7 ms·
Wouldn't it make more sense to just let the price of electricity go up?
by josephcsible 5y ago
Wouldn't it make more sense to just let the price of electricity go up?
- ctur 5y agoOnly if you want miners to have power and residents to be without it. Capitalism is not the cookie cutter solution to all problems.
- fastball 5y agoRight but that's not the problem here? If there are power shortages then the power companies should increase supply.
- throw1234651234 5y agoThere is no capability to increase supply. See my other post - Eastern Europe is out of coal and nat gas. Belarus has excess energy from Nuclear, but is still triaging exports. People will go without power this winter if this isn't done.
- fastball 5y agoSo don't rely on coal and nat gas? What about solar? Wind?
- throw1234651234 5y agoEurope tried that, now they are trying to buy more gas from Russia. See Poland for an example. The point of that real-time example? Wind and solar are great, but they take time and the infrastructure is not yet there. Nuclear is arguably cleaner and cheaper for the output in the long term. Of course, infrastructure for nuclear isn't there in Kazakhstan yet either.
- oblio 5y agoYup, the magic pixie fairy will manage to build out electricity producing capacity that takes years to decades to build in days, weeks or months at best.
- sudosysgen 5y agoBoth solar and wind are simultaneously underperforming in Europe at the moment because of weather phenomena that reduce wind and increase cloud cover, plus of course winter. There is no solution outside of nuclear, coal, and nat gas. And Europe, save for France, doesn't have enough nuclear to go around.
- kazen44 5y agowhich might not be possible in Kazakhstan considering the state of its infrastructure compared to energy use by miners.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tw04 5y agoSo the power company should spend tens to hundreds of millions of dollars building out infrastructure for subsidized bitcoin mining? And that makes sense how?
- throw1234651234 5y agoNo. Role of government is to provide minimum standard of living for general population. A lot of people will freeze in Kaza, as basic necessities are a huge part of their monthly budget and price hike is too severe to handle. "Let market sort itself" only works if government thinks about it in advance, have fair elections, low corruption, etc. Cost of natural gas / coal / oil is going up significantly and is a huge problem for all of Europe (not just Eastern) at the moment. A lot of Eastern Europe will have rolling blackouts and need to buy power from Russia / Belarus. Kazakhstan is in the same boat in that regard. I would venture that they are probably still on the USSR power grid as well and can buy easily from Russia / Belarus.
- BelenusMordred 5y agoThis is such a bizarre comment given the history of price controls and their horrendous outcomes.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoWas working fine in Kazakhstan until the crypto folks showed up to utilize subsidized power.
- kube-system 5y agoPrice controls on utilities in the US are extremely common and successful. There are good ways to implement price controls and there are bad ways. Also, there are just as many examples of bad outcomes when you treat markets which are inherently unfree (i.e utilites, where infrastructure is typically monopolized) as free markets.
- BelenusMordred 5y agoPrice controls are successful until they aren't. The US can subsidise an egregious amount of bad policies for a very long time I suspect, from agriculture to health, it's not really going to hurt as there are other parts of the diverse economy that can pay. An better example would be Venezuela, with the largest oil reserves on Earth, they subsidised energy costs to an extreme extent and it was one of the things that drove them into the ground. People seem to dislike my comment above, yet no one seems to be arguing for petrol to cost ten cents a litre. Why not subsidise fuel if doing such things has such a successful history in the United States?
- eldaisfish 5y agothis is such a narrow line of thinking. Imaging the hubris required to even suggest that an essential input to daily life should have its price affected by an almost completely useless financial hedge for the elites.
- mistrial9 5y agocolonial empires have been the worst offenders here, no? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/East_India_Company#Indian_Rebellion_and_disestablishment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/East_India_Company#Indian_Rebe...
- notreallyserio 5y agoI assumed, based on my experiences as a power consumer, they meant increase the marginal price of electricity above some threshold. That's how electricity is priced everywhere I've lived (US). Maybe it's different on Kazakhstan, although I don't think it'd be hard to implement.
- pjc50 5y agoThat makes everyone else in the country worse off.
- fastball 5y agoIf mining is a net positive for Kazakhstani miners, doesn't that make the country better off? That's a net export.
- oblio 5y agoRead and be enlightened: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Famine_(Ireland) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Famine_(Ireland)
- robjan 5y agoNo, because everyone pays higher electricity bills while a small number of people benefit from selling their mined crypto.
- dotancohen 5y agoThe traditional solution to that problem is taxation.
- fastball 5y agoHow is this different from a factory that uses a lot of electricity to produce shoes that are then exported? I thought that was a good thing to have in your country, but apparently because this is crypto it is suddenly a bad thing?
- depaya 5y agoA factory provides jobs to locals. A factory stimulates the economy by creating local economic activity (suppliers, logistics, construction, restaurants). A crypto operation might provide a small fraction of everything above while also producing nothing of tangible value to society.
- FartyMcFarter 5y agoMaybe it would make more sense to you, but not to most people I think. Electricity has much better uses than cryptocurrency.
- Tenoke 5y agoOf course it does. It also has better uses than say gaming, so if that is the logic maybe that should be banned, too.
- p49k 5y agoGaming isn’t a major contributing cause to a country’s energy crisis.
- FriedrichN 5y agoThere is a difference between the two. That's like comparing the fuel use or exhaust of a Fiat 500 to that of a cargo ship.
- Tenoke 5y agoUnder your analogy we shouldn't regulate car exhausts before we regulate cargo ships. At any rate, article says 250k mining devices there so the electricity usage is likely more from mining but not orders of magnitude more, and even if it was it would suggest they are not banned because of how useful it is (arguably gaming is even less useful) but because of size. But sure compare to gaming + TVs then.
- FriedrichN 5y agoAnalogies are meant to be used once. You shouldn't take them and use them for another purpose.
- oblio 5y agoDoes it have better uses than a regular Kazakh citizen being able to use the light bulb in their apartment? Or their fridge?
- DantesKite 5y agoIt actually would to some extent in a country with capable infrastructure. But I don’t believe Kazakhstan has that luxury.
- baybal2 5y agoKazakhstan used to have big oversupply of electricity. They used to sell electricity to Russia before bitcoins appeared.
- that_guy_iain 5y agoAs far as I can tell cryptocurrency's value comes from how much it costs to mine the currency. So that would just affect everyone who isn't mining currency since the miners just offset their costs by selling.
- josephcsible 5y agoBut cryptocurrency can be mined anywhere, not just in Kazakhstan. If only Kazakhstan raises their electricity prices, then the price of the cryptocurrency will basically stay the same, but mining will naturally move elsewhere.
- baybal2 5y agoKazakhstan been intermittently on the 1st, and 2nd place for mining output since fall in Chinese output. USA regained the firm lead after a few months when bigger Chinese mines moved there.
- exo762 5y ago> As far as I can tell cryptocurrency's value comes from how much it costs to mine the currency This is wrong. Multiple currencies use proof-of-stake and still have value. Price is determined by demand and supply.
- that_guy_iain 5y ago> Multiple currencies use proof-of-stake and still have value. Are they Bitcoin valuable? Are they as valuable as proof of work? I think not. > Price is determined by demand and supply. So the supply is lower because it's harder to mine so the price goes up and because the price is going up demand is higher. It's kinda like diamonds. Pretty useless but because the big companies hoarde all the diamonds they keep the price high and because the price is high people put value in them.
- gruez 5y agoYou got cause and effect flipped. Cryptocurrency's value determines how much money can be poured into mining it. If bitcoin is at $60k, the block reward is 6.25 BTC, and there's a block every 10 minutes, then the entire mining bitcoin mining system can only consume 6.25 * $60k = $375k worth of electricity every 10 minutes. If the cost of electricity doubles, all that would mean is that the system can consume half as much electricity.
- notahacker 5y agoI mean, as an authoritarian state whose elections are generally considered rigged they probably could let their peasants choose between darkness and food/heat to ensure wealthy foreigners continued to to use their country to print themselves money, but I'm not sure it would make sense to do so...
- rlpb 5y agoYou could tax income from mining instead, which would have the same effect but keep the electricity price stable for everyone else. A challenge might be in effective tax collection, but it isn't that hard to find heavy electricity consumers.
- GrumpyNl 5y agoThats the weird thing, the more you use, the cheaper it can be delivered to you, same with gas. It should be the other way around, the more you use, the more expensive it should get.