3 ms·
I’m not sure how to interpret this, even after reading the article. Is any reason given for why the last 4 Performance cores get only a limited amount of work?
by Aeolun 5y ago
I’m not sure how to interpret this, even after reading the article. Is any reason given for why the last 4 Performance cores get only a limited amount of work?
- wmf 5y agoI assume that a core cluster can power off if it's completely idle; this should be more energy-efficient than running both clusters at low utilization.
- masklinn 5y agoIt can also allow for boosting a core more: the “turbo” ramping is on a per-cluster basis so if only one core is loaded it’ll work at 3.2, two of them at 3.1, and 3 or 4 lowers that to 3.0.
- wmf 5y agoThat sounds like you'd want to keep both clusters on and spread the work so cores could clock higher. By packing everything onto one cluster, macOS is reducing clocks.
- eyelidlessness 5y agoLike sibling comment says, it’s more efficient. It allows those cores to sort of pretend they’re ECs. It also reserves those PCs for bursty workloads which would otherwise be contentious for cache and memory bandwidth in an evenly balanced scheduler.
- yazaddaruvala 5y agoIs it basically giving programs some automatic core affinity or are the unused cores meant to be unused until the first set are saturated? I guess also, are the 4 unused cores always the same?
- eyelidlessness 5y agoMy guess is it’s treating the “extra” cores as a throttling mechanism without throttling. If your thermal budget is 9 (8 + 2*1/2), and you operate normally with a thermal budget of ~5, you can temporarily go to 9 without any noticeable difference in actual performance, or heat, or cooling. In another sense, they’re probably leaving a lot of performance potential on the table to achieve that perception. As far as which cores are demoted… I definitely don’t know enough to speculate. If favoring the same set would affect longevity of the device, they’d rotate. If not it’s simpler not to do that. I have no idea which is more likely.
- matthew-wegner 5y agoKeep in mind the only devices with M1 Pro/Max CPUs are currently battery-powered laptops (which in itself is quite a strange inversion!) Probably the "high power" mode available on an M1 Max in a 16" chassis is doing just that. And maybe Apple will decide to treat some kind of new iMac Pro as more of a pro machine, and make it chunky enough to dissipate that sort of heat without needing much fan noise...
- stephen_g 5y agoYeah, it was surprising that they didn't pop these SoCs into the Mac Mini but perhaps they are doing a full redesign of the Mini and we'll see a new version some time next year? Obviously a 'Pro' version of the iMac is coming eventually with a larger screen but I don't think many people expected that yet. Maybe February or so next year...
- iSnow 5y agoLaptops command higher margins. They will want to milk the market with their Pro/Max laptops and then release Minis and larger iMacs next year. Also, even a huge company like Apple would want to stagger releases so design teams can have some constant workload. Releasing laptops and a new Mini and a new iMac would put quite some work on the team and then it would be idle for a time. They are probably done with the Mini and working on a Mac Pro right now.
- christoph 5y agoUnless I’ve misunderstood it’s somewhat guessed at, at the very end - “I suspect that Apple has done this to further improve energy efficiency and ensure good responsiveness to new CPU-intensive tasks.”
- deagle50 5y agoThey are in a separate, power and frequency gated cluster with its own L2. You'd want to keep that cluster in a low power state as much as possible.