4 ms·
Well... when we get to herd immunity isn't a purely scientific number, because it depends on peoples' behavior, and peoples' behavior changes to some degree dep
by AnimalMuppet 5y ago
Well... when we get to herd immunity isn't a purely scientific number, because it depends on peoples' behavior, and peoples' behavior changes to some degree depending on what public health officials are telling them (or depending on what the media is saying that public health officials are saying).
So you're kind of right in your criticism (what we need from scientists is science, not what they think we need to hear). And yet, there is also an element of validity in what they're saying here too - matters of science are not just matters of science. They change peoples' behavior, in ways that the scientists may not have taken into account.
- pdonis 5y ago> matters of science are not just matters of science. They change peoples' behavior, in ways that the scientists may not have taken into account. And given this, the only defensible position for the scientist to take is to tell the truth as best they know it, including the truth about what we don't know or don't understand, as well as about what we do know and do understand. That way the responsibility for other people's behavior is on the other people--they were told the truth as best the scientists knew it, and if they made a bad judgment based on that truth, it's their responsibility. Whereas, if a scientist tries to twist or filter the truth because of some belief they have about how it might change other people's behavior, now it's their responsibility if those other people end up doing something harmful, because they didn't just tell the truth as best they knew it, they tried to judge what they wanted other people to do and filtered what they said based on that. And that's not their job.
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoI agree, but I will go one step further: It is also the responsibility of the science reporters to not filter out the truth about what we don't know and don't understand. That part's important. Don't skip it to make the story sexier or more viral. In fact, I wonder if more of the responsibility for the recent problems is on the reporters, rather than the scientists.
- pdonis 5y ago> I wonder if more of the responsibility for the recent problems is on the reporters, rather than the scientists. Back when most science information only got to the general public through reporters, I think this might have been a valid point. However, now many scientists are communicating directly with the public, through blogs, articles, interviews, etc., so I think more of the responsibility for miscommunication falls on them directly. Some scientists are even doing end runs around the scientific process by publishing popular articles on their own research before it has been replicated or even reviewed by other experts in the field. (Personally, I never even bother reading an article by a science reporter; if I'm interested enough in the topic, I find the actual paper documenting the original research and read that.)
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoYes, many scientists are communicating through blogs, etc. However, I suspect that the general public still mostly gets their science information through reporters. The general public is not reading scientists' blogs. They're free to do so, but they don't.
- timr 5y agoYou're correct that "when" herd immunity is achieved is an estimate. But that doesn't make the author right. The point of the article is that you can't talk about it at all -- at least, not with out so-called "broader context" to weaken the discussions -- lest you undermine her preferred public health policy. I don't particularly care what any particular person thinks about the "herd immunity threshold". I don't really think it's a useful discussion, as a single number (i.e. "herd immunity" has probably been achieved and lost locally multiple times over the course of the pandemic). But the suggestion that anyone who dares make a prediction about it should be scolded for being an apostate is a steaming pile of anti-intellectual bunkus. And frankly, if someone disagrees with the author's preferred public health dictates, they should be allowed to talk about that too. I missed the memo where we made her judge and jury for scientific discourse.