5 ms·
Uber posts first profitable quarter on adjusted basis
- zucked 5y agoIs this adjusted using standard GAAP accounting practices, or the sort of creative accounting that has been commonplace in the past?
- fshbbdssbbgdd 5y agoCorrect. The most obviously wrong exclusion is stock compensation. Imagine Uber issued and sold $1B of stock each year. Obviously we wouldn’t count that as $1B of profit, because it’s just a change in capital structure. Stock compensation is the same thing. The fact that the stock issuance is bundled together with employee compensation (where it substitutes for cash) instead of going directly to the corporate treasury doesn’t matter.
- rsj_hn 5y agoWell, I think the point is that issuing more stock already shows up in the earnings per share data so there is not a good reason to double count it. A company that issues stock to employees is not losing money, what it's doing is transferring some wealth from one group of shareholders to a different group of shareholders. This hurts the bottom line of the first group and helps the bottom line of the second, but it does not hurt the balance sheet of the company. Likewise if a company votes to give a special dividend to a preferred stock and reduce the dividend to common stock by the same amount, then this hurts one group of shareholders over another, but it does not cause the company to incur a loss. And as the company's balance sheet is unchanged. its income statement should not be changed either. The flipside is to believe that the balance sheet should be changed because the liability increases by the amount of new stock. This is false because the liability has to be valued at market value and shareholder issuance only dilutes the value of an individual stock, it does not increase the shareholder equity. This treatment where GAAP rules misvalue the change to liability from share issuance rears its head when valuing share buybacks. Here too, they are valued at the purchase price, which creates all sorts of misvaluation problems for firms and creates the opportunity for mismanaging of corporate funds by purchasing shares high and selling them low, which really should result in a loss for the company, but according to the GAAP rules there is no loss because the equity is valued by the purchase price/price at grant and does not take into account the market price. So from this one bad rule comes other misvaluations that distort the balance sheet of a company and impede financial analysis. And all of this stems from a desire to discourage corporate behavior in share issuance rather than from a desire to accurately value the company. So I'll go by the non-GAAP figures.
- fshbbdssbbgdd 5y agoSuppose Uber issued $1B of stock, sold the stock on the open market, then gave employees a $1B bonus. Did Uber incur a $1B expense by paying the bonus, and if so, did they also earn an offsetting $1B in revenue by selling this stock, so this set of transactions should net to zero on the earnings statement? Isn’t this the same thing as stock compensation with an extra step? What am I missing here?
- trepanne 5y agoSelling stock doesn't impact the income statement; it is NOT revenue. It is capital raised. Your series of transactions would net to debit expense $1B, credit equity capital $1B. It would definitely fuck up your earnings, as it should. Stock compensation is compensation and should be expensed. It's not just GAAP, it is plain common sense. The dilutive effect on EPS isn't any kind of double-counting. It's just a proper accounting for the way the shareholders are constantly bleeding value to sustain normal operations.
- rsj_hn 5y agoAs you know, the sale of stock is a capital account operation, so just giving the money to an employee appears to be a current expense with no offsetting current revenue. It would be like selling off a share of your future profits to make current payroll (which is what it is). But what you are missing is that many modern companies, and especially software companies (2/3 of labor expenses are R&D), have capital that is basically IP created by their employees, and so just as it's a good idea to sell equity to buy some metal stamping machine, and this does not dilute the equity of the firm or cheat any shareholders, so it's also a good idea to sell equity to hire the person to write your application, or create a vaccine, or design a new engine, and this also does not dilute equity or hurt the company. In fact many times when key employees leave the share price of a company falls and the shareholders are more than happy to vote for boards that give stock grants to key employees that cause the company to earn more long term profits. And ultimately this is something that GAAP just can't handle due to its antiquated distinction between labor and capital investment -- under GAAP you can't expense a labor R&D expense over a period of time. You have to take the charge all in the same year. So this gives you misleading accounting results, and this is also why savvy investors look at the non-GAAP results and then they have to use their judgement to determine whether the IP that the company's employees are creating will generate the expected long term returns. Moreover if you are such a company, it makes excellent sense to finance R&D by selling stock, and for most companies R&D is almost entirely labor compensation. So ultimately GAAP is just out of touch with what capital investment means in the modern world - capital investment happens by paying people a lot of money to create IP for you, and not by purchasing tractors. Similarly stock analysts who view labor as purely a current expense and not an investment are also out of touch with many industries. That wont work in Biotech or Software or SpaceX or really any firm that does a lot of R&D. So let the stock market decide whether those equity sales are funding compensation that will generate the return or whether they will merely dilute -- the investors are the ones who need to price this, it can't be mechanically determined via GAAP rules designed to track the balance sheet of a 19th century coal plant.
- timoth3y 5y agoUber posted an adjusted Q3 profit of $8M. However, they posted an actual Q3 loss of $2.4B. On an adjusted basis I look just like George Clooney.
- lumost 5y agoHow were they possibly able to adjust away 2.4 Billion dollars?
- timoth3y 5y agoThe biggest chunk was excluding their net loss in investments in other companies. However, "adjusted earnings" is a PR number it doesn't have any particular financial meaning. If Uber wanted to make the case that they are moving towards profitability, they could talk about operating income or cash flow from operations or some other metric that has a GAAP meaning. Those are the numbers to watch if you want to know if the company can ever be profitable.
- absherwin 5y agoThe most significant adjustment was excluding a $3.2B writedown of the value of their stake in Didi
- vineyardmike 5y agoIn plain english: They bought some stake in company Didi. In this past quarter, they acknowledged this stake was worth 3.2b less than it was recorded as in their books. Therefore, their books now "lost" 3.2B in value. But they did not "overspend" by 3.2B in the sense most people expect when hearing "they just lost 3.2B this quarter"
- moralestapia 5y ago>In this past quarter, they acknowledged this stake was worth 3.2b less than it was recorded as in their books. Lol, how does that happen, honestly.
- ldbooth 5y agoUh huh. Adjusted, meaning EBITDA, or as Charlie Munger refers to them "bullshit earnings".
- absherwin 5y agoThat’s true for most adjustments. Buffett also suggests investors ignore income statement effects of marking securities to market. “I must first tell you about a new accounting rule – a generally accepted accounting principle (GAAP) – that in future quarterly and annual reports will severely distort Berkshire’s net income figures and very often mislead commentators and investors. The new rule says that the net change in unrealized investment gains and losses in stocks we hold must be included in all net income figures we report to you. That requirement will produce some truly wild and capricious swings in our GAAP bottom-line.” https://www.berkshirehathaway.com/2017ar/2017ar.pdf https://www.berkshirehathaway.com/2017ar/2017ar.pdf
- vineyardmike 5y ago> Adjusted, meaning EBITDA, No. Adjusted EBITDA. Meaning not EBITDA. EBITDA is not "bullshit earnings".
- jcrben 5y agoEBITDA is bullshit if depreciation is an expected, significant part of your business. For many vc-backed companies, it isn't, but for any company with major physical capex, it very much is a real expense. There's also the whole inconsistency with capitalizing software expenses... if you want to be aggressive about accounting, you certainly can. But of course the biggest part of this story is stock-based comp, which is very much a real expense.
- vineyardmike 5y agoTrue, but (1) uber owns nothing (mostly), and (2) depreciation doesn't really affect real-world profit/loss as a "regular person" expects. Its mostly an accounting tool (that often lets companies hide money). If you eg. build a building, you can depreciate ~10% a year in many cases, but that doesn't really mean you're losing/gaining money. Eg. a residential building can depreciate at 5% a year. If you owned and rented a house in SF, its not decreasing in value by 5% a year, probably even considering cost of repairs/upgrades grows as a building ages (the purpose of this metric). So including a (-5% of building) depreciation amount on the earnings of said rental property makes little sense when evaluating if its "profitable".
- tacker2000 5y ago“Uber’s preferred “adjusted ebitda” metric of the company’s underlying health excludes multiple costs including interest, taxes, depreciation and amortisation, as well as stock-based compensation.” See https://www.ft.com/content/4af56131-018a-412e-93d9-dcbb37232e01 https://www.ft.com/content/4af56131-018a-412e-93d9-dcbb37232...
- vineyardmike 5y ago> excludes multiple costs including interest, taxes, depreciation and amortisation That is exactly what "EBIDTA" means. And EBIDTA is pretty standard. The "IDTA" is not nearly as useful to gauge the health of a company as EBIDTA. Eg. companies that don't run a profit don't pay taxes, so if you make $0 after taxes, you basically have your whole tax amount to spend next year and it makes no difference. > [EBITDA] is derived by subtracting from revenues all costs of the operating business (e.g. wages, costs of raw materials, services ...) but not depreciation, amortisation, interest, lease expenses, and taxes. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Earnings_before_interest,_taxes,_depreciation_and_amortization https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Earnings_before_interest,_taxe...
- vineyardmike 5y agoHearing they're profitable is a great sign. Its great both because (1) i've recently heard a lot of people complain about price increases, so it's worrying to think a service many people using would need to be a lot more expensive (2) it validates a lot of the business models for start ups to get big to find profits, and validates that losing money - even lots - can lead to profits and hopefully sustainability.
- jer0me 5y agoThey’re not even close to being profitable
- vineyardmike 5y agoUh, isn't the whole point of this news that they are, in fact, close to being profitable?
- bagacrap 5y agodoesn't really seem like a healthy/fair market if the winner is picked by incumbent capitalists also you forgot a key part of the equation, which was to ignore pesky regulatory requirements I would hope startups aren't encouraged to follow this model but I hear "Uber for X" way too often so I know it already doesn't matter if Uber ever makes (non-VC) money, as the pyramid scheme is already seen as a wild success.
- spywaregorilla 5y agoI always like tracking whether uber is facing impending doom. The answer is no. They're still fine for a good long while. Here are the actual income statements: https://investor.uber.com/news-events/news/press-release-details/2021/Uber-Announces-Results-for-Third-Quarter-2021/ https://investor.uber.com/news-events/news/press-release-det... Are they profitable? No, but maybe closer than some are thinking, and further than others lol. If you ignore their 1.8B loss on Other Income which I think is mostly Didi, you've got a few big items left that seem likely to be recurring and "important": * + 100M gain on taxes (yes, gain as in benefit) * - 100M loss on interest * - 200M loss on depreciation * - 300M loss on stock comp So if I were to adjust their adjusted number, I would say they're still about 500M in the red for the quarter. In the most generous of takes I'd say they can get 40% gross margin on new revenue. So to make up $500M they'll need to do $1.25B more revenue which is about 26%. So... yeah I guess they could get there.