4 ms·
The mountain is in the South China Sea, a leading focus of the US Navy. We learn something about the state of underwater mapping from the fact that even in the
by wolverine876 5y ago
The mountain is in the South China Sea, a leading focus of the US Navy. We learn something about the state of underwater mapping from the fact that even in the South China Sea a mountain wasn't mapped.
Why can't satellites map the topology using something like RADAR (though likely using other frequencies), which I believe is done on land? Is there no technology that will penetrate water sufficiently? Is it a physical limit of electromagnetic energy and water?
I assume it hasn't been done by satellite because otherwise we wouldn't have unmapped mountains, and because the same technology could help find submarines, taking away their stealth and eliminating a nuclear deterrent.
- woeirua 5y agoRadar does not penetrate through brine water. Other remote sensing techniques have such poor resolution that they are relatively useless for this task. Unfortunately, sonar based bathymetry is really the best tool for this task and that means you have to run around with a surface ship mapping out the sea. As you can imagine the Chinese are not a big fan of American ships doing that in waters that they claim to be theirs.
- wolverine876 5y ago> sonar based bathymetry is really the best tool for this task and that means you have to run around with a surface ship Why can't it be done from a plane or satellite? I can imagine answers (e.g., sound doesn't travel as well through air), but does anyone know? > the Chinese are not a big fan of American ships doing that in waters that they claim to be theirs I'd be surprised if that stopped the US in this circumstance. They regularly conduct operations in the South China Sea.
- simonh 5y agoThe kind of sensors you can put on a plane or satellite simply can’t penetrate seawater effectively. It absorbs radar, dissipates heat and light. Sonar sound waves in air mostly just bounce off the ocean surface. This is why submarines are so stealthy and therefore militarily useful. As long as they stay quiet they’re almost impossible to detect without using relatively short range active sonar.
- roywiggins 5y agoSound doesn't transmit well at all between air and water in either direction. It just bounces off. You can't hear what's going on underwater when you're out of the water and you can't hear what's going on above water when you're underwater.
- nitrogen 5y agoHow do anti-glare coatings on lenses work? Could something similar be devised for the air-water interface?
- stickfigure 5y agoSure. You just need to apply your anti-glare coating to the world's oceans.
- nitrogen 5y agoI mean for acoustic waves. Alternatively/similarly, could an aerial sonar waveform be matched to the ocean surface waves to cause constructive interference below the surface, and destructive above it? Would it be possible to recover the reflections afterward? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-reflective_coating https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-reflective_coating > Layer thicknesses are chosen to produce destructive interference in the beams reflected from the interfaces, and constructive interference in the corresponding transmitted beams. This makes the structure's performance change with wavelength and incident angle, so that color effects often appear at oblique angles.
- zitterbewegung 5y agoWater isn’t air? Even air can become opaque.
- woeirua 5y agoSound doesn't travel as well through the air, but it still does. The primary reason that you can't do it from the air is that the surface of the ocean is a big irregular reflector of acoustic energy from the air, so the overwhelming majority of the energy will be lost. It just would never be practical. It might be possible to use airborne gravity gradiometry to map seaborne mounts. I'd never considered that before, but I see no reason to think it wouldn't work.
- TheOtherHobbes 5y agoI'm finding it hard to believe that satellite and/or local gravimetry would entirely miss an underwater mountain.
- nradov 5y agoThe air / water interface makes it impossible to get any useful sonar data from an aircraft. Some military helicopters carry dipping sonar that they can temporarily lower into the water, and specialized aircraft can also drop sonar buoys, but those are designed for detecting submarines and are mostly useless for bathymetry. The US Navy does regularly operate in the South China Sea. In fact the USNS Mary Spears oceanography research vessel was there recently, presumably gathering bathymetry and other data. https://www.marinevesseltraffic.com/vessels/USNS-Mary-Sears-(T-AGS-65)/CURRENT-POSITION/9207077/303859000 https://www.marinevesseltraffic.com/vessels/USNS-Mary-Sears-...
- wolverine876 5y agoThanks. (I'd upvote you but for some reason votes don't stick, on comments and stories: When I reload the page, the arrows return, as if I hadn't voted. flag/vouch behaves normally. Perhaps a mod will read this.)
- dredmorbius 5y agoVotes typically take a few seconds to resolve, possibly longer under load. HN's JS indicates them immediately when you're on the page. Check your profile's upvoted comments / posts link (https://news.ycombinator.com/upvoted?id=wolverine876&comments=t https://news.ycombinator.com/upvoted?id=wolverine876&comment... -- that's private for you only) to see if your upvotes have been registered. If not, drop a line to hn@ycombinator.com as I suspect they'll be interested.
- wolverine876 5y agoThank you. No upvotes in 2 days via that link and I'm not that stingy! I upvoted your comment just before I wrote this.
- dredmorbius 5y agoI'm confirming either no upvotes (or at least balanced ones) on my GP comment above.
- stickfigure 5y ago> As you can imagine the Chinese are not a big fan of American ships doing that in waters that they claim to be theirs. Why does anyone (besides China) care? Nobody in that region recognizes those claims.
- wolverine876 5y ago> Why does anyone (besides China) care? Nobody in that region recognizes those claims. China has power, military and economic, and thus can't be ignored. If Fiji claimed a region of the Pacific, it wouldn't matter (in this respect).
- tablespoon 5y ago>> Why does anyone (besides China) care? Nobody in that region recognizes those claims. > China has power, military and economic, and thus can't be ignored. If Fiji claimed a region of the Pacific, it wouldn't matter (in this respect). It isn't ignored, but that doesn't mean those claims are recognized. The US (at least) takes actions to specifically show that: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_navigation#Freedom_of_Navigation_Operations_(FONOPs) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_navigation#Freedom_...
- wolverine876 5y ago> It isn't ignored, but that doesn't mean those claims are recognized. Agreed. The GGP was asking if anyone cared. People certainly care about the claims, even if they don't recognize them.
- toyg 5y agoBecause China happens to have nukes, probably.
- ASlave2Gravity 5y agoA good techno-thriller might be some group of hackers nab the Chinese bathymetry database, which then finds its hands in some war hungry US general
- willis936 5y agoYes, water is a very excellent RF attenuator at all frequencies. Acoustic waves travel quite far in water, especially in the ~1 kHz range. Making loud sounds isn't something you want to do when you're somewhere you're not supposed to be though. If a mountain isn't making any noise then it's going to be difficult to know that it's there.
- nradov 5y agoElectromagnetic energy doesn't penetrate water, at least not enough of the right wavelengths to be useful for mapping. The US Navy and NOAA do sea floor mapping using sonar. But it's a big ocean and some areas haven't been covered very well.
- 01100011 5y ago> Why can't satellites map the topology using something like RADAR If you were close enough, say in a plane, you could do something to cause a soundwave to propagate through the water. Say you fire a femtosecond laser pulse or blast it with an ultrasonic pulse. You could then, probably, use a second laser to pick up the reflections as disturbances on the surface. Otherwise you're probably stuck, since RF doesn't propagate well through a conductive fluid. Submarines can communicate somewhat using very, very low frequencies of electromagnetic energy, but the problem with that is the resolution at those wavelengths would be very, very poor. The best bet at this point in time is probably to just make a bio-mimicing, underwater drone and map under the surface. If you were really clever, you'd just hook some electrodes into a whale's brain and make it carry your mapping payload, using whale sounds to map the ocean floor. Not very nice thing to do to a living creature, but we've done very bad things in the name of national security before.
- nradov 5y agoThe best bet at this point is to just tow a powerful side scan sonar behind a surface ship, as has been done successfully for decades. No need for any overly complex Rube Goldberg schemes.
- 01100011 5y agoI'm talking about areas where you need to covertly surveil the seafloor(say, in waters near China). Of course you wouldn't need any of those schemes for a normal mapping operation.
- fghorow 5y agoCivilian geophysicist (but not an oceanographic one) here. This is my best understanding: As others have posted, above surface based propagating EM techniques won't work because seawater is conductive. Acoustic waves are probably the best way to map bathymetry, but that requires active sonar. The subs don't use that because it gives away their position. Surface mapping (sidescan sonar) in the area is probably the best viable technique to do the job, but geopolitical concerns make it impractical. Aside from sonar, gravity and magnetostatics could in principle be used to find seamounts. But both suffer from a fundamental problem that "upward continuation" decays short wavelengths exponentially faster than long wavelengths. In other words, to horizontally resolve a seamount with a characteristic length of (say) 10km you'd need to fly no higher than 10km. That rules out satellites. What's left are airborne and surface based surveys, which face the same geopolitical issues as sidescan sonar. Give all of that, you might as well do the sonar survey, as long as you can solve the geopolitical problems.
- wolverine876 5y agoGracias. > above surface based propagating EM techniques won't work because seawater is conductive Dumb question: My very poor understanding is that the EM images are created by objects reflecting the energy back to the sensor. Is the problem that the water's conductivity will spread the EM in every direction or otherwise cause it to behave unpredictably? > "upward continuation" ?
- fghorow 5y agoIt's mostly that the inbound energy doesn't even reach the reflector. An optical analog (yes, yes, EM true) would be trying to image something well behind a mirror. "Upward continuation": both gravity and (after certain manipulations) magnetostatic surveys obey Poisson's equation. The characteristic (Green's) function has a 1/R decay. If you will allow me another optical analog, upward continuation is closely analogous to a detailed image being convolved with a 1/R blurring function. That's the heart of why I (roughly) say you can only resolve stuff of characteristic length R by observing/measuring from below a height of R. Higher than R, and the short wavelengths are completely attenuated, and you lose ability to resolve them.
- numpad0 5y agoI think it’s not just possible but done[1], I do wonder why it still happened though. Maybe maps were outdated or resolution is not ideal? 1: https://www.esa.int/ESA_Multimedia/Images/2012/05/Mapping_the_ocean_floor https://www.esa.int/ESA_Multimedia/Images/2012/05/Mapping_th...
- fghorow 5y agoThat radar is actually measuring the sea height. Sea height (on average) more-or-less defines the geoid (the height of an equipotential surface) over the oceans. That ignores sea height disturbances due to winds, currents, tides, etc. The geoid, in turn, is sensitive to local mass distributions. So yes, "it has been done", but the result is nowhere near the resolution or interpretability of a sonar survey. Still, it would greatly surprise me if the military _wasn't_ already using the technique. So, if there were interpretable results from the technique, I would personally expect the Navy already had them...
- marderfarker2 5y agoWhy is SCS US’s business? No I’m not from 50cent army.
- rsj_hn 5y agoGenerally the U.S. leads a coalition of western nations that protect international shipping via freedom of navigation exercises. So if some country like India declares it owns the Indian Ocean, or China declares it owns the SCS, or Egypt announces it owns the Mediterranean, then the U.S. (and other nations like the U.K., France, etc) will sail through the area as well as acommpany shipping traffic to demonstrate that, no, these are really international waters that anyone has a right to use, and that no one can claim for themselves. This is an important and useful exercise in order to keep important shipping lanes free. This is critical to the functioning of the global economy, on which the U.S., U.K., and other nations depend. It is in their interest to ensure that no nation claims ownership of these global transit routes.
- wolverine876 5y agoGreat answer, and I think there are much broader reasons too: International order is fundamentally anarchy. There is no power - no world government - that can enforce order (the United Nations is just an association, a place where sovereign countries can meet and make arrangements with each other). If the order breaks down, if 'might makes right', then international wars start; wars are bad or catastrophic for everyone. WWII was so destructive that the victors worried that the world could not survive another one (one reason they started the UN and what became the EU) - and that was 75 years ago. The 'US-led rules-based international order' strives maintain an order based on rules (laws), not on might. (Yes, this is all very simplified; motives and actions are not so simple.) A simple example is when Iraq invaded Kuawait in the early 1990s. They had the might, so they took it. The US, openly stating they would maintain international order, drove them out of Kuwait. To reinforce the point, they did it according to international law, and with a coalition of international partners. China seizing the South China Sea is a serious threat to that order - what will China seize next? If the only way to stop them is to fight a war - if there is no rules-based way to do it - the world and the people in it are in big trouble. So the US and allies (which is not only western, but democracies all over including Japan, India, etc.) work to undermine that claim.