3 ms·
> Surprisingly housing is so constrained at this point that in a major city like Boston you could purchase all outstanding homes for <200 Million dollars. And
by lotsofpulp 5y ago
> Surprisingly housing is so constrained at this point that in a major city like Boston you could purchase all outstanding homes for <200 Million dollars.
And then do what?
- taneq 5y agoSell them again now that you’ve pumped the market?
- lotsofpulp 5y agoIf it was that easy, what is stopping other cash rich entities? There are clearly large risks and liabilities associated with this maneuver.
- taneq 5y agoWhat makes you think they’re stopped? This is why Zillow doesn’t have to buy the whole market, all they need to do is buy enough for other investors to start piling on.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoAnd then? They trade houses between each other while paying property taxes and paying for security and upkeep of the houses? Real estate is not a secret business, and it is not like there is a massive population of buyers ready and able to pay top dollar. There are already many local players arbitraging real estate at any given time. It would be one thing if it was free or cheap to hold onto houses indefinitely, but not only is physical security a problem, but politically it is a minefield too.
- lumost 5y agoTwo problems emerge: 1) Housing is a leveraged asset and can't fall substantially without a lot of individuals, banks, and institutions going bust. Historic government interventions serve as a hedge against this. 2) If housing is expensive enough then individuals can't afford to sell their own home. If buying a new smaller home requires 2x the equity of my existing home then I probably can't reasonably move. This means that new homes are less likely to be offered for sale. It's clearly an unstable set of incentives, but it could be unstable for a very long time. My suspicion is that the only way for housing to exit its current cycle is a protracted period of high inflation in wages/goods/services which makes individuals more able to pay and depresses the financial returns on housing.
- lotsofpulp 5y ago1) does not apply since Zillow is not going to be buying the houses with taxpayer funded mortgages from FannieMae or such 2) it is true that people may not be able to afford to move, but people will keep dying and their houses will keep opening up. But the biggest thing is developed (buildings) real estate is very expensive to just hold empty, so there is incentive to keep it moving. I am not talking about foreign millionaire and billionaire apartments in tier 1 cities, those are obviously bought and sold under a different set of constraints and goals. But your general purpose houses in 99% of communities across the US need to be lived in and property taxes paid. I do agree with you that housing prices will not go substantially down nominally. Politically, all voters like to see their position improve, which means land and public stock market prices need to go up. But that does not mean Zillow will earn any decent risk adjusted return on buying and selling suburban tract built houses at scale.
- Phlarp 5y agoRaise the rent
- WalterBright 5y agoIf someone's business plan was to buy all the houses, then my business plan would be to aquire/build houses, and sell to that person at enormous markups.
- rsj_hn 5y agoYup. Buying all the houses is possible in a constrained market, but Phoenix is unconstrained, and transportation allows us to substitute constrained for unconstrained locations.
- brendoelfrendo 5y agoThat would be, more or less, exactly what they want, because the artificial scarcity begins dictating prices. You might try to sell to them, but they're not obligated to buy from you; they could simply point to the properties you're offering at enormous markup to unload some of the property they own at an enormous markup. And if they did buy from you at an enormous markup, they can point to those purchases as "comps" for the purposes of valuing their portfolio. This actually happens in the art world; there's a guy who goes out of his way to overpay for Warhol paintings, because a) he can corner a finite market and b) when a Warhol painting sells for a record amount, the value of his entire collection goes up even if he's the buyer.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoUntil no one wants to buy a Warhol at the price he is seeking. There is no guarantee that this will work indefinitely, just like houses in Boston becoming undesirable at a certain price point. It is possible that Boston houses are underpriced, but it is also possible people will start looking elsewhere. Probably have to dig into income trends and more data rather than just “Boston has limited housing, so it will always be rentable/sellable at a higher price”.