16 ms·
Artificial meat is the most important thing anyone could be working on right now. Convincing, nutritious, cheap artificial meat could turn the world vegetarian.
by pessimizer 5y ago
Artificial meat is the most important thing anyone could be working on right now. Convincing, nutritious, cheap artificial meat could turn the world vegetarian. This would have radical effects on the environment, the climate, and obviate the need to kill billions of animals every year.
"don't eat hyper processed foods" is a horseshit shorthand. It's types of processing that are problems, not the simple fact that food has been prepared. Sometimes I'll cook a dish with a lot of steps at home; am I supposed to assume that the 10-step food I cook at home is less healthy than the 2-step?
> eat moderately
This literally doesn't mean anything. Moderate is not an amount, or a composition.
- GhettoComputers 5y agoNo it won’t. Tofu has existed for centuries and it didn’t, impossible burgers didn’t. It’s hopeful, but in reality it’ll just give industrialized countries with poorer people less access to animal products, while those in 3rd world countries continue to grow chickens.
- Zababa 5y agoNeither tofu nor impossible burgers are a convincing replacement of a real piece of meat. They are replacement for processed meat.
- GhettoComputers 5y agoSure, neither of them are ribeye equivalents. But at what cost will people pay for the the fake foods, and what issues will they bring? I'm actually very fond of quorn (with egg white) which I could be convinced is a 1:1 piece of chicken.
- debacle 5y ago> Convincing, nutritious, cheap artificial meat could turn the world vegetarian. Which part of the world? The US? Eastern Europe? South America? The barrier to "convincing" and "cheap" are very high.
- GhettoComputers 5y agoSeitan, tofu, lentils and tempah have long fit this criteria so it’s not exactly high. It just hasn’t happened and it won’t happen just because some tech nerds who assume it hasn’t already happened decide you can do it with Frankenstein food by heavily processing it and using enough food flavorings to mask its plant origins and convincing you to pay more for a worst product.
- debacle 5y agoI don't consider any of those "replacement meats," they're foods in their own right. Falafel fits the bill as well, maybe mushrooms. The real problem is scale. We're much more likely to develop a microbial or fungal nutrient sponge that's far easier to manage (and probably better for you + the environment) than develop some sort of highly advanced fake meat extruder. One of the biggest issues really is momentum. It will be 20-30 years before a technology can compete with a guy in muddy jeans on a tractor. We are disrupting the fossil fuel industry, but that industry is only really about a hundred and fifty years old. The agricultural industry is nearly ten thousand years old, and it's experiencing its own renaissance with the advent of IoT.
- GhettoComputers 5y agoWhy not? I ate some quorn, its rather good, but its overpriced and I would never buy the vegan one.
- ben_w 5y agoI bought the vegan one before I left the UK (can’t find it in Berlin). It’s not great, but not terrible. (Vegan cheese however, has been terrible every time I’ve tried it). Now I’m using tofu or soy mince or similar depending on what meal I’m making. Those do need flavour, not having much of their own (unless bought pre-flavoured, smoked tofu works well).
- xboxnolifes 5y agoI don't see how any of those examples are anything like a meat replacement. Just because something is high in protean doesn't make it a meat replacement. That makes it a protean replacement.
- karol 5y ago> Convincing, nutritious, cheap artificial meat could turn the world vegetarian. You wrongly assume people in general want to or need to be vegetarian. We evolved to eat and digest animal based foods.
- wongarsu 5y agoDrastically reducing the consumption of real meat, especially beef, would have an impact on our greenhouse gas emissions comparable to making all planes and ships carbon neutral
- ben_w 5y agoYes, yet that doesn’t make it any easier to change peoples dietary preferences.
- agurk 5y agoI didn't know these numbers, so I had to look them up: * Ships are responsible for 90% of international transport, their CO2 emissions accounting for approximately 2.2% of the global total of such emissions [0] * Aircraft are responsible for 1.9% of greenhouse gas emissions (which includes all greenhouse gases, not only CO2) and 2.5% of CO2 emissions [1] [0] https://orbit.dtu.dk/files/158911010/Working_Paper_4_Emissions_from_Shipping.pdf https://orbit.dtu.dk/files/158911010/Working_Paper_4_Emissio... [1] https://ourworldindata.org/co2-emissions-from-aviation https://ourworldindata.org/co2-emissions-from-aviation
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- GhettoComputers 5y agoThat is an enormous lie. https://www.epa.gov/ghgemissions/sources-greenhouse-gas-emissions https://www.epa.gov/ghgemissions/sources-greenhouse-gas-emis... Agriculture in total is 10%. Transportation is 29%
- dTal 5y ago
- belorn 5y agoProcessed foods is mostly just a collective term for food with high amount of preservatives, food additives, heat treatment, cold treatment, grinding, emulsifying, and other mechanical force being applied. Each step changes the food in ways that can have benefits but also drawbacks. Turn an apple into apple juice concentrate and then add water and what you have is not an apple. You got an apple-inspired surgery drink with almost none of the food properties of an apple. If people tried to reconstruct the apple using food additives, the result could even look like a physical apple and possible even fool people into thinking they are eating one, and yet it would not be an apple with the microbes, fibers, vitamin, minerals, skin and other parts for which makes an apple an apple. A 10-step recipy that you cook at home might include some aspects of an identical finished product that you could have bought at the store, but in general I suspect it has fewer of the destructive steps. Those that you do yourself might also be less effective, as one don't usually intend to have left overs that can remain in the fridge for several months with no change.
- TeMPOraL 5y ago> food with high amount of preservatives, food additives, heat treatment, cold treatment, grinding, emulsifying, and other mechanical force being applied. I.e. the kinds of steps you cannot perform in your kitchen yourself, because you lack the necessary hardware and expertise. Home cooking is amateur-level food processing. It's still details of the individual steps that matter for whether the end product is healthy or not. As a shorthand, it has nonzero informational value, but it's really blaming the wrong thing - it's not processing as a concept that's problematic, it's particular decisions made by companies releasing food products. The closer you are to raw ingredients, the less opportunity there is for businesses to screw with the food (optimizing for profitability over nutrition).
- mauvehaus 5y ago"Sometimes I'll cook a dish with a lot of steps at home; am I supposed to assume that the 10-step food I cook at home is less healthy than the 2-step?" If your kitchen looks like a kitchen and not a chemistry lab or oil refinery and you're starting with things that are identifiably food, you're probably good to go either way. And while I'm no expert on the full cycle of meat production in he US, animals are routinely grazed on land that is unfit for modern, large-scale row cropping. I'm not saying that's the only way to turn soil and sunlight into plants, but it does seem to be the predominant one. It isn't clear cut to me that taking that land out of productive agricultural use and shifting the need to yet more industrial agriculture is a huge win. If somebody has done that math, I'd be very interested in seeing a source. And to be clear, I'm more than prepared to believe that it's a net win. It's pretty well established that cows create a lot of methane and that all the progress with seaweed-based supplements is dubiously applicable to free ranging livestock.
- TheCoelacanth 5y agoIt depends how many of those 10 steps involve cramming the food full of extra sugar, fat and salt. With industrially processed food, that's almost inevitably a big part of the processing. Industrially processed food wouldn't have to be so unhealthy, but it is consistently enough to make it a pretty accurate heuristic for how healthy food is.
- TeMPOraL 5y ago> If your kitchen looks like a kitchen and not a chemistry lab or oil refinery and you're starting with things that are identifiably food, you're probably good to go either way. Well, the flip side is that if your kitchen looked like a chemistry lab, you'd be able to make better food. The difference between cooking and chemical process engineering is that the latter actually cares about quality of outcome. There's a lot to be concerned about with what the food manufacturers are optimizing their products for, but reducing it to "processed = unhealthy" or "chemical sounding names in ingredient list = bad" is just like saying that the only real art is finger painting, everything else is not art.
- rubidium 5y agoThis list is not super “convincing”: Water, pea protein*, expeller-pressed canola oil, refined coconut oil, rice protein, natural flavors, dried yeast, cocoa butter, methylcellulose, and less than 1% of potato starch, salt, potassium chloride, beet juice color, apple extract, pomegranate concentrate, sunflower lecithin, vinegar, lemon juice concentrate, vitamins and minerals (zinc sulfate, niacinamide [vitamin B3], pyridoxine hydrochloride [vitamin B6], cyanocobalamin [vitamin B12], calcium pantothenate). Why is there a laxative in my fake meat? “100% free range grass feed beef” is a lot more convincing.
- phonypc 5y agoDo you take issue with any particular ingredients, or is the implication just "long list bad"? What are you calling a laxative?
- GhettoComputers 5y agoYes, I am not interested in a meat flavored veggie protein shake that is made of seed oils, costs more and is less nutritious. It’s disgusting. I don’t know who the market for it is, I’d sooner eat tofu than overpriced corporate crap with heavy processing and industrial refining. What is the benefit? Who buys this? People that don’t like meat but want to feel good about eating junk food that’s vegan and is a poor imitation of it?
- phonypc 5y agoIf the issue is seed oils, then by all means make that case. There are arguably convincing points to be made in that area. Implied outrage at long ingredient lists is not constructive.
- GhettoComputers 5y agoI didn’t post his list. Implying an ingredient which is made of overpriced heavily industrially processed mixtures of grain and beans mixed with flavorings and chemicals since the underlying implications is that plant based foods suck and need corporations to heavily process them until it’s bearable to eat despite its worst nutrition and higher cost than mean isn’t more constructive if you’re trying to convince others to eat non meat products.
- kvgr 5y agoThat is so wrong, it doesnt even need response but here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sGG-A80Tl5g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sGG-A80Tl5g
- Grakel 5y agoThere's absolutely no reason to stop eating meat, and we're not going to. Environmental concerns can be improved over time. It's a primary food type everywhere it can be gotten, and everywhere else is trying desperately to get more. Artificial meat will always be a minor alternative.
- Toutouxc 5y ago> no reason to stop eating meat, and we're not going to What if lab grown meat was significantly cheaper than animal-sourced meat? Because that could very well happen in the future, animal production isn't exactly cheap or effective.
- jraph 5y ago> There's absolutely no reason to stop eating meat Are you sure you see absolutely no reason to stop eating meat? You may need to read the parent comment again, a few are cited, including the "need to kill billions of animals every year" you didn't address. Whether those reasons are sufficient to stop eating meat is a separate matter. > we're not going to > Artificial meat will always be a minor alternative. I need a crystal ball, can you tell me where you got yours?
- GhettoComputers 5y agoWhere’s your crystal ball that says artificial meat is a larger alternative or it’ll be 1:1? Most people are poor and can farm themselves instead of relying on corporations to feed them.
- jraph 5y agoI have not stated that. That's the point: I have not attempted to take a guess at the future and stated this guess (or my wishes) as a hard fact.
- lm28469 5y ago> There's absolutely no reason to stop eating meat, and we're not going to. Most people in the west definitely eat too much and too low quality meat. In Germany it's pretty much the norm to eat two meat based meal a day, if not three. Meat in the US is an abomination, both in term of quality and amount consumed. No reason to stop eating meat altogether but plenty of reasons to start eating less of it I personally reduced my meat consumption by about 80% and mostly eat a vegetarian diet based on non processed food, I feel as good as ever, my performance in the gym didn't decrease, there is no reason to eat as much meat as we do really, it's purely cultural. I don't have anything against meat morally speaking, I still get a nice piece of it whenever I can when I'm eating out, I just cut the garbage quality meat (aka 80% of what's available in supermarkets)
- MrPatan 5y agoYeah, it's not the "processing" of it. It's that one of the steps in the process of almost all "processed" food is: "Add a ton of salt and sugar". It's not the processing, it's optimizing for getting your dumb starving brain in your fat meat puppet to go "More of that. Now." that is a problem. Processing is just a word, and not even that bad as shorthand. But here come the word thinkers and now it's heretical to... what? Let food see the inside of a factory? Big stainless steel vats are what make you fat? Word thinkers, man. That's a bigger problem than sugar.
- OneTimePetes 5y agoInstinct Hacking food?
- 8bitsrule 5y agoOur 'natural' hamburger is already being 'processed' by well- and long-bred cow 'laboratories' on 'factory farms'. Tipoff: the burgers don't look or smell like grass (or whatever cows eat these days, besides antibiotics and meat and bone meal). The big question, of course, is how much methane these 'laboratories' will produce! ';-)
- cheese_goddess 5y agoThere is a commnonly accepted standard about what is (ultra) processed or not. It's called NOVA and it's summarised in the following article: https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/nutritionsource/processed-foods/ https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/nutritionsource/processed-foods... And I quote: "Ultra-processed foods Also commonly referred to as “highly processed foods,” these are foods from the prior group that go beyond the incorporation of salt, sweeteners, or fat to include artificial colors and flavors and preservatives that promote shelf stability, preserve texture, and increase palatability. Several processing steps using multiple ingredients comprise the ultra-processed food. It is speculated that these foods are designed to specifically increase cravings so that people will overeat them and purchase more. They are typically ready-to-eat with minimal additional preparation. Not all but some of these foods tend to be low in fiber and nutrients. Examples are sugary drinks, cookies, some crackers, chips, and breakfast cereals, some frozen dinners, and luncheon meats. These foods may partially if not completely replace minimally processed foods in some people’s diets. One study using data from the U.S. National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey found that ultra-processed foods comprised about 60% of total calories in the U.S. diet. [4] An association has been suggested between the increasing sales of ultra-processed foods and the rise in obesity. [3]" In short, ultra-processed food is food that's full of stuff you don't need to eat or you don't want to eat, but that's there to make you buy the product, and keep buying it. It's food whose purpose is not to nourish, but to sell.
- gruez 5y ago>In short, ultra-processed food is food that's [...] there to make you buy the product, and keep buying it. It's food whose purpose is not to nourish, but to sell. This isn't really supported by the quote you posted. That aspect only gets a mention in one sentence, and even that's qualified by "It is speculated".
- phonypc 5y agoThe commonly accepted standard is incoherent. Chips are listed. Not "some" as is qualified for frozen dinners, but just chips. Chips are just sliced potatoes cooked in oil and salted. No "artificial colors and flavors and preservatives that promote shelf stability, preserve texture, and increase palatability". If you dust some MSG and onion powder on them I guess that technically fits under artifical flavor. But I can do that at home in a couple seconds. Does dusting the same MSG and onion powder on my roasted asparagus make it ultra-processed? Insofar as chips are an issue, it's that they contain too much fat, or too much salt or something. Not some magical property attached to them in an industrial factory. There are similar mismatches for their other examples.
- pif 5y ago> Convincing, nutritious, cheap artificial meat could turn the world vegetarian. Then, by definition, it's not meat. Please, let's keep calling things with their proper name!
- headsoup 5y agoNo, artificial meat is not. Always looking for solutions to the symptoms of the root cause, which is feeding overpopulation. We don't expect to hit a human carrying capacity, we expect to 'solve' that problem with technology and clever thinking and live anywhere we like forever. What happens when everyone's eating fake meat, but we've added another few billion people and we need more and more? Bigger factories, larger crops, wider distribution. Then that's the 'problem' and we need a new wonder thing. Fake meat and all these other engineered solutions (along with large scale monoculture and livestock industries) ignore and completely misunderstand the complexities and resources of the natural world. The ecosystems of soil, insects, plants, climate etc interacting and evolving. We think we're smarter than that and can do better with simple solutions to complex problems, so here we are arguing about not-meat.
- TeMPOraL 5y ago> We don't expect to hit a human carrying capacity, we expect to 'solve' that problem with technology and clever thinking and live anywhere we like forever. Yeah, that's more-less the whole point of technology, and civilization. The alternative is to pack up and go back to living in caves. Complex systems are there to be studied and managed with intelligent solutions. Not to scare us into trowing our hands up in the air and giving up.
- headsoup 5y agoMy point is not going about going backwards, it's realising there isn't infinite growth that we just need to solve for
- Zababa 5y ago> Convincing, nutritious, cheap artificial meat could turn the world vegetarian. This would have radical effects on the environment, the climate Way less than replacing fossil fuels. Unless you're against killing animals for moral reasons, artificial meat is not "the most important thing anyone could be working on right now".
- sbacic 5y ago> Convincing, nutritious, cheap artificial meat could turn the world vegetarian. I'm not so sure about that. I've recently had the opportunity to try a vegetarian diet for a week. I did not enjoy it, I found the food tasteless and insufficiently nutritious. But that got me thinking about all the dishes I usually consume which, while not exclusively plant based, are mostly made out of vegetables. All those dishes have a critical animal-based ingredient. The problem? Many of those ingredients aren't desirable by themselves - meat with significant bone and fat parts, pork hooves or ears, animal blood and others. Yet without them, you cannot make those dishes. I wonder, when we finally arrive at that artificial meat future, will today's "undesirable" parts of beef or pork or chicken become an expensive delicacy? Will it basically wipe out traditional recipes that depend on them? I'm not sure I'd want to live in such a world.
- DoingIsLearning 5y ago> This would have radical effects on the environment, the climate, and obviate the need to kill billions of animals every year. Let's agree on the ethical aspect of avoiding to kill animals. However, regarding the environment we need to look at the actual data and the weight of different activities on global greenhouse emissions: - Livestock farming : 5.8% - Road transport: 11.9% - Heating/cooling offices and house: 17.5% [0] So considering the actions we can take right now, we would get much more bang for buck in curbing emissions, by reducing heating and cooling costs in our own homes and avoid car usage, than we would by not eating meat. For the record I agree that we should stop animal cruelty but specifically on the environment the unconfortable truth is that there are more urgent 'confort' actions you can take right now, very people are willing to leave their car behind or curb their house A/C usage. [0] https://ourworldindata.org/emissions-by-sector#agriculture-forestry-and-land-use-18-4 https://ourworldindata.org/emissions-by-sector#agriculture-f...
- TheCoelacanth 5y agoOh, so it would only remove as much in emissions as completely removing half of all road transport in the entire world. Might as well not even bother then.