2 ms·
The 20k and 11k fees here are for invalidating and proving infringement respectively. The second one should dissuade trolls who want to target small users. Th
by pclmulqdq 5y ago
The 20k and 11k fees here are for invalidating and proving infringement respectively. The second one should dissuade trolls who want to target small users. The 20k fee is not to defend yourself from an infringement claim, it is to invalidate a patent. That is very different than defending yourself.
The equivalent filing in the US is about the same price, and the process of invalidating a patent is long and complicated, so in any jurisdiction you should expect to pay hundreds of thousands in legal fees for that process. On top of those fees, 20k isn't that much.
- rwmj 5y agoShouldn't invalidation of a patent simply be a matter of presenting evidence of prior art? I can imagine that you'd want to mandate that the evidence is presented in a certain format and possibly charge a very nominal fee (both to avoid time-wasters) but nothing more. The bias should always be towards invalidating patents, given the damage they do to competition.
- pclmulqdq 5y agoThere are a lot of different ways of invalidating a patent, and that is the simplest. However, that is also nominally what the examiner did during the issuance of the patent, so unless there was gross incompetence (eg the "shopping cart" patents), it's not that simple.
- rwmj 5y agoI've filed several patents and never seen any evidence that the examiner did anything apart from stamping paperwork.
- btrettel 5y agoType the application number into Global Dossier if it's published, and take a look at the "file wrapper" (term for all the documents listed). You'll get a better idea of what the examiner did. https://globaldossier.uspto.gov/ https://globaldossier.uspto.gov/ In the US at least, they typically put time stamped search logs in the patent file wrapper, so you can get a fairly good idea of what was searched and how long that took. It seems to me, however, that few patent attorneys will look at anything other than the "office actions", and they will look only at parts of those. Other jurisdictions don't seem to put anywhere near as many documents in patent file wrappers as the US does.
- rwmj 5y agoHere's the first patent I filed (and wrote(!)) which was in the UK. Can I search what the examiner did on this? https://patents.google.com/patent/WO1998024208A2 https://patents.google.com/patent/WO1998024208A2 The latest one I coauthored is a US patent which might easier to research: https://uspto.report/patent/app/20210034401 https://uspto.report/patent/app/20210034401
- btrettel 5y agoOn Google Patents you can get a shortcut to the USPTO Global Dossier if you search for "External Links". Looks like the USPTO Global Dossier is down for WIPO documents right now but the Espacenet Global Dossier is up: https://register.epo.org/ipfwretrieve?apn=GB.9703212.W&lng=en https://register.epo.org/ipfwretrieve?apn=GB.9703212.W&lng=e... You can see the search report for the WIPO document you linked to there. Often the descriptions are inaccurate, so in this case even though it just says "Published International Application" for all 3 documents, it's not necessarily that. The one dated 05.11.1998 is the search report. This one is not very detailed. The EPO version has a lot more: https://register.epo.org/application?tab=doclist&number=EP97913328&lng=en https://register.epo.org/application?tab=doclist&number=EP97... For the second one you mention, the USPTO Global Dossier lists a bunch of documents: https://globaldossier.uspto.gov/#/details/US/16530248/A/78395 https://globaldossier.uspto.gov/#/details/US/16530248/A/7839... You can get there by changing the "Type" drop-down menu to "Pre-grant Publication" and typing in 20210034401. You can look at a lot of search logs for this one. You can also read the "Notice of Allowance and Fees Due (PTOL-85)" to see why the examiner issued this patent.
- AlbertCory 5y agoEcho the other answer to this. If you know where to look, you can find what they searched. I'm not saying it was a thorough search, but it was a search.
- camkego 5y agoThe patent examination process is not well understood by most people. Once a patent is received, the patent examiner carefully places the application into a room full of other patent applications. Then kittens are released into the room with PATENT GRANTED stamps affixed to their feet. The kittens are then returned to their holding area to await the next round of patent examination. The patent examiners collect the applications from the floor and look to see which patent applications were granted. This is from an old HN post: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21000034 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21000034
- VBprogrammer 5y agoInvalidating a patent to me is an admission that the patent shouldn't have been granted in the first place. I appreciate that there is a long legal battle to get there but the patent authority then charging a fee feels like them getting money for their own failings. If anything they should be paying those people who's business was in legal limbo compensation for their error.
- pbhjpbhj 5y agoSo then, instead of accepting that patent offices can't find all relevant prior art/prior use (disclosed anywhere in the World) you require perfection in the discovery of relevant 'art' (closely related technical documents). That shifts the problem from "occasionally a patent is granted that isn't valid" to "it will cost $billions for even a single patent just to do a complete search" (more realistically this isn't possible you'd have to exhaustively search all prior publications). IMO if you want a patent system you have to make it work without expecting perfection from patent offices.
- AlbertCory 5y ago> "occasionally a patent is granted that isn't valid" ROTFL. It's more like "with software, the patent is virtually always invalid." I'm sure there are people better than I am, but I can invalidate practically any software patent. And I did it for Google, including in Germany in the Google Maps case of 2014. The average time an examiner is given for a patent is a day and a half (old data). That is not nearly enough time to find the "relevant prior art." So what the patent offices are doing is handing out worthless government "monopolies" and making tons of money in fees while they're doing it.
- pbhjpbhj 5y ago>ROTFL. It's more like "with software, the patent is virtually always invalid." // Yes, the establishment of prior art is particularly hard for software IMO, but that's mainly not an EPO issue (per the OP) as software patents in Europe are much more restricted compared to before the USPTO. Your timing is broadly right IME, probably a bit generous for less complex areas (though it varies and EPO spend a bit longer). Note that in part it's an industry issue - if software companies wanted to help them they can point out prior art before parents are granted (it's part of the process in EPO and USPTO jurisdictions). >I'm sure there are people better than I am, but I can invalidate practically any software patent. // EPO _granted_ patents? I'm highly doubtful you can do that in the normal search period (0.5-1.5 days). If you want to argue that far more resources should be devoted to patent examination; that's possible but in EPO countries the balance seems about right -- countries have a hard job arguing for thousands more civil servants to save only a few (!?) court cases. In USPTO you need an overhaul of the court system, massive increase in examining staff I don't think we'll fix it. All just my opinion of course.
- marcinzm 5y agoIsn't invalidating the patent one of the defenses you have against a patent troll? If they don't back off you may cost them all future business for that patent. This makes that potentially much more expensive to do.
- pclmulqdq 5y agoIt is, but it's a VERY aggressive line of defense. The OP was saying that this is an "SME killer" and that "No small company will be able to defend itself" against a patent suit. This is far from the case. A small company was never going to try to invalidate a patent to defend itself either way.
- indymike 5y ago> On top of those fees, 20k isn't that much. If we are comparing apples to apples, the actual court filing fees and such in the US are pretty small ($350 to sue in Federal court + $400 to file documentation), and if you cannot afford these fees the court has the power to waive them. For a small business with a clear case,this means your $20K is possibly enough to pay the lawyer and see the case though. Just recently, on this site, we had an article about SparkFun rebuffing a patent troll in US Federal Court for less than (or close to, as I recall) the EU filing fee. > On top of those fees, 20k isn't that much. Yes, the issue is when the fees are charged. A filing fee prevents discovery from ever happening. It is basically saying, you are too small, too poor to dispute a patent. That is not justice.
- zoobab 5y ago"That is very different than defending yourself." The counterclaim for validity court fees are set at 20.000EUR under the UPC. My company does not have those 20.000EUR, especially nowadays. Similar action in front of Belgian courts cost 165EUR, it is a 120X increase according to my calculator.