22 ms·
Looked at through a less "assume malice" lens: this line of internal questioning is how you get to a safer product for a wide userbase. The issue that Facebook
by shadowgovt 5y ago
Looked at through a less "assume malice" lens: this line of internal questioning is how you get to a safer product for a wide userbase.
The issue that Facebook is trying to solve is that kids already use the platform. They'd rather proactively have a configuration that is appropriate for that age group than offer none and have to deal with the consequences of the underage getting on adult Facebook and hitting content they aren't supposed to be exposed to (and, more corporate-selfishly: running the risk of being hauled in front of a Congressional committee or into court under the argument that they aren't complying with the spirit of COPPA if "kids just lie about their age" is a known issue on their platform that they haven't done anything proactive to address).
The original memo Ars is pulling from here is a pretty good read (https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/21095535-copy-of-young-people-philosophy_sanitized_opt-1 https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/21095535-copy-of-you...). The header is "The internet wasn't built with young people in mind, but we're about to change that." And, yeah... They've identified a real problem and a possible value-add for families.
- beefield 5y ago> The issue that Facebook is trying to solve is that kids already use the platform. I would assume that if Facebook cared the slightest bit, they would be able to identify users that are six years old and simply redirect them to a safe page that is not facebook. Maybe a page that says that if you really are overage, could you please send your id. At least that's what they seem to be doing if they think the user account is not legit for some other reason.
- fallingknife 5y agoYou mean like all of those "are you 18?" popups that I'm sure you always answered honestly?
- ahepp 5y agoThis company made over $85 billion revenue in 2020 based on the idea that they can precisely target ads to specific groups. The claim that they can't outsmart 6 - 13 year olds (elementary school children) is not believable.
- annoyingnoob 5y agoHere is my parental 'value-add' - Social Media is not appropriate for my 7 year old, at all on any level.