5 ms·
Tour De Babel -- Rant about programming languages
- silentbicycle 18y agoIn an aside about Emacs, Steve Yegge notes, "[...] I type 130 to 140 WPM, error-free, in Emacs, when I'm doing free-form text." That explains so much.
- kingkongrevenge 18y agoThis guy is possibly the worst writer I have ever read. I do not understand why his material keeps getting circulated.
- sofal 18y agoI read them because I find them entertaining, and I can even relate to a lot of the sentiments. A written piece labeled under the heading "Stevey's Drunken Blog Rants" is not intended to be a carefully crafted treatise. A drunken blog rant is a drunken blog rant. I do not understand why people think that a drunken blog rant has to follow a format that isn't at all representative of a drunken blog rant. It's funny. If the problem is that it's not funny to you, then that's a valid viewpoint, and I can respect that.
- KevBurnsJr 18y agoA drunken blog rant is a drunken blog rant. Cheers to that. I don't read a lot of stuff on the web top-to-bottom, especially opinion pieces, but I found this article exceptionally entertaining.
- bdr 18y agoThere's interesting content, even if you don't like his writing aesthetically.
- kingkongrevenge 18y agoA restaurant review has more content than this. This is just a list of personal tastes, with virtually no addressable argument. A lot of what he does say is idiotic. His entire lisp section, for example, is about an elisp system, which has absolutely nothing to do with the merits of learning real lisp. "Perl OO never really caught on." Um, have you looked at CPAN or the core module APIs in the last 8 years?
- omouse 18y agoPerl OO never really caught on because it isn't part of the core language. It's the same with Scheme. It's nothing to be embarrassed about or something that you want to try and correct. Also, what pray tell is a "real" lisp? Last I checked, Emacs-Lisp has macros and much of what makes any lisp a "real" lisp.
- jrockway 18y ago> Perl OO never really caught on because it isn't part of the core language. What? Perl OO did catch on, and it is part of the core language.
- omouse 18y agoPerl OO = library. Scheme OO = library. Library != language. The last time I tried to use Perl OO, CPAN had to download a bunch of stuff for Moose. That doesn't sound like it's part of the core language to me. Has the situation changed? Are there OO things included with the default dist of Perl?
- newt0311 18y agoActually in lisp (and scheme as scheme is a dialect of lisp), the line between library and language is so fuzzy that its practically invisible.
- jrockway 18y agoPerl 5 has had OO forever. Here's how it works: package Class; sub new { my $class = shift; bless {} => $class } sub method { my $self = shift; $self->{attribute} = 'value' }; package Subclass; our @ISA = qw(Class); sub method { my $self = shift; $self->SUPER::method(...); ... } package main; my $class = Subclass->new; $class->method; This is built into the core.
- silentbicycle 18y agoIt's not a very strong example of his writing, either.
- ojbyrne 18y agoI'm curious as to how you define "worst." As someone who once upon a time studied English, I love this paragraph: It's hard, though. It's a big jump. It's not sufficient to learn how to write C-like programs in Lisp. That's pointless. C and Lisp stand at opposite ends of the spectrum; they're each great at what the other one sucks at. That's good writing. Summarizes the writer's opinion in an active voice without latinate verbs or excessively long sentences.
- asdflkj 18y agoThere are two entire sentences there that could be thrown out without any change in meaning.
- ojbyrne 18y agoShort sentences and they're there for emphasis. I think it's in Strunk & White that they say "what do you do when you've shrunk your language so small that there's nothing left" - repetition! Say everything 3 times!
- orib 18y agoUgh. again, if you're going to tear on something, please... at least be right about it. For example, If your code base is 50 million lines in any language, you're doing it wrong, and it's going to be a pain to maintain. C++ has little to do with it. He also seems to think Python is losing to Ruby -- Sorry, no. They're both going strong, and growing rapidly. Both of them are winning hard right now. Also, his convolving of lisp and emacs is quite annoying. Emacs is not Lisp, and Lisp is not Emacs. Please don't confuse the two. Overall, I think that this is a rather poor article. Although I've definitely seen worse.
- silentbicycle 18y agoHe wrote that article quite a while ago (Sept. 2004), actually, and has a slightly more recent (Feb. 2005) follow-up that covers several more languages here (http://steve.yegge.googlepages.com/language-grubbing http://steve.yegge.googlepages.com/language-grubbing). Oddly, he acts as if he has no memory of writing the other thing. He gives a much more informed opinion of Python here, I think. His overall impression is essentially, "Python is a really good language, but I already know Ruby, which is good at the same things, so I'll just stick with that." I feel the same, really, but favoring Python over Ruby.
- ptn 18y agoPython is a really good language, but I already know Ruby, which is good at the same things I was under the impression that Ruby was mostly used for webapps, with really little use in other areas. Is this not correct? Python is used widely for a variety of purposes, like system programming.
- silentbicycle 18y agoRuby is a general-purpose scripting language. It just has a reputation as being used mostly for the web because Rails is its most popular app. I don't really use Ruby (I already know Python well, and while I've played with Ruby a bit, I think my studying time is better spent on languages that are more different), so I'm going to let Ruby-ists provide examples if they want.
- pmorici 18y agoI find it annoying that people's only real criticism against Python is the white space. I love that feature, it's like high real estate prices, keeps the rif-raf out.
- hbien 18y agoI <3 python and its mandatory white space, but requiring self to be listed as a parameter does bug me.
- schtog 18y agoI also don't understand that critic. I have never ever had a problem with it and it is a big part of what makes Python so readable. I don't think there is any other language that comes close to Python in terms of readability. What is the issue people have with it? They write code that writes code? That is the only issue I can come up with. And self, yes it might seem a bit unaesthetic at first but it is not such a big deal. For me, Python = productivity
- yariv 18y agoYou can write readable code in any decent language, and you can just as easily write unreadable code in Python. The important variable is the programmer's skill, not some language-imposed restriction. Besides, bad use of white space is rarely what makes code unreadable. It's usually poor organization, functions/modules that are too long, non-descriptive names, overly complex class hierarchies, etc. I think Python is a nice language but I disagree that its whitespace rules make it so much more readable than other languages.
- elai 18y agoWhen your working on cross multi-editor / multi-developer projects, you can do your tabs differently, (one might do tabs, another soft tabs, their soft-tabs are 4 spaces, another is 2, another is 8 (ack)) and you get irritating inconsistent tab errors. It can be quite annoying. Having to synchronize on such an irritating detail is even more irritating.
- 18y ago
- greyman 18y agoSorry, but I can't take seriously people, who are writing stuff like "C++ is the dumbest language on earth...". It's not even insulting.