13 ms·
A U.S. submarine struck an underwater mountain last month, the Navy says
- WillPostForFood 5y agoAn interesting aspect to the story is that it looks like China forced the Navy to disclose details the accident publicly accusing the US of a cover up. https://www.military.com/daily-news/2021/10/29/china-accusing-us-of-cover-after-mysterious-submarine-incident-south-china-sea.html https://www.military.com/daily-news/2021/10/29/china-accusin... I was worried it was a collision with a Chinese vessel. Communication was poorly handled by the Navy.
- JaimeThompson 5y ago"US Pacific Fleet released a press statement on the submarine incident five days after the collision occurred on October 2, delaying its release because of operational security concerns. China has capitalized on that delay, suggesting it is suspicious." Public notice within 5 days isn't too bad given we are talking about a strategic asset.
- WillPostForFood 5y agoYes, you are right, especially under normal circumstances. In this case it allowed a window for China to take advantage of the delay in releasing the information and use it for their own PR spin.
- brandmeyer 5y ago5 days also makes sense for a cautious quiet transit to a major port.
- shanxS 5y agoI wonder how did this really happen? I mean, mountains don't move, at least not the the timescale of a submarine's motion: 1. Don't submarine use some form of radars to figure what's around then and where are they headed? 2. Assuming there were radars, were there no alarms or were the alarms ignored?
- kevinsundar 5y agoSubmarines often don't use active sonar as that sonar could give away the presence and location of the submarine.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Don't submarine use some form of radars to figure what's around then and where are they headed? No. Radar is basically useless under water (many submarines do have surface search radar available, but that wouldn't help), and while they have sonar it breaks stealth and is usually used tactically, and with a very specific cause, not as a continuous interrogation of the environment.
- jandrese 5y agoAlso active sonar deafens nearby sea life. Running around with it on constantly would be an ecological harm.
- sulam 5y agoThere are several circumstances where submarines don't actually use their sonar. They have it, but a submarine that is pinging is easily identified / tracked. The underlying question is why they were in an area that hadn't been adequately mapped.
- dylan604 5y agoWhen evading, sometimes you have to leave the safe zone. OpFor will probably be familiar with safe operating areas and limit search zones. Would a USS Captain risk the boat by leaving uncharted areas to avoid detection? Just an idea of why.
- giantrobot 5y ago> Don't submarine use some form of radars to figure what's around then and where are they headed? No. When submerged they rely on navigation charts (with higher than normal bathymetric details), passive sonar, and their navigation instruments. A submerged submarine blasting out active radar and sonar to determine its position wouldn't be very stealthy. Not every part of every ocean has complete bathymetric details. Seamounts don't necessarily move but undersea volcanos can grow in size significantly in short periods of time. A change in a few meters height can make last year's chart inaccurate today.
- ckastner 5y agoThe article references a similar fate experienced by the USS San Francisco [1]. I find seamounts somewhat fascinating; it's so odd that immensely huge features like these are still not yet charted. The Muirfield Seamount [2] is a good example. The surrounding water is 5km deep, but the mount reaches until about 20m under the surface, as an unlucky ship found out. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USS_San_Francisco_(SSN-711)#Collision_with_seamount https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USS_San_Francisco_(SSN-711)#Co... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muirfield_Seamount https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muirfield_Seamount
- laurent92 5y agoDon’t submarines detect echos? When I walk into a room eyes closed, I know whether it is big or not, furnished or not depending on how the ambient noise gets reflected. Surely the sea must be full of noises and even a black spot of noise should be perceivable? Especially since detection sensibility hs gotten so high with new tech that countries don’t try to hide anymore, but they try to produce fake sounds in other places in the ocean to disturb the detection.
- ashtonkem 5y agoDetecting echoes requires that they’re running active sonar, which announces their presence to everyone and somewhat ruins the raison d’être for submarines. Running passive they can detect surface ships, but not mountains per se.
- jdavis703 5y agoTo further clarify, unlike the ships of WW II, today US subs mostly exist for a nuclear second strike capability. The strategy assumes the enemy doesn’t know where all the submarine nukes are, so they’re guaranteed to face nuclear retribution if they initiate an attack.
- oivey 5y agoThis isn’t true, and, as the article states, this submarine is specifically a fast attack sub. It attacks other submarines and ships. That’s still related to nuclear deterrence, but not in the way you’re saying.
- wolverine876 5y agoThe mountain is in the South China Sea, a leading focus of the US Navy. We learn something about the state of underwater mapping from the fact that even in the South China Sea a mountain wasn't mapped. Why can't satellites map the topology using something like RADAR (though likely using other frequencies), which I believe is done on land? Is there no technology that will penetrate water sufficiently? Is it a physical limit of electromagnetic energy and water? I assume it hasn't been done by satellite because otherwise we wouldn't have unmapped mountains, and because the same technology could help find submarines, taking away their stealth and eliminating a nuclear deterrent.
- woeirua 5y agoRadar does not penetrate through brine water. Other remote sensing techniques have such poor resolution that they are relatively useless for this task. Unfortunately, sonar based bathymetry is really the best tool for this task and that means you have to run around with a surface ship mapping out the sea. As you can imagine the Chinese are not a big fan of American ships doing that in waters that they claim to be theirs.
- wolverine876 5y ago> sonar based bathymetry is really the best tool for this task and that means you have to run around with a surface ship Why can't it be done from a plane or satellite? I can imagine answers (e.g., sound doesn't travel as well through air), but does anyone know? > the Chinese are not a big fan of American ships doing that in waters that they claim to be theirs I'd be surprised if that stopped the US in this circumstance. They regularly conduct operations in the South China Sea.
- simonh 5y agoThe kind of sensors you can put on a plane or satellite simply can’t penetrate seawater effectively. It absorbs radar, dissipates heat and light. Sonar sound waves in air mostly just bounce off the ocean surface. This is why submarines are so stealthy and therefore militarily useful. As long as they stay quiet they’re almost impossible to detect without using relatively short range active sonar.
- skunkworker 5y agoMore info https://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zone/42954/uss-connecticut-smashed-into-a-seamount-may-have-ripped-off-sonar-dome https://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zone/42954/uss-connecticut-...
- stevespang 5y agoCavemen would be able to conclude that the safe way to navigate through uncharted territory without sonar is the have a mini submersible drone out in front via cable (if needed) to make contact first and relay a DEAD STOP alert to the sub behind it.
- dirtyid 5y agoAre there GIS / mapping software where you can fly through sea mounts with water off? Maps of ocean floor would be amazing to explore in MS flight simulator. http://onemanz.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/ocean_floor_map_300.jpg http://onemanz.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/ocean_floor_ma...
- gnarlysasquatch 5y agoAren’t there maps?
- pugworthy 5y agoOnly where you go and record data to create said maps. Sonar systems have not mapped the entire sea floor, and as others have pointed out, sonar is the main effective way to create such a map.
- alfalfasprout 5y agoand running sonar in enemy waters is not exactly a good idea :)
- pugworthy 5y agoTrue, though they are very important for continued and safe commerce in said waters. If you have any kind of ship-based commerce passing through waters, you want good charted data, and you want that data made public for the safety of ships coming and going. It's worth pointing out that regular, non-military ships do run into uncharted seamounts too. A good example is the discovery of the Muirfield Seamount, which happened when a ship in what charts said was water over 5000 meters deep ran into it. The top was only 16-18 meters below the surface. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muirfield_Seamount https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muirfield_Seamount
- brokenmachine 5y agoWell, now the map of that area has one mountain on it.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- QuarterReptile 5y agoCharts. Yes, and arguably that's part of the problem. If everything is just 'charted', you lose sensitivity to the things that are old or low resolution because it's all on the same chart.
- teedotem 5y agoReminds me of this urban legend story: This is the transcript of a radio conversation of a US naval ship with Canadian authorities off the coast of Newfoundland in October, 1995. Radio conversation released by the Chief of Naval Operations 10-10-95. Americans: Please divert your course 15 degrees to the North to avoid a collision. Canadians: Recommend you divert YOUR course 15 degrees to the South to avoid a collision. Americans: This is the Captain of a US Navy ship. I say again, divert YOUR course. Canadians: No. I say again, you divert YOUR course. Americans: This is the aircraft carrier USS Lincoln, the second largest ship in the United States' Atlantic fleet. We are accompanied by three destroyers, three cruisers and numerous support vessels. I demand that YOU change your course 15 degrees north, that's one five degrees north, or countermeasures will be undertaken to ensure the safety of this ship. Canadians: This is a lighthouse. Your call Copied from here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lighthouse_and_naval_vessel_urban_legend https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lighthouse_and_naval_vessel_ur...
- jonsen 5y ago"...Helge Ingstad believed the vessel calling them to be one of the oncoming vessels they were tracking on radar. Assuming the tanker, slow moving and with its bright deck lights obscuring its navigation lights, to be part of the shore installation,...": https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/HNoMS_Helge_Ingstad_(F313) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/HNoMS_Helge_Ingstad_(F313)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ineedasername 5y agoNot a bad lesson to keep in mind in life: sometimes you're a lighthouse that has to deal with a ship, which is frustrating. And sometimes you're the ship, and you should learn from those mistakes.
- mig39 5y agolol! Great urban legend, you're right. I remember hearing it back in the 90s! https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/the-obstinate-lighthouse/ https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/the-obstinate-lighthouse/
- pugworthy 5y agoA different commenter mentioned airborne gravity gradiometry to map seaborne mounts. It definitely would work up to a point. It would tell you "there is more mass here", but there are different ways to interpret that information. A gravimetric map is not a map of land contours, but of the density of the geologic column below. That said, nearby masses (not below the sensor) also can influence the results. When doing gravimetric surveys on land, nearby buildings can have sufficient mass to influence the readings, so certainly a nearby seamount would also influence readings. Theoretically, a gravimiter inside of a submarine could be used to detect nearby masses. Which might or might not be a seamount you're about to run into. It would be like having automatic collision brakes on a car that could be misinterpreted based on ambiguous interpretation of sensor data. You'd want to get it right. For some background reading, I found this short write-up online about interpretation of gravity data -> https://sites.ualberta.ca/~unsworth/UA-classes/224/notes224/B/224B5-2006.pdf https://sites.ualberta.ca/~unsworth/UA-classes/224/notes224/...
- fghorow 5y agoI know of one gravity gradiometer technology developed by the US Navy for submarines that was de-classified and commercially deployed in airborne gravity (gradiometer) surveys. That happened in the '90s, and (as of about 2010 or so) the technology was adapted and actively deployed in Australian mineral exploration. The mining technology was named "Falcon" and the BHP was the mining company that deployed it. I have been out of that game for a decade, so for all I know the tech has changed corporate ownership a few times, but it definitely exists. You are absolutely correct. There are many, many ways to interpret such gravity information -- most involving solution of ill-posed inverse problems. I have my personal favorites, but so does every other working potential fields geophysicist.
- pugworthy 5y agoI used to be a research ship tech years ago and did a lot of shipboard gravity surveys on Navy ONR contract. Which kind of dates my geophysical work :) Sure could cover a lot more are on with a plane! I also wrote software to do 2.5D forward modelling for a geophysical consulting business.
- suyash 5y agoThis is hard to believe, what really did they hit or what hit them in that region is anyone's guess now.
- ProfessorLayton 5y agoI find it kind of crazy that the ocean isn't mapped out like most of the roads in the world are with street view. I get that sonar isn't stealthy and is not great for marine life, but considering the budget and capabilities of the U.S. military, I'm surprised they haven't gotten that over with as its own mission.
- jcun4128 5y agoSome companies are trying some pretty cool tech https://youtu.be/eR8TQ2rXTbE?t=119 https://youtu.be/eR8TQ2rXTbE?t=119 Dang read up on USS San Francisco briefly and ran across this tidbit about sonar, dang. > For those who dont know how tremendously loud it is. It can be used to kill enemy divers if they are near your ship. It will rupture your lungs at 200 Db and hemorrhage your brain at 210 Db, sonar operates at 235 Db ... also affects sea life
- mccr8 5y agoThe ocean's real big.
- dylan604 5y agoMaybe they should try using google earth
- mpyne 5y agoIf it were just marine life the Navy would certainly be willing to press the sonar button. The problem is that navigation-quality sonar gives away the position of the submarine, which is the polar opposite of what the Navy has submarines to do.
- hadlock 5y agoShipping lanes do exist, and are quite heavily traveled. They're marked on nearly all nautical maps in bright pink and even have their own rules/laws, and a lot of areas even have radio beacons to help ships into ports from many miles out. These "super highways of the sea" are very well marked and mapped. Outside of major shipping lanes there's almost zero economic reason to map the areas immediately outside of your own economic zones
- 5y ago
- paul_f 5y agoWould it be unusual for a sub to be traveling in a poorly mapped area? Seems they would only follow well known trusted underwater pathways
- ChuckMcM 5y agoI always wonder if the whales laugh at submarines for swimming around blind (not using active sonar). One of the more interesting thing over the last 10 years that I've been reading about has been the amazing amount of volcanic activity that is ongoing under the oceans. Not as photographic as crushing a community on an island, none the less mountains are growing out of the ground at an astonishing pace under the sea.
- cwkoss 5y agoIf an island appears in the middle of international waters, who gets it? Is it finders keepers?
- severine 5y agohttps://www.quora.com/International-Law-and-Legal-Institutions/If-someone-were-to-build-an-artificial-island-in-international-waters-could-they-legally-declare-it-as-a-sovereign-nation-If-not-to-what-country-would-this-island-belong https://www.quora.com/International-Law-and-Legal-Institutio...
- sumedh 5y agoI believe most of these islands formed by volcanoes are temporary and they are claimed by the ocean very quickly.
- jacquesm 5y agoA good reminder that we know less about what's happening under the surface of the ocean than we do about LEO and near space.
- ren_engineer 5y agoUS Navy is a mess, 3.5B submarine that is one of only 3 active in its class is now out of commission. They also imply human error, especially bad considering the Bon Homme Richard was lost due to bad fire fighter training. Billion dollar accidents seem to be becoming common in the Navy. At this point I really have no confidence in the US military considering the performance during the Afghanistan withdrawal. The performance is pathetic considering the budget they have
- motoboi 5y agoBillion dollars accidents will become more and more common because billion dollars ships will become more and more common. Accidents happen, risk management will never end that.
- vwcx 5y agoPropublica has a fascinating series on the failures of the modern Navy: https://features.propublica.org/navy-uss-mccain-crash/navy-installed-touch-screen-steering-ten-sailors-paid-with-their-lives/ https://features.propublica.org/navy-uss-mccain-crash/navy-i...
- consumer451 5y agoI don't know why I'm still shocked by things like this, but I am. > The Navy installed touch-screen steering systems to save money. > Ten sailors paid with their lives.
- protomyth 5y agoWell, to be fair, they decided to go with the Virginia class as a replacement after only three. US military considering the performance during the Afghanistan withdrawal - that's pure DC leadership and not a reflection on the actual troops.
- ren_engineer 5y ago>that's pure DC leadership and not a reflection on the actual troops. true, but the fact the Pentagon has been filled with liars for decades isn't a positive sign. And nobody has paid any consequences for the failure, not a single person fired or punished. Having lions led by sheep isn't a consolation, the results are still the same Major changes aren't going to happen until something really bad happens, and by then it might be too late to matter
- jasonhansel 5y agoShouldn't a submarine have some sort of system in place to warn about or prevent collisions? It seems like human error has to be a pretty large factor here.
- QuarterReptile 5y agoWhat is the (covert) sensor for this system? And yes, human error is a prerequisite for this to happen, and in no small amount.
- mpyne 5y agoA system like what, precisely? Keep in mind that such a system needs to ensure that a submarine remains almost impossible to detect, which is the whole reason this type of platform exists in the first place.
- gscott 5y agoLarge whiskers like a cat
- chiefalchemist 5y agoIf it's big enough to hit, how does it avoid any of the onboard high-tech high-budget detection systems? I understand the oceans are massive. But if there are 100,000 if these "structures" wouldn't there be better prevention? This are world class and world beating war ships, eh.
- alleycat5000 5y agoThere's a public effort to get it all mapped: https://seabed2030.org/ https://seabed2030.org/
- throwaway4good 5y agoUS spy planes over South China Sea likely surveyed nuclear fallout of sub collision, observers say https://www.scmp.com/news/china/military/article/3154476/us-spy-planes-over-south-china-sea-likely-surveyed-nuclear https://www.scmp.com/news/china/military/article/3154476/us-...
- m0zg 5y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dqDqvKYDv9M https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dqDqvKYDv9M I wouldn't read too much into what they say after the fact, and resign to the fact that we'll never know what actually happened.
- hoseja 5y agoIsn't there some sensing system that works within roughly the inertial envelope and is mostly or even theoretically undetectable outside of it? You'd think the subs would have it.
- stevenalowe 5y ago"That mountain had it comin'" replied the driver of the submarine...
- blitzar 5y ago"It wasnt there when I checked the mirrors before reversing"