12 ms·
San Francisco's homelessness is a humanitarian crisis
- padastra 5y agoLike most readers of this forum, I advocate supplying free drugs and free housing in some of the most expensive real-estate in the world, no strings attached, to people suffering mental health and addiction issues that destroy their insight and self control. Anyone who is against this position or wants to have a more nuanced discussion is privileged and clearly suffering from a lack of empathy and is therefore a worse human being.
- osipov 5y agoIs it time for the UN to take over San Francisco?
- systemvoltage 5y agoCompletely self-inflicted. Let’s make sure the rest of the US does not adopt SF policies. For that matter, west coast policies (LA, Seattle, Portland).
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jorts 5y agoWhat policies are you referring to besides zoning?
- Rebelgecko 5y agoWarm winters
- readthenotes1 5y agoLike Orlando.
- davidw 5y agoIt really is a function of housing and zoning is a big deal in those west coast cities. I found this quite convincing: https://www.slowboring.com/p/homelessness-is-about-housing-not https://www.slowboring.com/p/homelessness-is-about-housing-n...
- throwaway1777 5y agoThere’s no world in which housing gets cheap enough in nyc and sf for these unhoused people to afford it. Why can’t the unhoused move to a cheaper city like everyone else who can’t afford it here?
- crisdux 5y agoWhat did you find convincing about that article? It seems like it takes the worst evidence to support the mental health claim, disputes them and then offers similar fallacious arguments to blame housing issues. Anecdotally, I live in a quite affordable medium sized city in the midwest, and even we have a homeless crisis and an increasingly number of homeless encampments on public property. The local government being dominated by progressives, lets these encampments continue - which previously were never permitted.
- davidw 5y agoHe does not dispute that mental health and drugs are problematic. He points out that they are problems everywhere, and it's the places with high housing prices that have more homelessness. Right now, the price of homes is going up everywhere, and as a consequence, I'd expect to see more homelessness everywhere. The camps may also have something to do with this, which has little to do with what local politicians do or do not want: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Martin_v._Boise https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Martin_v._Boise It's bizarre how much people fight against this notion. You talk about not many people having Ferraris because they're expensive, and people look at you like "uh, ok, duh". But when the median price of homes is over 850,000 dollars (California), it's this BIG MYSTERY why people do not have homes.
- throwaway1777 5y ago
- teknolog 5y agoThere's a lot more than just zoning, although that might be the single biggest factor. On top of that, the permiting process is insane, takes forever (I've gone through it), and costs a lot of money. Your neighbors get a very long time to file any complaints on your proposal (which they always do, because NIMBY). It is such a painful thing that I'd rather avoid doing any more construction. CA has a lot of rules that make construction very expensive, and SF even more so (only cast iron drain pipes, because ABS is somehow not good enough in this historic city). Earthquakes are real, but forcing everybody with 5 units (I believe) to retrofit (at the same time) cost millions of dollars per property - driving up the rent. And now solar power is mandatory for new construction, and solar is great, but it does add tens of thousands per unit.
- coding123 5y agoMaybe start with these as possible options: Second house/vacation house (not rented): Multiply property tax by 10. Rentals (including airbnb): If mortgaged: Max the rental (monthly and daily) to 1.1x Mortgage amount + yearly property tax amount / 12. Unmortgaged: Property tax amount * 2 max per monthly income. Change the maximum amount you can sell a house to be equal to cost of materials plus 30 days of labor for 5 people. Owner builder homes can get a 60K automatic grant - everything must be verified - and limit land HOA rules that specify a minimum sized house. Make "Limited Density Owner-Built Rural Dwellings" possible in areas that are not affected by fire. Finally to make all this feasible - make junk properties illegal (noise limits + junkyard style land usage) It would solve a lot of NIMBY issues and please the YIMBYs. I have a billion other crazy ideas like this.
- eniotna 5y ago> Change the maximum amount you can sell a house to be equal to cost of materials plus 30 days of labor for 5 people. That's a terrible idea, who will construct anything if there is no money to be made? You don't fix those kinds of problems by price fixing, let the free market take care of the supply/demand issue. Unfortunately, the bay area is far from a free market when it comes to housing.
- coding123 5y agoThey're just ideas - maybe apply a federal grant to the builder of 60k for each house they make. :shrug: The problem with market rate is for homes is that it turns one person's ability to be homed into another person's extraneous income flip.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- phlakaton 5y agoConsider the cluster of policies that just resulted in the 469 Stevenson St project, alluded to in the article, getting axed. As I understand it: * The project had been before the Planning Commission for at least a year. * The project had completed an final Environmental Impact Report that had been approved by the Planning Committee. Another regulatory hurdle of questionable value for a mid-city development. * An advocacy group, Yerba Buena Neighborhood Consortium, apparently run by a local affordable housing ownership group called TODCO, had their lawyers file an appeal to the Board of Supes opposing certification of the EIR. What could have been a pro-forma approval is now another potential place for roadblock. * The environmental reasons? Millenium Tower FUD, gentrification, and shadows on a nearby mid-city plaza. The scope of EIRs has apparently gotten massive if gentrification is included. (Whether a Nordstrom valet parking lot better serves the local low-income community than actual housing with an affordable housing carve-out is another question.) * The Board of Supes reverses the Planning Commission's approval. Back to the drawing board. Or... if you want to _sell_ that property you can't do anything with, I'm sure there's a local property owner that will take it off your hands if the price is low enough. ;-) We see here multiple stages way beyond zoning where a housing project can get torpedoed, and that these extra stages have grown in scope to cover just about anything local property owners might want to object to. And that's not even considering San Francisco's Discretionary Review process, which gives local groups even _more_ opportunities to delay or kill your project if they don't like it.
- kgwgk 5y agoWouldn't the adoption of those policies in the rest of the US alleviate the issue in SF? (I imagine many homeless people who is going to SF would be going/staying elsewhere in that case, maybe I'm wrong about that.)
- generalizations 5y agoOr, it would just put the rest of the US in the same situation as SF. Doubling down isn't the reasonable response here. I think it should better be considered a failed experiment.
- mlindner 5y agoHomelessness is also assisted by climate. It's impossible to die of exposure in San Francisco.
- nemothekid 5y ago>Let’s make sure the rest of the US does not adopt SF policies. The rest of the US decided to just ship the homeless west. What could the west coast do other than throw them in the ocean?
- generalizations 5y agoThey tried shipping them east. Didn't really work.
- b0tzzzzzzman 5y agoAnd South West .. But that is a nice island
- president 5y agoLet them stay on the streets but at least they could try prosecuting the ones that break laws (assault, theft, hard drugs) instead of letting them run rampant on the streets.
- nemothekid 5y agoWhat do you do after prosecuting them? Issue them a fine? They are homeless. Throw them in jail? Then you are just housing them with extra steps. That's more expensive then just simply housing them; if the bay area won't build housing, why would the bay area expand prisons?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- president 5y agoIt's mainly about deterrence. Right now, crime is happening because criminals understand there is lax enforcement.
- rendall 5y ago> The rest of the US decided to just ship the homeless west. [citation needed]
- throwaway19937 5y agoMany social problems in west coast cities are self-inflicted but there's also the 9th circuit's Martin v. Boise decision (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Martin_v._Boise https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Martin_v._Boise). It prevents criminalizing public camping unless there's shelter space for everyone. Edited to fix link, thanks!
- ggreer 5y agoYour link is parsed incorrectly by HN, causing it to be a 404. The actual link is https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Martin_v._Boise https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Martin_v._Boise While I understand the logic of the courts, this decision has absolutely ruined public parks in much of the western US.
- gretch 5y agoperspective: I own a SFH in lower peninsula and have a lot of homeless near me - daily or semi-daily interactions. I'm typically YIMBY and pro-housing, though I lean against homeless-specific solutions (but it's case-by-case ofc). Read the article, watched the oliver segment. I think the problem with this angle of argument is that it pretty much solely relies on extreme empathy holding from current homeowners (aka those with power). And when that empathy is worn down, such as the example woman in the oliver segment who has to pick up human poop on a regular basis, then the argument just falls completely flat. Like it basically goes like this "Look how bad these ppl have it, don't you care?" and the answer is "No." - then what do you do? There's no avenue for follow up or iteration - you've just made a assumption just completely breaks. You can criticize the housed-first perspectives, but at least they try to find win-win common ground between the interest of the house (not picking up human poop) and the homeless (get a home). I'm also a big fan of the tax/finance forward methods and oliver had an example during his segment of a way to save $ per homeless per year spending. To me this article reads as the epitome of 'bleeding-heart' syndrome, and lacking critical thinking toward actual problem solving with multiple stake holder interests in play.
- ProfessorLayton 5y agoI take issue with framing homeowners as "those with power", particularly when talking about SF. Most people in SF are renters, not homeowners, and could easily overpower any self interested NIMBY homeowners... But they don't, for various reasons, but one of them is that they don't care either. Aside from housing, a lot of homeless people are in need of mental healthcare, and that's something no particular city is equipped to deal with without backing from the state.
- RC_ITR 5y agoI find it so weird that people blame homeless people for defecating on the streets. Where else can they go? One of c. 2 dozen 'pit stops' that mostly close by 8pm? That's the reason you've lost empathy for them, because they are humans who have to shit and are denied access to toilets?
- vineyardmike 5y ago
- bob229 5y agoGoodbye America. It was nice knowing you
- tosh 5y agoFWIW: Vienna had a housing crisis 100 years ago which lead to “Gemeindebauten” and eventually turned Vienna into one of the most-livable cities in the world. I know, it would be naive to reduce this to housing policy but it certainly played its part from what I can tell. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gemeindebau https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gemeindebau
- dmitrygr 5y agoSimilar ideas in some other places did not end as well: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Khrushchyovka https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Khrushchyovka
- nivenkos 5y agoStill better than not having any though?
- thriftwy 5y agoNot until they start to fall apart and their owners demand that they are provided with same or better home. This may be managed by building high rises, I wonder what happens when these start to fall apart.
- yayr 5y agoyou could say this to anything, e.g. startups. so what is here to learn?
- strangattractor 5y agoI have lived in SF for 20 years. There are no good single solutions once an individual becomes homeless. The barriers to re-entering housing are high and homelessness is often the result of multiple problems making a single policy ineffective. In my opinion, I lack evidence, the money should be targeting preventing people from ever getting homeless in the first place. The intervention needs to happens earlier because once a person is homeless the problems that contributed to their situation become insurmountable.
- Flatcircle 5y agoThe huge surge in homelessness is the result of drugs. Cheap opioids.
- craigmcnamara 5y agoIt's a common misconception that people experiencing homelessness are all junkies, but it's not true. A large number of homeless people are working poor. Estimates vary from 25% all the way up to 60%. If you sleep in your car because you're priced out of an apartment and you have a job, you're still homeless. Not everyone that's homeless has a needle in their arm, shouting at traffic on the street.
- Flatcircle 5y agoI would agree with you if this were 5 years ago. But the math you referenced is the data that’s been used to formulate a solution over the last decade and the problem’s only been getting significantly worse. So either your data is incorrect or the solution to build more housing is incorrect. Either way, the status quo problem/solution set is not working.
- craigmcnamara 5y agoEvery city in the state of California for many decades has failed to build enough housing to address the ever increasing demand for it and as a result people are losing housing. Every time rent increases significantly, homelessness increases significantly. The cost of housing in California cities and the Bay Area in particular has never decreased or even stabilized because we treat housing as an investment, keep it scarce through a number of local and statewide impediments to building, and expect outrageous returns on existing housing over time.
- heymartinadams 5y agoProblem: “63% said an inability to afford rent was the primary culprit” Solution: redistribute rents How: land-value taxation or municipal land trusts + basic income
- frockington1 5y agoWouldn't a land-value tax just increase rent? I would increase rent directly proportional to a land-value tax if I were a landlord in the city.
- davidw 5y agoLVT taxes the land. If you have 1 unit on 1 acre... it's going to pay the same amount in taxes as 10 units. So it's an incentive to use the land intensely enough in order to pay less in taxes.
- Gigachad 5y agoWouldn't high density living also explode land value though?. The block of land I live on would be worth $10M+.
- vletal 5y agoSure it would. Yet not to the full extent. The system is complex, not all people rent, not all home owners would be hit by the tax equally, ...
- Flatcircle 5y agoWhen will we call the homeless crisis what it really is? A drug problem. The majority of the people you see on the streets in tents etc, are drug addicts. Reframing the problem as a drug crisis can give the people that are trying to solve it new solutions. In a drug crisis, focusing on more housing might not solve the problem. We have been trying to solve the problem with more affordable housing for a decade and every year the problem gets worse. Because we're dealing with a drug epidemic. IMHO. It's opioids.
- craigmcnamara 5y agoYou're very incorrect. There are a huge number of people that are homeless that have full time jobs. There are a huge number of homeless people that don't use drugs. The problems they have are many and nuanced, trying to blame it on a single thing is a gross oversimplification of a complex problem. The solution to homelessness is housing first.
- liveoneggs 5y agopeople in tents?
- Flatcircle 5y agoFunny enough, your point of view has been the consensus over the last decade and has been used to formulate solutions and the problem’s only getting worse. So perhaps you might consider other points of view?
- craigmcnamara 5y agoConsensus is one thing, taking action on that consensus is another. We have failed to significantly increase the supply of housing so the cost of the existing housing has been on an unending march upwards. The solutions people are willing to implement are half measures and avoid the supply-demand causes of this problem.
- jerry1979 5y agoI came across research showing that the drug use people commonly find in homeless encampments leads to disaffiliation or the severing of social ties to people outside the encampment [0]. What do you think about the idea that addiction may not lead directly to homelessness, but rather that addictions prevent people from finding a place to live outside the encampments? [0] https://filtermag.org/drugs-homelessness/ https://filtermag.org/drugs-homelessness/
- stevecalifornia 5y agoThere are broadly two kinds of homeless: those who lost their job and are discreetly trying to get back on track... and those who choose this lifestyle and shit all over the place, make enormous amounts of trash, smoke meth in bookstore bathrooms, steal from stores and assault people. All day long I see the second group all over town destroying stuff and causing mayhem that ends up hurting innocent bystanders. Yet when the media talks about homelessness they only speak as if all homeless are in the first group-- down on their luck and needing a helping hand and if you feel anything other than deep guilt you are less than human. The ruse is up: everyone has too many anecdotes of being assaulted, having to walk out into the street to go around heaps of garbage, watching people openly inject drugs on sidewalks in front of unwilling witnesses. There are clearly two distinct things going on and they likely have two totally different solutions. If media and politicians keep communicating as if there is only one problem, despite what our ears and eyes tell us every single day, then this will continue to get worse and the outcome will likely be the same as the 'defund the police' movement-- a voter referendum that says 'enough of this nonsense'.
- Flatcircle 5y agoWe're living through an opioid epidemic and people are reframing it as a housing problem, SMH
- nverno 5y agoIt blows my mind how out of touch people have to be to reframe the problem in this manner. Better housing is always a good thing to strive for, but clearly not the driving factor for the vast majority of homeless.
- Flatcircle 5y agoThe “build more housing” coalition has been winning this argument for at least 7 years. Are you under the impression that mayors haven’t been green lighting more housing and small housing pop ups? Do you think government officials have yet to implement your plan? They are building more affordable housing and yet the problem is getting worse. I drive my kids to school on the LA freeways and have seen countless people under freeway on ramps and in tent cities next to freeways shoot up drugs or stumble around, obviously high on drugs. The scope of the problem has become shocking recently. Huge trash encampments bedside every freeway. It’s not rocket science. Drive through LA, drive through San Fran. Even the main image on the linked article shows a guy who clearly shows the effects of drug abuse. If it were a drug crisis, what would the solutions be? At least try to implement those and see where it gets us instead of deny the scope of the drug abuse effect because it has a moral component.
- chernevik 5y agoIt was more complicated than that in Seattle https://www.wethegoverned.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/12/Homelessness-Report.pdf https://www.wethegoverned.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/12/Hom... Definitely from a point of view, but well argued and documented
- asow92 5y agoThere is a fine line between empathy and enablement.
- asow92 5y agoThis has been up/down voted a lot fyi.
- fhood 5y agohaha, as it should. Taking the "hard line" here seems awfully stupid to me though. Isn't that what causes the problem? I would happily pay my share of taxes to provide the most problematic homeless with a lifetime supply of heroin and hookers if it meant my family could safely park their car when they visit.
- asow92 5y agoYou would? So you aren't paying your fair share of taxes now? How much would be fair to solve this problem then?
- fhood 5y agoI will admit that my current tax rate is a little....irritating in a state that can't seem to provide reasonable roads or trains, especially trains, ffs why is the east coast so much better at this. But I think that the segment of the homelessness that has the greatest negative impact on life in SF is probably smaller than you would imagine, and maybe it is just flat out worth it.
- asow92 5y agoOver here on the east coast we have a lot of legacy infrastructure to support those rail lines, but they're nothing compared to what they used to be a century ago. That said, I'm hopeful that this administration can actually complete the connection between Scranton PA and NYC, as it would economically help a badly hurting rustbelt community. As far as the homeless minority: sure, yes, they may not be as big of a population as we assume, and yet here we are discussing how much of a problem it is. Personally, I can get behind stuff like UBI to help those folks so long as it's distributed to everyone rich or poor, and/or other inefficient social programs are shutdown to help offset these costs. Otherwise I feel like we're just rewarding incompetence and penalizing success, which I believe is where we get into enabling the proliferation of the worst kind of society to live in — one filled with apathy, nihilism, and literally poo everywhere.
- fhood 5y agoLet's get one thing out of the way first, I support tax money being used to support the homeless, regardless of the cause of said homelessness, so maybe I am not the correct audience for the article but... I am incredibly confused as to why both this article and the Oliver piece are so proud of themselves for pointing out that not all, or not even the majority, of homeless suffer from serious mental health and addiction problems. Maybe these articles aren't targeted at me, BECAUSE I ALREADY KNOW THAT. Is there really ANYBODY who is referring to a single mother living out of a car because her rent got raised when they complain about the homeless?!?! In SF I would imagine most people aren't even referring to your garden variety homeless similar to what is most visible in cities like NY. The actual problem is not being able to park anywhere with anything in your car, and passing people lying on the street that look like they are barely even alive, as well as your traditional human waste and the smell that comes with. I don't want to act as though I am disagreeing with the conclusions of these articles, for the most part I'm not. I'm also not judging people for ending up homeless. Just please stop pretending that addiction and mental health issues are some sort of unfair characterization, because it is clearly a very accurate description of the group that is responsible for the most unpleasant manifestations of the homelessness in SF. I'm also not saying we should stop trying to help and house that specific group either. I'm just baffled by how this is being framed. "A humanitarian crisis, not an unsightly inconvenience"?!?!?!?!?! Has it not crossed the author's mind that IT COULD BE BOTH.
- nemothekid 5y agoI've lived in SF for 10 years and seeing this problem grow everyday led me down a rabbit hole where I tried to understand what I could do politically and who I should vote for and support to at least show that I cared about the problem. It led me down a path where I came to understand housing and it's role in Europe and China. The most important thing I've learned is people don't care about the homeless and just think they are unsightly. It's a humanitarian crisis in the same way your dirty dishes are a humanitarian crisis, for most people. These are not people to be saved, but dirt to be washed off the sidewalks. There are 4 ways to deal with the homeless that I've summarized: (1) Kill them. I mention this one first so that it's in the back of your mind as you read about how politicians, nationwide, strike down any effort to alleviate this problem. It's the feeling I get when people say "we should do something" but then oppose any housing-first approaches. (2) House them. Another poster mentioned it in this thread but this is essentially the approach to Vienna took. House people, in houses, not shelters, unconditionally. Once they have housing, then you can work on rehab and social/mental work. Without housing, the mental problems are impossible to solve. Of course, this would require effectively socializing the housing market and people & blackrock would scream about asset prices. (3) Inprison them. This arguably more expensive than (2) but it doesn't affect asset prices as much. You could even recoup that cost with free prison labor. Sure most of the guys who argue we should do this are also the ones that say vaccine mandates are an infringement on basic freedoms and that being forced to wear a mask is essentially 1984. Of course you would have to figure out where you would build this prison, and the NIMBYs would prefer you built it on the Moon (they wont say that though, they will say something like "Building prisons is racist"). (4) Let them camp on the streets. This is unsightly, but it costs the less and maybe you will get a bit of (1) too when they die of exposure. Most cities already employ (1) through (4), they just wait for winter to roll around and problem solved. And as we see in San Francisco, as long as the housing market is sufficiently limited, then having a homeless camp outside your window wont reduce your property values all that much, and you get to use them as a political tool to prevent even more housing from being built. Barring some political revolution or deadly plague I've become doom-pilled about this situation ever being resolved. Too many people, either directly or indirectly, largely benefit from the status quo. Paying $1B/year and extracting taxes from Salesforce is ultimately preferable solution than tanking the housing market.
- rweichler 5y agoMy uncle moved to SF in the early 2000s and died in May 2020 on Eddy St. Even before he became "homeless" he just did drugs all day and thought the world owed him something. He had a college degree and everything, worked white collar jobs, but decided he liked heroin more than that stuff, so he moved to the Tenderloin. Lack of housing wasn't part of the equation, it was the lifestyle that drew him.
- maccolgan 5y agoLifestyle of doing heroin while homeless? Is that a thing?
- Redoubts 5y agocrust punks are definitely a thing
- ghostbrainalpha 5y agoI'm sorry about your uncle. The crazy thing about Heroin, I think they talk about it in Trainspotting, is that it isn't entirely irrational to value heroin more than everything else in life. That's how unbelievably good it makes people feel. My great fear is that someday someone will make something as powerful as heroin, that doesn't have the same barrier to entry, and can easy be smoked out of a vape pen or something. Just that could easily be the demise of civilization.
- sizzle 5y agoYour last paragraph and username are evoking a lot of strong imagery of what this substance might look or feel like. How does fentanyl compare to H?
- huevosabio 5y agoI like Steven Buss's sketch of a strategy for dealing with homelessness in SF: https://sbuss.substack.com/p/plan-to-end-street-homelessness-part-1 https://sbuss.substack.com/p/plan-to-end-street-homelessness...
- riffic 5y agomind summarizing this a bit before I click over blindly to your link?
- mikestew 5y agoI'll save you a click: "Subscribe now so you don't miss part 2." Part 2 is (I'm assuming) where the "strategy" is explained. The link provided is just the lead-in describing the problem as the author sees it. D---, would not click again.
- lkbm 5y agoI just skimmed very briefly, and the above link seems to just be defining terms and establishing a model of homelessness. Part 2[0] has the first part of the plan, "mitigation", which seems to boil down to add a bunch of prefab structures as homeless shelters. Part 3[1] is the next step, "prevention": rental assistance, eviction defense (already exists, but underfunded), and informing residents of the programs. And add more housing Part 4 is supposed to be "treatment", but I don't think it's posted yet. [0] https://sbuss.substack.com/p/plan-to-end-street-homelessness-part-2 https://sbuss.substack.com/p/plan-to-end-street-homelessness... [1] https://sbuss.substack.com/p/plan-to-end-street-homelessness-part-3 https://sbuss.substack.com/p/plan-to-end-street-homelessness...
- abeppu 5y ago> We can’t begin to solve homelessness without building more housing. Yes we need to build more housing. But ... there are more vacant units in the city than there are homeless. The most recent ACS stats said there were >40k vacant units in the city. Meanwhile, the city was willing to pay $60k/yr per _tent site_ in safe sleeping site parking lots. Almost certainly in reality we will need to build more housing. But there's enough money being poorly spent that honestly we could afford to solve the _housing_ portion of it by putting people in 1BD apartments. We _choose_ not to, and this reveals our preferences if not our values. The revealed preference is, we'd _rather_ have homeless people sleep in parking lots at $5k/mo per tent than pay for an apartment at $3k/mo. We'd rather live in a society where property rights are respected than one where housing is considered a right (as in the state of NY). And we'd rather move the problem around continually than solve it. https://data.census.gov/cedsci/table?q=vacancy&g=0500000US06075&tid=ACSDT1Y2019.B25004&hidePreview=true https://data.census.gov/cedsci/table?q=vacancy&g=0500000US06... https://www.sfchronicle.com/politics/article/S-F-officials-want-15-million-for-tent-sites-16269998.php https://www.sfchronicle.com/politics/article/S-F-officials-w... https://missionlocal.org/2020/05/trove-of-text-messages-reveals-mayor-breed-ordered-sweeps-directly-despite-frequent-denials/ https://missionlocal.org/2020/05/trove-of-text-messages-reve... https://sfist.com/2020/12/18/mayor-breed-takes-to-medium-to-swipe-at-supervisors-media-coverage-of-homeless-hotel-program/ https://sfist.com/2020/12/18/mayor-breed-takes-to-medium-to-...
- RC_ITR 5y ago> The most recent ACS stats said there were >40k vacant units in the city. It’s critical to note that “vacant” can mean a lot of things when the census starts throwing the term around. For example, in San Francisco it could mean any of the following: * 6,694 of those vacancies were units currently listed for rent that hadn’t yet found tenants. Another 1,031 were homes for sale that didn’t yet have buyers. * 6,294 were homes with either current owners or renters that were just not living there. This can happen for any number of reasons: hospital stays, long trips out of town, delayed move-ins, even cases of homeowners who have died but are still technically counted as the resident. * 8,523 were “occasional use” homes—i.e., these were second homes, vacation homes, some types of short-term rentals, or just any unit that was accounted for but not lived in most of the year. *Finally, the census designated 11,760 homes in the catch-all category of “other vacant,” which primarily means vacancies without an obviously stated cause. For a city with 800K residents, 8k 'occasional use' homes and 10k 'potentially vacant' homes is not a lot. And it's not as though this crisis was caused by those numbers going up faster than residents. So yeah, more housing is 100% the answer.
- verdverm 5y agoMichael Shellenberger in his book San Fransicko offers a solution he is calling CalPsych. I recommend his interview on JRE (https://open.spotify.com/episode/5NxzDE5TmviUV8te2eZjMP https://open.spotify.com/episode/5NxzDE5TmviUV8te2eZjMP) His analysis and solution centers on treating this as a mental health issue, consolidating the efforts to deal with the problem, and generally modeling CalPsych after what the Dutch and several other European cities did to deal with their similar situations in previous decades.
- shartshooter 5y agoI just recently read this article in The Atlantic[0] that, to an extent, tied the wave of homelessness to a new version of meth that's taken over. the subheadline is Different chemically than it was a decade ago, the drug is creating a wave of severe mental illness and worsening America’s homelessness problem. It was worth a read for some context [0] - https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2021/11/the-new-meth/620174/ https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2021/11/the-new...
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> a new version of meth There was a recent article on HN rebutting this hypothesis [1][2]. (Convincingly, in my opinion.) TL; DR There isn't a different kind of meth as much as there is just a lot more meth. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29027284 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29027284 [2] https://dynomight.net/p2p-meth/ https://dynomight.net/p2p-meth/
- joshuahaglund 5y agoI feel like everyone talking about drug addicted homeless people shitting everywhere are really just upset that the issue affects them, in their otherwise class-insulated world, somehow. Here's a story about homeless students living in their cars. It's not just some drug addicts making bad decisions -- they are a minority. There are thousands of people sleeping on the streets and in cars because they can not afford housing. https://ktla.com/news/local-news/safe-parking-program-homeless-students-at-long-beach-college-can-sleep-in-their-cars-in-parking-structure/ https://ktla.com/news/local-news/safe-parking-program-homele...
- profeatur 5y agoThe sad truth is that the people in this situation lack shame. They lack the sadness that you feel when you see the way they live. They will take what you give them, and then they will take more. They will make you feel guilty for not giving enough. They will steal from you when you’re not looking. They will make you realize that beyond the external features towards which you empathize, there’s nothing inside. To whatever extent they were once alive, they’re gone now. The living dead. Their only remaining use is to be the partially sentient puppets of a childish political fantasy.
- Flatcircle 5y agoThe homeless crisis is a drug epidemic caused by the law of unintended consequences. Marijuana being legalized forced Mexican drug cartels to pivot into making synthetic meth (P2P meth) Synthetic meth is much cheaper to make and is hard to regulate because it can be made from a cocktail of various household products, (the older meth was made from ephedra, and could be somewhat regulated by curbing the sale of large amounts of ephedra) Whereas P2P meth can be made cheaply in large quantities with ubiquitous household chemicals Unfortunately P2P causes psychosis at a much faster and more prevalent rate than ephedra based Meth. So that’s what’s going on, there’s a huge influx of synthetic meth coming into America and really destroying a lot of lives. And homelessness is exploding For further reading https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2021/11/the-new-meth/620174/ https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2021/11/the-new...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jart 5y agoAccording to Hollywood one does not simply homebrew Phenylacetone. In movies like The Witness or the TV show Breaking Bad their entire plotlines revolve around people killing to get a drop of the stuff. It's not like it's anything new or that ephedra is some kind of natural produce that grows on trees. Skimming through your article it sounds like these cartel chemists are dropping dead in their laboratories trying to make it and producing a final product that's more like krokodil if anything.
- Flatcircle 5y agoYou shouldn’t skim the article and assume things and down vote stuff you don’t know about. Sam is a friend of mine and one of the leading experts about this crisis. You should read his book dream land and not jump to conclusions. He’s dedicated a lot to this story. https://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/1620402521/ref=dbs_a_w_dp_1620402521 https://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/1620402521/ref=dbs_a_w_dp_162...
- 5y ago
- RickJWagner 5y agoSan Francisco has the benefit of some wealthy taxpayers to stick for the sizeable bill that will be necessary. Seriously, this is a problem for the ages. If they take a continued 'soft' stance on homelessness, it's just a beacon to draw more to the population. To take a harder stance requires political change, which will take courage and some backtracking. As techies, many of us have a connection to SF. I hope for good results here, it will be something sociologists can discuss for a long time.
- greenail 5y agoThe questions that seems obvious to me are "Who's in power? How are leaders held accountable?".