of interest. Expert witnesses get called to testify by either party and it’s industry standard they get compensated for their time. That doesn’t create any conflict of interest, and for the University to suggest it does is basically saying they believe their own professors are so unethical they would commit the crime of perjury in exchange for a meager expert witness payment. Also, the idea they are a expert witness for the plaintiff in a case against the government creates a conflict because they work for a public university is the opposite of a conflict of interest. Whereas there would be more of a conflict if the experts were witnesses for the defendant (ie their employer). The University is so tone deaf they don’t realize it’s a conflict of interest for the university to prevent professors from acting as experts in cases against parties that fund the university and even worse that they back track in the face of public exposure and pressure by allowing them to testify on the condition they can’t be compensated as expert witnesses…it’s a clear attempt to punish the professors if they do testify, which they probably won’t do now since they aren’t being compensated for their time.
- endisneigh 5y ago> a meager expert witness payment To be fair expert witnesses get a few hundred an hour in compensation for preparing plus actually testifying. That being said in the grand scheme of things it's hardly a fortune, but compared to an average professor salary it's probably a decent bonus.
- supercheetah 5y agoThat shouldn't even matter. A conflict of interest doesn't invalidate what they would have to say. The problems with conflicts of interest in testimony is when that's deliberately hidden from anyone to see. Keep that in the open, and any problems from it will also be in the open.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]