4 ms·
Whether or not marriage as an institution is biased against males or females (honestly, it seems to be biased against both) I am always astounded by people who
by sliverstorm 15y ago
Whether or not marriage as an institution is biased against males or females (honestly, it seems to be biased against both) I am always astounded by people who see no value whatsoever in marriage.
America is practically founded on capitalism. How can you understand specialization & its benefits, and not see how marriage (well, used to) makes use of it?
Yes, if marriage was just about pretending "True Love is real, and the world is full of roses and daisies!" it would be a ridiculous sham. But as I have come to see it, it is more about facing the world as a "team". In larger groups (that is to say, extended family, all composed of marriage links), perhaps even as a "tribe"... think about that.
(Not to mention, kids are a thing we kind of need as a species, and I think most everyone is familiar with the plight of single parents)
- bbq 15y ago"But as I have come to see it, it is more about facing the world as a "team". In larger groups (that is to say, extended family, all composed of marriage links), perhaps even as a "tribe"... think about that." I agree! Why do those links have to be marital? I'm not sure they have to be. Which is why the we need to be more open.
- janees 15y agobecause, marital/blood link are more stronger than open/causal links.
- sliverstorm 15y agojanees' grammar is terrible, but he's not entirely wrong. We like to think we are above 'foolish' things like being related to people, but as my grandparents have put it, my brothers will always be my brothers. That is one thing that cannot change- and somehow, that is special. Call me base, call me old-fashioned, but I have come to feel that blood ties are not as imaginary as I used to believe.
- rcthompson 15y agoIf you want a concrete reason that "blood" ties are non-imaginary, there's kin selection: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kin_selection http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kin_selection
- bobo888 15y agoI don't think that marriage in USA is biased against anyone. But the divorce is HEAVILY biased agains men. For example, more than 70% of divorces are initiated by women, while they also get the custody of the children 90% of the time. When it comes for child support, it's even worse. If in a family the husband begins to get a lower salary due to the state of the economy, then everybody should/will spend less. But if a divorced father gets a lower salary, "the child's standard of living must not change". Did you earn $200,000 per year pre-divorce, and now you barely can find work for $50,000? Too bad for you, you'll have to get an extra job to be able to pay the same amount of child support. If you fail to pay, you get to jail, but the support payments accumulate, so when you get out you'll be in even more debt, which will land you back in jail, and so on. And of course, this whole time, you will be considered a "deadbeat dad". BTW, I was shocked to find out that, in some states, men* have to pay lifetime alimony. With all due respect, guys who get married on these terms are insane.
- burgerbrain 15y agoMarriage itself can be quite biased against males in the states. I have a friend who's wife successfully divorced him because she was not being "sexually satisfied". If a male tried to do the same, people would scream "domestic rape". Expectations of each sex, viewed through the lense of the courts, are very uneven. And of course after the divorce the situation only becomes more dire.
- sliverstorm 15y agoIf only that was the worst of cases. My mind is continually blown by the cases in which husband catches wife cheating, husband sues for divorce, wife gets custody, half of assets and alimony.
- whyenot 15y agoplease cite your sources
- sliverstorm 15y agoThis is one of those things teetering on the edge of "public knowledge". I have never met a single person who believes women receive the short end of the stick in divorce. In fact the only complaint from the women's end of things I've ever heard is '50% of his income is not enough'. It is of course anecdotal, but as best I can tell, it is anecdotal evidence that is shared by every person in America- aka, 'public knowledge'.
- burgerbrain 15y agoYou can "handle things as a team" without bringing into bring into the equation the full force of a modern judiciary system and a stone-age property rights system.
- sliverstorm 15y agoThe judiciary system and stone-age property system instill a certain permanence. It is much harder to give everything you've got when the other party can up and walk away whenever they please. Maybe in modern times we have better solutions than a modern judiciary system, but the system is the way it is for a reason.
- mortenjorck 15y agoWould you co-found a company without the full force of a modern judiciary system?
- burgerbrain 15y agoI wouldn't co-found a company with someone I had an emotional attachment to.
- pagekalisedown 15y agoI love children, but as a specie, we've secured our dominant position on this planet a long time ago. There's over 7 billion of us now. If children isn't your thing, why bring some into the world, and risk neglecting them?
- sliverstorm 15y agoThe main problems are these: 1) Due to social values, we build momentum. If marriage ceases to happen and children cease to be born, 50 years from now we won't have 50 million fewer people- we'll have 1 billion fewer people, and it will take decades to reverse the trend. (made-up numbers, but I hope you take my point) 2) It's not just about protecting the species. We have a tiny bit of a Ponzi scheme going. The young support the old, and as a result graphs like this: http://japanfocus.org/data/fig3.jpg http://japanfocus.org/data/fig3.jpg (Japan's population) As a taxpayer, make your blood run cold.
- pagekalisedown 15y ago1) I understand your point, but according to this: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_population http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_population It only took a decade to go from 6 to 7 billion. We can build up a population in the blink of an eye. 2) Do parents have children to bring more tax payers into the world? :) Ponzi scheme or not, people taking the time to establish themselves first means fewer children, but also fewer neglected children.
- sliverstorm 15y agoDo parents have children to bring more tax payers into the world? :) You say it like it's a silly idea, but not long ago people in America had children expressly for the purpose of helping around the farm, and in Asian cultures there is still an explicit overtone that parents have children so that they have someone to depend upon in old age. And by 'explicit overtone', I mean your parents say it to your face and you become a social pariah if you abandon your family- at least as best I understand it from my Asian friends.