5 ms·
> Basic needs really shouldn't be investment material. Companies providing and selling food, energy, and consumer staples are investment materials. I don’t get
by sokoloff 5y ago
> Basic needs really shouldn't be investment material.
Companies providing and selling food, energy, and consumer staples are investment materials. I don’t get why housing should be a special carve-out and don’t see a workable answer to how to provide food for everyone while banning all investment in companies that grow or sell food.
These companies are invested in precisely because these are basic needs. The company gets the capital it needs to operate, consumers get a reliable supply of food, energy, and clothing, employees get steady jobs providing these staples, investors get a relatively safe store of value and some income. Who exactly loses in these investments in supply basic food, energy, and consumer staples?
- Aeolun 5y agoBut this clearly isn’t true for housing. Landlords keep buying up more and more, supply only goes down, and the prices keep going up.
- Panzer04 5y agoAnd are the landlords just leaving the house empty for the hell of it? Or is it being rented out to people? I know with one is more likely. The thing is, housing is a surprisingly flexible commodity (too expensive, people live with parents/share, and then move back out if prices fall) , and encouraging everyone to buy a full on house in a suburb is a recipe to drive expensive housing.
- ChuckNorris89 5y ago>And are the landlords just leaving the house empty for the hell of it? No, but a landlord who got into the market early when properties were dirt cheap can leverage that and buy more and more for renting them out, reducing the supply and increasing the competition if you want to buy your first property and not be a renter your whole life. You know, like when you want to settle down and have kids, you're gonna be out-muscled by a landlord who already has 3 properties and is is looking to buy 2 more. >housing is a surprisingly flexible commodity (too expensive, people live with parents/share, and then move back out if prices fall) The thing is this is one of the reason why birth rates are so low in rich western cities. How can you expect people to start families if you expect adults to live in shared accomodations or move in with their parents? Having access to cheap, spacious housing that's just for living and not part of someone's investment vehicle, would definitely make "nesting" an enticing proposition for young adults, like it was for the boomer generation. But if you expect them to bum around between living with roommates and living with their parents like adolescents, and their only hope of nesting being to grind away after years in university at some soul-sucking job 40+ hours/week plus commutes just to afford a bank loan for a shoe-box that they'll have to pay off till they die, then of course they'll realize this expectation of their life is a scammy wage-salve trap and say "to hell with that, I'd rather stay single, childless and free and spend my time and money on travelling, clubbing, netflix, meme-stocks and videogames". But of course, fat chance to get governments to admit their policies of enriching the banks, property investors and the older owning class by squeezing the young is the cause of this. To them, the real reason why the young can't afford to settle down is because "these pesky millennials and zoomers spend all their money on iphones and avocado toast, so to fix this we'll allow uncontrolled mass immigration from the third world". Housing can't be an affordable necessity for starting a family that everyone should have access to while at the same time being an investment vehicle design to enrich their owners. It's either one or the other and most of the west has chosen the latter while talking how the former is more important. In Austria, the goverment isn't even hiding the fact that housing is officially an investment vehicle, with the conservative party throwing the blame back on the people for not having bought properties as the reason why they stay poor and can't afford to keep up with rent increases. Despicable!
- themitigating 5y agoI think you are over stating the flexibility of moving out, getting a roommate, or moving in with your parents. What if your parents moved into a smaller residence and can't fit a family?
- mellavora 5y agoYes, a lot of landlords do leave the house empty. Maybe not for the hell of it, but if it is empty you don't risk getting a bad tenant. Even with good tenants, a tenant means you have more responsibility w.r.t repairs/maintenance costs etc. If the property is appreciating at 10-30% yoy, why take the risk of renting it?
- pornel 5y agoBasic food is subsidized and regulated. Even in the US: corn subsidies, grain reserves, and the Onion Futures Act.
- ensignavenger 5y agoHousing is also subsidized in the US, the FHA, USDA and VA all have housing subsidy programs. States and local governments also operate housing subsidy programs.
- nuerow 5y ago> I don’t get why housing should be a special carve-out and don’t see a workable answer to how to provide food for everyone while banning all investment in companies that grow or sell food. The economy exists to support everyone's life, not the other way around. Just because you can argue someone can make a quick buck selling a basic necessity, that does not mean it's ok to deprive a whole community of basic necessities. Take for example water. Would it be ok to hold everyone hostage over access to it, and even lobby for municipalities to stop the public sector from encroaching onto a service provided by a private business, just because Nestle and the likes bottle and sell it? The current delta between the have and have-nots, and the profound impact that "small" real estate investments have on pushing access to housing far out of reach of your average middle and upper-middle class family, is a collosal social and economical red flag. Access to housing has a profound impact on everyone's lives and even community. You accept jobs based on access to housing, and the amount of time wasted supporting said job is time eaten away from the time you spend doing far more important things like caring for your children and family. Being deprived from that just because a faceless investor wanted to park his bailout money somewhere and decided to dump it in real estate hurts society.
- convolvatron 5y agoi think you misunderstand. the tail has been wagging the dog for some time now. it is not for the market to adapt to our needs, it is for us to adapt to the market and hopefully we can extract what we need.
- nuerow 5y ago> it is not for the market to adapt to our needs, it is for us to adapt to the market and hopefully we can extract what we need. The market isn't a magical entity which demands human sacrifices. It's quite possible to keep it reigned in with a combination of banning private property investments[1] with public housing and urban renewal projects. Cut down on detrimental demand and increase supply. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28422768 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28422768
- jelly 5y ago>Companies providing and selling food, energy, and consumer staples are investment materials. >companies that grow or sell food. House builders would be the analogous party to that. The parent comment is describing landlords, specifically part-time landlords who buy up family homes and turn them into rental properties. Your analogy doesn't apply to those landlords.
- sokoloff 5y agoA supermarket is in the business of buying food in bulk and then offering portions of food suitable for a shorter time period. A gas station buys 8000 gallons of gas from a tanker and offers it by the gallon at retail. Target/Walmart buy pallets of jeans and offer them individually to consumers. The supermarket didn’t grow the food, gas station refine the fuel, nor did Target manufacture the jeans. A landlord is in the same business but for housing: buying in bulk (in this case in the time dimension) and selling a shorter time period’s worth of housing.
- citizenkeen 5y agoNo, a grocery store is like a sub-developer, buying in bulk and splitting it up. There is no other physical necessity sold on a time dimension. I cannot rent you water, or rent you food. Once the grocery store has sold a certain amount of food, they have to re-enter the market and buy more. Once a gas station has sold a certain amount of gas, they have to re-enter the market and buy more. Once a sub-developer has sold a certain number of homes, they have to re-enter the market and buy more. A landlord does not. A landlord is not the same thing.
- jelly 5y agoIts an interesting way of describing landlords, but we have now worked our way back to GP's original criticism, just stated in a different/less-tangible way: For landlords, the simple act of buying housing (a basic need) allows them to extract a profit in the time dimension, and it shouldn't work like that.
- zchrykng 5y ago
- twelvechairs 5y agoThe real difference (surprisingly not mentioned yet) is land for housing in cities is incredibly finite. Food, energy and consumer staples can be produced endlessly
- EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK 5y agoMetaverse to the rescue! Soon everyone will lay in their capsules with oculus on and walk the endless green pastures!
- jseban 5y agoThe key here being housing in cities and I would also add in nice neighborhoods, in cities. You can still expand the city, and build more cities. For practical matters, land is not finite. Food and consumer staples are similarly finite if you only look at the nicest and most attractive versions of it. There is a constant "shortage" of michelin star food and ferraris
- bjornsing 5y ago> banning all investment in companies that grow or sell food Nobody wants to ban companies from building and selling houses. Buying them and keeping them as investment vehicles is something else entirely.
- sokoloff 5y agoInvestment buyers and owner-occupants both provide the cash to the homebuilders to allow them to go build the next home. You can't sell a home without a buyer. I don't think requiring anyone who wants housing to be financially able to buy an entire home is sensible, meaning that some entity needs to be in the business of paying for more housing than they personally need to allow people to have housing who can't or don't want to buy an entire dwelling unit. Maybe you want the government to have a monopoly on that activity, but someone needs to provide it or you end up with far less access to housing and far more people living on the street than currently.
- Workaccount2 5y agoNobody wants to ban them, but also NIMBY.
- jollybean 5y ago"I don’t get why housing should be a special carve-out " Capital and leverage. Wealthy and access to capital can build, rent and make giant returns. Students paying off debt cannot even get the minimum down payment. If everyone rented, and, if transition costs were very simple i.e. you could 'jump homes with ease' - then this would be less of a problem. Also I would add stability. A government job which can be had for life, they will get a mortgage. A private sector worker or freelancer, may have blips in income, a bad blip means no mortgage payment which is very bad. The consistency required for 25 years of paying off something lends power to the entrenched kinds of workers.
- tjr225 5y ago> Students paying off debt cannot even get the minimum down payment. This is huge. My wife and I are pretty privileged and own a very modest fixer-upper home on the very edge of a coastal metro area. We somehow managed this only after a decade of paying off ~150k of student loans that our parents encouraged us to take out when we were effectively children. I have friends who are software engineers who own big houses in the city who skipped a 4 year degree altogether or their parents were able to pay for their education. The difference between them and me? They were able to pocket that 150k as opposed to giving it to some useless university administrators and various federal lenders.
- logfromblammo 5y agoPrivate utility companies are often subjected to regulatory board controls. Their local monopoly is limited by a representative (supposedly) of the public's interests. That low-risk investment has its potential returns limited to what a board deems "reasonable". Some states regulate residential housing, or at least taxes on it, to limit what municipalities and counties may do with their taxing authority. It wouldn't be much of a stretch to regulate the rents charged by "housing provider" individuals or companies to be, on average, 1/3 of average local income.
- torben-friis 5y ago>Companies providing and selling food, energy, and consumer staples are investment materials. I don’t get why housing should be a special carve-out and don’t see a workable answer to how to provide food for everyone while banning all investment in companies that grow or sell food. Companies providing and selling food are providing a service. Large investors that buy in bulk, keeping new hosing out of the market to keep prices high, are not really providing anything - they are just a different kind of consumer. I would make a parallel with the relation between gamers and bitcoin miners in the graphic cards market: miners can pay more and buy in bulk, which makes prices rise and prices out gamers. Only in this case, the people who are being priced out are no longer able to cover a basic need.