11 ms·
Top officers of a Navy nuclear sub have lost their jobs over undersea collision
- natded 5y agoI do wonder what they ran against. Did they navigate into one of the Chinese man-made islands? Or to Chinese / Nork sub
- m00dy 5y agoIt could be Chinese stealth underwater drone.
- thuccess129 5y agoTo avoid a repeat crash like a Boeing 737max8, submarines can be equipped with sensors acting at long distances like a lobster's antenna or catfish's whiskers, snake's tongue or slime mold's feelers to map out immediate surrounds and continuously refresh the map.
- wycy 5y ago> Did they navigate into one of the Chinese man-made islands? This was my pet theory as well. Man-made sea mounts would be inherently uncharted and would be a great defense against adversary submarines.
- 1cvmask 5y agoMeanwhile we keep promoting the top generals and politicians who back disastrous wars. Failing upwards only applies to the top tier.
- namdnay 5y agoI’m really not sure the military did much pushing for Iraq or Afghanistan. It was the ideologues in the CIA, the Government and the media who pushed and lied till they got what they wanted
- amcoastal 5y agoI'd be interested to see a more thorough report. This seamount wasn't mapped, we might be firing people for no good reason to save face. Or maybe the officers were drinking whiskey and playing quarters. It's sad I don't have enough confidence in the military justice system to assume it's a situation like the latter instead of the former.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- blitzar 5y ago> we might be firing people for no good reason to save face ... It's sad I don't have enough confidence in the military justice system What made you lose faith in the military justice system? Given that they tend to err on the side of allowing war crimes, I would have thought they were overly lenient, and predisposed to a coverup than swift to hand down punishments.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- raxxorrax 5y agoIt isn't too easy to actually "see" a mountain without active sonar that you don't use while on patrol in a submarine. They also don't have windows... I believe there are some modern sensors that could have helped, but it is questionable that they were installed. This sound far more like saving face and maybe even incompetence by higher officer ranks.
- bilbo0s 5y agoThis sound far more like saving face and maybe even incompetence by higher officer ranks Given this happened in the 7th, my money is on incompetence.
- rob74 5y agoNever mind the whataboutism, but running against a stationary obstacle (a seamount) in a submarine is nothing that should happen to an experienced crew, and "sinking" a submarine can have disastrous consequences (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kursk_submarine_disaster https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kursk_submarine_disaster), so I think these measures are entirely justified...
- ethbr0 5y ago> running against a stationary obstacle (a seamount) in a submarine is nothing that should happen to an experienced crew Why not?
- anotherhue 5y agoMaps
- jeffwass 5y agoFrom the CNN article : When it comes to knowing the terrain beneath them, even astronauts might have it easier than submariners, according to Shugart. "Basically, the surface of the moon is better charted than the bottom of the ocean is," he said.
- pas 5y agoThe seafloor is not mapped 100% to a sufficient resolution. Underwater navigation is not that simple (no GPS). Plus even if this big underwater mountain were on a map, maps are not perfect.
- danbruc 5y ago[...] sound judgement, prudent decision-making and adherence to required procedures in navigation planning, watch team execution and risk management could have prevented the incident [...]
- ethbr0 5y agoThat doesn't fill me with confidence that it's definitively the boat's fault. How many companies have you known who threw engineers under the bus when {insert same quote}? While at the same time the de facto daily operation procedures throughout the entire company were to constantly ignore or skip those same safeguards? I'm not saying it's not the crew's fault, but I am saying that a statement like that doesn't prove it's reasonably the crew's fault. Ultimately though, it's leadership's decision who to place in command or particular roles, so it's their right to reassign or remove commands at whim.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y ago> we keep promoting the top generals Which ones?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- throwaway4good 5y agoAnother indication that we were in fact close to a nuclear disaster.
- bell-cot 5y agoNotice how much worse this sub's collision was - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USS_San_Francisco_(SSN-711)#Collision_with_seamount https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USS_San_Francisco_(SSN-711)#Co.... But there was no nuclear disaster in that case, either. Might your statement be mostly, ah, aspirational?
- throwaway4good 5y agoFirst indication was that they send one of these guys out after the incident: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_WC-135_Constant_Phoenix https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_WC-135_Constant_Phoen...
- smileysteve 5y agoThat's not how this works. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29117947 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29117947
- throwaway4good 5y agoOne thing is the nuclear engine that drives the boat, another is what sort of weaponry it had on board. Judging from the public available pictures the damage was substantial creating the possibility of some sort of Thule airbase scenario. That the US sent out their sniffer planes is public record as they were carrying trackers that allowed open source observers to see them. I think it is a very serious story that has gotten hardly any coverage in the western media. https://mobile.twitter.com/SCS_PI/status/1454692456449003522 https://mobile.twitter.com/SCS_PI/status/1454692456449003522
- WalterGR 5y agoAlso see: A U.S. submarine struck an underwater mountain last month, the Navy says (npr.org) 138 points by nradov 2 days ago | 199 comments https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29087458 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29087458
- readonthegoapp 5y agowow, how did i not see anything about this story? i've been a bit busy-ish, but....i was definitely interested to know how we almost ended the world. that would be pretty funny tho - aliens get the last recording from the space station in about a trillion years: "How did World 2 end? Well, if you can believe it, it was an accident. The driver was in the loo and checking his crypto, and, well...he hit a mountain. Underwater. Unmapped. Until then."
- belorn 5y agoWhy would the world end? The nuclear reactor that is powering the sub is quite small, producing generally 1/10 of the energy of a nuclear plant. They are designed to withstand direct torpedo hits, and historically when for example a nuclear sub had most of its own torpedoes explode from within the sub, killing everyone inside, the power plant itself survived without damage (there exist is a good documentary about kursk accident and the salvage operation of its two nuclear plants). Even if it did have a meltdown, it is likely to be a depth if its hitting an underwater mountain. You could explode the biggest nuclear bomb every created at the Mariana Trench and the only effect we would get at the surface would be some bubbles. Water is pretty good at not be compressible, while at the same time able to diffuse the explosion while it is traveling upwards. The problem of a nuclear sub colliding underwater is the human lives lost because of the crash.
- readonthegoapp 5y agoThe sub is tomahawk-capable and those tomahawks are nuclear warhead-capable. It's just one of the ways we're playing with (nuclear) fire. Previous incidents with nuclear-powered and/or nuclear-armed subs have come close to ending the world previously.
- pseudolus 5y agoThe silver non-radioactive lining here is that there does appear to be some institutional accountability - at least on the front line. Would be great if that accountability bled into the civilian world.
- gostsamo 5y agoDepends. Sometimes the only people who get fired are those who can't defend themselves while the hire command does not investigate the reasons for the failures beyond the more immediate ones.
- sswaner 5y agoI believe that is true in this case. The 7th Fleet has incurred a series of accidents in recent years. Lack of training, overworked staff, and delayed maintenance may have been contributing factors beyond the control of those punished.
- xwdv 5y agoHeh, you think this is about accountability? This was like a politically motivated move by someone who saw an opportunity to remove a senior officer they didn’t like.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- atonse 5y agoDo you actually have information implying such or is it mainly cynicism? Because I wondered the same but I know at least my thoughts are not based on any intuition or knowledge of how the Navy operates, whatsoever.
- moron4hire 5y agoCut out some high ranking field officers, don't have to pay out their pensions, and make room for lower ranking officers to move up without risking new blood entering the admiralty that might question why everyone is running short staffed and not training enough? Sounds like a huge win.
- dghf 5y agoSo have they been kicked out of the Navy, or just removed from these postings?
- atdrummond 5y agoJust the latter. Removal from the service would only happen that quickly with resignations; otherwise, there are bureaucratic (and legal) hoops to be jumped through.
- hilbert42 5y agoYou'd really have to wonder how this could happen after the 2005 incident when the USS San Francisco hit an uncharted seamount in the Pacific. I claim no expertise in submarine navigation/collision avoidance but it seems to me that the something that went awry with the USS San Francisco might have happened again some 16 years later. Why weren't lessons learned? I'd have thought that the detection of something as big as a seamount would have been child's play to a modern submarine and thus easily avoided. After all, detection of underwater objects is what submarines do - and one's enemy sub is a damned size smaller than a seamount. What gives? Does anyone with sufficient declassified knowledge know how this could happen? Even if everyone was being inattentive or having lunch (as they were on the USS San Francisco) then why wouldn't sophisticated detection equipment warn well ahead of any potential accident happening? I've been curious about this since that incident in 2005, now that it's happened again I'm even more so. Lastly, do we really know the extent of uncharted seamounts? Silly, question being in the negative. Perhaps, rephrased the question should be how reliable are the charts/maps submarines use these days. (This could be just my lack of knowledge, but it seems subs may be blinder underwater than my perception of them has been until now.)
- jmacd 5y agoMy boat has a $1000 piece of garmin equipment which will tell me exactly how far away the landmass under me is, and has another sonar angled forward which tells me a little bit about what's coming up. It's possible that this type of sensing equipment isn't used when they are in hostile environments?
- astura 5y agoThe entire point of a submarine is that nobody knows it's there. If they are using easily detectable equipment then people who are listening know they are there.
- fallingknife 5y agoYour boat is not trying to evade enemies that may want to locate and destroy it, so it doesn't matter if it is constantly emitting sound.
- smbv 5y agoFirst thing that came to mind was a Monk episode. https://imdb.com/title/tt1268705 https://imdb.com/title/tt1268705
- IG_Semmelweiss 5y agoIncompetence is far likelier to like at the top of a bureaucracy where politics and charm are far likelier to be rewarded, and the consequences of decisions are harder to attribute or have a long time horizon. In addition, political capital is accumulated (and saved) while at the top of an institution, which works as as a "get out of jail" card. Lower members of the institution reap no benefits like those given to top brass, and often the outcomes of their poor decisions are inmediate and directly attributable. In this example, its not hard to see why the sub managers were terminated. Clear attribution, inmediate effects from accidents, and the accused were not at the top of the org
- QuarterReptile 5y agoAre you saying the sub's CO is the lowly person being sacrificed for some higher up? This CO knew beyond a shadow of a doubt that he was fired the instant he heard the collision alarm. Those are the rules. The president is the top of this bureaucracy; are you suggesting he should be impeached and the CJCS, CNO, CSP, CTF74, and subron-5 fired? Any other heads you would like to see roll? There have certainly been regimes that have functioned in that way, but 'accountable' isn't the word used to describe them.
- throwawaylinux 5y ago> Are you saying the sub's CO is the lowly person being sacrificed for some higher up? A troubling pattern of incidents and (alleged) failures to recognize or react to systemic problems in the navy is emerging. The most important question now is not about the incompetent crews and commanders on these boats and ships, it is why such people keep being allowed to command and serve on vessels in the first place.
- QuarterReptile 5y ago>The most important question now is not about the incompetent crews and commanders on these boats and ships, it is why such people keep being allowed to command and serve on vessels in the first place. Which 'such people' are you referring to?
- i_am_proteus 5y ago>"Thomas determined sound judgement, prudent decision-making and adherence to required procedures in navigation planning, watch team execution and risk management could have prevented the incident," according to a 7th Fleet statement. This indicates that there was some uncertainty in the bathymetry around where the grounding occurred, annotated on a chart available to the crew.
- astura 5y agoThe lede is a bit buried here - they fired the captain, XO, and COB (COB is a senior enlisted position, not an officer).