6 ms·
Whale: “Hey, I found some fish.” Whale Eliza: “Interesting. How does that make you feel? Whale: “What the fuck?”
by ceejayoz 5y ago
Whale: “Hey, I found some fish.”
Whale Eliza: “Interesting. How does that make you feel?
Whale: “What the fuck?”
- gnarbarian 5y ago"If a lion could speak we wouldn't understand him." - Wittgenstein https://ideasandaction.com/if-a-lion-could-speak/ https://ideasandaction.com/if-a-lion-could-speak/
- amelius 5y agoWouldn't simple sentences with the structure subject-verb-object be universal to any rational speaker? A lion could say "I want food", or "I see dog", or "dog eats food". I don't see why a lion's worldview could be so different from ours that this wouldn't be possible.
- IIAOPSW 5y agoSVO isn't even universal in human languages.
- amelius 5y agoThe order is not important. The structure is that the sentence has a subject, verb and object.
- tsol 5y agoJust to problems off the top of my head; In order to understand "I" you have to be able to understand there's an "other". Do lions understand others are also fully capable beings? Or are they kinda of "egotistical" the way a human baby is, where they just don't really understand the concept of "other people". And do they understand what "seeing" is, so that they can use it in a sentence like that? That's also abstract, it communicates that you as a being are using your sense of sight to see a certain thing. Are lions conscious of the fact that they're seeing, or do they just see things?
- amelius 5y agoWell, perhaps the lion has more primitive cognitive capabilities, but the premise was that we wouldn't understand the lion (not the other way around).
- samirillian 5y agolol, the opposite of this actually
- chippy 5y agowhat the eat
- torben-friis 5y agoNot sure if it's the case with whales, bit as far as I know there is no recorded use of questions in the animal kingdom - all communication seems to be enunciative, or orders. Questions are exclusive to humans...
- jd115 5y agoThis is because humans are the only living thing which feels inadequate enough to ask questions. No other creature feels like it lacks knowledge. And yes, I'll take it a step further: the reason science glorifies questions is because science is human beings systematically mass-hypnotising each other into greater and greater inadequacy. You ever notice how you never get enough answers in science? Every "answer" you get scientifically only seems to bring about more and more questions? We call it "scientific curiosity" and pretend to marvel at it, but come on, how shallow is that. What every other living creature (and every newborn human) intrinsically knows is that it knows all it needs to know. And that whenever it needs to know more, it will know it. That's it. There is no scientific process, no philosophical inquiries, no questioning. No doubt. No lack.
- rsj_hn 5y agoYou must not have a dog waiting for you when you come home late
- jd115 5y agoYes, great point - but this is only because the animals we domesticate have been brainwashed by us humans into feeling (almost, but never quite) as inadequate as we do.
- glogla 5y agoTo ask questions, you have to 1) understand that others have minds 2) understand that there are things you don't know 3) understand that others might know things you don't 4) understand that you may ask them and they will tell you. That's actually a lot of advanced cognition, even if it doesn't look that way to us.
- geenew 5y agoYou should look up the Far Side comic where a professor invents a dog translator. Turns out the only thing dogs say is 'Hey! Hey! Hey!'.
- notahacker 5y agoI can easily believe that's actually true. Dogs would probably be equally disappointed to learn that they only thing we glean from how they smell is that they need a shower!